Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So very sad, can't believe he has chosen her

208 replies

NewbieSM · 28/01/2024 02:09

Sorry for the late long post, I am in Australia but don't really have many people to talk to about this and am feeling very low today.

I've just had a massive fight with my Dad about his wife's drinking problem and he essentially kicked me out of his house and told me to never come back.

Back story: My step mother is an alcoholic has been for 35 years, she made my childhood an absolute nightmare, physical and mental abuse, stealing money from me, destroying expensive items like phones, passports (multiple times) to stop me from visiting my mum overseas. She would get black out drunk almost everyday, pass out and piss the bed so when I got home from school my younger siblings and I would have to drag her down the hall in to the shower to clean her up. She was arrested 3 times for drunk driving, once with all us kids in the car, I remember all of us crying and me screaming at the police to leave her alone as he drove us and our car to police station. I was 11. My Dad is a classic conflict avoidant type personality and always brushed it under the rug, made excuses for her, stuck his head in the sand basically.

Fast forward to today, I get a call my from 17 year old half brother, he's really upset and nearly in tears, he's just logged into his online banking and his mum has wiped his account of all his savings from his part time job. She's stolen his atm card, just like she did to me multiple times 10 years ago.

I'm fuming, so I drive over there to comfort my brother and confront her and my Dad. DB is so so upset, he's been saving up for a car for nearly 2 years and she's gone and fucked it all up. I tell DB to get in my car while I talk to Dad, the stupid bitch is hiding out in her room so she doesn't have to face the music, typical. Dad was so dismissive of me, kept saying it's not her fault this is the disease, we need to support family blah blah blah I'll replace the money. That's just not good enough imo, he needs to kick her the fuck out, she needs rehab not enabling. I told him he is risking his relationship with all of his kids for a woman who doesn't deserve it and he needs to make the right choice. He blew up me, told to keep my nose out of it, who did I think I was to lecture him and issue ultimatums and I was "emotionally bankrupt". He told me to get out of his house and don't bother coming back.

I've taken my brother to my house and set him up in the spare room to cool off for a couple days, but I am so upset at how my Dad spoke to me. Even though I am a 30 year old woman I am still his first born child, I can't believe he has chosen her over me AGAIN. He had a second chance to do things differently with my two younger brothers but he hasn't learned and has now fucked up two more people's mental health. I'm so done with it all but I can't imagine a life without my Dad who I still love very much. What do I do now Mumsnet, how do I move on?

OP posts:
SnozPoz · 29/01/2024 18:24

It sounds like a lot was said in the heat of the moment. Give it time for everyone to cool off and then see where you're at. I'd be surprised if your dad doesn't reach out to you. Maybe this argument was needed for him to do something about the situation? I'm sorry you've had to go through all this

StaunchMomma · 29/01/2024 18:23

I think it's time to accept that your step Mum isn't the only person who abused you as a child, OP. Your Dad has stood by and allowed her to abuse all of his children over many years. That in itself is also abuse.

He has protected her over all of you and facilitated her cruelty and neglect knowingly. You would be well within your rights to cut both of them out of your life and concentrate on your siblings.

I'm so sorry you've been through all of that. If there are other siblings in the house of a younger age, I would seriously consider reporting them to SS. It's dreadful that no adults in your life did the same for you.

Well done for standing up for your brother, OP.

DriftingDora · 29/01/2024 18:13

I'm so sorry for this awful situation affecting you and your siblings, OP. From the sound of her - and the fact that your Dad is enabling her behaviour - she wouldn't co-operate with any agencies who help alcoholics (not sure what you might have in Australia), so I'd guess this would be a waste of time.

I think the poster above who spoke about a co-dependent relationship might be spot on. Why the hell does your Dad think this is acceptable behaviour and that her needing support for alcoholism trumps your brother being entitled to not have his savings stolen? It's foul - and I hope your brother has been to the police to report the theft? If not, he should do so asap. Edited to say: and in future your brother should put his money in an account she doesn't know about and keep all access to it away from her thieving paws.

