Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No inheritance because of pilot training

557 replies

Poily · 27/01/2024 12:21

My brother is a pilot for a major airline in the UK. My parents were not able to borrow against their house to fund it so had to use pretty much all their savings. £150k was roughly what was spent.

Due to their failed business (folded just after Covid) they racked up massive loans trying to save their hospitality-related business. When they sell their house they won’t end up with much.

So I don’t know exactly how it works but some of that £150k ends up in a bond which the airline then pays out to my brother every month in his pay packet. But if my brother walks away from the airline he walks away from this bond also. It’s a lot of money. Gets paid over 7 years I think.

AIBU to think my brother should not quit his job and move to the Middle East (stupid salary) as he plans to do? He way paying that bond money to my parents.

Brother has said he will cover my parents bills. Great. Thats the right thing to do. But that cuts me out. As my parents were transferring the bond
money into a savings account for my kids.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Shania7788 · 27/01/2024 15:07

If the deal was to pay your parents back then yes he should do this. It sounds like he will be paying it in the form of rent and bills which is still paying it back. It also sounds like your parents need this money to live so it’s unreasonable to expect it to go straight to your kids. Your only option is to speak to all of them and ask for some of it to be paid to you like the original plan. However, your parents’ money is theirs to do what they want with, it’s only inheritance if they have passed away. So if they need it to live because of their failed business it’s tough luck and you will have to see if anything is left after they pass away

Pookerrod · 27/01/2024 15:06

HarrietStyles · 27/01/2024 14:21

But they didn’t give him any money 🤷🏼‍♀️They loaned him money that he is paying back and still continues to pay back. So the brother ends up with nothing. The OP however HAS been gifted money every month by her parents, with no expectation to repay it, she’s just pissed that it’s stopping. If anyone has been unfairly treated it’s the brother.

This!

Plus on top of the brother paying back the loan, he is offering to house then for the rest of their days which must be a massive weight off their shoulders.

You are being super unreasonable OP. If anything, you should be offering the money your parents have given your children back. They clearly cannot afford to be passing inheritance on before their deaths.

redheadsaregreat · 27/01/2024 15:06

OP when your parents gave them the 700 directly and they then paid 700 rent, where did the money come from to put towards your dc?

Because if now he pays direct to the landlord then they don't have to so they will still have 700 more than they would have had. Why are they stopping putting money aside for your dcs? Not that they need to but the maths doesn't add up.

YeahIsaidit · 27/01/2024 15:04

redheadsaregreat · 27/01/2024 15:02

It's irrelevant where it goes as long as it is being repaid. You are stuck on semantics. He gives it to them and they pay rent or he keys it directly to the landlord. No difference. He is still 700 down and they are still 700 up.

But now that it's going directly to a landlord, OP(s kids, yeah right) won't get anything, greedy mare

redheadsaregreat · 27/01/2024 15:02

Poily · 27/01/2024 12:44

Yes but my brother will no longer transfer £700 to parents in new arrangement. His repayment comes in the form of rent will be directly paid to landlord.

It's irrelevant where it goes as long as it is being repaid. You are stuck on semantics. He gives it to them and they pay rent or he keys it directly to the landlord. No difference. He is still 700 down and they are still 700 up.

NewFriendlyLadybird · 27/01/2024 15:02

How much of the bond has been repaid already and is sitting in your children’s savings accounts?
Are you suggesting that your brother remains on a lower salary for x more years in order to ensure that your parents continue to pay money into your children’s savings accounts, even if they might not be able to cover their own rent?
Do you think that he should not take this opportunity to earn a much higher salary, cover your parents’ rent and bills, and then accommodate them with him when they retire?

Jk8 · 27/01/2024 15:01

Poily · 27/01/2024 12:39

Why should my brother’s choice of repayment negatively impact my kids?

So basically your parents, when they were better off, supported their kids = your brother & you & now their poor they can't also support your kids ???

I agree it's unfair given how you's have been raised (no judgement as id love it myself) but realistically you'll have to find the money to support your own kids from now on .

redheadsaregreat · 27/01/2024 15:00

Poily · 27/01/2024 12:35

Well my brother has said he will be pay their rent alongside some spending money. And parents are happy with that. So the £150k seems to have been forgotten.

I think the long term plan is for brother to save money whilst he works in the Middle East (no income tax) and then come back to the UK and build a house with accommodation for parents.

I think my parents view this as my brother as being generous. So the £150k is very neatly forgotten about.

If he's paying for their rent then he IS still paying back the loan. Why is this not how you see things?

redheadsaregreat · 27/01/2024 14:58

OP isn't it more 'no inheritance because your parents are broke'?

