Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No inheritance because of pilot training

557 replies

Poily · 27/01/2024 12:21

My brother is a pilot for a major airline in the UK. My parents were not able to borrow against their house to fund it so had to use pretty much all their savings. £150k was roughly what was spent.

Due to their failed business (folded just after Covid) they racked up massive loans trying to save their hospitality-related business. When they sell their house they won’t end up with much.

So I don’t know exactly how it works but some of that £150k ends up in a bond which the airline then pays out to my brother every month in his pay packet. But if my brother walks away from the airline he walks away from this bond also. It’s a lot of money. Gets paid over 7 years I think.

AIBU to think my brother should not quit his job and move to the Middle East (stupid salary) as he plans to do? He way paying that bond money to my parents.

Brother has said he will cover my parents bills. Great. Thats the right thing to do. But that cuts me out. As my parents were transferring the bond
money into a savings account for my kids.

AIBU?

OP posts:
BoohooWoohoo · 28/01/2024 16:09

Yalta · 28/01/2024 12:51

From my understanding the parents loaned ds £150,000 for his pilots training

The airline have been repaying this £150,000 money/bond whatever you want to call it at around £1700 per month and so far after about 4 years have repaid to ds £80,000

Except ds has been paying his parents back as £700 per month and keeping an extra £1000 to himself.

Now he wants to jack his job in, forget about repaying the other £116,000 because in a few years time he will build a house with an annexe for them and despite supposedly not having the money to pay for this dream property he is taking his parents to view houses he can’t afford in the hope they will forget about what he owes and they will live in rented for the foreseeable future with the dream of an annexe to keep them from thinking about what they could do if they had got paid back.

In the meantime, out of the goodness of his own heart (or the £116,000 he isn’t going to pay back) he is going to pay his parents rent and bills. Which will be more than £700. But I bet not more than £1000 per month (Don’t forget he has already been paid and not passed on a £1000 per month for the last 4 years)

Is nobody noticing the discrepancy

Everyone in this family is being unreasonable

The parents for depriving their creditors of money they are owed

The Ds for not repaying his parents

Op for taking £34,000 that should have gone to her parents creditors and still wanting an inheritance from her perfectly healthy parents

And the ds and his parents for wasting peoples time viewing properties they can’t afford and have no intention of buying

I am probably about the parents age and lost work and businesses in the pandemic.
Maybe I am different but if I had gone bankrupt then my first thought would be paying off creditors not trying to con them out of money they are owed.

I have been a creditor and it isn’t pleasant to lose 6 figures and look on as these people laugh about directing money owed to me and other creditors into family members bank accounts

There’s lots we don’t know.

The parents may be giving OP £700 out of the £1700 that they get each month. They are in debt with CCJs so map need £1000pm

As parents have CCJs and debts, they probably can’t find a landlord who will rent to them. Having their son rent a house on their behalf and paying bills might be more convenient for the parents because of the CCJs and debts. Even if brother stayed at his current job, it may be more convenient for the parents to have him rent a house and pay the bills on their behalf rather than receive cash because of the CCJs and debt situation. OP is assuming that paying their bills is an attempt to stop her kids getting £700pm but it’s impossible to say based on the info provided.

The wife has has agreed to living with the parents when they move back from the Middle East and OP says he’s a good guy so will probably come through with the house and bill promise.

daliesque · 28/01/2024 15:52

CJsGoldfish · 28/01/2024 13:55

I know my brother is doing a good thing caring for them but I am allowed to feel aggrieved by the imbalance of it all
By 'imbalance' I assume you mean your brother doing everything to take care of your parents whilst you do fuck all?
Your parents have been subsidising YOUR life choices, handsomely, for long enough don't you think? Their circumstances have changed and all you can do is bang on about not having extra money come your way anymore 🙄

This. You really do sound as if you begrudge your parents any comfortable life at all.
I'm not surprised they turned down your in laws rental. They probably realise how much they are being bitched about in your household and want nothing to do with it.....when they have been giving your kids a huge amount of money each month.
Your brother is a good man and it is funny to read the mental gymnastics that some people in this thread have made to make him out to be the bad guy and the OP anything other than the bitter, entitled madam she actually is.
You want a good retirement? A private pension? A social life now?
Get out and get a job then.

