Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No inheritance because of pilot training

557 replies

Poily · 27/01/2024 12:21

My brother is a pilot for a major airline in the UK. My parents were not able to borrow against their house to fund it so had to use pretty much all their savings. £150k was roughly what was spent.

Due to their failed business (folded just after Covid) they racked up massive loans trying to save their hospitality-related business. When they sell their house they won’t end up with much.

So I don’t know exactly how it works but some of that £150k ends up in a bond which the airline then pays out to my brother every month in his pay packet. But if my brother walks away from the airline he walks away from this bond also. It’s a lot of money. Gets paid over 7 years I think.

AIBU to think my brother should not quit his job and move to the Middle East (stupid salary) as he plans to do? He way paying that bond money to my parents.

Brother has said he will cover my parents bills. Great. Thats the right thing to do. But that cuts me out. As my parents were transferring the bond
money into a savings account for my kids.

AIBU?

OP posts:
changeme4this · 28/01/2024 19:49
  1. Sit down with your parents and brother and have a frank discussion with proper figures as to who has borrowed what, been given what (your children) and how much is left to be repaid of the loan.
  2. forget inheritance. The parents are not dead yet, may still need to end up in a care facility which costs, and 150k pounds or whatever is left isn’t much to cover the additional amounts they will need. the balance if any, of the loan may well be going into the construction costs for the annex that will be housing your parents…
laclochette · 28/01/2024 19:47

I think talking about it as "inheritance" is an unfortunate framing that has led to a lot of the criticism you're getting.

Basically your brother has had a loan from your parents to the tune of £150k that has given him a big financial advantage. You haven't - presumably you've not wanted or needed that sort of money for a specific career goal - but it does feel lopsided and I can understand the sense of injustice. I'm a bit confused by the complexity of the whole job / bond situation to be honest, not a world I'm familiar with, but ultimately if he pays them back in some form, then it will equal out, surely. If I've understood correctly, he is offering to cover their living costs - and paying their rent is still giving them money, it's just money given with a specific purpose in mind.

What's complicated matters is that your parents' financial circumstances have changed and badly, so they're now in a less fortunate position and are less able to continue to gift to the remainder of the family in the meantime.

Your parents are much less well off than they used to be. Surely that is ultimately the reason why they can't enrich you/your kids. You used to have wealthy parents and prospects to match. Now you have poor parents. You need to adjust your expectations accordingly.

steff13 · 28/01/2024 19:31

Poily · 28/01/2024 11:52

I would argue the £150k is the inheritance.

Day to day there is not much I can do. I’m a stay at home mum with very young children. We also live approx 2.5-3.5 hours away (depends heavily on London traffic)

My in laws offered my parents a rental property at reduced rates, they declined.

I know my brother is doing a good thing caring for them but I am allowed to feel aggrieved by the imbalance of it all.

But the argument that the 150,000 is an inheritance is completely unsupported.

Jk8 · 28/01/2024 19:26

Jk8 · 28/01/2024 19:25

@splutter Clearly you read the post it was attatched to...?

The figures were mentioned by that poster & I was clarifying that if his income was £1,700 a month then £700 payments would be a large chunk that would leave him with £1000 to live on which is not at all the same as some with £1,000+ a month flinging the odd £50 & she got the figure in guessing from the OP saying the original money would be payed back in wages over a minimal service time period ?!?

*minimun

Jk8 · 28/01/2024 19:25

@splutter Clearly you read the post it was attatched to...?

The figures were mentioned by that poster & I was clarifying that if his income was £1,700 a month then £700 payments would be a large chunk that would leave him with £1000 to live on which is not at all the same as some with £1,000+ a month flinging the odd £50 & she got the figure in guessing from the OP saying the original money would be payed back in wages over a minimal service time period ?!?

kkloo · 28/01/2024 19:24

Universalsnail · 28/01/2024 18:42

Your parents can spend their money how they like. Noone is entitled to inheritance. That said if he pretty pissed if my parents spent 150k on my sibling and therefore I would get nothing.

Except they didn't do that did they?

They lent him 150k, he's been paying them back and is still continuing to pay them back.

splutter · 28/01/2024 19:19

@Jk8 @Yalta
Where are you getting these figures from? I've scoured the OPs posts and I can't see anything about £116k or £1700 being paid by the airline? Who's come up with these figures.

I read it as the parents lent 150k. He's been paying them back. We have no idea how much has been paid back.

Separately the parents have been paying 700 pm into an account for the OPs dc.

The parents are selling their mortgage free house to pay off their debts.

