Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Labour should add ‘getting us back in the EU’ to their election manifesto

281 replies

bluewanda · 28/01/2024 09:08

We had the referendum, we gave Brexit a go, and nearly 9 years on, I think it’s plain for most people to see that leaving the EU was a massive mistake. Even people I know who voted for Brexit admit that now they wished they hadn’t, given the shitshow that has unfolded since. So, why not nip it in the bud and get back in the EU ASAP? If Labour would add it to their election manifesto that would speed up the process, as we’d have a mandate by the end of this year. So why don’t they?

OP posts:
jasflowers · 29/01/2024 15:47

EasternStandard · 29/01/2024 14:02

@Daftasabroom looks like you’re right although it was two second look so reserving any one else coming along with a correction

In that case I don’t know why they’d rule it out so early

I thought by now everyone knew a CU doesn't mean FOM but obv we are all different in knowledge.
A CU in itself doesn't really do much, Turkey has one, with the EU and they can all be very different from each other (Turkey most defo doesn't have FOM)

The obvious route for the UK, should it chose, is EFTA, out of farming and fishing policies, can negotiate own FTA's, yes there is FOM but it can be frozen more easily than the full fat one.

Ticks so many boxes for both leavers and remainers, why a EFTA type agreement wasn't sought is a mystery to me.

UK was a founding member too, going back to our roots!!!

OnGoldenPond · 29/01/2024 15:05

@CoatRack we have a parliamentary democracy in this country and I believe that elected representatives should make these decisions for good or ill. That's the job we put them in to do. I don't believe we should have had the referendum in the 70s.

I don't believe in referenda at all. They undermine our political system and just pander to short term populism.

Bululu · 29/01/2024 15:01

BTW KS has some dreadful unelectable people in his cabinet. They are the ones who would do the damage and push KS out.

EasternStandard · 29/01/2024 14:56

In fact no love lost for Labour here but if they want to come in swinging around ideas of change it won’t help them with the policies they have.

If that makes them under deliver well ok but actually what @BouncingJAS says on prospects is more relevant to me.

AlreadyDropped · 29/01/2024 14:52

I think we’ll end up back in in all but name, and with limited ability to direct decisions. A poor compromise but better than what we have now.

Labour won’t touch if at this election because they have Remainer votes in the bag anyway.

Bululu · 29/01/2024 14:52

I would benefit if we join so it would be nice but Labour would not do this. If they do they know they would loose the elections which is why they are quiet. Labour is not better. Apart from Brexit. Covid, wars, masses of illegal immigration are problems of other Western countries too. Any government in charged is bearing the brunt. I dread the future and yes we have bad it but you have not idea how much worse would get.

EasternStandard · 29/01/2024 14:50

EffieeBriest · 29/01/2024 14:47

@EasternStandard essentially the tories have had 13 years to grow the economy. Unsuccessfully as it happens. Northern Powerhouse - look how momentous that was. If anything the tories should be defending their policies. I mean the proof is in the pudding. How affluent and happy we all are. How the economy is forging ahead outside London and the south east. If anyone should be subjected to this kind of interrogation and held to account it should be them.

Labour still need to say how.

IMO a decent bump would come from changing EU status

Other than that they’ll have to give detail.

EffieeBriest · 29/01/2024 14:47

@EasternStandard essentially the tories have had 13 years to grow the economy. Unsuccessfully as it happens. Northern Powerhouse - look how momentous that was. If anything the tories should be defending their policies. I mean the proof is in the pudding. How affluent and happy we all are. How the economy is forging ahead outside London and the south east. If anyone should be subjected to this kind of interrogation and held to account it should be them.

Daftasabroom · 29/01/2024 14:46

They're not comparable but we also had the referendum on AB voting, I wonder whether that will prove to be as significant, in a negative way, as Brexit. Would we have had a less partisan and less polarized HoC? Would British police serve us better,?

Daftasabroom · 29/01/2024 14:39

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 14:03

@Daftasabroom

A Customs Union requires that both sides agree on the same set of rules.