Lemonade84 · 28/01/2024 15:33

Wow! Honestly one of the most grabby threads I've ever read. My parents are in their 50s and inheritance wouldn't even cross my mind.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 28/01/2024 15:21

Poily · 28/01/2024 11:52

I would argue the £150k is the inheritance.

Day to day there is not much I can do. I’m a stay at home mum with very young children. We also live approx 2.5-3.5 hours away (depends heavily on London traffic)

My in laws offered my parents a rental property at reduced rates, they declined.

I know my brother is doing a good thing caring for them but I am allowed to feel aggrieved by the imbalance of it all.

The imbalance is in your favour.

Your brother has been loaned 150k that he is paying back.

Your children have been given £700 a month.

Abitofalark · 28/01/2024 15:03

Yalta · 28/01/2024 12:51

From my understanding the parents loaned ds £150,000 for his pilots training

The airline have been repaying this £150,000 money/bond whatever you want to call it at around £1700 per month and so far after about 4 years have repaid to ds £80,000

Except ds has been paying his parents back as £700 per month and keeping an extra £1000 to himself.

Now he wants to jack his job in, forget about repaying the other £116,000 because in a few years time he will build a house with an annexe for them and despite supposedly not having the money to pay for this dream property he is taking his parents to view houses he can’t afford in the hope they will forget about what he owes and they will live in rented for the foreseeable future with the dream of an annexe to keep them from thinking about what they could do if they had got paid back.

In the meantime, out of the goodness of his own heart (or the £116,000 he isn’t going to pay back) he is going to pay his parents rent and bills. Which will be more than £700. But I bet not more than £1000 per month (Don’t forget he has already been paid and not passed on a £1000 per month for the last 4 years)

Is nobody noticing the discrepancy

Everyone in this family is being unreasonable

The parents for depriving their creditors of money they are owed

The Ds for not repaying his parents

Op for taking £34,000 that should have gone to her parents creditors and still wanting an inheritance from her perfectly healthy parents

And the ds and his parents for wasting peoples time viewing properties they can’t afford and have no intention of buying

I am probably about the parents age and lost work and businesses in the pandemic.
Maybe I am different but if I had gone bankrupt then my first thought would be paying off creditors not trying to con them out of money they are owed.

I have been a creditor and it isn’t pleasant to lose 6 figures and look on as these people laugh about directing money owed to me and other creditors into family members bank accounts

There is more than one discrepancy. The OP has said variously that the airline is paying £700 a month or that the airline is paying at a rate that has repaid £80k over four years. It's not clear from the random snippets of information scattered like confetti what the actual facts and figures are. I've asked where the other £70k of the £150k is, as it appears to have been suggested it's not with the airline.

Also haven't you noticed that the brother isn't going to pay all of their rent and bills, which will be more than £700? And we don't know what's happening about a house because all we know is they are going to view "a property". This could mean a house to buy, a house to rent for them or a plot on which to build this house with annex that he envisages. He would presumably own both the house and the annex. So there are lots of unknowns which is why it is difficult to say who benefits and or loses more and where to place a judgement on who's right or wrong.

kkloo · 28/01/2024 14:39

Yalta · 28/01/2024 12:51

From my understanding the parents loaned ds £150,000 for his pilots training

The airline have been repaying this £150,000 money/bond whatever you want to call it at around £1700 per month and so far after about 4 years have repaid to ds £80,000

Except ds has been paying his parents back as £700 per month and keeping an extra £1000 to himself.

Now he wants to jack his job in, forget about repaying the other £116,000 because in a few years time he will build a house with an annexe for them and despite supposedly not having the money to pay for this dream property he is taking his parents to view houses he can’t afford in the hope they will forget about what he owes and they will live in rented for the foreseeable future with the dream of an annexe to keep them from thinking about what they could do if they had got paid back.

In the meantime, out of the goodness of his own heart (or the £116,000 he isn’t going to pay back) he is going to pay his parents rent and bills. Which will be more than £700. But I bet not more than £1000 per month (Don’t forget he has already been paid and not passed on a £1000 per month for the last 4 years)

Is nobody noticing the discrepancy

Everyone in this family is being unreasonable

The parents for depriving their creditors of money they are owed

The Ds for not repaying his parents

Op for taking £34,000 that should have gone to her parents creditors and still wanting an inheritance from her perfectly healthy parents

And the ds and his parents for wasting peoples time viewing properties they can’t afford and have no intention of buying

I am probably about the parents age and lost work and businesses in the pandemic.
Maybe I am different but if I had gone bankrupt then my first thought would be paying off creditors not trying to con them out of money they are owed.