Does she take Dad's money and spend it on drink too or does she just nick her stepchildren's? She sounds a right piece of work and I would put as much distance between you as you can, for your own sanity, as you never know what she'll do next. She certainly proves the saying 'you can choose your friends, but you're stuck with your family'. Sadly, unless your Dad wakes up and smells the coffee, she'll continue to try to get away with her outrageous actions and make everyone else suffer. Is there anyone else in the family you could talk to?

cremebrulait · 29/01/2024 18:04

Reminds me of my childhood!

Who is the signor? Did she steal his card? Call the police. Call the bank.

middle finger to her!!!!
he’s clearly going to need that money.

Calliopespa · 29/01/2024 18:02

LunaNorth · 28/01/2024 02:21

You were absolutely right to say what you did, and your brother is lucky to have you.

Your dad will have his reasons for siding with his wife. I’m not saying he’s right - he might be in a co-dependent relationship with your SM, he might love her beyond all reason, he might feel somehow responsible for her - who knows?

The point is, sadly we can’t control other people and make them behave the way we want them to, or the way they should. We can only control ourselves and the way we behave - and it sounds as if you are doing a great job at that.

It’s your dad’s loss. It sounds like he’s doing a great job of driving away all the people in his life who would be the greatest help to him. You told him things he didn’t want to hear and he blew up because he knows you’re right.

You might find that he’ll realise that and reach out one day, or he might not. Either way, I think you might need to distance yourself for your own sake. He’s only ever going to hurt and disappoint you while he’s still in denial about his wife’s condition and behaviour.

It sounds as if your brother is going to need some extra support long-term. Are you in a position to give that to him?

Edited

I think this about sums it up OP.

I’m sorry about the situation. It sounds complicated and I understand the hurt of him “ choosing” her but at this point I don’t think it’s because she is so heavenly 😇. There’s something far more complex - probably guilt that he hasn’t been able to stop her reducing herself to this pitiful state. He is probably able to be tougher on you because he knows you are more altogether . That doesn’t make it fair but I hope it maybe makes it a little less hurtful to see it that way.

Givemethereins · 29/01/2024 18:02

It sounds like you took on the role of parent as a child,.to your dad. This would have been a survival technique in order to get love.
However your relationship was never a proper parental one and the relationship you have with him now is probably mostly you holding on to him for fear of abandonment.
He already abandoned you a long time ago.
It's time to let him go. Maybe stop holding onto what you think of as your relationship to him.
Set your boundaries and priorities. Seek therapy and counselling.
This can't be done alone.

senua · 29/01/2024 08:40

I think it is time to go nuclear.
The youngest DC is coming up 18 y.o. It's hardly worth going nuclear now.

Do the best for youngest DBro to help launch him into adult life; leave father and mother/step-mother to fend for themselves.

Devonshiregal · 28/01/2024 21:29

Keep your brothers - move their schools. I’m be the best thing for you and them even if tough and not to the plan. You can be a proper family.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 28/01/2024 20:42

What do you do? Say your DB will be staying with you for a few days until the money is paid back. I know it will be a pain due to school, but for a few days it is surely manageable?

If DB goes back, make a deal you will pick him up anywhere at any time no questions asked if he feels he needs it.

You said social services is the nuclear option, but seem to think contacting to police would be less of a problem? And that your dad is a good guy just weak. I dont want to sound critical and your dad sounds like a decent guy but his weakness in excusing and downplaying her behaviour is at the expense of the children in the family and that is most definitely not a good thing to do. I think it is time to go nuclear. Clearly what he is doing is not working, and she has no motivation to change, so something has to be different.

ThreeLocusts · 28/01/2024 19:47

OP speaking as the child of an out of control father and a mother struggling to cope, I wish I'd had a sister like you. It's great what you're doing for your brother.

Don't kick yourself for the choices you made as a child. You were child. Hats off for having become a more than functional adult regardless.

Mrsgreen100 · 28/01/2024 19:11

k1233 · 28/01/2024 03:07

Make your father give your brother his money today.

Then go to the police and press charges for theft.

This today !

Golden407 · 28/01/2024 19:00

k1233 · 28/01/2024 03:07

Make your father give your brother his money today.

Then go to the police and press charges for theft.

What sort of advice is this? Her father has already said he'll replace the money, how exactly is she going to "make" him do it today, even if she could what would it achieve?
How can she press charges for theft? No ones stolen anything from her. That would be her brother, maybe he doesn't want to press charges against her mother? Does he get a say?

There's no simple advice in a situation like this. Stay calm, logical and support her brother, that's about it

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 28/01/2024 18:52

I had a father and a brother who were alcoholics, OP so your posts resonate deeply. Your brother is so lucky to have you. As others have said, make sure you look after you. We parentified children have a tendency to feel responsible for the world and its woes and the resultant stress and anxiety can make us feel overwhelmed.

💐💕

ScierraDoll · 28/01/2024 18:05

❤

bonzaitree · 28/01/2024 15:58

I would go no contact with the pair of them.

My brother I would arrange regular meet ups with him.

puffinhoarder · 28/01/2024 15:14

perfectstorm · 28/01/2024 11:55

OP, have you ever heard of a form of abuse known as 'parentification'?

Your father has abused you. He turned you into the adult partner helping him support his infantilised alcoholic wife.

He is in a co-dependent relationship with her and he has thrown all of you kids under the bus to maintain that relationship. He's no better than she is, I'm afraid.

You, on the other hand, have managed to build a life despite them, and are now supporting your baby bro. I don't know how you managed to emerge from a childhood like yours in one piece but hats off.

You deserved so much better, and so does your baby brother. Frankly, I don't think he should return at all. But that's a huge ask for you, and not one you owe anyone.

This is really insightful and I would echo this.

I had to do a lot of work to untangle my feelings towards my dad because I thought of him as her victim like me. Which he was in many ways, but he also had the agency and means to leave when I did not. And he chose to keep us in the situation.

I really feel for you and your siblings and hope you find a way through this.

Minfilia · 28/01/2024 15:02

Your dad is utterly spineless and has failed all his kids.

Your poor DB! Reading everything you’ve said, I have no idea why you want a relationship with him or his wife.

JFDIYOLO · 28/01/2024 14:05

Sadly it's likely that one day he'll be alone, having alienated all his children, and future grandchildren, too. And for what.

user1492757084 · 28/01/2024 12:57

You did the right thing.
Your Dad needs to replace that money within a set time.
No one is safe living there with her.
You could help your brothers fool proof their banking and valuables. Would your father agree to them having a lock for their rooms? A section of the house where their mother just cannot gain entrance?
They also need a safe space that is available for them at short notice.
Your father does need to be the only one living with that drunk woman who is affected by her.
Hopefully he will brain storm with you about how to control sections of the house just for the boys.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 28/01/2024 12:15

poopoolala · 28/01/2024 06:59

I hate the idea that it's a disease .. cancer is a disease ffs .

My dad was an alcoholic and he chose the bottle over us ..

It's so sad 😞.

I think it's medically acknowledged that alcoholism is a disease. Saying not to drink is akin to telling an anorexic just to eat.

I have no words for the OP - unbelievably awful for her and I can but admire her resilience

Highfivemum · 28/01/2024 12:13

Reading your post is heart wrenching. I feel for all of you. yes it is a disease but to carry on with heads in the sand like your dad just enables the user. It is your Dad who needs to be the one to challenge her and make decisions that will stop enabling her to carry on. This has triggered a lot of emotions for me. I can’t say to much for fear of outing but I understand totally where you are coming from. Sadly you need to move away from your Dad. Concentrate on your DB and if and when your Dad sees sense he may come looking for you.
stay strong and trust your instincts. Best wishes.

Bracksonsboss · 28/01/2024 12:11

NewbieSM · 28/01/2024 03:12

Thank you everyone for your responses, it helps me feel less alone.

Yes I would take my brother in a heartbeat but I'm not sure if that's what he wants. He is angry at his Mum but he still loves her of course, so he feels very conflicted. My other brother is 19, so technically still lives there but isn't home much between work, hobbies and his girlfriend.

