Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be surprised by the difference in take home pay between 38k and 48k?

112 replies

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 17:15

Recently I have looked into reducing my work hours by 0.2 FTE. This would knock £10k off my salary, but only £400ish off my take home pay per month.
This money would be saved through childcare costs anyway so I’d be no worse off for at least 5 more years.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
0rangeCrush · 31/01/2024 18:56

usernamealreadytaken · 31/01/2024 18:50

Your post title was "AIBU To be surprised by the difference in take home pay between 38k and 48k?" and the first posters advised that it looked like you had miscalculated your tax. Perhaps post in general chat, or financial, if you don't want people thinking you're miscalculating your tax, and trying to help you get even more money back. AIBU invites comments, on a discussion forum.

YABU for assuming that everyone would know you were referring to the Scottish wages/tax system. YANBU for being surprised that under the Scottish tax system the difference in pay is different to under any other tax regime.

UNAT, F early 50s, post-meno, UK, England, European.

It’s not my fault the first posters completely misread the question is it? Did I ask for help getting money back? Did I ask for advice?

No. I asked if it was unreasonable to be surprised that the difference was so small. It’s not my fault that people assumed incorrectly that I was incorrect. Do you think I’d be dumb enough not to do a simple tax calculation; or to be dumb enough to ask for financial advice on a discussion forum? Again; that’s on the reader who lacks comprehension; not me.

0rangeCrush, neither orange or crushed, understands tax better than others understand the English language.

OP posts:
usernamealreadytaken · 31/01/2024 18:50

0rangeCrush · 31/01/2024 18:21

Except I didn’t ask for advice about tax did I? The information was clearly correct for where I lived - be that Scotland, England, India, or anywhere else.

Are you suggesting I need to mention being Scottish on each post? Do I need to state I’m female too? Should I add my age? Marital status? Occupation? Where I am on my menstrual cycle? Where do we stop?

Your post title was "AIBU To be surprised by the difference in take home pay between 38k and 48k?" and the first posters advised that it looked like you had miscalculated your tax. Perhaps post in general chat, or financial, if you don't want people thinking you're miscalculating your tax, and trying to help you get even more money back. AIBU invites comments, on a discussion forum.

YABU for assuming that everyone would know you were referring to the Scottish wages/tax system. YANBU for being surprised that under the Scottish tax system the difference in pay is different to under any other tax regime.

UNAT, F early 50s, post-meno, UK, England, European.

GintyMcGinty · 31/01/2024 18:26

0rangeCrush · 31/01/2024 18:23

Could you please edit your post to state where you come from? I wouldn’t want to confuse anyone.

0rangeCrush, from Scotland, female, mid 30s, coupled up, and approximately three days post ovulation.

Ooops of course.

GintyMcGinty, from Scotland, woman, 49, married with children, menopausal.

Humblest apologies.

0rangeCrush · 31/01/2024 18:23

GintyMcGinty · 31/01/2024 18:14

How very England-centric of you 😂

Could you please edit your post to state where you come from? I wouldn’t want to confuse anyone.

0rangeCrush, from Scotland, female, mid 30s, coupled up, and approximately three days post ovulation.

OP posts:
0rangeCrush · 31/01/2024 18:21

usernamealreadytaken · 31/01/2024 18:02

Given that we're on a UK-based international forum, and unless the post is on one of the international pages, I would guess most users are assumed to be in England by default, unless otherwise stated. Being Indian is irrelevant unless the poster is Indian and in India; similarly being English is irrelevant if you are in another location - it's the location which is relevant for tax (and many other) purposes.

But thanks for the unnecessary pedantry, which only serves to prove the initial point, I feel.

Except I didn’t ask for advice about tax did I? The information was clearly correct for where I lived - be that Scotland, England, India, or anywhere else.

Are you suggesting I need to mention being Scottish on each post? Do I need to state I’m female too? Should I add my age? Marital status? Occupation? Where I am on my menstrual cycle? Where do we stop?

OP posts:
GintyMcGinty · 31/01/2024 18:14

usernamealreadytaken · 31/01/2024 18:02

Given that we're on a UK-based international forum, and unless the post is on one of the international pages, I would guess most users are assumed to be in England by default, unless otherwise stated. Being Indian is irrelevant unless the poster is Indian and in India; similarly being English is irrelevant if you are in another location - it's the location which is relevant for tax (and many other) purposes.