I have been a creditor and it isn’t pleasant to lose 6 figures and look on as these people laugh about directing money owed to me and other creditors into family members bank accounts

There is no discrepancy when it comes to the brother, why are you trying to insist there is one. He's not planning on forgetting the other 100k+that he owes them.

He used to pay the money back from the airline, now he's going to pay it back from his new job.

There's no weird "out of the goodness of his heart" story here except for the one you're trying to spin.

kkloo · 28/01/2024 14:36

Poily · 28/01/2024 11:52

I would argue the £150k is the inheritance.

Day to day there is not much I can do. I’m a stay at home mum with very young children. We also live approx 2.5-3.5 hours away (depends heavily on London traffic)

My in laws offered my parents a rental property at reduced rates, they declined.

I know my brother is doing a good thing caring for them but I am allowed to feel aggrieved by the imbalance of it all.

How is it the inheritance when they don't have it to give?
They need that money to live off.

Yalta · 28/01/2024 14:25

TheShellBeach
*I'm also flouncing off this thread, OP, but not because you're a grabby and entitled individual.

It's because despite five different posts explaining to you how to quote when you're replying to people, you're still writing random posts, which make no sense, throughout your thread, and my autistic brain can't cope with that anymore*

Maybe she can’t use the quote function because like me her phone is too old to have the latest updates on it

How to tell someone you have a newer phone without saying you have a newer phone😄

daliesque · 28/01/2024 14:20

SuperGreens · 27/01/2024 12:52

So your brother has agreed to pay to house your parents for the rest of their lives, and you are angry about this because you would prefer that money goes to you instead?

Pretty much this.

Yalta · 28/01/2024 14:15

I know my brother is doing a good thing caring for them

Why do they need caring for. Are they infirm.
Why have they gone from business owners to not being able to take care of themselves in 4 years

Why didn’t they have a Limited company? That way they wouldn’t have lost the house

justtidying · 28/01/2024 14:06

Poily · 28/01/2024 12:19

Also my parents are not destitute. I am not taking advantage of people with nothing. They offered the £700. Both have private pensions. Yes, they can’t maintain their previous lifestyle. But still go for meals out, concerts etc. More than I do at any rate!

If they can't maintain this lifestyle, then refuse this money.

My parents are financially stable, private pensions etc. I wouldn't dream of accepting this amount for my DC for them. As I said, we settled on £10 a month, which I have saved for them.

Tell them to keep their money, they worked hard for it, and that you will take care of your grandchildren. That might help them sort out their living arrangements.

TheShellBeach · 28/01/2024 13:57

I'm also flouncing off this thread, OP, but not because you're a grabby and entitled individual.

It's because despite five different posts explaining to you how to quote when you're replying to people, you're still writing random posts, which make no sense, throughout your thread, and my autistic brain can't cope with that anymore.

CJsGoldfish · 28/01/2024 13:55

I know my brother is doing a good thing caring for them but I am allowed to feel aggrieved by the imbalance of it all
By 'imbalance' I assume you mean your brother doing everything to take care of your parents whilst you do fuck all?
Your parents have been subsidising YOUR life choices, handsomely, for long enough don't you think? Their circumstances have changed and all you can do is bang on about not having extra money come your way anymore 🙄

splutter · 28/01/2024 13:52

But your brother is paying back the £150k. I'm struggling to see why you think he is winning and you are losing.
At the end of the day he will have paid back the money so hasn't had an inheritance. He will house them until their end time which will end up costing him more than he borrowed in bills, council tax etc. Your dc have some tens of thousands.

Why do you feel he has something you don't?

Menomeno · 28/01/2024 13:40

We’ve been generous with our children. We’ve gifted each of them a house deposit and helped them out with interest free loans. They know that if they’re ever in need they can turn to us. BUT DH and I always say that if any of them ever became expectant or grabby, or felt they were entitled to OUR money, they wouldn’t see another penny while we’re alive or dead. I would be heartbroken if my kids behaved like this.

roarrfeckingroar · 28/01/2024 13:34

I'm confused.

Your parents gave your DB ~ £150k.
He is paying them back and will be providing care when they live with him in later life.

So that cancels out the £150k as it's being paid back.

