Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think most people have no idea how wealthy people live their lives?

994 replies

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 07:38

Just that really off the back of a lot of threads but most recently one where multiple people were adamant that the only way it’s possible to have no savings if you have salaries of £200k plus unless one of the couple is squirrelling savings.

Followed up with how do they pay for a broken down car with savings? Hasn’t even dawned on them that people on those salaries don’t have cars that are breaking down.

Is it so hard to believe that money literally eliminates money worries? That you can create a level of security that means savings and such aren’t needed?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
spriots · 28/01/2024 11:50

I think the OP's point is that she doesn't have to worry about money because she has lots.

I don't understand why she thinks people might not understand this already

Nevermind31 · 28/01/2024 11:49

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 07:50

We don’t live beyond our means. We have no debt at all apart from mortgage. This is what I mean. The assumption that it’s impossible not to have savings but also assuming living beyond means. Those who really are established wealthy just don’t have either. They aren’t sitting there stretching themselves for a meal or worrying about money sitting in a low interest bank account.

You see “savings” as money in a readily accessible bank account.
you don’t need “savings” if you have other assets that you can liquidate at shortish notice should you need to (ie a portfolio in readily tradeable securities). But also… how do you buy a new car unless you get it on finance? The new kitchen? Because those things don’t come out of £13k a month…
”savings” is just a term for money that is available. I think what you want to say is that you are so wealthy that you don’t have to worry about saving up for things most people do. What you don’t mean is that you don’t have any money should something happen

SkulkHollow · 28/01/2024 11:47

For someone who is being so unbearably smug about money, it's funny that the OP clearly has no idea about sound financial management.

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 11:47

Whoknows101 · 28/01/2024 11:23

It doesn't have to be "frivolous stuff". Is a £300k extension 'frivolous" to you? How about buying university age children a property? To the truly wealthy it certainly isn't, and doing so wouldn't compromise their future investments either.

The "investments" which you are referring to having are likely long-term investments that are relatively illquid - not because of the technical access to them but because of the long term nature of their expected gains. A wealthy family would not put themselves in the position of having to liquidise them at the "wrong" time.

Again, there is no obvious purpose to your posts or this thread other than "bragging" that you are relatively financially comfortable and living within your short-term means.

They are clearly relatively high compared to a sizeable portion of the population.

These means are also clearly relatively low compared to genuinely wealthy families - who don't holiday at Disneyland or leave themselves without a large sum of liquid funds to spend on things you define as frivolous because you lack the disposable income to deem them justifiable.

Children have an ISA and other things in place, they’re covered.

We had an extension, we remortgaged for it as the interest on mortgage is less than the interest we earn on investments. It wouldn’t have made sense to access investments at that time. Clearly if it made more sense to access investment funds we would have done this but property improvement is itself an investment. But again, that’s not really savings for a rainy day or an emergency is it?

OP posts:
SomeCatFromJapan · 28/01/2024 11:46

Paying up a holiday over three months is just something normally off people do, it's hardly the hallmark of a wealthy person.
OP your family has a good income but you're not what I'd call wealthy and you're astonishingly relaxed about savings under the circumstances, as well as astonishingly naive about redundancies.

snowmobileon · 28/01/2024 11:45

unlikelychump · 28/01/2024 07:50

Are you just showing off OP?

Correct

SallySilly · 28/01/2024 11:45

Bizarre thread.

We are in a similar financial position as OP. We have savings, investments, pension pots etc. Whilst I appreciate we are in an incredibly fortunate financial position, I do not consider us to be incredibly wealthy. My husband and I are fairly frugal and appreciate that our earning potential may not always be what it is now and would both like to retire with a comfortable pension pot.

We discuss all financial purchases over £100 or so - not for permission, just because they what we do. I would absolutely feel stressed if our boiler broke!

Lilifer · 28/01/2024 11:44

"No they are not. Savings are money you can easily access in the case of an emergency. That’s not the case with pension or investments, neither of which can be accessed."

