Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

War, conscription & fitness

62 replies

petitetiti · 27/01/2024 18:56

I have no idea how fit people were the last time there was military conscription in the UK. I don't think even a small fraction of the 18 to 50 (?) are nearly fit enough. What happened in Ukraine? What would happen in the UK? It would take YEARS to get this generation fit again.

OP posts:
petitetiti · 27/01/2024 19:34

Polis · 27/01/2024 19:31

I don’t know if it’s related but my husband has suddenly decided to lose a bit of weight and up his fitness levels.

That's interesting... so has my husband!

OP posts:
ChedderGorgeous · 27/01/2024 19:33

Beaverbridge · 27/01/2024 19:16

I've got my bus pass, I could be in the Home Guard!!.

Don't tell him Beaverbridge !

Polis · 27/01/2024 19:31

I don’t know if it’s related but my husband has suddenly decided to lose a bit of weight and up his fitness levels.

petitetiti · 27/01/2024 19:28

BorgQueen · 27/01/2024 19:13

Perhaps all the young fit Men arriving on dinghys should have to do 3 years conscription to become British citizens.

People seem to be forgetting that although our Armed forces have shrunk, we have a lot of reservists and TA. It’s the TA who are doing a lot of the training of Ukraine’s Soldiers, a friend has been doing it for a year now.

If national conscription in a war setting actually happened, they would be doing all the non-combatant work like supplies/ cooking/ laundry etc. to allow our properly trained Men and Women to do their jobs.

I think this is actually a great idea! I don't know if the MOD recruits from the commonwealth. But we should have something in place like 5 years of military service and you get to become a British citizen.

OP posts:
LordEmsworth · 27/01/2024 19:28

Do you genuinely believe that those called up in the late 40s and 50s were fit, able and willing? I am pretty sure that's not true, however misty eyed politicians (who didn't experience it) get about it...

GreyhpundGirl · 27/01/2024 19:23

40-60% volunteer recruits were rejected on health grounds for the Boer Wars- its one of the reasons state intervention started under the Liberals from 1906. The beginnings of the welfare state as it were. 15 years later WW1 started and Britain got volunteers then conscripted, same as 25 odd years after that for WW2. I doubt these men were as fit as professional soldiers given their very short training.

midgetastic · 27/01/2024 19:23

We have German family

According to them the youth of Germany are in training - gym use and such has soared since Ukraine was invaded

Iam4eels · 27/01/2024 19:22

Conscription on a mass scale is highly unlikely to happen however during WW2 conscription and evacuation highlighted just how unhealthy large swathes of the population were.

brunettemic · 27/01/2024 19:22

It depends how you look at fitness. The average person who is “fit” now is infinitely fitter than their equivalent during WW1 or 2 but what we (probably) have are far more overweight people now. You can be overweight and fit in fairness but it’s obviously not always the case.

1982mommaof4 · 27/01/2024 19:21

I will be encouraging my son to bloody disappear!

NotDoingOk · 27/01/2024 19:20

1982mommaof4 · 27/01/2024 19:13

If it's mandatory and say for example my son refused to go would that mean prison?

That's generally how it works. In the states, all males have to register for the draft when they turn 18. During war, they start with the enlisted forces, then they pull in reserves and can call up former servicemen, especially with certain specialties. After that it's a lottery. During Vietnam they used birthdays, and if your number came up you went. (Or fled to Canada or shot your foot or cut off your trigger finger)

1982mommaof4 · 27/01/2024 19:16

@Zaapp this exactly this!!!!

Beaverbridge · 27/01/2024 19:16

I've got my bus pass, I could be in the Home Guard!!.

Zaapp · 27/01/2024 19:16

1982mommaof4 · 27/01/2024 19:13

If it's mandatory and say for example my son refused to go would that mean prison?

I read a poll somewhere said that 40% would point blank refuse to go. I don't think they can put 40% of 18 to 40yr olds in prison. They were saying to judges not to jail rapists and burglars recently as there's no room for them.

mpsw · 27/01/2024 19:16

Conscriptions is not on the cards.