Why should you/your kids get money from your parents? Wouldn't that be unfair on your brother?

dimllaishebiaith · 28/01/2024 13:12

If the bond was being repaid over 7 years, and its already been 4 of those years then over half the bond has been repaid back. You parents may therefore consider the half that's been paid back to be "yours" and the other half to be your brothers

The fact you are moaning when over half has already been paid back makes it sound like you think the whole of it should be "yours"

SuperDopper · 28/01/2024 13:06

Yalta · 28/01/2024 12:51

From my understanding the parents loaned ds £150,000 for his pilots training

The airline have been repaying this £150,000 money/bond whatever you want to call it at around £1700 per month and so far after about 4 years have repaid to ds £80,000

Except ds has been paying his parents back as £700 per month and keeping an extra £1000 to himself.

Now he wants to jack his job in, forget about repaying the other £116,000 because in a few years time he will build a house with an annexe for them and despite supposedly not having the money to pay for this dream property he is taking his parents to view houses he can’t afford in the hope they will forget about what he owes and they will live in rented for the foreseeable future with the dream of an annexe to keep them from thinking about what they could do if they had got paid back.

In the meantime, out of the goodness of his own heart (or the £116,000 he isn’t going to pay back) he is going to pay his parents rent and bills. Which will be more than £700. But I bet not more than £1000 per month (Don’t forget he has already been paid and not passed on a £1000 per month for the last 4 years)

Is nobody noticing the discrepancy

Everyone in this family is being unreasonable

The parents for depriving their creditors of money they are owed

The Ds for not repaying his parents

Op for taking £34,000 that should have gone to her parents creditors and still wanting an inheritance from her perfectly healthy parents

And the ds and his parents for wasting peoples time viewing properties they can’t afford and have no intention of buying

I am probably about the parents age and lost work and businesses in the pandemic.
Maybe I am different but if I had gone bankrupt then my first thought would be paying off creditors not trying to con them out of money they are owed.

I have been a creditor and it isn’t pleasant to lose 6 figures and look on as these people laugh about directing money owed to me and other creditors into family members bank accounts

There’s no discrepancy. We have no idea how much is being repaid each month. OP assumes it’s £700 because that’s how much was being set aside for her children.

The brother will continue repayments. But rather than giving to parents who will give to landlord, he’s giving direct to landlord. I suspect that’s to allow their parents to claim benefits so that the don’t have to declare £700 being paid into their account each month which will exceed the £6k savings limit.

Yalta · 28/01/2024 13:03

*Sirzy · Today 12:53

We don’t know how much he has been paying back each month. The OP has said as much, she is guessing £700 as that’s what is paid for her children each month but like most of the figures she has just been guessing*

They have been declared bankrupt so we do know that the ds has been only repaying £700 per month which has I presume gone straight into grandchildren’s bank account because if he had paid his parents then none of it would have gone into the gcs bank account. It would have gone to who ever was dealing with the bankruptcy and paying off creditors.

The guessing on the other figures seem to add up to what he has been paid back through the airline

Teder · 28/01/2024 12:53

Poily · 28/01/2024 11:52

I would argue the £150k is the inheritance.

Day to day there is not much I can do. I’m a stay at home mum with very young children. We also live approx 2.5-3.5 hours away (depends heavily on London traffic)

My in laws offered my parents a rental property at reduced rates, they declined.

I know my brother is doing a good thing caring for them but I am allowed to feel aggrieved by the imbalance of it all.

can you explain why you think it’s the inheritance? How would they live? They’d spend that on rent, surely?

why are you accepting £700 a month for your children while they are losing their home?! Why are you bloody whining about your inheritance when you are receiving it now via your children.

you have chosen to have children, be a SAHM and you don’t do anything to help your parents yet your brother is being criticised?

if you were my daughter, I’d withdraw the £700 a month immediately. So ungrateful and money grabbing.

Sirzy · 28/01/2024 12:53

We don’t know how much he has been paying back each month. The OP has said as much, she is guessing £700 as that’s what is paid for her children each month but like most of the figures she has just been guessing.

Yalta · 28/01/2024 12:51

From my understanding the parents loaned ds £150,000 for his pilots training

The airline have been repaying this £150,000 money/bond whatever you want to call it at around £1700 per month and so far after about 4 years have repaid to ds £80,000

Except ds has been paying his parents back as £700 per month and keeping an extra £1000 to himself.

