Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be surprised by the difference in take home pay between 38k and 48k?

112 replies

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 17:15

Recently I have looked into reducing my work hours by 0.2 FTE. This would knock £10k off my salary, but only £400ish off my take home pay per month.
This money would be saved through childcare costs anyway so I’d be no worse off for at least 5 more years.

OP posts:
0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 21:31

Also, I was part-time (0.6) pre pay rise and on a salary of £25k, which meant I got UC to help pay childcare costs (no other help other than with childcare costs)

Then I got a pay rise (which I lost hundreds of pounds in strike pay to get) which brought me above the UC threshold, so I had to pay childcare costs (which was fair enough) but also brought me above the student loan pay threshold and into the higher pension bracket, so I had to work two additional days (IE go full time) in order to break even.

So I was no worse off on £25k than I was on £48k. Which is … mental, to be frank. I had exactly the same amount after childcare costs.

OP posts:
Version · 27/01/2024 21:17

butelass · 27/01/2024 18:25

The minute you mentioned £48k and that it made so little difference dropping to £38k, knew you were a Scottish classroom teacher. The £43,662 threshold for moving into the 42% tax band is a national disgrace, with fiscal drag, the people it hits worst are far from wealthy, and it's no wonder that people in this bracket are making these choices.

I think many many people in rUK don't realise that a Scottish taxpayer on around £50k pays ca £2k more in annual income tax than if they were resident over the border. And everyone earning over £28k pays more despite the sound bites from our first minister about most people paying less. That's only cos average wages are so shockingly poor. And the ratio of non-tax payers concerning for the future.

The average Scottish resident receives approximately £2k more state funding than a resident of England so this sounds about right that the taxes paid now reflect this. It's be more than £2k additional state funding now because of inflation (this report is from 2021):

www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/sites/default/files/publications/funding-devolution-barnett-formula.pdf

English taxpayers have been subsidising all of the other nations. Barnett formula needs scrapping, it's indefensible.

OP it makes total sense to cut your hours. This is what has been happening for years now with the cliff-edges in England at £50k and £100k. If you have children in childcare the marginal tax rate after £100k can be well over 100% so tens of thousands of people are doing the same as you. Obviously people won't work more to be worse off! But apparently this is obvious to everyone except our Governments... The UK Chancellor commissioned independent research to find out why UK productivity is so dire and one of its main conclusions was that the tax system makes it not worthwhile for people to work full time. If they want to fix it they need to scrap the withdrawal of child benefit and the withdrawal of the personal allowance (not sure if you have these ridiculous systems in Scotland too, that actually cost more than they raise in tax?), make childcare funding universal again not withdraw it at an arbitrary threshold, and also significantly lower the universal credit taper rate (the same thing is happening in lower paid jobs because of this: the marginal increase in income from working more is low because of the high taper). And significantly raise the tax thresholds which are too low in all of the UK countries. Sadly Ministers say they want growth and rising living standards but are too stupid to take these obvious steps even though economists have set the evidence out to them in a number of independent reports.

If tax thresholds had been uprated with inflation over the last few decades then the 40% rate would start at around £90k earnings. It's the withdrawals creating sudden cliff edges doing the most damage, though as people simply won't work any more hours once their tax hits these thresholds.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 27/01/2024 21:14

For me, and I'm on the left, it's about fiscal drag and the fundamental dishonesty of not being clear about what failure to raise income tax thresholds means. If we're to have societies where lots more people are going to pay 40% income tax as a matter of policy, governments should be clear about that. Make the case and be prepared to defend it, rather than trying to sneak it in via the back door.

nandinos · 27/01/2024 21:11

CheesecakeandCrackers · 27/01/2024 21:06

Interesting! I'm not Scotland so slightly different. I was on 3 days then went up to 4 and was disappointed in the increase. Have just gone back up to 5 so waiting to see how much more I get for that day! I say a day I'm now doing 5 in 4 because I was effectively doing the same hours when I was on 4 so felt frustrated at carrying the extra work without pay.

Yes when looking at going PT I was advised that 4 really means 5 days work squeezed into 4! But having used up A/L by temporarily doing 4 day weeks once I found that having a whole day to myself was still so much better.

