Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

TW / Are convicted rapists allowed to keep their children?

30 replies

petitetiti · 27/01/2024 18:46

A convicted rapist has served his time and is then released. He is on the Sex Offender's Register and has to register with the police etc. What happens if he is in a relationship and has a child with his partner? Does SS remove the child immediately?

Not a lived experience in any way, just curious about what the law says.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ALotMore · 29/01/2024 02:54

Not convicted rapist, but family court judge determined in a fact-find that the father raped the mother, but still granted unlimited access to DC as it was considered it doesn't pose a risk to them.

KreedKafer · 28/01/2024 12:10

There are too many variables to say one way or the other. It would depend on the circumstances of the rape, when and where it happened etc, what country he was sentenced in, the age of the victim, whether it was his only offence, etc.

Also bear in mind that someone who has committed a violent or sexual crime towards an adult may have zero inclination to harm children. Plenty of people who have done jail time for things like GBH are allowed to keep their kids because their offending hasn’t ever been directed towards their children or partner. So it’s possible that someone who raped an adult woman might not be deemed a risk to their own child.

Obviously we all find rape an utterly abhorrent crime and I think most of us wouldn’t want a convicted rapist anywhere near our child, regardless of what the actual level of risk would be. But I think a court would just look at the actual, material risk to the child - which might actually be very low.

In the case I assume you’re talking about, I suspect that concerns about the risk to the child(ren) were probably related to other factors, rather than (or as well as?) the father’s conviction. There were a lot of clues in the initial media coverage when the couple went on the run. But obviously that kind of reporting quite rightly has to stop once someone has been charged, to avoid prejudicing the trial.

petitetiti · 28/01/2024 11:35

I'm sorry for the dad and while I believe in 2nd chances I could not get with someone who has committed such a crime before.

However don't all parents fight to keep their kids? I somehow feel that society has led them to take the decisions they took, however stupid it was.

OP posts:
Elleherd · 28/01/2024 08:59

Tbf in the case referred to, he was deported to the UK in 2010 after completing his sentence. It has been reported he was living locally to her in London, and working as a laborer when he met her in 2016.

Bubbleohseven · 28/01/2024 08:40

I imagine it's very common when men are released from prison that they quickly get a woman pregnant. It ensures they'll have somewhere to live.

ScrambledSmegs · 28/01/2024 08:37

Ponoka7 · 28/01/2024 07:56

In the UK our sentencing is supposedly based on the severity of the crime. This is reflected in the need to declare a prison sentence over three years on a DBS. In some states they have the three strikes rule, no consideration for the age of the offender etc. So you can be sentenced for a long time for 'lesser' crimes.
We'd look at the details. You've asked the question the wrong way around. Our child laws start with the right of a child to have a relationship with their parents. Is the child at risk of significant harm by that relationship? We've had situations of pedophiles being given access because their crimes were on the opposite sex of their child. So, no, being a convicted rapist wouldn't necessarily get your child removed. In the CM/MG case SS had other concerns.

Yes, this. Added to it the fact that MG was tried and sentenced as a juvenile. Not saying that the crime wasn't awful however 20 years is much more than he would have received in the U.K.

Social services had this family on their radar for other reasons.

Ponoka7 · 28/01/2024 07:56

petitetiti · 28/01/2024 06:15

I don't understand @ScrambledSmegs why it is not comparable.

In the UK our sentencing is supposedly based on the severity of the crime. This is reflected in the need to declare a prison sentence over three years on a DBS. In some states they have the three strikes rule, no consideration for the age of the offender etc. So you can be sentenced for a long time for 'lesser' crimes.
We'd look at the details. You've asked the question the wrong way around. Our child laws start with the right of a child to have a relationship with their parents. Is the child at risk of significant harm by that relationship? We've had situations of pedophiles being given access because their crimes were on the opposite sex of their child. So, no, being a convicted rapist wouldn't necessarily get your child removed. In the CM/MG case SS had other concerns.

Elleherd · 28/01/2024 07:50

The twenty year sentence It isn't comparable to someone sentenced to and serving 20 yrs here, because a home invasion rape in the UK would be unlikely to result in him being sentenced to, let alone serving, 20 years.
Additionally he was tried as an adult when 14/15 yrs old at the time. (15 when tried for 2nd crime)

Also, while I very much doubt it's relevant in this case from what I've read, one should be cautious of different standards of evidence and racial bias in some cases in the USA. They've a much higher proportion of proven miscarriages of justice, especially involving non white defendants. We're far from perfect but dislike convicting on witness ID & circumstantial evidence alone.

The law here would have no interest in him engaging in a consensual sexual relationship and having children. SS might take an interest if he set up with a woman who already had girls in the home, but only if something brought the family to their attention.

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 28/01/2024 07:42

largeprintagathachristie · 27/01/2024 19:39

Women's Hour had a big interview on this on Wednesday (24th Jan).
Parents convicted of sexual offences against their children don’t automatically lose their parental rights.

I was going to mention the same interview, which was one of the most awful things I'd ever heard.

A father was convicted of raping his own daughter, got out of prison, and the mother had to actively argue against his parental rights and prevent him from seeing the children (who were his actual victims).