The brother is changing jobs but will continue to pay back the parents by paying their rent once they have sold their house and move into rental

At some point in the future when the brother returns to the uk the parents will live with him at which point he will cover all their costs.

The parents are not particularly old or frail so presumably they will end up living with brother on his dime for many many years/decades.

In what part of this will the brother not be paying back the inheritance plus some? The parents will potentially be living with him on his money for 15-25 years. He's covering them.

Jk8 · 28/01/2024 19:09

@Yalta No mention of creditors (but a mention of them selling their house to pay bills im assuming their attempting to pay off any outstanding debts) but it's possible they might be more accepting of money being paid directly to the landlord so a £700 a month regualr payment doesn't interfere with their welfare payments if theyve signed on ???

Jk8 · 28/01/2024 19:05

Yalta · 28/01/2024 12:51

From my understanding the parents loaned ds £150,000 for his pilots training

The airline have been repaying this £150,000 money/bond whatever you want to call it at around £1700 per month and so far after about 4 years have repaid to ds £80,000

Except ds has been paying his parents back as £700 per month and keeping an extra £1000 to himself.

Now he wants to jack his job in, forget about repaying the other £116,000 because in a few years time he will build a house with an annexe for them and despite supposedly not having the money to pay for this dream property he is taking his parents to view houses he can’t afford in the hope they will forget about what he owes and they will live in rented for the foreseeable future with the dream of an annexe to keep them from thinking about what they could do if they had got paid back.

In the meantime, out of the goodness of his own heart (or the £116,000 he isn’t going to pay back) he is going to pay his parents rent and bills. Which will be more than £700. But I bet not more than £1000 per month (Don’t forget he has already been paid and not passed on a £1000 per month for the last 4 years)

Is nobody noticing the discrepancy

Everyone in this family is being unreasonable

The parents for depriving their creditors of money they are owed

The Ds for not repaying his parents

Op for taking £34,000 that should have gone to her parents creditors and still wanting an inheritance from her perfectly healthy parents

And the ds and his parents for wasting peoples time viewing properties they can’t afford and have no intention of buying

I am probably about the parents age and lost work and businesses in the pandemic.
Maybe I am different but if I had gone bankrupt then my first thought would be paying off creditors not trying to con them out of money they are owed.

I have been a creditor and it isn’t pleasant to lose 6 figures and look on as these people laugh about directing money owed to me and other creditors into family members bank accounts

•The parents were wealthy/wealthier when their children were younger

•The parents paid £150k for getting their son training for a job (= income)

•The job paid £1,700 of which he paid back £700 a month while living on £1,000

•The parents didn't need the money & neither did OP so they put it into savings for her children - their grandchildren

• the parents later lost their business & are now selling their house for no profit

• op's brother decieded to go for a higher earning job abroad that will advance his career

• the brother earning more (& probably getting free housing if he's based overseas) said he will pay the formally 'unneeded' money directly to a landlord to get them properly housed & when he returns to the UK will plan long term to house them in a place with him

• OP's kids are no longer recieving £700 a month because her grandparents are no longer wealthy NOT because their family no longer cares

• OP's just realised how bad the situation is & the lifestyle changes now she doesnt have parents who own their own home & business & a brother getting a garunteed income & her children £700 a month shes got a brother whos advancing her career, parents who are supporting him & planning their lives around that & children she will need to take on a second job to have any sort of hope of putting almost £10k a year into savings for

cremebrulait · 28/01/2024 18:52

Poily · 27/01/2024 12:26

No my parents are fit and healthy. But this new arrangement means I have no hope of having anything.

I find it in poor taste for anyone to be concerning themselves about their possible future inheritance. Its their money. Their choice. And who knows what the future holds. How dare anyone expect to inherit.

Rummikub · 28/01/2024 18:51

But op would you really feel
comfortable getting that 700/month whilst your brother pays your parents bills and your parents then potentially go without in their retirement?

What is your solution to this? Could your parents move in with you?

HeidInTheBaw · 28/01/2024 18:49

I know 2 airlines that do this for sure. Others ‘bond’ pilots for a few years so they get the cost of their training on a certain type of aircraft back. Pilots can leave but they have to pay the cost of the type-rating back. Pilots in the UK don’t earn as much as people think. A first officer is lucky to start on around £24k.

splutter · 28/01/2024 18:46

Universalsnail · 28/01/2024 18:42

Your parents can spend their money how they like. Noone is entitled to inheritance. That said if he pretty pissed if my parents spent 150k on my sibling and therefore I would get nothing.

Would you be pissed if your sibling paid your parents back, housed your parents with them in their old age and your parents put tens of thousands in an account for your dc too?

