Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No inheritance because of pilot training

557 replies

Poily · 27/01/2024 12:21

My brother is a pilot for a major airline in the UK. My parents were not able to borrow against their house to fund it so had to use pretty much all their savings. £150k was roughly what was spent.

Due to their failed business (folded just after Covid) they racked up massive loans trying to save their hospitality-related business. When they sell their house they won’t end up with much.

So I don’t know exactly how it works but some of that £150k ends up in a bond which the airline then pays out to my brother every month in his pay packet. But if my brother walks away from the airline he walks away from this bond also. It’s a lot of money. Gets paid over 7 years I think.

AIBU to think my brother should not quit his job and move to the Middle East (stupid salary) as he plans to do? He way paying that bond money to my parents.

Brother has said he will cover my parents bills. Great. Thats the right thing to do. But that cuts me out. As my parents were transferring the bond
money into a savings account for my kids.

AIBU?

OP posts:
kkloo · 28/01/2024 01:09

Poily · 27/01/2024 12:39

Why should my brother’s choice of repayment negatively impact my kids?

Why do you think the repayment should go to your kids accounts when your parents need the money?

My guess is that your brother thinks the money should have been going to the parents and for some reason they felt unable to tell you they wanted to stop sending the money to your kids accounts so they agreed to do it this way.

Your thread title is very misleading.

kkloo · 28/01/2024 00:42

Yalta · 28/01/2024 00:35

All those saying that the ds is helping his parents through a horrible time

Would you feel helped if you gave someone £150,000 and they helped you by repaying you £700 per month for the next 4 years and then they wanted to forget about repaying the balance but will pay your rent and bills of around £700 per month until you move into a lovely little annexe attached to their big house and you get to go on weekends away to view lovely properties and dream about where you could live .... one day

Presumably the brother thinks the current situation wasn't fair..
He must have wanted the parents to have their own money back but for whatever reason it was going straight to the OPs kids savings,

Maybe he thought the OP was a cheeky fucker for allowing this and not saying look don't pay that into the kids savings seeing as you have no savings left of your own!

So because the parents or the brother didn't want to say that to the OP they just told them about the new arrangement where he was going to pay their rent and bills instead.

If he's paying their rent and bills then presumably they still have money they could transfer to the kids savings if they wanted to, but they haven't offered that so it sounds like they've just done it this way to avoid an awkward conversation.

There's no suggestion that the brother isn't going to pay the parents back the balance at all. The only issue the OP has with it is that the payment has stopped being transferred to her kids.

kkloo · 28/01/2024 00:37

Cherrysoup · 27/01/2024 20:51

It’s true, they don’t owe the OP an inheritance, but I can thoroughly understand why she’s feeling that it’s unjust if he throws in the towel with this job and that means he’s not getting the £150K paid back. It’s bound to cause resentment. It appears very unequal.

But he's going to pay them back more from his new job.

He used to pay £700 a month, he's now going to pay more than that.

Yalta · 28/01/2024 00:35

All those saying that the ds is helping his parents through a horrible time

Would you feel helped if you gave someone £150,000 and they helped you by repaying you £700 per month for the next 4 years and then they wanted to forget about repaying the balance but will pay your rent and bills of around £700 per month until you move into a lovely little annexe attached to their big house and you get to go on weekends away to view lovely properties and dream about where you could live .... one day

joonam · 28/01/2024 00:32

I would be pretty upset too

kkloo · 28/01/2024 00:30

@Yalta
Now the ds wants to jack it all in and forget about paying anything else back to his parents.....

If your brother has only repaid around £34000 when is he going to repay the rest

The brother has told the parents he's going to pay their rent and bills, he's actually going to be paying more back per month than he has been paying!

Previously the parents put the amount in the savings account for the OPs kids.
Now they're accepting it back for themselves for their own bills.

So this is nothing to do with the brother. Even if he was staying at the airline the parents could have stopped putting the money into the kids savings accounts and used it for rent and bills.