OP this is rubbish. I have an investment portfolio with Investec bank and I can access monies in there any time I want, it's the reason I chose this particular portfolio.

I think you this thread is not genuine.

Popquizzer · 28/01/2024 11:44

"We have no debt at all apart from mortgage."

I've never heard anyone with a mortgage on the house they live in describe themselves as wealthy. Most would see a mortgage as something you might have taken out at the beginning of your career before you started earning properly and paid it off.

spriots · 28/01/2024 11:44

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 11:42

I cannot even begin to tell you what a complete waste of time premium bonds are.

Your initial investment makes nothing but you might win £100000. As opposed to our investments which do make a return every month.

If our financial advisor had suggested a premium bonds my husband would have left smoke.

You're missing the point

Premium bonds are better than leaving loads in a current account getting no interest which seems to be what you do

tennesseewhiskey1 · 28/01/2024 11:43

OP do you just want us to tell you that you are wealthy? If I’m being honest - in my circles you aren’t. You are fine - comfortable. You still have a mortgage. How many properties do you have? At least 3? Kids all in private school? I don’t know what you want from this thread at all - except for us to tell you you’re wealthy? The wealthy I know don’t go around telling people they’re wealthy. It’s really weird.

paintitblue · 28/01/2024 11:42

Is it so hard to believe that money literally eliminates money worries? That you can create a level of security that means savings and such aren’t needed?

Tell that to Steve Bing.

AlreadyDropped · 28/01/2024 11:42

I’d like a genuinely wealthy person (£100m+ in assets) to do a thread like this. I’d like to know what that’s like- in particular how you raise children with motivation to make a contribution to society, and whether you live without material wants or just start to want more expensive things.

Someone bragging about having comprehensive boiler cover isn’t really cutting it.

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 11:42

WithACatLikeTread · 28/01/2024 11:40

Just curious but is it just your DH working?

No.

OP posts:
AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 11:42

DownByTheLakes · 28/01/2024 11:37

And if, at the end of each month, she'd put that excess cash into an ISA or Premium Bonds, it would be a bit more money than her just leaving it in the current account before she paid for those flights in Month 3. I think she's trying to say that's so negligible to her, as a wealthy person, that winning £200 on the PB would be nothing anyway, no more significant than spotting 10p on the pavement. But I figure - why not have it anyway? And in the highly unlikely event she scoops the £1m jackpot, is that also totally inconsequential to her? Maybe so!

I cannot even begin to tell you what a complete waste of time premium bonds are.

Your initial investment makes nothing but you might win £100000. As opposed to our investments which do make a return every month.

If our financial advisor had suggested a premium bonds my husband would have left smoke.

OP posts:
WithACatLikeTread · 28/01/2024 11:40

Just curious but is it just your DH working?

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 11:38

BillionaireTea · 28/01/2024 11:33

God this is painful. I really hope your job isn't something where you need to understand language and concepts.

No. I don't personally consider paying monthly bills as savings. Because I am in the same position as you and they pay themselves automatically, comfortably within the total of my income, and they are paid in the same cadence I am paid.

My sister is paid weekly. She has to SAVE UP for her bills to be paid at the end of the month. She also has to have a bit more left over for other things she might want to buy or emergencies, because this SAVING doesn't happen by itself, as her income is low.

I am determined to get to the nub of your stupid question here OP. Is it about the definition of saving up? The intention of putting money aside for something in future?

You do that!!! But you do it AUTOMATICALLY.

Jan - 13k comes in, 8k goes out. Balance 5k
Feb - 13k comes in, 12k goes out as you buy random things that occur to you. Balance 6k.
Mar- 13k comes in. Oh, we would like to go to Disney! Look the flights cost £7k. Let's buy them. Usual 9kish goes out as well. Balance now at end of month is £2k.

You have SAVED UP to go to Disney land. You just did it without having to do it very consciously. It still counts as savings.

