Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So very sad, can't believe he has chosen her

208 replies

NewbieSM · 28/01/2024 02:09

Sorry for the late long post, I am in Australia but don't really have many people to talk to about this and am feeling very low today.

I've just had a massive fight with my Dad about his wife's drinking problem and he essentially kicked me out of his house and told me to never come back.

Back story: My step mother is an alcoholic has been for 35 years, she made my childhood an absolute nightmare, physical and mental abuse, stealing money from me, destroying expensive items like phones, passports (multiple times) to stop me from visiting my mum overseas. She would get black out drunk almost everyday, pass out and piss the bed so when I got home from school my younger siblings and I would have to drag her down the hall in to the shower to clean her up. She was arrested 3 times for drunk driving, once with all us kids in the car, I remember all of us crying and me screaming at the police to leave her alone as he drove us and our car to police station. I was 11. My Dad is a classic conflict avoidant type personality and always brushed it under the rug, made excuses for her, stuck his head in the sand basically.

Fast forward to today, I get a call my from 17 year old half brother, he's really upset and nearly in tears, he's just logged into his online banking and his mum has wiped his account of all his savings from his part time job. She's stolen his atm card, just like she did to me multiple times 10 years ago.

I'm fuming, so I drive over there to comfort my brother and confront her and my Dad. DB is so so upset, he's been saving up for a car for nearly 2 years and she's gone and fucked it all up. I tell DB to get in my car while I talk to Dad, the stupid bitch is hiding out in her room so she doesn't have to face the music, typical. Dad was so dismissive of me, kept saying it's not her fault this is the disease, we need to support family blah blah blah I'll replace the money. That's just not good enough imo, he needs to kick her the fuck out, she needs rehab not enabling. I told him he is risking his relationship with all of his kids for a woman who doesn't deserve it and he needs to make the right choice. He blew up me, told to keep my nose out of it, who did I think I was to lecture him and issue ultimatums and I was "emotionally bankrupt". He told me to get out of his house and don't bother coming back.

I've taken my brother to my house and set him up in the spare room to cool off for a couple days, but I am so upset at how my Dad spoke to me. Even though I am a 30 year old woman I am still his first born child, I can't believe he has chosen her over me AGAIN. He had a second chance to do things differently with my two younger brothers but he hasn't learned and has now fucked up two more people's mental health. I'm so done with it all but I can't imagine a life without my Dad who I still love very much. What do I do now Mumsnet, how do I move on?

OP posts:
Fancylike · 28/01/2024 11:14

Really feel for you, your stepmom sounds exactly like my half-sister. No one could help her and she destroyed every relationship she had. Luckily her husband had more of a backbone and protected their kids and moved her out into a rehab. But it didn’t help, she hooked up with other addicts there then ended up drinking herself to death in a public park.

You just have to be there for your half-siblings and mentally relive your father from the equation. He’s not a good dad and a selfish person who has ignored your pain.

NewbieSM · 28/01/2024 11:14

Thank you everyone for the replies, I know you are all right. It's easy to say just cut him off, but my Dad really isn't all bad. As kid I watched how much he struggled looking after so many young kids and dealing with her. It wasn't always terrible sometimes we knew she was drunk but Dad just let her sleep it off her in her room and we got on with it.

I think he confided in me as a teen because he has great shame about it and because of her addiction has become quite socially isolated. I used to be pleased that he treated me as an adult when having these conversations but I see now that he was manipulating me to keep me onside.

He has done a lot to try and stop her drinking, she doesn't ever have any money, anything she needs he will buy but he has to be there with her to pay for it. She doesn't work or drive anymore as she can't be trusted. She's a total liability and he has put these restrictions in place to prevent her accessing booze. This is why she steals, because there is no other way for her to fund her habit. He has infantilised her to try and protect her and it totally fucked us over in the end. She doesn't drink as much as she used to because of this but when she does it's pretty bad.