Notamum12345577 · 28/01/2024 00:26

XelaM · 27/01/2024 12:26

Wow is it usual for pilots to have to pay £150K up front and be tied by this to the airline? Sounds horrendous

Airlines rarely fund pilot training. I heard minimum of 100k for training. So it isn’t a carer to consider unless you have rich parents!

Yalta · 28/01/2024 00:22

*You’re right it is unequal.

one child is trying to support his parents through a horrible period and make sure they are suitably provided for.

the other is complaining about her children not getting £700 a month and saying she can’t help as she doesn’t live close*

Whilst the other sibling has been receiving an extra £1666 per month for 4 years, in total £80,000 from the airline repaying him. Out of that he has been repaying the parents at £700 per month

The parents in turn have been giving this money to the grandchildren.

Now the ds wants to jack it all in and forget about paying anything else back to his parents and go and earn big money in the Middle East even though he doesn’t like the Middle East. (So that doesn’t look like it is going to be along term plan)

Whilst the parents might be bankrupt and have lost their house there seems to be something quite off and quite deceitful

The parents seem to be trying to hide money from their creditors and like a lot of people who think they are smart enough to get one over on others they leave themselves open to be conned themselves

If your brother has only repaid around £34000 when is he going to repay the rest

Also if he needs to go to the Middle East to have enough money for this grand plan then why is he looking at places this weekend.

He either has the money so why can’t he repay your parents and why would he need to go abroad to work or he doesn’t. In which case why is he viewing properties with your parents?

Or is this more about showing them a dream that has as much chance of becoming reality as his repayment plan for the £150,000 he borrowed

What’s to say that if the parents had an extra £150,000 then maybe they wouldn’t have lost the business. That £150,000 could have been the difference between surviving long enough to be able to rebrand or sell and wouldn’t have go bankrupt and lose their home
and maybe forcing their ds to be more realistic and found a training programme more within his personal budget

kkloo · 27/01/2024 23:51

Rainsew · 27/01/2024 20:57

Well no, but I wonder if you had a sibling and they had £150k to enhance their life whether you'd be happy with fuck all from your parents? When it's theoretical of course it's easy to say it's their money to do as they please with which it is, but I don't know anyone who wouldn't feel aggrieved.

He's paying it back though.

MeinKraft · 27/01/2024 23:14

@CJsGoldfish I could not agree more. The OP is sitting on £30-40k of her parents money whilst they sell their house to pay their debt, her brother is going to bail them out and provide them with a home and care for the rest of their lives and OP has the nerve to be miffed for some inexplicable reason.

BestZebbie · 27/01/2024 23:08

I don't quite get this because your brother hasn't inherited/been given anything - he did get 150k but it was a loan?
So yes, he should pay it back and not just decide not to.
But this should be because your parents now need the money, not so your children can inherit, because if he pays it back that makes you and your brother even at no inheritance each and so if money was then given to your children and not him, that advantages your branch of the family in inheritance over your brother's line.

CJsGoldfish · 27/01/2024 23:04

Why should my brother’s choice of repayment negatively impact my kids?
How about YOU make it up OP. They're your kids so why don't you take over the payments? Your brothers business is really not your concern and it is ONLY that the gravy train is no longer stopping at your station.
The concern for your parents and the situation they are in isn't exactly shining through this grabby post.

See to me the loan has become a gift all of a sudden
The loan that has been continuously repaid and clearly still will be by your brother providing housing and care for your parents now that their circumstances are so drastically changed. They must be so glad that he has stepped up for them. You weren't clear about how often you help them out?

Brother is doing right my parents. Happy about that. But it means I am now totally overlooked
Your brother sounds like a great guy. Not only has he been paying back what your parents lent him but will now be ensuring that they are looked after in every way in their older years.

You could jump in at any time before he builds a house for them to live in and offer to have them live with you? You can take care of them, he can go back to giving them money instead and you can get your grabby little paws on it that way.