I wouldn’t agree that counts as saving BUT even if I did did we NEED to do that? No. We did not. Which is the point. Here and elsewhere I see people saying you NEED a
pot of savings for emergencies. What emergency do I need access to savings for? The point is we don’t. We can cover what we need without even thinking about it. Any saving would be for luxury items which we don’t feel the need to save for and even if we did that isn’t a pot of savings that we actually NEED.

OP posts:
DownByTheLakes · 28/01/2024 11:37

BillionaireTea · 28/01/2024 11:33

God this is painful. I really hope your job isn't something where you need to understand language and concepts.

No. I don't personally consider paying monthly bills as savings. Because I am in the same position as you and they pay themselves automatically, comfortably within the total of my income, and they are paid in the same cadence I am paid.

My sister is paid weekly. She has to SAVE UP for her bills to be paid at the end of the month. She also has to have a bit more left over for other things she might want to buy or emergencies, because this SAVING doesn't happen by itself, as her income is low.

I am determined to get to the nub of your stupid question here OP. Is it about the definition of saving up? The intention of putting money aside for something in future?

You do that!!! But you do it AUTOMATICALLY.

Jan - 13k comes in, 8k goes out. Balance 5k
Feb - 13k comes in, 12k goes out as you buy random things that occur to you. Balance 6k.
Mar- 13k comes in. Oh, we would like to go to Disney! Look the flights cost £7k. Let's buy them. Usual 9kish goes out as well. Balance now at end of month is £2k.

You have SAVED UP to go to Disney land. You just did it without having to do it very consciously. It still counts as savings.

And if, at the end of each month, she'd put that excess cash into an ISA or Premium Bonds, it would be a bit more money than her just leaving it in the current account before she paid for those flights in Month 3. I think she's trying to say that's so negligible to her, as a wealthy person, that winning £200 on the PB would be nothing anyway, no more significant than spotting 10p on the pavement. But I figure - why not have it anyway? And in the highly unlikely event she scoops the £1m jackpot, is that also totally inconsequential to her? Maybe so!

honeylulu · 28/01/2024 11:37

Yes wealthy and "comfortably off" people do have investments/savings. So do you OP - in the form of your pension and house. (Others have likely said the same but I haven't read the whole thread.)

As for liquid cash savings, you say your monthly income is enough to cover large expenses that crop up such as emergency repairs or booking holidays. Our income is similar to yours and I'm aware how fortunate we are. But there are many many months where we have not had those extra big expenses so current account cash builds up. When this happens I shift it into extra pension payments/ISAs on the advice of our financial adviser. This is how we paid off our mortgage - we haven't one for the last 5 years. Cars all fully paid for too. OP are you really saying you just blow £13k every month and you still have a mortgage??? I'm gobsmacked.

Get a financial adviser, I think you need one!

Teentaxidriver · 28/01/2024 11:36

This ranks as one of the most bizarre threads on MN that I have read. I am not sure why the OP feels the need to post in explicit, micro detail about her financial situation. My impression is of a pompous, conceited, self-obsessed bore looking to rile the little folk with stories about her (supposedly) earnt riches. Frankly I don’t give a toss about her financial set up but it has made me chuckle, reading about the assets, investments and tax planning.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 28/01/2024 11:34

All this thread proves is that you shouldn't debate or argue with an idiot.

They'll drag you down to their level and beat you on experience and relentlessness.😀

Posters will drop out as they realise the OP is clearly incorrect and unwilling to recognise that but the OP will continue on and on as they are so assured of their superiority.

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 11:34

alpenguin · 28/01/2024 11:27

Lost cats? I’m talking about the blase approach to money, especially for us little people who earn nowhere near as much and struggle month to month to survive.

It’s because I said I would choose to put a cat to sleep before I put it through the trauma of expensive invasive surgery. Weird thing to get upset about.

OP posts:
BillionaireTea · 28/01/2024 11:33

God this is painful. I really hope your job isn't something where you need to understand language and concepts.