(And don't get me started on how, after the two girls told the police what happened, they weren't believed, the mother was accused of emotional abuse and parental alienation, and the daughters were told they'd be removed from her care and sent to live with their father. This only didn't happen after another (unrelated) child came forward).

So I can't imagine a baby born to a convicted rapist would automatically be removed.

petitetiti · 28/01/2024 06:15

ScrambledSmegs · 28/01/2024 00:50

Oh - you're thinking of the case being tried at the moment, of the couple who went on the run and the baby died?

The 20 years jail term in that case was in the US which has different sentencing styles to the U.K. It's not comparable.

I don't understand @ScrambledSmegs why it is not comparable.

OP posts:
ScrambledSmegs · 28/01/2024 00:50

petitetiti · 27/01/2024 19:33

The story I read was about a man who committed rape with violence and served 20 years. Then he got out and got a woman pregnant.

Oh - you're thinking of the case being tried at the moment, of the couple who went on the run and the baby died?

The 20 years jail term in that case was in the US which has different sentencing styles to the U.K. It's not comparable.

JWhipple · 27/01/2024 20:53

Each case would be risk assessed using a specific tool to do this, based on the offence and the person's history and behaviour. Even if no convictions relating to children, they might have a history of domestic abuse which children might witness.
Even in a case where the offence is against children, the full details are shared with the child's parent or guardian by social services and they parent/guardian can decide if they want to take the risk. However if there are concerns in that scenario regarding keeping child safe then they may be eventually faced with the decision to choose between child and partner.

So no. Each case is carefully assessed based on multiple factors and child is not automatically removed

petitetiti · 27/01/2024 19:44

HappyHamsters · 27/01/2024 19:36

Was it consensual when she got pregnant or did he rape her too

It was consensual.

OP posts:
Lovemusic82 · 27/01/2024 19:43

titchy · 27/01/2024 19:06

Rapists are allowed to live with children. Assuming they're not paedophiles they wouldn't be assessed to be a risk to a child.

Yes, I believe this is correct. As long as the rape wasn’t of a child then the rarest is not seen as a risk to a child. Obviously each case is different and it would be down to of SS thought there was a risk to the child. There are many convicted criminals that have served time that have access to their children because the crime doesn’t put the child at risk.

largeprintagathachristie · 27/01/2024 19:39

Women's Hour had a big interview on this on Wednesday (24th Jan).
Parents convicted of sexual offences against their children don’t automatically lose their parental rights.

HappyHamsters · 27/01/2024 19:36

petitetiti · 27/01/2024 19:33

The story I read was about a man who committed rape with violence and served 20 years. Then he got out and got a woman pregnant.

Was it consensual when she got pregnant or did he rape her too

petitetiti · 27/01/2024 19:33

MartinsSpareCalculator · 27/01/2024 19:14

If a rapist served 20 years they'd have no children under 18 so social services wouldn't do anything.

But yes, a rapist can live with their children where social services have assessed and decided the risk to the children is negligible.

The story I read was about a man who committed rape with violence and served 20 years. Then he got out and got a woman pregnant.

OP posts:
petitetiti · 27/01/2024 19:32

ArnieLinson · 27/01/2024 19:10

If the rapist served twenty years, that was a very violent crime.

do you think people change?

I believe that people can change but I would not stick around if I found out that my partner was a convicted rapist.

OP posts:
HRTQueen · 27/01/2024 19:30

The situation would be assessed with regular visits from social services

new partners are informed and situation assessed

and many women will allow their partner to return or allow a new partner who has served prison time for sec offences as they likely to believe they are innocent

and no I do not believe these men ever change

SUPerSaver721 · 27/01/2024 19:23

Is he a child molester or was the person he raped over 18? Only asking because i think if it was an adult he raped then hes not seen as a danger to children. I think i read somewhere that a rapist who got a girl pregnant under 16 was able to visit his child when he got out of prison. Was it the rotherham rapists?

MartinsSpareCalculator · 27/01/2024 19:14

If a rapist served 20 years they'd have no children under 18 so social services wouldn't do anything.

But yes, a rapist can live with their children where social services have assessed and decided the risk to the children is negligible.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 27/01/2024 19:13

In theory, unless there was a link between the type of victim or situation and the children, rapists have as much right to a family life as anyone else who has served their time.

ArnieLinson · 27/01/2024 19:10

petitetiti · 27/01/2024 18:51

I've heard this argument before. But can a rapist change after 20 years of serving time? I mean, is the child of a rapist in automatic danger? I see both sides but I also would like to believe that offenders may be rehabilitated.

If the rapist served twenty years, that was a very violent crime.

do you think people change?

titchy · 27/01/2024 19:06

Rapists are allowed to live with children. Assuming they're not paedophiles they wouldn't be assessed to be a risk to a child.

Toopolitetoask · 27/01/2024 19:05

It wouldn't automatically result in removal - the guidance is very clear that criminals can have children and care for them, and this is the case for many families in the UK.

Depending on their conditions, (eg if on SO register) new partner would be made aware and there would be an assessment about whether the person was a risk to children. If the man had raped an adult, it's much more likely to be a concern around potential domestic abuse, control etc rather than concern about direct threat to the child (remember that the majority of rapes are against someone known to the perpetrator or in the context of some form of relationship/friendship)