Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No inheritance because of pilot training

557 replies

Poily · 27/01/2024 12:21

My brother is a pilot for a major airline in the UK. My parents were not able to borrow against their house to fund it so had to use pretty much all their savings. £150k was roughly what was spent.

Due to their failed business (folded just after Covid) they racked up massive loans trying to save their hospitality-related business. When they sell their house they won’t end up with much.

So I don’t know exactly how it works but some of that £150k ends up in a bond which the airline then pays out to my brother every month in his pay packet. But if my brother walks away from the airline he walks away from this bond also. It’s a lot of money. Gets paid over 7 years I think.

AIBU to think my brother should not quit his job and move to the Middle East (stupid salary) as he plans to do? He way paying that bond money to my parents.

Brother has said he will cover my parents bills. Great. Thats the right thing to do. But that cuts me out. As my parents were transferring the bond
money into a savings account for my kids.

AIBU?

OP posts:
IncompleteSenten · 28/01/2024 12:25

Well what more can anyone say. You feel entitled to your parents money. 🤷 Unfortunately for you they aren't dead yet so you can't have it. Whatever if anything is left when they're dead you can fight over.

IAmAnIdiot123 · 28/01/2024 12:25

Poily · 28/01/2024 12:19

Also my parents are not destitute. I am not taking advantage of people with nothing. They offered the £700. Both have private pensions. Yes, they can’t maintain their previous lifestyle. But still go for meals out, concerts etc. More than I do at any rate!

Can you explain why him paying £700 a month to them is worse than paying a significant amount more for their rent and bills etc? I'm feeling really stupid bit I'm struggling to understand why you feel there is an imbalance here. Surely he will be paying back the £150k (and more) this way. And if he had continued paying the £700 a month and there was £150k at the end, why would your children inherit the lot instead of your brother recieveing half?

Sighhhhh · 28/01/2024 12:20

Frankly, you and your brother are pretty damn entitled.

Poily · 28/01/2024 12:19

Also my parents are not destitute. I am not taking advantage of people with nothing. They offered the £700. Both have private pensions. Yes, they can’t maintain their previous lifestyle. But still go for meals out, concerts etc. More than I do at any rate!

OP posts:
SuperDopper · 28/01/2024 12:15

Poily · 28/01/2024 11:52

I would argue the £150k is the inheritance.

Day to day there is not much I can do. I’m a stay at home mum with very young children. We also live approx 2.5-3.5 hours away (depends heavily on London traffic)

My in laws offered my parents a rental property at reduced rates, they declined.

I know my brother is doing a good thing caring for them but I am allowed to feel aggrieved by the imbalance of it all.

So, that’s 75k each?

At a rate of £700 a month, it will take your brother 9 years to pay back £75k, and that’s ignoring anything paid back already.

If your brother pays £700 as cash to your parents each month, how will your parents pay their rent and bills over those 9 years, if they set aside the repayments for you instead? Similarly, beyond those 9 years, what will happen then?

XelaM · 28/01/2024 12:08

Poily · 28/01/2024 11:52

I would argue the £150k is the inheritance.

Day to day there is not much I can do. I’m a stay at home mum with very young children. We also live approx 2.5-3.5 hours away (depends heavily on London traffic)

My in laws offered my parents a rental property at reduced rates, they declined.

I know my brother is doing a good thing caring for them but I am allowed to feel aggrieved by the imbalance of it all.

What imbalance? The £150K was a loan that your brother has been repaying. You/your kids on the other hand have been receiving cash gifts every month, which you have no intention to repay. You're the one taking way more than your brother.

IncompleteSenten · 28/01/2024 11:58

Well, you are allowed to feel however you want but if my parents were struggling financially and going broke, what I'd feel would be really sorry for them and morally obligated to return to them any savings they had earmarked for my children. 🤷

Iwasafool · 28/01/2024 11:55

MeinKraft · 28/01/2024 11:07

@Iwasafool the creditors haven't been given a choice though? The money has been hidden from them, they may not be happy to wait at all. We don't know that the money was owed to someone who wouldn't miss it for a few years like HMRC or Mastercard. The debts were accrued because of a small business folding so the creditors could very likely be the business suppliers, potentially other small businesses.

The OP said they'd agreed.

Poily · 28/01/2024 11:52

SuperDopper · 28/01/2024 11:35

You still haven’t answered two very important questions:

Why do you think you will have any inheritance when your parents have lost everything?

What are you doing to support your parents following their change of circumstances?

I would argue the £150k is the inheritance.

Day to day there is not much I can do. I’m a stay at home mum with very young children. We also live approx 2.5-3.5 hours away (depends heavily on London traffic)

My in laws offered my parents a rental property at reduced rates, they declined.

I know my brother is doing a good thing caring for them but I am allowed to feel aggrieved by the imbalance of it all.

OP posts:
TheShellBeach · 28/01/2024 11:41

Poily · 28/01/2024 11:32

There was an arrangement set up that my parents would pay back their loans with the sale house. The other side preferred this as an option.