But thanks for the unnecessary pedantry, which only serves to prove the initial point, I feel.

How very England-centric of you 😂

usernamealreadytaken · 31/01/2024 18:02

Given that we're on a UK-based international forum, and unless the post is on one of the international pages, I would guess most users are assumed to be in England by default, unless otherwise stated. Being Indian is irrelevant unless the poster is Indian and in India; similarly being English is irrelevant if you are in another location - it's the location which is relevant for tax (and many other) purposes.

But thanks for the unnecessary pedantry, which only serves to prove the initial point, I feel.

0rangeCrush · 31/01/2024 16:29

usernamealreadytaken · 31/01/2024 08:45

Given that you live in the UK, with a population of around 67m, and Scotland makes up around 8% of that population (or around 10% vs just England at 83%), it's entirely reasonable for English/England to be the default when you're probably talking to mainly English people. If you want to avoid this sort of confusion, then perhaps stating relevant facts upfront might help.

This is the internet; not England. Statistically I’m far more likely to be Indian than English; therefore I suggest that all English posters introduce each post with “I’m English” for avoidance of doubt.

Thank you.

OP posts:
usernamealreadytaken · 31/01/2024 08:45

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 17:43

Exactly.

Quite frustrating that Scottish people need to state that; like English is somehow the default.

Given that you live in the UK, with a population of around 67m, and Scotland makes up around 8% of that population (or around 10% vs just England at 83%), it's entirely reasonable for English/England to be the default when you're probably talking to mainly English people. If you want to avoid this sort of confusion, then perhaps stating relevant facts upfront might help.

0rangeCrush · 28/01/2024 19:22

Palacelife · 28/01/2024 17:52

I’ve found this, I’m going the other way, up from £38 to £45 and am thinking as it’s a little more travel cost, why have I bothered!

Mine went from £41k to £48k (due to a wage rise) and I get about £260/month extra.

OP posts:
Palacelife · 28/01/2024 17:52

I’ve found this, I’m going the other way, up from £38 to £45 and am thinking as it’s a little more travel cost, why have I bothered!

RagzRebooted · 28/01/2024 01:36

I do 0.8FTE, the day off in the week means more to me than the small amount of difference it would make to my pay (£36k Vs £31k but about £300 a month due to student loan, pension, tax and NI). DH works away in the week (and 50-60 hours) so l use the time to run errands and do housework so we don't have to do so much at the weekend.
Overtime is much less appealing when you're only getting 50% of it!

Beenaboutabit · 28/01/2024 00:55

Not exactly the point because OP has done the sums, but anyone in Scotland on £48k paying 10% pension will only be taxed as if they are earning £43,200.

That’s below the £43,662 threshold for higher tax rates.

OP is not a higher rate tax payer, if she's paying 10% pension contributions, despite some of the claims above.

Princessandthepea0 · 27/01/2024 23:09

nandinos · 27/01/2024 20:23

YANBU to be surprised OP! You see it on MN all the time. I'm surprised this thread has remained civil so far, 3 pages in but it's Saturday night.
MN-ers yelping like rabid dogs at anybody earning over 50K, saying that 'high earners' should be 'grateful', they feed 5 kids on 19K a year so the former are probably just really bad at money management and buying too much avocado toast.

Especially when childcare and transport are so expensive.

This is the most accurate description of MN I have ever read.

Alcyoneus · 27/01/2024 23:02

Oh well, who needs taxpayers in Scotland. It’s more important to make sure that male rapists get to rape freely in women’s prisons. If UK is in trouble, Scotland is a dumpster fire.

MrsBobtonTrent · 27/01/2024 22:51

Nuts isn’t it. Pandemic really brought home to us that we were no worse off working much fewer hours. Our drop in income didn’t have a huge effect on our take home pay and the relatively small decrease could be weighed against the quality of life that came with more free time. Not surprisingly lots of other people found the same and the govt got all panicky trying to get people back to work. No thanks! Our business is smaller but our overheads reduced and we don’t bother battling with Brexit and overseas orders anymore. Small thinking by the government which now faces reduced tax income as a result of making working too expensive and complicated.

Gonnawashmymouthout · 27/01/2024 22:45

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 20:02

This is the internet, not England.

