Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be surprised by the difference in take home pay between 38k and 48k?

112 replies

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 17:15

Recently I have looked into reducing my work hours by 0.2 FTE. This would knock £10k off my salary, but only £400ish off my take home pay per month.
This money would be saved through childcare costs anyway so I’d be no worse off for at least 5 more years.

OP posts:
Waffle19 · 27/01/2024 19:29

I can’t remember the exact figures but when I dropped to 0.8 FTE I was only £20 a week worse off after childcare so yes does sound possible.

Pippippipi · 27/01/2024 19:26

It’s not just the 42% tax in Scotland that kicks in at 43k, it’s such a high marginal rate as you continue to pay ni at 10% until you reach the rest of uk high threshold.

so on earning 43-50k you have 42% tax, ni 10%, student loans 9%, pension 10% for example! So could be taking home only 29% of your wage above the threshold.

easylikeasundaymorn · 27/01/2024 19:11

I'll probably go over the tax threshold (in eng) within the next 2 years by the time I get to the top of my pay bracket (presuming it doesn't increase by then which I think the govt have currently frozen until 2028, although might change in an election year), so am planning to drop hours once I do so, probably to a 9 day fortnight.

I wonder if a lot of people will do the same. Apparently 3 million people will be brought into the higher rate if the freeze stays in place. It also has knock on effects on savings rates etc.

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 19:05

FloofCloud · 27/01/2024 18:54

Remember you'll be putting less I to your pension pot too, though that may not be as high as childcare at your time of life

My employer pays in 27% I pay in 10%.

Im increasing mine by £100/month, out of the saved costs.

I’ll go back to full time when we no longer have childcare costs. This will be no issue; even if I do the last day as a supply teacher.

OP posts:
NewYearNewCalendar · 27/01/2024 19:03

Yes, as soon as you’re over a tax band dropping that fifth day becomes a lot easier! Definitely an issue in England at £50/60/100k as well because of the child benefit/childcare drop offs.

I work part time and have also agreed with partner that extra from our combined income goes in to my pension to help address that imbalance.

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 19:03

Dogsahoyy · 27/01/2024 18:42

My husband has cut one day a week for a similar reason. It means a significant amount of the cleaning and tidying and batch cooking gets done on his day off. I wfh and we usually manage lunch together that day too.

Yeah mine does most of the housework on his days off, providing the child isn’t a psychopath that day.

OP posts:
0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 19:01

Y0URSELF · 27/01/2024 18:22

Yes of course both sexes can go part time so they can do unpaid labour for the Benefit of the family unit / children / elderly relatives .

Yet for some inexplicable reason it seems to be 99% women who do this and bear the cost. And men who continue to benefit.

its odd isn’t it .

Not our situation, partner been p/t since eldest was born.

OP posts:
0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 19:00

johnd2 · 27/01/2024 18:15

Surely the tax works the same for both partners? To be honest even childless and/or single people can go to part time as well. Spend more couple time as well as parent/child time.
Could be Friday= couple time
Saturday= mummy /child time
Sunday= daddy/ child time
Etc for two or more children.
Basically it can improve the whole family relationships

It’s going to be:
monday - one kid in school, other at home with dad. Me at work
tuesday - as above.
wednesday - everyone at work/childcare
thursday - as above
friday - partner at work, me at home with youngest, eldest at school.
saturday/Sunday - everyone home.

So I work Monday-Thursday, he works Wednesday to Friday, nobody works at weekends.

OP posts:
0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 18:56

Y0URSELF · 27/01/2024 18:10

I understand why this is attractive in the short term. But you need to factor in the very real long term costs that are solely on you and not on your husband / partner. These are your lost pension contributions and your lost promotion opportunities.

Effectively you are taking money out YOUR savings and putting them into your partners. You will feel the impact of this later, especially if you are in that 33% of couples who divorce ( and that 95% of mothers who end up as effectively the sole carer ). Your living costs will be a lot higher and your income will be lower.

I’m a teacher and have no interest in either a pupil support teacher or a faculty head; which are really my only promotion opportunities. Plus, the relatively small increase in my wage if I was a promoted teacher would also be taxed at 42%, thus not be worth it for the extra time I would have to put into it.
I’m going to increase my pension contribution by £100/month too, as mentioned earlier.
My partner is also part time so this really isn’t a feminism issue. Even when I reduce hours I’m still the higher earner.

OP posts:
MissersMercer · 27/01/2024 18:55

I was going to up my hours until I realised after tax and NI I'd get just £70 extra each month. Not worth it at all.

FloofCloud · 27/01/2024 18:54

Remember you'll be putting less I to your pension pot too, though that may not be as high as childcare at your time of life

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 18:50

FUPAgirl · 27/01/2024 18:01

Talk about win-win! Lucky you op, I recently had to increase my hours due to my pay.

I had to work full-time when my eldest was younger despite not wanting to; so I’ve been there on both sides. This is purely a tax and childcare costs issue; not just because I want a day off though.