Menomeno · 27/01/2024 22:51

hellsBells246 · 27/01/2024 22:24

Focus on improving your own earnings and savings for your children if it’s important to you

This is rich, @Babadook76 , since OP's brother was only enabled to earn so well by his parents giving him £150k, while OP got NOTHING.

She didn’t get NOTHING. She’s had half the £80K that her brother has repaid so far.

hellsBells246 · 27/01/2024 22:24

Focus on improving your own earnings and savings for your children if it’s important to you

This is rich, @Babadook76 , since OP's brother was only enabled to earn so well by his parents giving him £150k, while OP got NOTHING.

hellsBells246 · 27/01/2024 22:19

parietal · 27/01/2024 12:31

So if your brother owes £150k to your parents, he should pay that back in cash. Not by paying bills randomly or whatever. Then your parents can decide what to do with the money, whether let you inherit or spend it on a cruise.

Your bro should pay his debts

Ignore the question of inheritance.

This.

hellsBells246 · 27/01/2024 22:18

XelaM · 27/01/2024 12:26

Wow is it usual for pilots to have to pay £150K up front and be tied by this to the airline? Sounds horrendous

Why should the airline pay to train them then have them leave and go elsewhere?

redheadsaregreat · 27/01/2024 21:27

ReindeerRider · 27/01/2024 21:22

Inheritance is a red flag here - no one is dead OP!!

It sounds like your parents were financially comfortable and basically lent your brother £150k for his flying career. Your brother was paying this back to them at the rate he was reimbursed by his employer. He wishes to change employer now so had suggested to parents that he repay via rent and future housing costs plus bills. This is their arrangement and they are clearly okay with it as they actually need help with housing and bills now and in the future. He isn’t stealing anything from his parents he’s ensuring he repays his debt to them. He owes you or your children nothing.

On your side you have never taken a loan from your parents so there is nothing for you to repay. You were expecting a huge inheritance from them however their financial fortunes have drastically declined and they are basically broke now with massive debts. There is NO inheritance available for you even if they die this year there is fuck all in the pot for you OP.

On your children’s side their grandparents have been making extremely generous monthly savings for them. The grandparents are now SKINT hence the monthly savings are stopping. This also has fuck all to do with your brother. There is no suggestion that your children’s savings of £30/40k (a hell of a lot!!!) be returned to your parents to service their debts.

so in summary you should be feeling bloody lucky that your children’s savings have been ring fenced and your brother is going to provide for your parents going forward (yes in repayment but if they aren’t extremely elderly then housing bills over their remaining lifetime are likely to exceed his debt anyway!!)

you are being utterly unreasonable is saying your brother is stealing your inheritance or depriving your children of their savings. The gravy train has stopped because your parent’s business folded and they are utterly broke.

Edited

Exactly this

ReindeerRider · 27/01/2024 21:22

Inheritance is a red flag here - no one is dead OP!!

It sounds like your parents were financially comfortable and basically lent your brother £150k for his flying career. Your brother was paying this back to them at the rate he was reimbursed by his employer. He wishes to change employer now so had suggested to parents that he repay via rent and future housing costs plus bills. This is their arrangement and they are clearly okay with it as they actually need help with housing and bills now and in the future. He isn’t stealing anything from his parents he’s ensuring he repays his debt to them. He owes you or your children nothing.

On your side you have never taken a loan from your parents so there is nothing for you to repay. You were expecting a huge inheritance from them however their financial fortunes have drastically declined and they are basically broke now with massive debts. There is NO inheritance available for you even if they die this year there is fuck all in the pot for you OP.

