Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think most people have no idea how wealthy people live their lives?

994 replies

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 07:38

Just that really off the back of a lot of threads but most recently one where multiple people were adamant that the only way it’s possible to have no savings if you have salaries of £200k plus unless one of the couple is squirrelling savings.

Followed up with how do they pay for a broken down car with savings? Hasn’t even dawned on them that people on those salaries don’t have cars that are breaking down.

Is it so hard to believe that money literally eliminates money worries? That you can create a level of security that means savings and such aren’t needed?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
spriots · 28/01/2024 11:18

It's not that people are too stupid to grasp your point, it's that your point is stupid

BobnLen · 28/01/2024 11:17

Has OP got a special car, even brand new ones can break down but not OPs according to her, or does that mean she has a chauffeur.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 28/01/2024 11:15

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 11:10

No. It’s that people aren’t cannot grasp it. They cannot. As evidenced by this thread and the two threads that led me to post this in the first place.

There's no end to your superiority both intellectually and financially, is there?

Many people understand the point you are trying to make, even though you have articulated it extremely poorly.

I'm certain there are people on the thread who are on much better positions than you but aren't crass enough to mention it. Money talks but wealth whispers.

onemoremile · 28/01/2024 11:15

But even in a month or two you could earn a bit of interest on say £10k while it isn't doing anything else. It seems odd to throw that away for the sake of 5 minutes and two internet transfers.

TooManyChangesTooSoon · 28/01/2024 11:15

OP, Investments and pensions = savings!

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 28/01/2024 11:14

Cash sitting in your current account isn’t savings.

But in a previous post you defined savings as "money you can easily access in the case of an emergency"

We aren’t saving it though. It’s just not been spent.

That's an odd distinction in the context of money leftover at the end of the month. If it happens frequently, it builds up. To me, that is essentially being saved.

Are suggesting that people living month to month find £100 left in their account and that’s immediately considered to be savings?

I think that if someone usually spent all their income in a month, but one month had £100 leftover, they may well say "I've managed to save £100 this month".
If they have £100 leftover every month, they'd say "I earn enough to save £100 a month" even if not actually transferred to a savings account, because at the end of every month their account is £100 higher. If every few months they spend that chunk, I'd say they save £100 a month for 3 months, then spend it.

DownByTheLakes · 28/01/2024 11:14

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 11:12

But I don’t want it to earn interest. I want to use it to pay for the holiday. If I wanted it to
”earn” an income I would add it our investment budget and kiss it goodbye.

Ok. Well, I mentioned I put the school fees into Premium Bonds. I pay them three times a year. In the interim, I like to have them in PB because I'll get a cash prize - maybe one day £1m! More likely £100. But to me, that's a better place for them than just sitting in my current account doing nothing.

indigoskies · 28/01/2024 11:14

'That we don’t need a pot of money aside for an emergency broken boiler.'

OK. Is that it?

Alcyoneus · 28/01/2024 11:14

OP is a modern day Hyacinth Bucket. Has delusions of grandeur. Wants to considered wealthy. And will make a fool out herself to do so. What a bizarre individual.

WithACatLikeTread · 28/01/2024 11:13

Why does it matter?

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 11:13

BillionaireTea · 28/01/2024 11:12

I don’t agree that money we have left over is the same as someone making a conscious effort to put money aside in savings.

So is this, after 20 effing pages, your core question? "Are savings only savings when you carefully manage them, or can they be savings when they happen without you needing to think about them?"

The definition of savings is having enough liquid to pay for additional expenses. It doesn't matter a flying badger's arse whether you keep this resource in a sock under the bed or on your child's GoHenry card or in a normal bank account or in a savings account or in the form of a Picasso that you know the auction house would buy back within 3 hours.

Obviously anyone who said "wow, 200k and no savings, someone must be squirelling money away" meant this: 200k salary paid every month with nothing left over, zero balance after tax, zero contributions to any other asset, implies you are spending a fairly big whack every month without fail and that seemed unusual.

You've got all stressed out about people accusing you/DH of squirreling money away. Ok you're not hiding money, you're just leaving it to wash around in your current account.

Is this what you are asking? Are you OK now?!

You think I’m stressed? I’m really not. Bored? Amused? Somewhere between to two. Definitely not stressed.

OP posts:
RootVegAndMash · 28/01/2024 11:13

Someone with savings, budgeted for and regularly deducted from salary will not need to reduce their standard of living or budget more heavily over X months if...part of the roof blows off, boiler blows up, to pay for their £10k holiday, whatever.

Someone with no accessible savings WILL have to budget, possibly heavily, to pay for such things.

It doesn't matter if your monthly income is £2k or £20k. When you have an unexpected £10k bill, if you usually spend the majority of your income (not including investments) you'll need to reduce your usual standard of living, pull back on your usual spending, to pay for that.

If you live that way and it's not necessary to do so more fool you. Poor financial resilience and understanding isn't something to be proud of, however much your salary is.

ManchesterBea · 28/01/2024 11:13

This is the most bizarre thread!

Enjoyable read, though agree with the previous posters, a person who earns a reasonable amount monthly is trying to tell everybody how wealthy people live their lives, despite not being one.

Odd, but amusing.

BillionaireTea · 28/01/2024 11:12

I don’t agree that money we have left over is the same as someone making a conscious effort to put money aside in savings.

