Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So very sad, can't believe he has chosen her

208 replies

NewbieSM · 28/01/2024 02:09

Sorry for the late long post, I am in Australia but don't really have many people to talk to about this and am feeling very low today.

I've just had a massive fight with my Dad about his wife's drinking problem and he essentially kicked me out of his house and told me to never come back.

Back story: My step mother is an alcoholic has been for 35 years, she made my childhood an absolute nightmare, physical and mental abuse, stealing money from me, destroying expensive items like phones, passports (multiple times) to stop me from visiting my mum overseas. She would get black out drunk almost everyday, pass out and piss the bed so when I got home from school my younger siblings and I would have to drag her down the hall in to the shower to clean her up. She was arrested 3 times for drunk driving, once with all us kids in the car, I remember all of us crying and me screaming at the police to leave her alone as he drove us and our car to police station. I was 11. My Dad is a classic conflict avoidant type personality and always brushed it under the rug, made excuses for her, stuck his head in the sand basically.

Fast forward to today, I get a call my from 17 year old half brother, he's really upset and nearly in tears, he's just logged into his online banking and his mum has wiped his account of all his savings from his part time job. She's stolen his atm card, just like she did to me multiple times 10 years ago.

I'm fuming, so I drive over there to comfort my brother and confront her and my Dad. DB is so so upset, he's been saving up for a car for nearly 2 years and she's gone and fucked it all up. I tell DB to get in my car while I talk to Dad, the stupid bitch is hiding out in her room so she doesn't have to face the music, typical. Dad was so dismissive of me, kept saying it's not her fault this is the disease, we need to support family blah blah blah I'll replace the money. That's just not good enough imo, he needs to kick her the fuck out, she needs rehab not enabling. I told him he is risking his relationship with all of his kids for a woman who doesn't deserve it and he needs to make the right choice. He blew up me, told to keep my nose out of it, who did I think I was to lecture him and issue ultimatums and I was "emotionally bankrupt". He told me to get out of his house and don't bother coming back.

I've taken my brother to my house and set him up in the spare room to cool off for a couple days, but I am so upset at how my Dad spoke to me. Even though I am a 30 year old woman I am still his first born child, I can't believe he has chosen her over me AGAIN. He had a second chance to do things differently with my two younger brothers but he hasn't learned and has now fucked up two more people's mental health. I'm so done with it all but I can't imagine a life without my Dad who I still love very much. What do I do now Mumsnet, how do I move on?

OP posts:
senua · 28/01/2024 09:51

I think that you need to step back a bit, OP. Your Dad will see this as you interfering, projecting your problems onto your DBro and therefore not listen; you need impartial, external input.

Does your DBro's school have a pastoral team who can help?

Dmsandfloatydress · 28/01/2024 09:35

This could be my life but with my biological mum who is a mentally ill alcoholic. I supported my dad whenever she created chaos for him to repeatedly throw it back in my face once she was sober and acting normal again. My two younger brothers didn't survive this childhood. One dead the other an addict. He is 72 and still championing her cause. I'm no contact with her for the last 8 years, which has been bliss. Aside from him pestering me to have her back in my life. Even though they are divorced and she destroyed his life. Apparently he just loved her more than his kids. I don't have anything for you just a rather unexpected mumsnet hug!

Gettingbysomehow · 28/01/2024 09:35

I agree with the poster who said press charges for theft. That will wake your father up hopefully.

Letsrunabath · 28/01/2024 09:24

I’ve no experience of what your family are going through, wanted to say that it’s wonderful that you and your siblings are so close and can help each other out, you sound like a fantastic big sister.

StandardLFinegan · 28/01/2024 09:24

I just wanted to add to the op that it’s not necessarily wrong in itself that a man prioritises his relationship with his wife over that with his dc, although it’s not about choosing one over the other. ( Many people on Mumsnet disagree with this but that’s for another thread.) In a functional family a man supporting his wife and vice verza means that the dc are automatically supported too.

What is wrong here op is that your dad has supported his wife who has stolen from his dc and allowed her to emotionally traumatise his children and wreak havoc on the entire household. Never mind driving them in a car while intoxicated. In other words, he put you in physical and emotional danger. As much as he loved her, he should have drawn a line and protected you and put your welfare and that of your siblings first.

I agree with pp that your dad is as sick as your stepmother.

Please don’t feel you have to answer this op but it makes me wonder what led to the break up of your dad’s marriage to your mum? And whether your stepmom was already an alcoholic when your dad married her?

FuckityFuckBollocks · 28/01/2024 09:20

My step-mum is an alcoholic and after many years of her plying my dad with wine he’s gone the same way now too. He is very passive, conflict avoidant too and seems to be totally codependent.