@WickerMam It's not the taxpayer that should be 'lifting up' those on lower wages. FT jobs should pay everyone enough to live on including childcare etc.
I can't say I blame people choosing to work less and go on UC when it would cost them to work. Yes, there's career progression, pensions etc but it's when DC are young and many people don't have 'careers' anyway to have lost any progress.

Not everyone can be high-flyers. Where would we be without people doing the ordinary jobs?

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 27/01/2024 21:08

Gonnawashmymouthout · 27/01/2024 20:29

Calm doon hen. Mumsnet isn’t just for the English.

Also, I'd have thought it'd be obvious that there were going to be student loan contributions? We've got a low percentage of take home pay on the 5th day, from someone young enough to have childcare aged DC and with a higher than median salary. It wasn't a big leap!

CheesecakeandCrackers · 27/01/2024 21:06

Interesting! I'm not Scotland so slightly different. I was on 3 days then went up to 4 and was disappointed in the increase. Have just gone back up to 5 so waiting to see how much more I get for that day! I say a day I'm now doing 5 in 4 because I was effectively doing the same hours when I was on 4 so felt frustrated at carrying the extra work without pay.

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 20:35

Gonnawashmymouthout · 27/01/2024 20:29

Calm doon hen. Mumsnet isn’t just for the English.

“You should maybe try Scotsnet”

🙄

OP posts:
Meowandthen · 27/01/2024 20:35

Gonnawashmymouthout · 27/01/2024 20:31

Jeeze. The world doesn’t revolve around England. A few other nations on the island

Calm down. No one said that.

I have simply explained why some posters have assumed. I made no assumptions so direct your ire elsewhere.

WickerMam · 27/01/2024 20:33

Pippippipi · 27/01/2024 19:26

It’s not just the 42% tax in Scotland that kicks in at 43k, it’s such a high marginal rate as you continue to pay ni at 10% until you reach the rest of uk high threshold.

so on earning 43-50k you have 42% tax, ni 10%, student loans 9%, pension 10% for example! So could be taking home only 29% of your wage above the threshold.

I've always supported this - despite having two incomes of ~50k in my household, so taking a maximum hit.

It has always seemed right that working people on very low incomes get lifted up, at the expense of people who can afford it. I appreciate the advantages of living in Scotland - e.g. free eye tests, prescriptions, NHS dentist, etc, and so initially it felt like a fair balance.

It does feel like the balance has moved though, and not enough people are benefitting, compared to the people who are worse off.

And I think it has had unintended consequences. E.g. how many people in the quoted bracket getting a pay rise decide to just salary sacrifice the extra % into pension instead, as it would barely be noticeable in their pay? And I also work 0.8, as its just not worth increasing it.

I've just not seen the evidence that the extra I am paying is actually helping anyone.

Gonnawashmymouthout · 27/01/2024 20:31

Meowandthen · 27/01/2024 19:54

There is good reason to assume, especially in respect of tax.

Population of Scotland - 5.5 million
Population of England and Wales - 60 million

🤷🏻‍♀️

Jeeze. The world doesn’t revolve around England. A few other nations on the island

AuContraire · 27/01/2024 20:29

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 19:51

Good job I’m not then?

To be fair I’d probably take home the same anyway, so swings and roundabouts.

But you need to pay these higher taxes so that the Scottish Government can fund all the 'free university places' that you won't be able to take advantage of because you don't live in a deprived area.

Gonnawashmymouthout · 27/01/2024 20:29

WYorkshireRose · 27/01/2024 17:28

Cross posted. The fact you're in Scotland and have SL contributions would have been useful info to include in the OP.

Calm doon hen. Mumsnet isn’t just for the English.

Zanatdy · 27/01/2024 20:27

Yeah it’s not as bad as you think when you factor in 10k less isn’t 10k take home less and when you’re paying high childcare it’s worth going part time for a few years. Yes you’ll lose out on some pension too but I don’t regret going part time for those early years. Been back full time for a while now and pensions looking fine but if I’m able I might top it up a bit before retirement (20 years to go!)

Meowandthen · 27/01/2024 20:25

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 20:02

This is the internet, not England.

As mentioned earlier; I wasn’t asking people to check my calculations (in which case this information would have been provided) - I was merely shocked at the small difference. My home country is irrelevant.

