Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask an I overreacting or being odd?

207 replies

Fiddlesticks35 · 27/01/2024 11:24

My parents(DP’s)…I’m finding them ridiculously intrusive in what they say…I want to put boundaries in place but I don’t really know how to go about it without being rude or getting their backs up

this is why….

example 1 -missed phoncall so I call back

me- sorry I missed your call I was busy.
DP- oh ok…busy with what?
me- eh…insert random job

example 2- DP Call me (I’m in the car on hands free)
me- hi how are you
dp- (realising im in the car) oh hi where are you going?
me- 🙄insert random place ( I feel this is not necessary)

example 3 - several missed phone calls from one or both parents

me - hi, everything ok?
dp- oh yeah just ringing to say (inset the most random trivial thing!)

example 4 - phone or face to face

me - I was out with a friend / at an appointment
dp- which friend? What appointment?

ok my question is why do they always look for further info? Why can they not accept the information they have been given!!!? They wouldn’t do it to anyone else! what difference does it make to them!

and for the record they are not lonely and they have plenty to do, I talk to them but they need to understand that they can’t know every single detail of every single thing I do! I’m mid thirties ffs!!

AIBU to be irritated by this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Starseeking · 28/01/2024 03:09

My parents are like this as well OP, mine are really quite nosey, I feel your pain.

However, I know that they are retired and bored, (they don't really go anywhere or do much anymore in their early 70's), and these sorts of conversations help fill up their day.

I draw my own boundaries where I need to, but most of it is harmless chitchat, so I don't get too worked up about it.

bohemianmullet · 27/01/2024 23:21

I think I understand from your clarifications why you are not liking the questioning. It sounds like it you feel that gathering so much info on you just provokes worry or getting anxious about you or make you anxious or make you interact more, rather than be a casual sort of conversation that most people are imagining from your first examples. Is it something like that?

I wonder if you have to feed the desire for interaction and conversation without giving away things you don't want to. Could you chat more about general topics or ask their opinions on things or find other ways to interact that aren't needing every detail of your life?

I do feel a bit sorry for them in that conversation can be hard on the phone. People want to keep a connection with loved ones and a conversation that is so very restricted and formal where no questions of a personal nature can be asked and no information about what's going on in people's lives is really exchanged does sound a bit hard going and remote.

On the other hand, you obviously feel each bit of information delivered is maybe used as an excuse to phone again or worry about it. (Your example of phoning again for result of appt or checking you've taken meds). In which case you maybe are justified in holding them a little at bay. But I would think about whether there's other stuff you can talk to them about like interests, politics, programmes you've watched, hobbies whether yours or theirs, or whatever that can engage and create a sense of closeness without giving away too much personal information that you don't want to divulge.

BOOTS52PollyPrissyPants · 27/01/2024 23:14

I agree with you they sound nosy and none of their business what you are doing as you are not a child. Sounds pretty annoying to be honest.

Nevermind31 · 27/01/2024 22:14

its called a conversation, and being interested.
either there is some other background here (controlling parents? Not excepting boundaries?), your reaction is odd (and reminds me of my friend who was later diagnosed with paranoia)

Mistlebough · 27/01/2024 21:53

It sounds as you would prefer a much colder, more distant relationship with your parents. They sound quite normally interested in trying to make connections with your current life, but you are trying to keep them at a distance. There seems to be a mismatch between the depth of involvement in each other’s lives that you want, with you being secretive and withholding.

You ascribe negative motivations to their questions (“intrusive, nosey”)whereas to me they sound like normal questions to show interest and not just have a bland superficial conversation. They sound as though they want to be close and loving, but you want space. It’s pretty sad for them if they realise but for you to be comfortable it sounds like you will have to say something.

CaputDraconis · 27/01/2024 20:27

MohairTortoise · 27/01/2024 19:58

OP,
I agree with you.
I have had this with my mother for years.
We're not having a conversation. We're having a question and answer session.
The whole point of a conversation is the exchange of information, yet for some people, their idea of a conversation is a constant onslaught of questions.
A typical exchange with my mother goes something like this;

Mother : What have you been up to today?
Me : Work and meeting with a colleague this evening for a drink. What about you?
Mother : Have you eaten?
Me : Not yet, I'll grab something later. Mother : What are you having for dinner?
Me : I'm not sure yet. What about you?
Mother : Where are you going?
Me : Just to colleagues house to discuss work related things.
Mother : Who else will be there?
Me : No one else. What are your plans for this evening?
Mother : Are you going to be drinking?
Me : No, I'm driving. So what have you been up to lately?
Mother : What time will you be home?
Me : I'm not sure, probably not late. So how is your bad leg now?
Mother : Which colleague is this?
Me : My line manager. What are your plans for tomorrow?
Mother : Are you in trouble at work?
Me : No. I've got to go now. Bye.