I totally get how you feel about the fact he’s put her alcoholism before the rest of the family. It’s shit, it really really is.

Ultimately, it may you closer together with your siblings. Can your brother live with you?

AlAnon is probably worth trying too, I really should try to get some extra support too.

Willmafrockfit · 28/01/2024 09:19

i think you just need to be strong for your db
be an ear for him and a place for him , he needs to chose whether to go back or what

user14699084789 · 28/01/2024 09:19

Gosh OP what a lot to be dealing with!
I’m an only child, of two only children, and I’ve made a bit of a hobby of studying other families habits having little of my own!
And my conclusion is often that people put up with utterly appalling behaviour that causes much unhappiness “because Family…” well, you don’t have to! Would you keep in contact with friends or neighbours that behaved like this? That bring misery and unhappiness at every turn? No, of course you wouldn’t.

Your Brother is lucky to have you, get him out of there and the older one too if possible. I’d let your Dad visit at your home if you want to keep contact with him, but I’d never be setting eyes on your StepM again in your shoes!

PinkDevon · 28/01/2024 09:17

You’re a good sister OP!

justasking111 · 28/01/2024 09:15

If your brother doesn't go to the police do it on his behalf. Get it logged. It's time to go nuclear for your dad's sake.

My dad finally escaped my mother. Had 15 quiet years before he died. He left instructions we weren't to tell her he was ill or when his funeral was. She didn't find out for three months then went mad when she did wanting to know where the money was.

RedStripeypillow · 28/01/2024 09:00

You sound really lovely and don't deserve this at all. Your little brother is very lucky to have you and you are no doubt the maternal figure that he needs in his life.
Sounds like you and the other siblings just need to detach and let them get on with it. Pull together to help the younger brothers to leave and do the same. Letting go will be the hardest but I believe it will become easier with time and you will find peace eventually.

RonObvious · 28/01/2024 08:58

lostontheunderground89 · 28/01/2024 04:45

@Tilllly

AA (alcoholics anonymous) is fundamentally a cult where you have to believe in a 'higher power' to recover. So for a lot of alcoholics (myself included - I recovered by myself) it's not a suitable recovery route.

AA is not a cult. It works for many people (myself included). It isn’t always the best answer for everyone though, and I’m glad you found another solution.

OP I’m going to add another vote for your half-brother reporting this to the police. I can’t believe your Dad is brushing this off!

Purplehat123 · 28/01/2024 08:58

read the book ‘Adult children of emotionally immature parents’ - it’s life changing!

My mum is the same with my dad - no matter how emotionally abusive he is or how many people/family members cut her out because they can no longer deal with him, she still stays no matter what.

and I truly never understood why she always chose him over everyone - including her own children and grandchildren.

The section in the book about ‘passive parents’ let me finally understand why she is the way she is and helped me come to terms with the fact she was never going to chose me and that in turn led me to finally cut contact and be free of the pair of them without any guilt.

your father is just as guilty as this awful woman - he is the adult and he is the one who supposed to protect his children. His behaviour is selfish to the core.

theleafandnotthetree · 28/01/2024 08:54

chosenone · 28/01/2024 07:47

Also it’s one disease where the ‘sufferer’ has the cure! They have the key to stop it all! As difficult as it will be and they have to want to etc… not the same for diseases such as cancer. Enablement just makes it worse for everyone,

You’ve done amazingly here OP and thank god your db has you. Police involvement and all of you explaining that you’re stepping away surely has to be the next step.

Exactly, they have the capacity to stop the disease either through stopping drinking or taking their own life to end everyone's else's misery if they can't stop. OP I would feel zero guilt for wishing this awful woman dead, you can have mental health problems and also be a terrible person. This seems to be the case here. Your father I would judge just as if not more harshly, that he allowed 2 more children to be born into this shitshow is actually unbelievable.

Emotionalsupportviper · 28/01/2024 08:53

lostontheunderground89 · 28/01/2024 04:45

@Tilllly

AA (alcoholics anonymous) is fundamentally a cult where you have to believe in a 'higher power' to recover. So for a lot of alcoholics (myself included - I recovered by myself) it's not a suitable recovery route.

Nonsense!

There are many atheist/ agnostic member of AA.

What the organisation does ask people to recognise is that they are in the grip of an addiction that they aren't strong enough to fight alone.

People are asked to recognise a "higher power" but it isn't necessarily God if you don't believe. It can be the organisation itself, the support of other members, or even your own inner strength that can emerge when you are in a supportive environment.

It is not a "cult".

IVbumble · 28/01/2024 08:49

@NewbieSM one of the best things I did to help in a long term difficult alcoholic situation was to attend a local Al-anon group.