The UK (now) is intent on diverging from a common set of rules (making it poorer), but id you want a CU type deal, it will have to revert back to EU rules. There is no choice there.

I absolutely get that, and have no problem with it. It's not like we've made much in the way of positive strides with trade deals we've done so far.

DdraigGoch · 29/01/2024 14:38

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 14:00

@GasPanic

They cannot raise income taxes further because the top 10% are basically maxed out. Behavioral changes have already happened with people working less or flat out retiring.

So they can only really go after the "adjustments" or lower hanging fruit of taxes.

So they will likely target:

  1. Pensions
  2. VAT on [insert here]
  3. Corporation Tax (reduce the exemptions)
  4. Tax exemptions

Basically, they seem to be targeting the multitude of tax exemptions in the UK economy to gain a bit of revenue.

This means the next five years will be grim. The UK economy will keep sinking until it stabilises at a lower real GDP per capita. I don't think the Brexiters realised just how poor the UK was going to end up outside of London.

Which is why I mentioned that they should be putting forward some proper reform. Flatten out the marginal rates, merge NI into income tax (that alone would remove a good few loopholes), tax capital gains as income tax rather than at a lower rate, replace IHT with applying CGT when inherited assets are liquidated etc.

EasternStandard · 29/01/2024 14:38

Chersfrozenface · 29/01/2024 14:25

Labour's approach is to get the UK economy growing faster, not raise taxes, per Rachel Reeves last October.

I can see why they would say that. Taxing non doms and levying VAT on private schools won't raise enough Reversing the Tories changes to National Insurance and any tax cuts they make before the election won't either. And yet they don't want to raise taxes.

It'll be interesting to see how thr next Labour government purposes to grow the economy.

Labour's approach is to get the UK economy growing faster

Well they’re going to need to say how because it’s pie in the sky otherwise

HelloClouds · 29/01/2024 14:33

The election campaign will result in serious scrutiny of Labour’s policies. You can be sure that they will try to be as vague and inoffensive as possible while repeating things that no-one could disagree with (“we support the NHS” etc etc).

It’s going to be almost impossible for them to lose, but remember how quickly Theresa May’s campaign fell apart over the social care policy!

Chersfrozenface · 29/01/2024 14:25

EffieeBriest · 29/01/2024 14:10

In the end it’s a fight between low taxes and next to little state intervention or hoping folk will be happy to fork out more in tax for better social care provision, to fund renovation of collapsing state schools, improve the criminal justice system, support NHS. That’s the stark choice.

Labour's approach is to get the UK economy growing faster, not raise taxes, per Rachel Reeves last October.

I can see why they would say that. Taxing non doms and levying VAT on private schools won't raise enough Reversing the Tories changes to National Insurance and any tax cuts they make before the election won't either. And yet they don't want to raise taxes.

It'll be interesting to see how thr next Labour government purposes to grow the economy.

EffieeBriest · 29/01/2024 14:18

@GasPanic I actually thought New labour did some great things only to be dismantled by the tories. Obviously there were some not so good but to lump them in with the current lot is ridiculous.
Not sure what your other comment was about re people trying extract more than they contribute. Most don’t earn enough to do this. I’ve never claimed any benefits, I’m a crit care nurse so wage isn’t amazing, I guess you’d class me as a drag on the economy but my job is invaluable.

EasternStandard · 29/01/2024 14:15

The issue is due to being maxed on tax people make behavioural changes as @BouncingJAS says

You get to the point of a very difficult spiral down and that’s when it will be very tough to get out of

EffieeBriest · 29/01/2024 14:10

In the end it’s a fight between low taxes and next to little state intervention or hoping folk will be happy to fork out more in tax for better social care provision, to fund renovation of collapsing state schools, improve the criminal justice system, support NHS. That’s the stark choice.