Yet another random post.

Please use the quote function.

SuperDopper · 28/01/2024 11:35

Poily · 28/01/2024 11:32

There was an arrangement set up that my parents would pay back their loans with the sale house. The other side preferred this as an option.

You still haven’t answered two very important questions:

Why do you think you will have any inheritance when your parents have lost everything?

What are you doing to support your parents following their change of circumstances?

Poily · 28/01/2024 11:35

DB also paid for flight instructor training. Forget if this was self funded or if parents paid.

OP posts:
Poily · 28/01/2024 11:32

There was an arrangement set up that my parents would pay back their loans with the sale house. The other side preferred this as an option.

OP posts:
IncompleteSenten · 28/01/2024 11:26

XelaM · 28/01/2024 10:17

Wow it's a wonder anyone becomes a pilot with those kind of up front costs! Is this a career only for the rich? Who would be able to pay that kind of money up front? Seems insane especially as other well-paying careers are so much easier to get into.

Edited

My husband had lessons for his ppl. Fixed wing aircraft. 25 years ago and it was an eye watering £75 per hour.

It's always been bloody expensive!

notimagain · 28/01/2024 11:23

@XelaM

Wow it's a wonder anyone becomes a pilot with those kind of up front costs! Is this a career only for the rich? Who would be able to pay that kind of money up front? Seems insane especially as other well-paying careers are so much easier to get into.

The whole training situation in the UK radically maybe 30 years back the advent of “easy credit” and a lot of training has been paid for on the back of house price inflation.

FWIW I was a council house kid who benefited from the military system, served there quite some time, then spent my own money on what was need to gain civilian licences and ended up flying commercially for several decades.

goingdownfighting · 28/01/2024 11:15

OP this is none of your business.

Firstly how much has he already paid back?

Also it's worked out for your parents as any portion of the debt outstanding hasn't been used in a sinking business or paying off debts.

Also your brother has taken in a burden of debt going forward that will likely far exceed what he owes them.

If he pays back whatever he owes are you willing to step up and help your parents.

What are the other solutions?

MeinKraft · 28/01/2024 11:07

@Iwasafool the creditors haven't been given a choice though? The money has been hidden from them, they may not be happy to wait at all. We don't know that the money was owed to someone who wouldn't miss it for a few years like HMRC or Mastercard. The debts were accrued because of a small business folding so the creditors could very likely be the business suppliers, potentially other small businesses.

Poily · 28/01/2024 11:05

HoppingPavlova · 28/01/2024 02:44

@Frozensun A bond is usually when your employer pays for some specified training and you pay them back over a period of time (from your wages) or you agree to be based somewhere for a period. If you leave, employee pays the employer the outstanding amount. You don’t pay the amount up front and then have to pay back as well. So, I’m confused as to how any bond fits into this scenario

I think OP used incorrect terminology. I don’t think it was a bond per se, but rather he was bonded if he wanted reimbursement. It’s not uncommon.

One of my kids is in this scenario. They funded expensive quals up front as easier to get a job once qualified as opposed to sitting in huge pile of unqualified applicants wanting the job with employer forking out for quals and taking a chance on you passing, not failing, having to re-take etc. Because they have hired you as fully qualified but first role post quals (in that position), you are worth more to them instantly so they are happy to agree to reimburse you the cost of your quals providing you agree to be bonded. In my kids case, they reimbursed monthly over 2 years on the basis they are bonded for 5 years. If they leave anytime from day 1 right through to 1 day short of 5 years, they have to re-pay the employer their reimbursement for the quals. Nothing pro-rata about it. If they left 1 year into it, they can’t say the employer has received 1/5 and they shouldn’t repay this aspect of the reimbursement.

It seems to be common in roles across many industries now.

The flight schools and airlines refer to them as bonds.

All of a sudden the bond which initially provided you with APL sponsorship and formed part of your training fees, has now become owned by your employer. As a result, the airline now has security against your employment in a bid to provide financial incentive to prevent you from wanting to jump ship. As part of your employment contract you will receive terms for the return of your security bond in exchange for a number of years service of which the typical duration is around 7 to 10 years.

OP posts:
Iwasafool · 28/01/2024 10:50

MeinKraft · 27/01/2024 19:14

'Maybe the creditors have agreed to wait for the house to be sold as they will get their money then.'

Right so ignoring the completely unethical aspect of that, are the parents actually planning to continue sending £700 a month to the grandchildren's bank accounts even if the brother doesn't go to the Middle East, once the debts are paid? Because they'll probably want that money and if they're so badly in debt they're having to sell their house it sounds like they need it.

What is unethical about it? If the house will raise enough to pay everyone and they are willing to wait then surely it is between them. If you owe me £10k and you can either give me £100 a week for 2 years or give me £10k next year surely I can decide which I'd prefer. I'd prefer the lump sum as paying in bits and pieces just feels like you end up with less, if you were in that position and wanted the monthly payments then that's great, crack on.