So is this, after 20 effing pages, your core question? "Are savings only savings when you carefully manage them, or can they be savings when they happen without you needing to think about them?"

The definition of savings is having enough liquid to pay for additional expenses. It doesn't matter a flying badger's arse whether you keep this resource in a sock under the bed or on your child's GoHenry card or in a normal bank account or in a savings account or in the form of a Picasso that you know the auction house would buy back within 3 hours.

Obviously anyone who said "wow, 200k and no savings, someone must be squirelling money away" meant this: 200k salary paid every month with nothing left over, zero balance after tax, zero contributions to any other asset, implies you are spending a fairly big whack every month without fail and that seemed unusual.

You've got all stressed out about people accusing you/DH of squirreling money away. Ok you're not hiding money, you're just leaving it to wash around in your current account.

Is this what you are asking? Are you OK now?!

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 11:12

indigoskies · 28/01/2024 11:11

What exactly is it that people can't grasp?

That we don’t need a pot of money aside for an emergency broken boiler.

OP posts:
AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 11:12

DownByTheLakes · 28/01/2024 11:10

I move it across to a) stay organised, and b) it earns better interest - or in the case of PB it's fun to win the prizes each month?

But I don’t want it to earn interest. I want to use it to pay for the holiday. If I wanted it to
”earn” an income I would add it our investment budget and kiss it goodbye.

OP posts:
indigoskies · 28/01/2024 11:11

What exactly is it that people can't grasp?

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 11:10

DownByTheLakes · 28/01/2024 11:09

So your whole point is that wealthy people don't have to worry about money. And you think this is a brand new, revelatory concept?

Some people organise their money differently to you - they might not be worried, but prefer to have the school fee cash sitting separately from the general-use cash, or the holiday fund earmarked elsewhere for tidiness or a better interest rate or whatever.

Other people scrimp to put money aside in a savings account. It's a struggle and a necessity because they need to have that safety net. I see that your situation is different to theirs, but not to the people in my paragraph above.

I'm also confused as to why this matters to you? Why is it so important for you to insist that you don't have savings, just a load of cash as though these are totally different concepts?

No. It’s that people aren’t cannot grasp it. They cannot. As evidenced by this thread and the two threads that led me to post this in the first place.

OP posts:
DownByTheLakes · 28/01/2024 11:10

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 11:07

Why would you do that? Why move it into one account and then pay rather than just pay? Because you can’t afford it.

so again, all these people relentlessly people who are financially secure or whatever you want to call it have to have savings, for what? What is it we are saving for? So far I’ve had it suggested:

broken car. This wouldn’t cost us anything.
boiler. As above.
holidays - we just pay for these.
redundancy - that isn’t something we could “save” for and if it happened - very unlikely - we have assets / investments that would mean we are fine.
life threatening aggressive cancer - I would use the nhs even if we had savings for a condition like that.

No one has actually yet given me an example
of anything that we actually need an emergency pot of funds for.

I move it across to a) stay organised, and b) it earns better interest - or in the case of PB it's fun to win the prizes each month?

ChampagneLassie · 28/01/2024 11:09

What’s your point? I deal with lots of wealthy people. Most have considerable amounts in cash savings. I’ve not yet met anyone who has such a blase attitude to assuming their income is safe no need to save. But everyone is different.

HappiestSleeping · 28/01/2024 11:09

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 07:48

People at this level are rarely made redundant. They make others redundant.

That just isn't true. It can all stop in a heartbeat. Don't ask me how I know, I just know.

AinsleyHayes · 28/01/2024 11:09

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 10:55

I absolutely agree it is. Which is why I find it weird when people who don’t have that income are emphatically telling me that (a) we have to have savings and (b) that my husband is definitely squirrelling away money because there’s no way he isn’t because of the salary.

Ahhhhhh, I think I sort of get it now. This is a TAAT.

Maybe you should care less what your financial inferiors think of you, OP.

DownByTheLakes · 28/01/2024 11:09

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 11:03

I know. Which is the point.

So your whole point is that wealthy people don't have to worry about money. And you think this is a brand new, revelatory concept?

Some people organise their money differently to you - they might not be worried, but prefer to have the school fee cash sitting separately from the general-use cash, or the holiday fund earmarked elsewhere for tidiness or a better interest rate or whatever.

Other people scrimp to put money aside in a savings account. It's a struggle and a necessity because they need to have that safety net. I see that your situation is different to theirs, but not to the people in my paragraph above.

I'm also confused as to why this matters to you? Why is it so important for you to insist that you don't have savings, just a load of cash as though these are totally different concepts?

indigoskies · 28/01/2024 11:09

OP, it doesn't matter

BiddyPop · 28/01/2024 11:09

Investments are savings to a lot of people.

But unless you have access to a credit card with a large limit easily, not having an emergency fund is not sensible. If the boiler blows (even if regularly maintained, it happens), someone crashes into your car, emergency illness etc - you will need access to cash at some point. Just to deal with the immediate problems facing you.

And in the current economic and geopolitical climate, something could happen very easily where cash and items to barter may be very important for a period.

We have a good household income but I focus on saving emergency funds first before investments. And both DH and I having our own emergency funds as we are often in different places due to the nature of our work. So we may each need to organise ourselves independently of the other temporarily.

Yes, we can and do keep on top of maintenance, buy quality brands, do all that kind of thing. But emergencies still happen and even quality brands can fail.

Swipe left for the next trending thread