OP posts:
0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 18:49

Kazzyhoward · 27/01/2024 17:52

Which illustrates why we are seeing staff shortages, due to people working fewer hours when they realise they're not that much worse off. Financially incontinent politicians!!

On the plus side, people will get the long yearned for improvement in work life balance.

OP posts:
0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 18:47

Ohhbaby · 27/01/2024 17:52

So true about the Saturday shopping. It's the worst. And I always feel so sad for the poor screaming babies and toddlers who spend a week in childcare and then get dragged around the shops on their only days off

Fortunately my kids are not really in childcare except school and then 1.5 days per week. But yeah, I’d like to go to the zoo or something at the weekend instead of Aldi.

OP posts:
Dogsahoyy · 27/01/2024 18:42

My husband has cut one day a week for a similar reason. It means a significant amount of the cleaning and tidying and batch cooking gets done on his day off. I wfh and we usually manage lunch together that day too.

CaramelMac · 27/01/2024 18:33

I earn less than you and with childcare costs I was actually paying to go to work on Fridays, I’m now better off working 4 days a week, which is fine by me.

IsadoraSpoon · 27/01/2024 18:28

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 17:43

Exactly.

Quite frustrating that Scottish people need to state that; like English is somehow the default.

It was ever thus on MN OP. It's a big frustration of mine even though I now live in England.

johnd2 · 27/01/2024 18:28

Y0URSELF · 27/01/2024 18:22

Yes of course both sexes can go part time so they can do unpaid labour for the Benefit of the family unit / children / elderly relatives .

Yet for some inexplicable reason it seems to be 99% women who do this and bear the cost. And men who continue to benefit.

its odd isn’t it .

Oh I don't have the actual statistics, do you have a link?, in my case I'm on 28 hours a week and I know quite a few male parents in my department on 4 days a week. But my workplace is likely more progressive than average.
I was surprised at the official shared parental leave uptake figures because similarly in my workplace most of the partners seem to take a few months

butelass · 27/01/2024 18:25

The minute you mentioned £48k and that it made so little difference dropping to £38k, knew you were a Scottish classroom teacher. The £43,662 threshold for moving into the 42% tax band is a national disgrace, with fiscal drag, the people it hits worst are far from wealthy, and it's no wonder that people in this bracket are making these choices.

I think many many people in rUK don't realise that a Scottish taxpayer on around £50k pays ca £2k more in annual income tax than if they were resident over the border. And everyone earning over £28k pays more despite the sound bites from our first minister about most people paying less. That's only cos average wages are so shockingly poor. And the ratio of non-tax payers concerning for the future.

Y0URSELF · 27/01/2024 18:22

johnd2 · 27/01/2024 18:15

Surely the tax works the same for both partners? To be honest even childless and/or single people can go to part time as well. Spend more couple time as well as parent/child time.
Could be Friday= couple time
Saturday= mummy /child time
Sunday= daddy/ child time
Etc for two or more children.
Basically it can improve the whole family relationships

Yes of course both sexes can go part time so they can do unpaid labour for the Benefit of the family unit / children / elderly relatives .

Yet for some inexplicable reason it seems to be 99% women who do this and bear the cost. And men who continue to benefit.

its odd isn’t it .

johnd2 · 27/01/2024 18:15

Y0URSELF · 27/01/2024 18:10

I understand why this is attractive in the short term. But you need to factor in the very real long term costs that are solely on you and not on your husband / partner. These are your lost pension contributions and your lost promotion opportunities.

Effectively you are taking money out YOUR savings and putting them into your partners. You will feel the impact of this later, especially if you are in that 33% of couples who divorce ( and that 95% of mothers who end up as effectively the sole carer ). Your living costs will be a lot higher and your income will be lower.

Surely the tax works the same for both partners? To be honest even childless and/or single people can go to part time as well. Spend more couple time as well as parent/child time.
Could be Friday= couple time
Saturday= mummy /child time
Sunday= daddy/ child time
Etc for two or more children.
Basically it can improve the whole family relationships

Y0URSELF · 27/01/2024 18:10

I understand why this is attractive in the short term. But you need to factor in the very real long term costs that are solely on you and not on your husband / partner. These are your lost pension contributions and your lost promotion opportunities.

Effectively you are taking money out YOUR savings and putting them into your partners. You will feel the impact of this later, especially if you are in that 33% of couples who divorce ( and that 95% of mothers who end up as effectively the sole carer ). Your living costs will be a lot higher and your income will be lower.

FUPAgirl · 27/01/2024 18:01

Talk about win-win! Lucky you op, I recently had to increase my hours due to my pay.

maltesefiction · 27/01/2024 18:00

Income above the threshold is taxed so high, a lot of the time it is not worth it.

johnd2 · 27/01/2024 17:57

Yeah totally agree, it doesn't make sense for the extra day working.
You get 50% extra weekend (depending if you slice it that way) and lose 10% pay if that. If you go 50=>60k then you also get back the child benefit on top of the 40% tax bracket. And 100k if you're near there you also get the tax free child care.
Given the extra life balance it should be mandatory for all parents/carers (just kidding, but I'm sold on it!)

Swipe left for the next trending thread