As mentioned earlier; I wasn’t asking people to check my calculations (in which case this information would have been provided) - I was merely shocked at the small difference. My home country is irrelevant.

When I was on £38k, I would have assumed someone of £48k was “well off” as it sounds way more than £38k.

“This is the internet, not England”

😂

Gonnawashmymouthout · 27/01/2024 22:43

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 22:28

I am Scottish. Note the quotation marks.

Aaarrgghh… completely misread your sarcasm . Sorry !

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 22:28

Gonnawashmymouthout · 27/01/2024 22:26

So…. If we are Scottish we should stick to one wee forum? Away bile yer heid hen

I am Scottish. Note the quotation marks.

OP posts:
Gonnawashmymouthout · 27/01/2024 22:27

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 21:31

Also, I was part-time (0.6) pre pay rise and on a salary of £25k, which meant I got UC to help pay childcare costs (no other help other than with childcare costs)

Then I got a pay rise (which I lost hundreds of pounds in strike pay to get) which brought me above the UC threshold, so I had to pay childcare costs (which was fair enough) but also brought me above the student loan pay threshold and into the higher pension bracket, so I had to work two additional days (IE go full time) in order to break even.

So I was no worse off on £25k than I was on £48k. Which is … mental, to be frank. I had exactly the same amount after childcare costs.

It’s absolutely crazy!

Gonnawashmymouthout · 27/01/2024 22:26

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 20:35

“You should maybe try Scotsnet”

🙄

So…. If we are Scottish we should stick to one wee forum? Away bile yer heid hen

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 22:17

Version · 27/01/2024 22:12

It is mental. Then there is the enormous difference between how one and two parent households are taxed. In England a single parent with two children using childcare has to earn more than £150k to get the same net household income after tax and childcare that a couple both earning a median full time salary receive, i.e. they have to earn more than double the amount the two people are earning combined to reach the same outcome for the household. The UK tax system is beyond ridiculous and any Chancellor with half a brain would reform all of these perverse incentives on day one in office and can't be taken seriously on any claim to want to improve the economy or living standards until they do so. Sadly, brains are in short supply, it seems!

I definitely think they should consider household income rather than individual income for tax purposes. It would also maybe incentivise more fathers to take a more active parenting role by dropping their hours too? Maybe that’s just specific to my own circumstances though.

OP posts:
Version · 27/01/2024 22:12

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 21:31

Also, I was part-time (0.6) pre pay rise and on a salary of £25k, which meant I got UC to help pay childcare costs (no other help other than with childcare costs)

Then I got a pay rise (which I lost hundreds of pounds in strike pay to get) which brought me above the UC threshold, so I had to pay childcare costs (which was fair enough) but also brought me above the student loan pay threshold and into the higher pension bracket, so I had to work two additional days (IE go full time) in order to break even.

So I was no worse off on £25k than I was on £48k. Which is … mental, to be frank. I had exactly the same amount after childcare costs.

It is mental. Then there is the enormous difference between how one and two parent households are taxed. In England a single parent with two children using childcare has to earn more than £150k to get the same net household income after tax and childcare that a couple both earning a median full time salary receive, i.e. they have to earn more than double the amount the two people are earning combined to reach the same outcome for the household. The UK tax system is beyond ridiculous and any Chancellor with half a brain would reform all of these perverse incentives on day one in office and can't be taken seriously on any claim to want to improve the economy or living standards until they do so. Sadly, brains are in short supply, it seems!

FloofCloud · 27/01/2024 21:55

@0rangeCrush that's good to look after your pension x

nandinos · 27/01/2024 21:35

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 21:31

Also, I was part-time (0.6) pre pay rise and on a salary of £25k, which meant I got UC to help pay childcare costs (no other help other than with childcare costs)

Then I got a pay rise (which I lost hundreds of pounds in strike pay to get) which brought me above the UC threshold, so I had to pay childcare costs (which was fair enough) but also brought me above the student loan pay threshold and into the higher pension bracket, so I had to work two additional days (IE go full time) in order to break even.

So I was no worse off on £25k than I was on £48k. Which is … mental, to be frank. I had exactly the same amount after childcare costs.

I'm not surprised at that.
I played around with a couple of benefits calculators and came out with a similar result...