They lent your DB money. As long as he pays it back then there is no inequality. Neither of you will have got anything from them. Infact your dc have money being put aside for them so potentially they will be benefiting a bit.

If he doesn't pay it back you have more of a point

XelaM · 27/01/2024 14:58

Caerulea · 27/01/2024 14:54

By the sounds of it, your parents have lost everything. Their business (and hospitality is usually a labour of love) & their home. I'm not sure why this money is coming to your kids at all, it should be for them to live out their forced retirement, to do mad shit with if they want to.

I'd be devastated if my parents struggled in their older years & my kids benefited from that.

This! Why is the £700 your brother paying going to your kids? I don't get the set-up at all.

Theatrefan12 · 27/01/2024 14:58

I'd be devastated if my parents struggled in their older years & my kids benefited from that.

This 100%!

To even be moaning about her parents money when they have this going on is what makes the OP come across badly

As others have asked but as far I can see the OP has not answered, what has happened to the money already paid into the kids accounts? Because if my parents business had failed and they had debts then that money would be going back to them without a thought

skyeisthelimit · 27/01/2024 14:56

Ohnoooooooo · 27/01/2024 14:40

The man has been paying the money back - sounds very much like the money was a loan rather than a gift. So its not that he was given the money as an early inheritance or considers it an early inheritance.
When he pays it back sounds like he will not have an inheritance either due to tight finances but can't these poor parents be allowed to spend their own money in their life time on themselves?

yes of course, which is why my post says if there is nothing left, there is nothing to leave.

I also said that inheritance is not guaranteed. At the end of the day the money belongs to the person and if there is any left when they die, then the family get an inheritance.

I will make some provision for my DD by putting at least half the house in her name, which will also save it from care home fees, but ultimately I would not live in poverty just to be able to leave an inheritance. Inheritance is "leftovers" in a way.

OP is entitled to feel hard done by though if DB ends up having been gifted money and she gets nothing. Even if originally loaned, it turns into gifted once the repayments stop.

If the payments are continuing but are needed to pay for living costs, then ultimately DB will repay it all, and house the parents, and there won't be any inheritance for either of them.

DrRichardWebber · 27/01/2024 14:56

I totally get what you’re saying. My brother is also a pilot, and borrowed from my parents to do the course. He’s paid it all back now because he’s earning mega bucks. As should your brother. YANBU.

Megifer · 27/01/2024 14:56

SuperDopper · 27/01/2024 13:56

Except it isn’t a gift and he’s still paying them back?

Think everyone knows it's going to turn into at least a partial gift of a huge amount. 150k at 700 a month....minus whatever tiny dent he's put in it.... my maths isn't great but that's a pretty long time.

Also tbh my comment was just a general observation about MN competitive not-arsedness about unequal treatment with siblings.

Abitofalark · 27/01/2024 14:55

catelynjane · 27/01/2024 13:55

It's about her 4th or 5th post into the thread. She says their rent and bills will come to more than £700 a month or something.

Ah, thank you. I read the OP several times thinking I was going mad. Following your tip, I found it! The OP's post no 6 says

Parents rent and bills will be more than £700 a month.

And no 8:

Yes but my brother will no longer transfer £700 to parents in new arrangement. His repayment comes in the form of rent will be directly paid to landlord.

I have more questions than answers but from the bits and pieces it seems that the brother paid for his training using a loan of £150k from parents, which his airline employer is reimbursing him for over 7 years, from which he pays back his parents £700 a month. And now that arrangement may cease.

Beyond that we know the parents have had some misfortune and own a house with debts and we don't know the OP's or brother's own current financial circumstances and whether they own property or assets.

SuperDopper · 27/01/2024 14:55

skyeisthelimit · 27/01/2024 14:36

OP, ignore all the nasty comments. YANBU to feel this way, however inheritance is never guaranteed, so you need to think of this as gifts.

What is unfair, is that your DB has been given over £150K and you have received nothing. It sounds like your parents were trying to equalise that unfairness by putting the bond money aside for your DC.

Due to your DB wanting to change jobs, that will stop .

Yes it is extremely unfair. DB is a little selfish to quit before he has repaid your parents.

You need to discuss this with your parents, but if they have nothing, then there is nothing to leave.

DB is taking care of your parents financially so none of that should fall to you, due to the circumstances.

FGS. Do people not read posts properly?!

The money was a loan. There is no gift. It was being repaid. And it is still being paid back.

OP is just bitter that the repayments won’t be set aside for her and her children anymore and instead used on her parents’ living costs, after they lost their home and business.