But if it were, lack of fitness is pretty easily remedied throughout basic training, when there would be daily phys and remedial sessions added on for those who need them. As you'd be in camp, diet would be controlled too.

What would be the real challenge , and much harder, is instilling the esprit de corps, sense of duty and common purpose, and possibly a shift from considering self to considering team

As well as learning your trade and how to fight

Zaapp · 27/01/2024 19:14

missmollygreen · 27/01/2024 19:03

Conscription won't happen
The population is far too cynical and self absorbed now

Self absorbed?

So we live in a country that's put an older generation through war then abandoned them to live in mouldy flats, having to chose to 'eat or heat' with zero help with the mental and physical issues directly caused by their 'service'.

And we clearly see this.

There's no affordable homes for us, we're being crippled by the government. Rising living costs, lack of health care, lack of support for anyone dealing with mental health issues. People dying of cancer because they can't get appointments fast enough. No quality of life, rising pension ages, air pollution

They've basically thrown the working (and creeping into middle) class under the bus and told us to fuck ourselves and work harder basically whilst they sit in their 2nd and 3rd homes claiming expenses on their lunches from Pret and a £50 bottle of wine....

And now they want to push us I to Russia as cannon fodder as they watch from the safety and warmth of their country homes with their grown kids who I'm sure will have some sort of trustfund exemption.

Fuck that. Fuck it this way, fuck it that way and fuck it sideways too, just for good luck.

NotDoingOk · 27/01/2024 19:14

I don't think it's something that is going to happen imminently.

But could it happen? Sure.

1982mommaof4 · 27/01/2024 19:13

If it's mandatory and say for example my son refused to go would that mean prison?

BorgQueen · 27/01/2024 19:13

Perhaps all the young fit Men arriving on dinghys should have to do 3 years conscription to become British citizens.

People seem to be forgetting that although our Armed forces have shrunk, we have a lot of reservists and TA. It’s the TA who are doing a lot of the training of Ukraine’s Soldiers, a friend has been doing it for a year now.

If national conscription in a war setting actually happened, they would be doing all the non-combatant work like supplies/ cooking/ laundry etc. to allow our properly trained Men and Women to do their jobs.

PaperDoIIs · 27/01/2024 19:13

Things like these tend to be done in stages if the time line allows. So you send the proper army out then ask for volunteers that get to train for while before being sent off. You rely on public good will and if circumstances allow you set up "home guards" based on volunteers as well that get a bit less training. If numbers are very low and conscription comes in place , special permission can be given to people whose health needs would put them or others at risk. Only when truly desperate (basically everyone else that's suitable is dead) and normally in a last hail mary attempt, you pick absolutely everyone left and use them as cannon fodder.

Toddlerteaplease · 27/01/2024 19:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I thought the same thing! I've got MS so I'm out!

OhmygodDont · 27/01/2024 19:09

missmollygreen · 27/01/2024 19:03

Conscription won't happen
The population is far too cynical and self absorbed now

I mean I’d fight for my children in my country. Would I sacrifice myself for others in another country with no relevance to my families life’s at home. No.

we never get thanks as the U.K. for sticking our noses into issues anywhere in the world. When we do help it’s never enough or it’s the wrong help or too late or whatever. We still end up on the wrong end of the blame game with many of our troops dead and given up lots of our supplies and resources.

ChedderGorgeous · 27/01/2024 19:09

missmollygreen · 27/01/2024 19:03

Conscription won't happen
The population is far too cynical and self absorbed now

The state of the population won't have am effect on if conscription will happen or not. If there is a crisis , it will, and it will be mandatory.

bradpittsbathwater · 27/01/2024 19:08

Why so many posts like this tonight on MN? It looks like it's the same poster trying to drum up worry and hysteria. The user names are a similar style. Get a life!

Oliotya · 27/01/2024 19:06

missmollygreen · 27/01/2024 19:03

Conscription won't happen
The population is far too cynical and self absorbed now

Self absorbed or informed enough to not sacrifice themselves to fight in wars started by old white men?