No. I don't personally consider paying monthly bills as savings. Because I am in the same position as you and they pay themselves automatically, comfortably within the total of my income, and they are paid in the same cadence I am paid.

My sister is paid weekly. She has to SAVE UP for her bills to be paid at the end of the month. She also has to have a bit more left over for other things she might want to buy or emergencies, because this SAVING doesn't happen by itself, as her income is low.

I am determined to get to the nub of your stupid question here OP. Is it about the definition of saving up? The intention of putting money aside for something in future?

You do that!!! But you do it AUTOMATICALLY.

Jan - 13k comes in, 8k goes out. Balance 5k
Feb - 13k comes in, 12k goes out as you buy random things that occur to you. Balance 6k.
Mar- 13k comes in. Oh, we would like to go to Disney! Look the flights cost £7k. Let's buy them. Usual 9kish goes out as well. Balance now at end of month is £2k.

You have SAVED UP to go to Disney land. You just did it without having to do it very consciously. It still counts as savings.

AnneValentine · 28/01/2024 11:33

Newstarto · 28/01/2024 11:28

To us it is because we don’t see it as a pot of money we access. It’s something entirely separate. Of course we could if we desperately needed to

and there we have it. Access to a sum of money, which is pretty much just volatile savings

It would not be instant access and would require a lot of effort. It’s not something that could be considered in anyway emergency savings. Much like “I don’t need savings I own a house” wouldn’t make sense. Because I’m assuming when people say you need emergency savings they’re not including things like equity in property but a pot of money that can be easily accessed.

If in fact things like that are included and emergency savings includes things like this then I apologise. I completely missed the point. Given the statement “for an emergency” I took that to mean a pot of money saved that could be accessed at the drop of a hat.

OP posts:
Didimum · 28/01/2024 11:32

IBE45 · 28/01/2024 09:15

Is £13000 a month truly wealthy though, especially with no savings. It's extremely well off and comfortable, and probably puts you in the top 1 % or 2% of earners. However the difference between the top 1% and the top 0.1% is extreme. I thought to be considered truly wealthy you needed around £1m just sitting in the bank. Having been exposed to truly wealthy people, I am most definitely not one, they own estates, millions in property/investments, businesses etc. £13k a month is very well off, but it isn't truly wealthy.

I was just thinking this and wondered if I’d read it correctly, because I don’t consider £13k a month income wealthy at all. That’s ‘well off high salary’ position, but isn’t wealthy.

OP keeps banging on about the wealthy not needing savings and investments not being savings, but all the scenarios of needing money other posters have given her she has answers with either ‘selling property’ (using an investment), ‘paying for it in instalments’ (that is saving - short term or long term, saving and the ability to save) or ‘not doing it (eg, putting a pet down instead of paying for surgery to save it), which isn’t answering the question.

She claims people with exceedingly high salaries don’t get made redundant, which is the most bizarre thing I have ever heard. Yes they do. Me and my husband have seen in first hand in both our industries (and they aren’t obscure ones). However if someone posed her with the question of redundancy, she would simply answer ‘retire early’, or ‘withdraw some of private pension’ or ‘sell a property’, all of which is relying on an investment saving. Don’t even get me started on her reliance of insurance and the event of them not paying out or only partially paying out.

The belief that scenarios don’t happen to you because you haven’t experienced them yet does not equal ‘wealthy people don’t need savings’. It’s simply a piss poor way of managing your money and OP sounds very miseducated in that.

OP, at best, is asset rich and cash poor, which describes a lot of the country’s high earners. That is not wealth.

And, if OP were to claim any sort of ‘jealousy’ or any inexperience on my part, we bring in £11k a month and have save a six-figure savings. One of us also works in finance at director level. We are not wealthy, we are well off (and very lucky). And we also aren’t naive enough to believe that savings aren’t necessary or complacent enough to believe the wind never changes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread