Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS partner extremist views - how to handle

60 replies

entropynow · 27/01/2024 23:02

Getting more than a bit fed up with DSs partner ranting about various pro anarchist and similar subjects - any kind of political nuance is accepting global injustice, every conflict is goodies and baddies and no middle ground, frankly at times dehumanising those disagreed with, we should abandon Israel to their deserved fate, etc etc.

I'm broadly progressive, but this kind of thing brings to mind Pol Pot or the Cultural Revolution. This person is in their 30s ffs not a bloody student. DS roughly like me, moderate Labour type, just rolls his eyes, but partner appears to think I'm a suitable alternative audience bc ILs are Tories and just shout back. Can't really say just knock it off, however tempted, guests should be treated politely etc.

Any ideas, Aibu even to engage in good faith debate? Or just change the subject?

OP posts:
ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 28/01/2024 08:15

New house rule - anyone talking shit politics is on hoover duty/washing the dishes/ ironing.

Have it cross stitched and hang it in the kitchen if you have to.

boong121 · 28/01/2024 08:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Dotchange · 28/01/2024 08:09

Muthaofcats · 28/01/2024 07:38

So the definition of anti semetic then?

I wouldn’t welcome anyone with such disgusting views in my home.

How is being ‘anti what the state of Israel is doing’ anti- Semitic? I read that as they are any Israeli government?

But I digress. OP - just be clear and firm ‘ I don’t want to discuss this- we have very different views, so let’s leave it’. And just say it every time.

Muthaofcats · 28/01/2024 08:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Sorry but I’m not getting drawn into a debate with a racist. You think Jews first claim to the land was when the U.K. gave it to them? Your ignorance isn’t worth responding to. That’s not to say I support Netanyahu or the politics but what you are claiming is nothing to do with politics and just pure hatred of Israel as a concept. Anyone who thinks Israel is colonialism is supporting anti semitism. The ICJ literally just confirmed Israel has the right to defend itself from Hamas. It isn’t for you or I to determine whether that endeavour has been proportionate at every turn. It will take the court years to analyse the evidence but you’re so confident to take a punt yourself now? Based on what, tik tok and what your racist uncle says in the pub!?

i couldn’t follow your last point because it was incoherent but I think you were trying to say Stalin was a Jewish person, look at how evil Jewish people are? Something like that?

i am reporting you.

boong121 · 28/01/2024 07:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

boong121 · 28/01/2024 07:49

He is in his 30s, he is not a child who needs to be told off for having an opinion that differs from their parents.

Leave him to it, avoid subjects that will cause unnecessary arguments. What you or he thinks doesn't matter in the big picture.

Muthaofcats · 28/01/2024 07:38

entropynow · 27/01/2024 23:18

Not anti semitic, anti what State of Israel is doing. So am I but I try to understand why they're so afraid/ aggressive. DS partner just thinks they are a colonial project committing genocide, end of.

Edited

So the definition of anti semetic then?

I wouldn’t welcome anyone with such disgusting views in my home.

Lurkingandlearning · 28/01/2024 07:36

“New house rule, reviving old fashioned rule. Politics, religion and money are not suitable subjects for polite conversation.”

If they are impolite and and break the rule you can be impolite and tell them to shut the fuck up

Workwhat · 28/01/2024 06:49

entropynow · 27/01/2024 23:18

Not anti semitic, anti what State of Israel is doing. So am I but I try to understand why they're so afraid/ aggressive. DS partner just thinks they are a colonial project committing genocide, end of.

Edited

But the are?
You sound very apathetic and complacent. So it's hard to tell if they are actually a bit if a nightmare or they just think you don't give a shit.

While I probably agree with them on Israel, I think there's appropriate ways to engage in discussion and tbh if I felt somone didn't care I'd just leave it and judge them. But not everyone can do this, I've got some relatives like this and it is exhausting. But equally if you're all eyerolling about a genocide I think that is equally exhausting.

What are the other things they talk about? Are they coming at the Israeli think from a right wing perspective? That's an important distinction I think.

Irridescantshimmmer · 28/01/2024 04:25

There is a guy who lives on my street who is prone to heated discussions about politics, where he will just blow up into verbal aggressive yelling. He' s completely unhinged. I once saw him talking at someone from the intercom of a block of flats about capitalism. The tennant would not let him in his flat as he had more sense and I found the irony of it amusing.

WandaWonder · 28/01/2024 02:48

Don't know why these topics keep on coming up but if they do it just debate people

'They are here taking our jobs'
'Who is?, what is your source?, can you give an example of this?, how do you actually know this?' the usual kind of questions

'Covid immunisation is filled with tracking devices'
'Where is it located, is it invisible?, what colour is it?, who is employed to track what qualifications do you need?'

The intelligent levels of this conspiracy theorists is not that high

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 28/01/2024 02:41

@PyongyangKipperbang *yeah, I agree with this
that I do not discuss politics with any of my right wing family, and they with me. I would adopt the PP's fathers approach of saying "No, no politics in my house! We all have our own views and I do not want them voiced in my home. More tea anyone?"
More tea anyone,? Or "weather's warmed up a bit since past couple of days don't you think?"

PyongyangKipperbang · 28/01/2024 01:33

We have a "No Politics in the Pub" rule....which has been expanded to mean that I do not discuss politics with any of my right wing family, and they with me. I would adopt the PP's fathers approach of saying "No, no politics in my house! We all have our own views and I do not want them voiced in my home. More tea anyone?"

Grimchmas · 28/01/2024 01:07

Smile and nod with a "mmm".

Even more effective when you're busy doing something else like knitting, cooking or reading. Pick up a magazine if you have to. Leave the room if you have to ' "mmm. Oh is that the time, I'll go put the dinner on." "Mmm. Oh I know what I meant to show you, uncle dave sent this card from Peru.."!

She's looking for engagement or a rise. Be a bland agreeable wallflower, she'll soon get bored.

Fionaville · 28/01/2024 00:57

That was me with my FIL in my 30s (not the Israel topic) We really used to go at it. I cringe now remembering it! Now, I avoid discussing politics or current affairs, for the sake of peace. I think he secretly misses it and still tries to get a rise out of me. I just smile and nod. That shuts it down. I'd just leave the room everytime she starts. It'll soon stop. Don't hold it against her, some of us are still militant in our 30s. Some forever, but that's a different story.

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 28/01/2024 00:57

Not sure what this is about or what views pertaining to, but when it comes to bigots I've learned over the years to just shut down or ignore.
There's no reasoning or rational discussion with.

soupfiend · 28/01/2024 00:53

I wouldnt be discussing it at all or engaging, who wants to be railed at and ranted to in their own home

Presumably your son also feels somewhat the same, otherwise whats the attraction so not sure why you say he's rolling his eyes

Its boring and immature when its so poloarised

Plus Ive found over the years, extreme left wing views and extreme right wing views are often one and the same, they go so far round on each side they meet each other

WinterDeWinter · 28/01/2024 00:53

Mmm. Dyou know, I do think about this stuff a lot but sometimes I need to give it a break -it can be a bit overwhelming, like watching too much news. Tell me - what have you two been cooking/watching/ reading lately?

Lalalalala555 · 28/01/2024 00:51

Ask questions.
Ie do you see this subject as black and white or are there ways you see both sides having valid points.

Polite guests don't bring up politics.

Gloryloroliesjo · 28/01/2024 00:50

I have friends who are definitely right and quite bigoted. I just ignore,correct them or just change the subject!

ChiefEverythingOfficer · 28/01/2024 00:49

hoarahloux · 28/01/2024 00:46

Doesn't sound like you've attempted to listen to them at all.

Why should she Subject herself to this drivel.

Refer back to peaceful enjoyment of own home.

hoarahloux · 28/01/2024 00:46

Doesn't sound like you've attempted to listen to them at all.

TheSlantedOwl · 27/01/2024 23:50

Ask them very pointedly exactly what they are doing to support the causes they champion. What action are they taking because talking at others is just an attempt to dominate.

Ranting virtue signalling to a captive audience is pure fucking narcissism.

ChiefEverythingOfficer · 27/01/2024 23:45

entropynow · 27/01/2024 23:02

Getting more than a bit fed up with DSs partner ranting about various pro anarchist and similar subjects - any kind of political nuance is accepting global injustice, every conflict is goodies and baddies and no middle ground, frankly at times dehumanising those disagreed with, we should abandon Israel to their deserved fate, etc etc.

I'm broadly progressive, but this kind of thing brings to mind Pol Pot or the Cultural Revolution. This person is in their 30s ffs not a bloody student. DS roughly like me, moderate Labour type, just rolls his eyes, but partner appears to think I'm a suitable alternative audience bc ILs are Tories and just shout back. Can't really say just knock it off, however tempted, guests should be treated politely etc.

Any ideas, Aibu even to engage in good faith debate? Or just change the subject?

You can say knock it off.

Something along the lines of - you find the constant diatribe at odds with the peaceful enjoyment of your home (joking).

Just tell DS to ask them to not bring up politics as it's making you uncomfortable in your own home. His visitor, his problem.

Somatosensational · 27/01/2024 23:41

I wouldn’t enter a debate, it just feeds it. I’d change the subject or make excuses and leave the room.

Swipe left for the next trending thread