My sister has called my Dad and told him to transfer the stolen funds today, wife should still have cash on her there's no way she spent it all, he needs to find it and give it back to my brother. The card has been cancelled and I'll help my brother open a new account at a different bank with only his name on it. I do think my Dad will pay it back like a previous poster said, he wants us to all forget about this and keep pretending everything is fine.

Don't want to make any concrete plans until my brother is a bit more settled, he knows he can always stay here if he needs and we can work something out with school and his job, yes if he gets paid back we could chip in a bit more for a car and insurance and he could drive himself.

OP posts:
Grammarnut · 28/01/2024 11:13

She is an alcoholic who needs help. But the help must come from her wanting to cease to drink. Your DF could - and perhaps is - move her towards this but only an alcoholic can decide to move out of their particular hell. Sadly, this impacts on you and on your DB. You can help your DB and also support your father in trying to sort out your DSM - if that is possible. Please don't be upset about what you said. You also need to support yourself and your DSs.

alltoomuchrightnow · 28/01/2024 11:07

Yes, Al Anon call it a disease.. a family disease. I went to them for two years.
There were plenty of athesists too. Higher power can mean what you want it to mean.
The only thing I had issue with was encouragement to do the Twelve Steps, which I didn't. I think I posted about it on here at the time. I don't understand why non drinkers like me were encouraged to do so. My then fiance certainly wasnt... he refused to attend AA, saying he'd rather die (which, he did)...
Apart from that, it was an amazing place, I ended up going four nights a week, it gave me a safe place to cry, share, rant..

CleansUpButWouldPreferNotTo · 28/01/2024 10:58

I'm so sorry for you and your siblings, all of them. What a mother to have, and your dad just keeps enabling her while ignoring what's happening to the children.

You are an amazing big sister! May I suggest you sit your brother down and tell him in detail about when she stole from you and how you were persuaded to let it go, then tell him that for her sake, she needs a 'short sharp shock' for her own good and theft charges plus a visit from the police will do this. Tell him you're behind him all the way - he already knows this but it'll be good to have it said again - and get him to press charges.

Then maybe both her and your dad will wake up. Sending both of you warm wishes..

Sapphire387 · 28/01/2024 10:53

Honestly, I think one of the best things you can do is help give your half-brothers some sort of sense of normality and stability by having them in your home as much as possible (not saying they have to live there) and presenting a different example to this shitshow you have all grown up with.

All three of you need to distance yourselves from them both. Your dad is an enabler, perhaps he's in denial, who knows? But while he's enabling her, honestly I believe the best thing you could do is walk away. Sorry, I know it doesn't feel that simple because he's your dad.

As for her... she's beyond help. I don't buy all this 'alcoholism is an illness' stuff. People DO have a choice, hard as that choice may be. I think my view is coloured by my husband's experiences with an alcoholic dad (he's NC with him) and then growing up to have an alcoholic partner (DSD's so-called mother) who abused alcohol and drank herself to death. Unless she's willing to help herself, nobody can help her and you're best off as far away as possible.

senua · 28/01/2024 10:44

Is DBro due some wages, at the month-end? Ask his employer (pronto) not to put the money in the compromised bank account.

BusyMummyWrites01 · 28/01/2024 10:36

Could you and DB report your SM for theft? She’d have to face the consequences and the court may agree to give her a suspended sentence if she goes into rehab - and then your dad can’t avoid the situation any more?

Sometimes addicts have to reach rock bottom before they get help - and their enablers have to be forced to step back. It sounds as though, as a couple, they need an intervention as he is as much responsible for her sickness and the impact it has on you and your siblings?

Snowdogsmitten · 28/01/2024 10:30

I hope on his lonely deathbed your father is overwhelmed by shame and sorrow at allowing his long-dead wife to abuse, torture and steal from his children, over and over again.

Rosscameasdoody · 28/01/2024 10:22

As others have said, your dad is enabling what sounds like a very serious addiction if she has resorted to drinking hand gel. If he’s been doing it for 35 years there really isn’t much chance of talking him round to getting her some help now. The long standing addiction will be taking its toll on her health by now, so it’s likely some sort of health related event will bring things to a head anyway.