On your children’s side their grandparents have been making extremely generous monthly savings for them. The grandparents are now SKINT hence the monthly savings are stopping. This also has fuck all to do with your brother. There is no suggestion that your children’s savings of £30/40k (a hell of a lot!!!) be returned to your parents to service their debts.

so in summary you should be feeling bloody lucky that your children’s savings have been ring fenced and your brother is going to provide for your parents going forward (yes in repayment but if they aren’t extremely elderly then housing bills over their remaining lifetime are likely to exceed his debt anyway!!)

you are being utterly unreasonable is saying your brother is stealing your inheritance or depriving your children of their savings. The gravy train has stopped because your parent’s business folded and they are utterly broke.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 27/01/2024 21:17

Rainsew · 27/01/2024 20:57

Well no, but I wonder if you had a sibling and they had £150k to enhance their life whether you'd be happy with fuck all from your parents? When it's theoretical of course it's easy to say it's their money to do as they please with which it is, but I don't know anyone who wouldn't feel aggrieved.

Most people whose children were getting £700 a month from their bankrupt grandparents wouldn’t consider themselves as being given “fuck all” imo

DriftingDora · 27/01/2024 21:07

notimagain · 27/01/2024 19:15

@DriftingDora

Still a hell of a lot of money, though! OP's brother must have known in advance what sort of amount of was involved in his training (presumably so did the parents as they were doing the paying).

They might not have done.....the economics of this can be a mystery to none -flyers, and the flying schools can be, to put it politely, less than transparent than the rose tinted specs they put in their ads when it to comes to what a package does and doesn't include.

The brother hopefully would have known what the basic commercial licence element would have cost (that's the 80k plus a bit) but as the OP has mentioned it sounds like there was possibly a type rating (expensive) and possibly extra flying for recency due covid . If that was done before the brother had joined the airline formally that might have been self funded.

Whatever the reason there's more than a few who have blown 150k on training on the way to a job at an airline.

Edited

By heck, with that sort of money involved the training schools should be transparent about exactly what's involved. I thought it wouldn't be cheap to train, but didn't realise it was such megabucks. The thought of spending all that money and not qualifying doesn't bear thinking about.

Cosyblankets · 27/01/2024 21:01

kkloo · 27/01/2024 19:59

If your parents hadn't given him the money then they'd surely have wasted more trying to keep their business afloat and would be living off it themselves anyway so there wouldn't be any inheritance left for you.

The fact they had lent some to your brother at least gives them some security now to provide for their living costs.

This

Rainsew · 27/01/2024 20:57

CreateHope · 27/01/2024 12:27

Inheritance isn’t a birth right 🙄

Well no, but I wonder if you had a sibling and they had £150k to enhance their life whether you'd be happy with fuck all from your parents? When it's theoretical of course it's easy to say it's their money to do as they please with which it is, but I don't know anyone who wouldn't feel aggrieved.

Sirzy · 27/01/2024 20:52

Cherrysoup · 27/01/2024 20:51

It’s true, they don’t owe the OP an inheritance, but I can thoroughly understand why she’s feeling that it’s unjust if he throws in the towel with this job and that means he’s not getting the £150K paid back. It’s bound to cause resentment. It appears very unequal.

You’re right it is unequal.

one child is trying to support his parents through a horrible period and make sure they are suitably provided for.

the other is complaining about her children not getting £700 a month and saying she can’t help as she doesn’t live close.

Cherrysoup · 27/01/2024 20:51

Overthebow · 27/01/2024 12:29

It’s between your parents and your brother. If they’re happy with it then that’s up to them. They don’t owe you an inheritance.

It’s true, they don’t owe the OP an inheritance, but I can thoroughly understand why she’s feeling that it’s unjust if he throws in the towel with this job and that means he’s not getting the £150K paid back. It’s bound to cause resentment. It appears very unequal.

HarrietStyles · 27/01/2024 20:43

The brother changing his job and changing his repayment terms to their parents is a complete red herring to the situation.

It boils down to:

  • Parents were previously putting £700 per month into saving accounts for OPs children.
  • Now parents are broke and can’t afford to continue putting money into the children’s savings.
  • OP is pissed off that the gravy train has ended.

Anything to do with the brother is unrelated and distracting from the above.

Swipe left for the next trending thread