Spirallingdownwards · 27/01/2024 14:55

skyeisthelimit · 27/01/2024 14:36

OP, ignore all the nasty comments. YANBU to feel this way, however inheritance is never guaranteed, so you need to think of this as gifts.

What is unfair, is that your DB has been given over £150K and you have received nothing. It sounds like your parents were trying to equalise that unfairness by putting the bond money aside for your DC.

Due to your DB wanting to change jobs, that will stop .

Yes it is extremely unfair. DB is a little selfish to quit before he has repaid your parents.

You need to discuss this with your parents, but if they have nothing, then there is nothing to leave.

DB is taking care of your parents financially so none of that should fall to you, due to the circumstances.

Except he has been given nothing.

He was loaned money and is paying it back.

OP's kids have been given money.

If the £150k is to be split equally to OP/DB he needs to repay £75k. He has already paid some. He will continue paying and we don't know how how much he has already reaped.

THEN he will house and look after his parents by providing housing and no financial worries. Meanwhile OP is helping them how?

Caerulea · 27/01/2024 14:54

By the sounds of it, your parents have lost everything. Their business (and hospitality is usually a labour of love) & their home. I'm not sure why this money is coming to your kids at all, it should be for them to live out their forced retirement, to do mad shit with if they want to.

I'd be devastated if my parents struggled in their older years & my kids benefited from that.

LookItsMeAgain · 27/01/2024 14:53

@Poily - I am thinking that you need to shift your mindset from thinking that this is your inheritance or something that your children may be in line to receive.

I do think that if your parents paid £150k towards your brother receiving his wings, he need to take out a loan for that amount and pay the £150k back to his parents so his financial dealings are with a bank and not your parents any more.

That way, your parents have their money to do with as they see fit when they can decide how/what to do with it.

I also think that if they are 'forgetting' about the £150k (which is a hell of a lot of money to be forgetting about or writing off) they either see your brother as the golden child or they themselves have little appreciation for the cost of things and the value of money. They have had money in the past and they probably believe that they still have time to get it again. This is not necessarily true.

If I were you, I'd arrange to have a chat with both parents and explain that the money they spent on your brother getting his pilot's license could see them comfortably off for a while into their retirement but as it is, they are going to have to be very frugal with no mention of any inheritance at all. Let the focus be on them and their financial situation and you are simply expressing a concern about how they will manage in the months and years to come.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 27/01/2024 14:52

Livelovebehappy · 27/01/2024 14:42

I get why it irks you. It’s ok people saying inheritance isn’t a birth right, but that’s the way it is - usually your parents assets are passed down to the next generation. That’s the way it’s always been. But tbh this is an agreement made between your parents and your db, and it seems nothing was considered at the time, in writing, to all the situations which could occur as to how the debt would be paid. It all seems a bit vague. You can either sit and inwardly seethe for the rest of your days, or sit down with them all and voice your concerns to get everything out there.

So far the only people being given anything with no expectation of it being paid back, in cash or care, are the Op’s children

Zanatdy · 27/01/2024 14:52

I don’t think it’s great for parents to treat two children so differently and I certainly wouldn’t spend 150k on one child and nothing for the other. My mum also wouldn’t and would consider how one of us might feel. So would most of the people claiming you’re being unreasonable

mightydolphin · 27/01/2024 14:51

It sounds like your parents are happy with the arrangement. It must be reassuring for them to know that they'll be able to live with their son when they're older. Ultimately, any money they could have been paid back may well have ended up spent on care home costs. You sound entitled.

TammyJones · 27/01/2024 14:51

Abitofalark · 27/01/2024 13:51

Where did the figure of 700 a month come from? The OP didn't mention it as far as I can see. It just appeared like a rabbit from a hat.

Rent and bills I think.

SuperDopper · 27/01/2024 14:50

Rosiiee · 27/01/2024 14:23

@HarrietStyles i think what the OP is saying is that by paying the parents bills and rent directly he’s essentially repaying less than the agreed on 150k. Someone further up the thread said that it would take him 17 years to pay back the 150k yet he plans on having his parents move in with him and to discontinue the payments.

The difference between what was loaned and what was repayed would essentially be a gift. A gift that OP didn’t receive.

If It’s going to be equal, then OP would get £75k.

We have no idea how much has already been paid and how much is left. OP hasn’t revealed that information. So your post is pure speculation.

BungleandGeorge · 27/01/2024 14:50

Surely whatever money is currently paying their bills will be available if your sibling takes on that responsibility and they can save it for you if they wish.

Swipe left for the next trending thread