I was so so scared to go because I thought somehow I had failed by not being able to fix the situation even though I had tried & tried but nothing had worked. I was exhausted with the responsibility of it all & the weight I felt on my back for so long.

I almost didn't go in but just making that first step completely changed my life & today I am so grateful to my younger self for accepting that I needed support.

Mikimoto · 28/01/2024 08:45

DB gets repaid TWICE his savings or goes straight to the police.

MrsMoastyToasty · 28/01/2024 08:44

Don't repay your brother from your own savings. If your SM had stolen from a stranger, she would be up in court for theft. Why should the fact that it has happened within the family mean its any different? Actions have consequences.

alittleprivacy · 28/01/2024 08:39

lostontheunderground89 · 28/01/2024 04:45

@Tilllly

AA (alcoholics anonymous) is fundamentally a cult where you have to believe in a 'higher power' to recover. So for a lot of alcoholics (myself included - I recovered by myself) it's not a suitable recovery route.

I'd add that the same is essentially true of al-anon. It was one of the worst things I could have done when living with an alcoholic husband. I was actively discouraged from leaving him when he was at his worst. To just believe in him when he was in recovery while actively being discouraged from taking any steps to even protect myself financially. Even after I left him when he relapsed massively after DS was born, I had an actual psychiatrist tell me I should accept him and stay with him.

Recovering from severe addiction is incredibly difficult. Loving someone who is addicted is in many ways worse. But the whole industry that exists to supposedly help those people is the type of anti-therapy that makes everything much harder.

5128gap · 28/01/2024 08:33

I don't know whether this is of any comfort to you, but the dad you love is as broken and as damaged as his wife. His life will have been the sort of hell that no emotionally healthy person chooses. No one sets out thinking its a good use of their one precious life to live with and enable an alcoholic, losing everything else in the process. His codependency makes him as sick as she is.

Please know, I'm not excusing him, his treatment of you and your brother is unforgivable, but you asked how can he do it, and I think that is how.

On a practical level, I think its time for you to detach for the sake of your own wellbeing. The first part of that is acceptance, and training yourself not to expect anything different. This is the father you have. What level of relationship can you have going forward that protects you from further harm and gives you space to heal? It may be the odd conversation, it may be nothing at all. But you decide that, because that's the part you do control.

If you can, keep your brothers savings for him and give him a safe haven. You have each other and that's worth a great deal.

Bluetrews25 · 28/01/2024 08:27

It's not a disease.
It's an addiction. That started with a conscious choice to drink.

If she's been drinking at that level for that long then her liver will start to give up very, very soon IME.
Sorry.
She is never going to stop.
Does your DF drink too? (this was the way with PILs who both died of alcohol related issues)
Can your brother cycle from yours to work/school?
Sending a hug through the ether. Alcoholism is horrible to watch.

Soundofthebeat · 28/01/2024 08:26

Lovely OP, sorry to read this, I have a very similar story but it was my alcoholic bio mother and enabler father. Similar stories of cleaning up vomit, her smashing the house up in temper and he just buried his head in the sand and as the eldest I had to become his helper and confidante.

Ruined myself and my brothers childhood and the damage has lasted years. My mother eventually died and my father within weeks moved another woman into his house. She wasn’t an addict but was a nasty, bitchy piece of work who hated the close relationship us kids had with our father. Similarly to you, when I confronted him he blew up and told me to get out and never speak to him again.

Yet again he chose his ‘woman’ over his kids.
incredibly painful but he again showed his true colours and I did exactly what he wanted. I’ve not spoken to him for 8 years. I hope the bed he’s made for himself is very comfortable. He’s a weak, pathetic man who has no right to be in mine or my children’s lives.

As hard as it will be, let your father sink with her, cut or go very low contact. You siblings will be good support for one another. Let your father’s choices pave the way for his future, he will have to look after his wife and himself as they get older. They don’t deserve any of you. Good luck

Ginandjuice57884 · 28/01/2024 08:25

Find yourself and your siblings some support. I just had a quick look and Smart recovery have a presence in Australia and appear to offer online meetings. Look for the youths only ones, and the ones for friends and family.

Sceptre86 · 28/01/2024 08:23

He will always choose her over you. You can love your dad as much as you want but that doesn't mean he will return it and is worthy of being called 'dad'. I always find posts like this hard because kids from families like yours always struggle to cut ties because they still blindly love their parents. He enabled her allowing your childhood to go to pot and has done so with 7 children. 7 young people who's lives have been impacted by an alcoholic. The only way you will be completely free of the mess is to cut ties with your stepmother and parent. Hard as it will undoubtedly be you will never get the relationship you want.

I'd let your dvro know he can stay at yours should he want to but you won't be engaging with the step mum and your dad. It's up to him if he decides to contact the police.

Swipe left for the next trending thread