XelaM · 28/01/2024 10:50

HoppingPavlova · 28/01/2024 10:39

Wow it's a wonder anyone becomes a pilot with those kind of up front costs! Is this a career only for the rich? Who would be able to pay that kind of money up front? Seems insane especially as other well-paying careers are so much easier to get into

Nope, not only for the rich, there are other pathways. I know 2 families where the kids got defence force scholarships. That meant:

  • salary from day 1 on entering the force
  • full degree funded by the defence force
  • finish basic training and immediately become an officer
  • pilot training, full quals, nothing to pay
  • they needed to stay with the defence force for 5 years from entry. Both of those kids quit immediately after their 5 years and had a job lined up on a major commercial. The airline trained them on their jumbo jets, paid whilst doing so, and started flying on very good money.

I also know of one person who went from the military (Air Force but non scholarship route so had to work their way up). Then they get into commercial airlines the same way but at an older age (around 30yo in this guys case). He said lots of them do this solely with the aim of transferring to large commercial airlines without having to fork out any money. He said they prefer to take people with military flight experience rather than those that have paid to achieve their quals in a civilian manner as it’s thought they perform better under pressure in an emergency situation, but that may be bunk and just his take on it, or may be true, no idea.

Thank you. That's very helpful. The aviation world is fascinating.

shepherdsangeldelight · 28/01/2024 10:44

I am very much thinking that the OP's children are only getting £700 a month because that's a way of hiding it from OP's parents creditors. Otherwise I doubt they would be getting anything (did they get anything before your brother's employer started paying back the bond money, OP?)

I also suspect that that's the amount that is coming back from the bond each month and as brother has agreed to cover it indefinitely, parents are no worse off and brother is no better off. OP is just worse off as a result of her parents being bankrupt.

HoppingPavlova · 28/01/2024 10:39

Wow it's a wonder anyone becomes a pilot with those kind of up front costs! Is this a career only for the rich? Who would be able to pay that kind of money up front? Seems insane especially as other well-paying careers are so much easier to get into

Nope, not only for the rich, there are other pathways. I know 2 families where the kids got defence force scholarships. That meant:

  • salary from day 1 on entering the force
  • full degree funded by the defence force
  • finish basic training and immediately become an officer
  • pilot training, full quals, nothing to pay
  • they needed to stay with the defence force for 5 years from entry. Both of those kids quit immediately after their 5 years and had a job lined up on a major commercial. The airline trained them on their jumbo jets, paid whilst doing so, and started flying on very good money.

I also know of one person who went from the military (Air Force but non scholarship route so had to work their way up). Then they get into commercial airlines the same way but at an older age (around 30yo in this guys case). He said lots of them do this solely with the aim of transferring to large commercial airlines without having to fork out any money. He said they prefer to take people with military flight experience rather than those that have paid to achieve their quals in a civilian manner as it’s thought they perform better under pressure in an emergency situation, but that may be bunk and just his take on it, or may be true, no idea.

FrenchieF · 28/01/2024 10:37

I’ve read through this thread I really can’t believe you want to keep receiving £700 a month for your kids when your parents are alive and well and need their money. Your brother is prepared to keep paying back and provide a home for your parents and your concern is your inheritance. For your brother to leave his airline it’s probably financially better to go with his new job or he would not have taken it. Your parents will benefit from having a secure home. I know it would be better to get the full amount in one go, but they may just end up paying it all to debtors.
its maybe the better solution. Hope it works out well for your parents. I’m sure they’ll help your kids if and when they can. You’ve already had a few years of deposits towards your kids . Be grateful for that. They sound like they have been very supportive and generous.

Olivie12 · 28/01/2024 10:21

You are very unreasonable!

If my parents were in so much debt, there's no way I would let them give my children $700 a month. The priority should be on paying the debt.

They are healthy and presumably have many years to live, they should save that money for their care in later years and only accept inheritance until they die.

It seems that you were taking advantage of them, you should be ashamed of yourself.

XelaM · 28/01/2024 10:17

notimagain · 28/01/2024 09:01

105k is the ideal case and will work if you come immediately out of the flying school with your MPL or ATPL with the brand new rating on a light twin and then go straight into the sponsoring airlines training on commercial type and straight onto the airlines payroll

Problem I have heard is that some of these supposedly sponsored courses didn’t guarantee a job straight out of flying school…any long gaps in the post training process due to the airline itself having a hold on it’s part of the process, usually the conversion onto the commercial type, and the students can end up having to pay out to keep that licence valid…certainly happened to a few due Covid, it’s still a risk if there’s a major downturn.

I do agree 150k is a bit of an outlier but I can see how that sort of cost could be accrued, IMHO it’s certainly credible.

If you are thinking of airline sponsored training (MPL or ATPL) you need to look at the small print in the contracts very carefully.

Edited

Wow it's a wonder anyone becomes a pilot with those kind of up front costs! Is this a career only for the rich? Who would be able to pay that kind of money up front? Seems insane especially as other well-paying careers are so much easier to get into.