Chersfrozenface · 29/01/2024 14:08

EasternStandard · 29/01/2024 14:02

@Daftasabroom looks like you’re right although it was two second look so reserving any one else coming along with a correction

In that case I don’t know why they’d rule it out so early

Ifside the Customs Union, the UK cannot negotiate its own independent trade deals with other countries. Outside the CU, it can

Though that's hardly been a stellar success so far.

GasPanic · 29/01/2024 14:07

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 14:00

@GasPanic

They cannot raise income taxes further because the top 10% are basically maxed out. Behavioral changes have already happened with people working less or flat out retiring.

So they can only really go after the "adjustments" or lower hanging fruit of taxes.

So they will likely target:

  1. Pensions
  2. VAT on [insert here]
  3. Corporation Tax (reduce the exemptions)
  4. Tax exemptions

Basically, they seem to be targeting the multitude of tax exemptions in the UK economy to gain a bit of revenue.

This means the next five years will be grim. The UK economy will keep sinking until it stabilises at a lower real GDP per capita. I don't think the Brexiters realised just how poor the UK was going to end up outside of London.

I wouldn't disagree with any of that.

What I would disagree with is people claiming that being a member of the EU would be some sort of solution to it.

GasPanic · 29/01/2024 14:05

EffieeBriest · 29/01/2024 13:53

@GasPanic are you happy with the state of the UK though ? As far as I can see most of our public service s are crumbling and not for purpose. Ultimately I guess it depends where you live and your level of affluence as to how much you are affected.
Labour will probably start releasing their manifesto contents over the next few months. Many of their ideas were pilfered and watered down by the tories last election so no doubt they’ll try to keep stuff under wraps as long as possible. And it’s a cert that they will be lambasted in the headlines in the run up.

I am not happy with the state of the UK, but I don't see anything that Starmer or Sunak is proposing that is going to make it any better.

We've had almost 30 years of awful government, where people have become more takers than givers.

Society is now about how much people can extract from it, not how much they can contribute. We're now reaching the point where the extraction is becoming unsustainable and we need to move back towards more of the population being net contributors rather than takers. That is going to cause a lot of pain.

In addition the government(s) has(ve) pursued policies that have degraded the voting publics standard of living. They have not supplied adequate housing and services, while allowing huge numbers of people into the country to try to drive GDP and enrich some sections of society at the expense of others. Not surprisingly this policy will soon reach its end point.

I will wait for the manifestos to see which of Labour or the Tories is most likely to enact policies that will rebalance the country, but I'm not expecting much from either side.

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 14:03

@Daftasabroom

A Customs Union requires that both sides agree on the same set of rules.

The UK (now) is intent on diverging from a common set of rules (making it poorer), but id you want a CU type deal, it will have to revert back to EU rules. There is no choice there.

EasternStandard · 29/01/2024 14:02

@Daftasabroom looks like you’re right although it was two second look so reserving any one else coming along with a correction

In that case I don’t know why they’d rule it out so early

BouncingJAS · 29/01/2024 14:00

@GasPanic

They cannot raise income taxes further because the top 10% are basically maxed out. Behavioral changes have already happened with people working less or flat out retiring.

So they can only really go after the "adjustments" or lower hanging fruit of taxes.

So they will likely target:

  1. Pensions
  2. VAT on [insert here]
  3. Corporation Tax (reduce the exemptions)
  4. Tax exemptions

Basically, they seem to be targeting the multitude of tax exemptions in the UK economy to gain a bit of revenue.

This means the next five years will be grim. The UK economy will keep sinking until it stabilises at a lower real GDP per capita. I don't think the Brexiters realised just how poor the UK was going to end up outside of London.

EasternStandard · 29/01/2024 13:59

Daftasabroom · 29/01/2024 13:58

I was on the understanding that CU didn't require FOM of people? SM obviously does.

I've done a quick Google, I think I'm correct. Happy to be corrected.

Really?

Ok off to google..

EasternStandard · 29/01/2024 13:59

SM and CU have already been ruled out. Policies are thin outside that

If people wanted Labour to get a funding bounce then they’ve ruled out the obvious and most impactful way already