When I was on £38k, I would have assumed someone of £48k was “well off” as it sounds way more than £38k.

It’s a UK website.

I made no comment about the calculations. I clearly replied to someone cross about the location assumption with an explanation.

nandinos · 27/01/2024 20:23

YANBU to be surprised OP! You see it on MN all the time. I'm surprised this thread has remained civil so far, 3 pages in but it's Saturday night.
MN-ers yelping like rabid dogs at anybody earning over 50K, saying that 'high earners' should be 'grateful', they feed 5 kids on 19K a year so the former are probably just really bad at money management and buying too much avocado toast.

Especially when childcare and transport are so expensive.

Mybootsare · 27/01/2024 20:20

Hell, if someone can calculate that they don’t want to work more hours because it would affect their UC then you’re just right to calculate your wage on fewer hours

This is so true. The government really needs to get a grip on the low wage/ pay stagnation coupled with high housing and transport costs situating we have here if it wants people to work more hours. People are not incentivised to work as much as they can.

I don’t have a lot of responsibility in my work and am on about 40K. I have actively resisted promotion.

The job is flexible enough so I can also do my creative career on the side which is rewarding and brings in around 5-10K a year. I’d have to think twice if it was worth it to get a promotion earning 50K that then left me no time or energy for my creative career.

If pay hadn’t been suppressed in this country for the past 14 years I’d probably already be getting about 50K + in my current role.

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 20:02

Meowandthen · 27/01/2024 19:54

There is good reason to assume, especially in respect of tax.

Population of Scotland - 5.5 million
Population of England and Wales - 60 million

🤷🏻‍♀️

This is the internet, not England.

As mentioned earlier; I wasn’t asking people to check my calculations (in which case this information would have been provided) - I was merely shocked at the small difference. My home country is irrelevant.

When I was on £38k, I would have assumed someone of £48k was “well off” as it sounds way more than £38k.

OP posts:
Meowandthen · 27/01/2024 19:54

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 17:43

Exactly.

Quite frustrating that Scottish people need to state that; like English is somehow the default.

There is good reason to assume, especially in respect of tax.

Population of Scotland - 5.5 million
Population of England and Wales - 60 million

🤷🏻‍♀️

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 19:52

ConsuelaHammock · 27/01/2024 19:35

Well done you for putting your family first. The government can’t keep taking off tax payers and not expect them to sit down and work out what’s best for them financially. You’ll have years to work when your children are older. Enjoy these years.
Hell, if someone can calculate that they don’t want to work more hours because it would affect their UC then you’re just right to calculate your wage on fewer hours.

Yep, exactly. I’d have to be nuts to keep working full time for nothing. I hope more of my colleagues do the same.

OP posts:
0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 19:51

Ineedaholiday23 · 27/01/2024 19:33

If you were in any of the other UK countries, you'd be earning a lot less as a non promoted CT.

Good job I’m not then?

To be fair I’d probably take home the same anyway, so swings and roundabouts.

OP posts:
LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 27/01/2024 19:46

saltnvini · 27/01/2024 17:39

£400 a month is loads though??

Yes but she saves on the childcare costs so it equals out

joelmillersbackpack · 27/01/2024 19:40

Not in Scotland but full time I’d earn 47k and working 0.8 FTE means I’m also £400 a month worse off. Well worth it imo, to have a more balanced life.

ConsuelaHammock · 27/01/2024 19:35

Well done you for putting your family first. The government can’t keep taking off tax payers and not expect them to sit down and work out what’s best for them financially. You’ll have years to work when your children are older. Enjoy these years.
Hell, if someone can calculate that they don’t want to work more hours because it would affect their UC then you’re just right to calculate your wage on fewer hours.

Ineedaholiday23 · 27/01/2024 19:33

If you were in any of the other UK countries, you'd be earning a lot less as a non promoted CT.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 27/01/2024 19:30

Pippippipi · 27/01/2024 19:26

It’s not just the 42% tax in Scotland that kicks in at 43k, it’s such a high marginal rate as you continue to pay ni at 10% until you reach the rest of uk high threshold.

so on earning 43-50k you have 42% tax, ni 10%, student loans 9%, pension 10% for example! So could be taking home only 29% of your wage above the threshold.

Really? Wow, I'm shocked so many people still bother.