I think you ought to inform your dad that if the money isn’t paid back into your brothers’ account pronto, you will go to the police. Then tell him you think it’s time for contact to be cut between them, you and your brother, as you don’t want to be dragged into a situation which clearly isn’t going to end well.

AColdDarkWinter · 28/01/2024 10:22

I'm so sorry, OP. My childhood was similar and I know exactly what it's like -- how that level of insanity just becomes normal to you. Your story about the bottles really resonated with me. I've been there. I remember being the last child at school to be picked up by my (drunken) father after a drama club meeting, and hiding in the bushes in the dark so that no one would realise he was hours late. Another time I poured half his vodka bottle down the sink and refilled it with water. I remember how furious I was when I did it (aged 10 or so). He never mentioned it, though he must have noticed. The kicker? He was a psychiatrist.

From experience, if you want a relationship with your father I'm sure you'll still be able to have one, once everyone's emotions have calmed a bit. He'd be only too happy to sweep all this under the rug and never mention it again. The question is, do you want one? He'll never change. He's too enmired in the fog of enabling her. I'm sorry. It sucks.

Bless you for being there for your brother. He desperately needs some stability and people he can count on. The pain of this kind of betrayal from your parents, the two people who are supposed to take care of you, cuts very deep. Take care, OP. You're making all the difference in the world to him. x

32degrees · 28/01/2024 10:21

Sorry, I meant Youth Allowance, not Ausstudy.

srcusyd.net.au/src-help/caseworker-help/centrelink/centrelink-independence/

StandardLFinegan · 28/01/2024 10:19

Drinking is a distraction from issues that the alcoholic cannot face.

This is (more or less verbatim) from Instagram but it’s very true:

“Pain travels through families until someone is willing to stop and actually look at the problem and challenge it, instead of deluding themselves, pretending everything is going ok, or distracting themselves with drink, drugs, gaming, or another addiction”

32degrees · 28/01/2024 10:17

OP, has your brother contacted the bank to alert them that the money has been stolen?

How was she able to access it? The bank may have to replace it.

I'd also call Centrelink and see what options there may be for your brother if he was to become independent of his parents now. He may be eligible for ausstudy or similar and not have to work so many hours.

Centrelink may also be able to link him in with services that support him.

FizzyStream · 28/01/2024 10:15

ILikeMySpace · 28/01/2024 07:29

I hate the idea that it's a disease .. cancer is a disease ffs

I totally agree.

I think it is more appropriate to say it is a mental health issue. You don't find happy, balanced people drinking in this way. A disease isn't something you inflict on yourself. I don't feel sorry for your SM, but I do think she needs drastic measures to stop her drinking, if not just for others sake.

As a recovering alcoholic I agree it isn't a disease. This gives the power to some unknown entity when it's ourselves that are choosing to drink; even if that is guided by a mental health issue. In my case my undiagnosed ADHD was making my life a misery and the only way I felt I could socialise was with a drink and then that got totally out of hand.

I may be wrong but I think AA go down the "it's a disease route". I chose not to go to AA as I didn't believe in their values and have managed to stay sober for years now luckily.
A lot of successful recovery comes from education and the correct mental health support but the person has to be 100% invested and it's not easy.

Whoopaday · 28/01/2024 10:12

I would go to the police, but be aware they will involve social services which is what I think needs to happen, especially if he lives with you. You might be able to get help with school transport and he might get access to funding or help when he reached 18. It’s not a bad thing and it shows how serious you are about him living with you.

Cherrysoup · 28/01/2024 10:09

Your dad is a hopeless case. My dad was the same, enabling my mother’s drinking all of my life. The only thing you can do is support your brothers, try to get them out, set them up independently and keep them away from their parents, unfortunately. I’d definitely encourage him to report the theft, she needs consequences, as does your dad, who doesn’t seem to take her actions seriously.

Imbusytodaysorry · 28/01/2024 10:07

Your db needs to report this theft to the police .
He needs to also move out as soon as is possible .
This is a toxic situation for him in fact an it’s mega toxic for you all. Time to move on in life your dad didn’t chose his wife over you tonight he chose her over all you kids many many years ago.