Universalsnail · 28/01/2024 18:42

Your parents can spend their money how they like. Noone is entitled to inheritance. That said if he pretty pissed if my parents spent 150k on my sibling and therefore I would get nothing.

Happygoluckyx · 28/01/2024 18:37

Because neither you or your kids have any right to anyone’s money until the moment in time they choose to give it to you. This reeks of entitlement. I’m sure you’re a nice person really and this is just a blip

kkloo · 28/01/2024 18:36

boomingaround · 28/01/2024 17:57

This is an extremely strange thread. The OP and half of the people on it don't seem to understand that if you pay money back it is a loan not a gift.

The OPs children has been getting money from her parents when her brother has not been getting anything. If her brother and her children were being given the same amount then her parents would have been waiving the £700 monthly repayment due from her brother and paying the same amount to her children.

OP you are being extremely selfish and entitled. You should be grateful to your brother for helping support your parents. I'm actually staggered you have allowed your parents to pay your children anything when they clearly can't afford it and have lost everything themselves.

It's extremely strange. They seem to have just run with the very misleading thread title and ignored all the facts in the OP which showed that the brother is still continuing to pay it back.

The only difference now is that the parents will be using it for living costs, instead of putting it in the OPs kids savings!

Pinkrinse · 28/01/2024 18:30

Poily · 27/01/2024 12:28

But this inheritance will be stopping due to brother’s suggested set up

If your brother is paying them back by paying bills, then your parents will have excess money saved by not paying bills. It up to your parents what they do but I think you should speak to them about how you feel this unfair to you. If you don’t it will fester.

mickey54 · 28/01/2024 18:20

I

DoughBallss · 28/01/2024 18:19

it has worked out unfair yes but your parents spent their money on what they wanted to spend it on.

i really dislike this mindset that inheritance is god given right. Aim to get yourself to a point where you don’t need inheritance and hope your parents die long after you need it.

pmama · 28/01/2024 18:02

The problem is in the maths - 150k for 7 years is monthly 1,785, without any interest (think about last year inflation...). If same period is discussed, it would be much less. Maybe new rental would be under the name of brother (referring to transfer directly to landlord), could it mean some less tax payment situation?
Future build a house project is too uncertain and far away, maybe he will never move back to the UK. Bear in mind, I guess if there would be any health issues due to age, the living abroad sibling would have difficulties to offer immediate help, so more pressure on the in UK sibling.
I think 150k is huge amount of money if it is provided to one sibling and missing out the other. Pilots are paid well (usually), so it could mean that missed out sibling is more challenged in life, not just because she was not provided with the amount, but also that chosen job is paying less (as self financed education choices are sometimes made with more compromises).

boomingaround · 28/01/2024 17:57

This is an extremely strange thread. The OP and half of the people on it don't seem to understand that if you pay money back it is a loan not a gift.

The OPs children has been getting money from her parents when her brother has not been getting anything. If her brother and her children were being given the same amount then her parents would have been waiving the £700 monthly repayment due from her brother and paying the same amount to her children.

OP you are being extremely selfish and entitled. You should be grateful to your brother for helping support your parents. I'm actually staggered you have allowed your parents to pay your children anything when they clearly can't afford it and have lost everything themselves.

Citylady88 · 28/01/2024 17:45

I understand to an extent why you're upset OP. The thing is though given your parents bad financial choices lately isn't it likely that if there was a safe 150k sat in the bank pre covid it would have been used to try save their business, or would now form part of what they currently owe along with house value, or need to be used from now on to support them in their retirement. So in almost every circumstance it would be gone. And if your brother didn't owe them now instead of him funding them now they'd be asking you for financial support too.

fetchacloth · 28/01/2024 17:40

CreateHope · 27/01/2024 12:27

Inheritance isn’t a birth right 🙄

Quite. It's the parents' money and entirely up to them.

kkloo · 28/01/2024 16:21

@BoohooWoohoo
OP is assuming that paying their bills is an attempt to stop her kids getting £700pm but it’s impossible to say based on the info provided.

Presumably the parents need the rent and bills paid so the money goes directly to that.
If they don't need the money for rent and bills then the fact that the brother will pay them should mean they have enough money left to keep paying into the kids bank accounts if they want to, but they haven't offered that so presumably they want to stop the arrangement.

kkloo · 28/01/2024 16:09

Lemonade84 · 28/01/2024 15:33

Wow! Honestly one of the most grabby threads I've ever read. My parents are in their 50s and inheritance wouldn't even cross my mind.

Especially when they've lost everything including their house!!
And the OP thinks that the money the brother is paying them back should continue to go to her kids.
Insane.