Honestly as horrible as it sounds sometimes I wish she would do us all a favour and just drink enough to kill herself. I know that's wrong to think that and I've never said it out loud but it's how I feel.

I don't want social services to get involved plus not sure they would do much as my brother is only a year shy of 18. I reckon that would be the final nail in the coffin of my relationship with my Dad if I did.

I would like to file a police report for the theft of money and fraudulent use of DBs bank card, but that's my DBs decision and he is understandably reluctant to go with the nuclear option. Bloody hell I wish I went to the police when she did this to me, but Dad convinced me not to, of course Angry

Absolutely report it. It will be the only way she will get help as it will force your dad to acknowledge the issues as the decision is taken out of his hands. It is the only way to make this any better

tsmainsqueeze · 28/01/2024 11:56

This is such an awful situation and my heart goes out to you and your siblings.
Your brother is blessed to have you , you could be the anchor that keeps him on the right path for the rest of his life .
I think she really does sound like a lost cause , you and your siblings are the ones that matter now , let your dad do his own thing.
Take care of yourself now and get some therapy if you need it , you have done enough , far too much actually ,when you should have been the one being looked after.
I really hope things get better for you and your lovely brother , hopefully with your other siblings by your side .
But don't get any further involved with their disastrous lives , if neither of them choose to help themselves then your influence means nothing , put your energies into those that really matter .

perfectstorm · 28/01/2024 11:55

OP, have you ever heard of a form of abuse known as 'parentification'?

Your father has abused you. He turned you into the adult partner helping him support his infantilised alcoholic wife.

He is in a co-dependent relationship with her and he has thrown all of you kids under the bus to maintain that relationship. He's no better than she is, I'm afraid.

You, on the other hand, have managed to build a life despite them, and are now supporting your baby bro. I don't know how you managed to emerge from a childhood like yours in one piece but hats off.

You deserved so much better, and so does your baby brother. Frankly, I don't think he should return at all. But that's a huge ask for you, and not one you owe anyone.

StandardLFinegan · 28/01/2024 11:23

NewbieSM · 28/01/2024 11:14

Thank you everyone for the replies, I know you are all right. It's easy to say just cut him off, but my Dad really isn't all bad. As kid I watched how much he struggled looking after so many young kids and dealing with her. It wasn't always terrible sometimes we knew she was drunk but Dad just let her sleep it off her in her room and we got on with it.

I think he confided in me as a teen because he has great shame about it and because of her addiction has become quite socially isolated. I used to be pleased that he treated me as an adult when having these conversations but I see now that he was manipulating me to keep me onside.

He has done a lot to try and stop her drinking, she doesn't ever have any money, anything she needs he will buy but he has to be there with her to pay for it. She doesn't work or drive anymore as she can't be trusted. She's a total liability and he has put these restrictions in place to prevent her accessing booze. This is why she steals, because there is no other way for her to fund her habit. He has infantilised her to try and protect her and it totally fucked us over in the end. She doesn't drink as much as she used to because of this but when she does it's pretty bad.

My sister has called my Dad and told him to transfer the stolen funds today, wife should still have cash on her there's no way she spent it all, he needs to find it and give it back to my brother. The card has been cancelled and I'll help my brother open a new account at a different bank with only his name on it. I do think my Dad will pay it back like a previous poster said, he wants us to all forget about this and keep pretending everything is fine.

Don't want to make any concrete plans until my brother is a bit more settled, he knows he can always stay here if he needs and we can work something out with school and his job, yes if he gets paid back we could chip in a bit more for a car and insurance and he could drive himself.

Yes situations like this are always more nuanced than we can put in to words in a couple of paragraphs. I think everyone understands that op and despite your justified hurt, you sound like you have great insight in to your dad’s situation.

However, if I can indulge in some armchair psychology without any formal training whatsoever, 😀, I would urge you, very gently, to step back even further and not follow the example you have been set. It’s very unfair of me to accuse you of being like your father, because you are absolutely not, but it’s sometimes ingrained in us to follow the path our main carer has travelled. In other words, just be careful not to be too tolerant. It may be time to draw a line for your brothers’ sake if not your own.