Get Counseling and let go of the past .

32degrees · 28/01/2024 10:03

Which state are you in OP?

Reporting the theft might be the best thing anyone can do for her.

With this offence plus her drink driving she'll present to court with a clear history of an alcohol problem. If she gets a good legal aid lawyer they might be able to negotiate a diversion or alcohol education program. Then she'd have to do it, and it would make the stakes higher if she reoffended.

I'm so sorry for you OP. It's incredibly unfair for you and your siblings.

Your brother is lucky to have you.

TheSnakeCharmer · 28/01/2024 10:02

I'm surprised that she's still alive after 35 years of drinking that much. She almost certainly won't be for much longer. My sister has end stage liver failure after drinking heavily for 20 years. My parents were also alcohol dependent. I am so sorry that you have had such a shitty upbringing. I don't know the situation with your mother, but I am also sorry that she didn't intervene and that you didn't live with her instead.

I would write your dad a letter. I would explain that, whilst alcoholism is a disease, he is enabling his wife's condition and that, as a result, she will almost certainly not be alive for much longer. You could include information on the reality of liver failure and what happens when your liver fails and information on how to get her liver assessed and seek help.
You could say that you feel very sad that he is yet again putting her over his children and that you have decided to step back. You could point out that, if she continues to drink and things don't change, he will one day find himself on his own.

He's putting her first now because she is so vulnerable, but when you were younger, you were also very vulnerable and shouldn't have been put in that situation.

There's a great book on understanding addiction called "understanding and helping an addict" by Dr Andrew proulx. It's worth reading. It's helped me understand my sister and her behaviours more, but also given advice on how not to enable and how to protect your own emotions. It's helped me to refuse a lot of my anger and frustration. I'm more understanding of my sister's behaviour, but equally aware of how not to enable it. I would get it, have a read and then send it to your Dad. He can't just keep burying his head in the sand over this.

Windymcwindyson · 28/01/2024 10:01

Well surely if it is an illness and df isn't seeking help for her he is assisting her suicide? Can't think how she is even still alive..

Willmafrockfit · 28/01/2024 09:59

senua · 28/01/2024 09:51

I think that you need to step back a bit, OP. Your Dad will see this as you interfering, projecting your problems onto your DBro and therefore not listen; you need impartial, external input.

Does your DBro's school have a pastoral team who can help?

good advice

JFDIYOLO · 28/01/2024 09:53

I'm so sorry. Drug addicts will do anything to get their fix, and relationships come a distant second.

She is in the gutter and why he would choose her over everyone else is a mystery.

But he has.

Probably guilt, love, pity, shame and more, all scrambled together.

Your bro is so lucky to have you, your DH is supportive and it seems there is good communication with the family otherwise. Are you in contact with mum and sister? I'd be going all out to strengthen all those relationships because they'll be there for the future ... which the previous generation won't.

She has stolen your brother's money, which he saved through hard work and plans for the future.

Family pressure on the pair of them to pay him back. A clear, consistent message from you all to them. He's chosen her so he's enabled her and should be doing the paying - sounds like she hasn't got a bean. Your bro must get his money and his dream back.

JMSA · 28/01/2024 09:53

I am FURIOUS on your behalf FlowersFlowersFlowers

StockpotSoup · 28/01/2024 09:52

I'm so done with it all but I can't imagine a life without my Dad who I still love very much. What do I do now Mumsnet, how do I move on?

This is what he’s relying on, I’m afraid. He’s managed to talk you out of reporting your stepmother to the police on more than one occasion; he knows you don’t want to give up on a relationship with him and your siblings, so he brushes things under the carpet and hopes you’ll eventually give in and do the same.

I think the time has come to call his bluff. Don’t get in contact; ignore any attempts at contact. I’m not denying that it will be very hard, but at the moment, he thinks he can get away with this behaviour because you always give in and come back. You need to stand firm and make him realise he’s at a genuine risk of losing you forever.

Swipe left for the next trending thread