Now he wants to jack his job in, forget about repaying the other £116,000 because in a few years time he will build a house with an annexe for them and despite supposedly not having the money to pay for this dream property he is taking his parents to view houses he can’t afford in the hope they will forget about what he owes and they will live in rented for the foreseeable future with the dream of an annexe to keep them from thinking about what they could do if they had got paid back.

In the meantime, out of the goodness of his own heart (or the £116,000 he isn’t going to pay back) he is going to pay his parents rent and bills. Which will be more than £700. But I bet not more than £1000 per month (Don’t forget he has already been paid and not passed on a £1000 per month for the last 4 years)

Is nobody noticing the discrepancy

Everyone in this family is being unreasonable

The parents for depriving their creditors of money they are owed

The Ds for not repaying his parents

Op for taking £34,000 that should have gone to her parents creditors and still wanting an inheritance from her perfectly healthy parents

And the ds and his parents for wasting peoples time viewing properties they can’t afford and have no intention of buying

I am probably about the parents age and lost work and businesses in the pandemic.
Maybe I am different but if I had gone bankrupt then my first thought would be paying off creditors not trying to con them out of money they are owed.

I have been a creditor and it isn’t pleasant to lose 6 figures and look on as these people laugh about directing money owed to me and other creditors into family members bank accounts

Jk8 · 28/01/2024 12:43

HoppingPavlova · 28/01/2024 01:34

Anyway, the whole thing is just a maths issue and OP doesn’t understand maths.

*Brother borrows 150K
*Brothers employer will repay this 150K over 7 years.
*Brother agrees to repay parents at $700/month over 17-20 years (as OP seemed to think his loan repayments were 700/month).
*Parents choosing to give grandkids 700/month as a gift, now around 30/40K total.
*Parents go bust, no $$ left from business, debt, house sold, no equity. This leaves them no spare $$ to gift to grandkids as savings as they have been doing.
*Brother will now be paying 700/month as rent/bills on behalf of parents instead of directly to parents who will pay it as rent/bills. Smart move as parents unlikely to get rental in own names due to debt plus otherwise it would be see as income that may effect pension/entitlements.
*If brother pays 700/month rent/bills for next 15 years the initial debt is repaid. At this point the only people ‘ahead’ is OP’s kids who have a 30/40 K gift sitting there.
*Brother may go work in ME for 5 or so years. Higher salary means more than current salary including reimbursement (or they wouldn’t do it). They are still repaying 700/month to parents in form of covering rent/bills during this time.
*When the come home from ME they can either keep repaying 700/month to parents in form of covering rent/bills for 10 years and be even (debt repaid), OR can provide an annex for parents in lieu of rent/bills for this time and also be even.
*If parents pass away after 15 years, brothers debt has been repaid but OP’s kids still have gift of 30/40K. So at that point brother is the one out of pocket with inheritance and if OP is so concerned about being fair, should have her kids hand over 15/20K. Doubt that would be offered or requested.

Whole thing seems to be odd storm in a teacup by someone who can’t do maths, and has weird ideas about what/when inheritance even is!

I think OP's just having a delayed reaction to the fact her parents who have always provided for 'kids' them/the brother/grandchildren are no longer wealthy or in that position & is upset it's her kids will grow up outside of the lifestyle she had (the decision to go it alone at uni but still get help when needed, support for pilot training, £700 a month in savings for her babies ect.)

Lots of people lose jobs, businesses, houses in their lifetime & thankfully your parents sound like good generous people who set themselves up well with a high earning son who will stand by them while building his own career.

As for the grief around it - & it is genuine grief for family members who experiance this sort of 'poverty' change - there is counciling & support out there

IncompleteSenten · 28/01/2024 12:31

I'm flouncing off the thread and unwatching now because I've known people like you in real life and it's disgusting and bad for my blood pressure. Three memorable ones were a) talking about taking money off their elderly parent as borrowing against the inheritance and b) picking up the parent's belongings and talking about who'd get what and what it was worth while the parent was in the next room and c) when their remaining parent did die, said that, and I quote " if he'd died 3 years ago the house would have sold for a lot more"

So I see you and I hope you get all the pennies you richly deserve out of them.

pinkyredrose · 28/01/2024 12:28

Sirzy · 27/01/2024 20:52

You’re right it is unequal.

one child is trying to support his parents through a horrible period and make sure they are suitably provided for.

the other is complaining about her children not getting £700 a month and saying she can’t help as she doesn’t live close.

This.