Every conversation is the same. She doesn't exchange information. She just asks questions and wants answers. That's the only value to the conversation.

She is the same with everyone, hence to say she has very few people to talk to now, and the ones I know who talk to her repeatedly reply with 'I don't know/I'm fine', and now she complains that she's left out and lonely.
I have tried to raise it with her but whilst she sees my point at the time, she immediately reverts back to the questioning.
She also has severe FOMO and maybe that's got something to do with it but her line of questioning repels people, the exact opposite of what she wants.

I think you make a very important point here. It is one sided.

There are only questions from the other party and no information given. So it isn't a normal conversation as so many other posters have stated.

If I say I am going out for lunch, my sister will want to know: where, when, who with, what I'm ordering, if I liked it, what my favourite disk was, how many other people were there, where did I park etc.

But if I ask her what she's been up to or similar it is brushed aside with another question.

MohairTortoise · 27/01/2024 19:58

OP,
I agree with you.
I have had this with my mother for years.
We're not having a conversation. We're having a question and answer session.
The whole point of a conversation is the exchange of information, yet for some people, their idea of a conversation is a constant onslaught of questions.
A typical exchange with my mother goes something like this;

Mother : What have you been up to today?
Me : Work and meeting with a colleague this evening for a drink. What about you?
Mother : Have you eaten?
Me : Not yet, I'll grab something later. Mother : What are you having for dinner?
Me : I'm not sure yet. What about you?
Mother : Where are you going?
Me : Just to colleagues house to discuss work related things.
Mother : Who else will be there?
Me : No one else. What are your plans for this evening?
Mother : Are you going to be drinking?
Me : No, I'm driving. So what have you been up to lately?
Mother : What time will you be home?
Me : I'm not sure, probably not late. So how is your bad leg now?
Mother : Which colleague is this?
Me : My line manager. What are your plans for tomorrow?
Mother : Are you in trouble at work?
Me : No. I've got to go now. Bye.

Every conversation is the same. She doesn't exchange information. She just asks questions and wants answers. That's the only value to the conversation.

She is the same with everyone, hence to say she has very few people to talk to now, and the ones I know who talk to her repeatedly reply with 'I don't know/I'm fine', and now she complains that she's left out and lonely.
I have tried to raise it with her but whilst she sees my point at the time, she immediately reverts back to the questioning.
She also has severe FOMO and maybe that's got something to do with it but her line of questioning repels people, the exact opposite of what she wants.

Fiddlesticks35 · 27/01/2024 19:41

@RachelSTG they may be my parents but that doesn’t mean I want them to know everything going on in my life…my life my business to be fair

OP posts:
RachelSTG · 27/01/2024 19:30

Fiddlesticks35 · 27/01/2024 11:59

I just find it intrusive to be honest…

if someone says I was at an appointment..I don’t “what appointment?” I might say. All ok? And I’ll let them say…oh yes all good or whatever they want to say.

How do you ever get to know anyone other than superficially with that sort of response? I'm sure you're not meeting up with anyone that interesting to warrant all the secrecy. These people are your parents, why are you being so overly formal!?

brunettemic · 27/01/2024 19:14

Love posts like this…of course you’re overreacting and of course you’re being odd 😂

Fairymother · 27/01/2024 18:55

Fiddlesticks35 · 27/01/2024 11:30

So if you rang someone and they said oh sorry I missed your call I was busy, you would feel justified in saying “busy with what?” I wouldn’t ask anyone that!?

Depends how close you are. My parents, friends, other family i would totally ask that to make conversation.
The teacher of my children, builder etc. probably not.

MrsSlocombesCat · 27/01/2024 18:43

I don’t think it’s you, it’s them. I would feel exactly the same. I can’t believe how many people are normalising this. I would give vague replies, like ‘oh this and that,’ or ‘nothing interesting’. If you don’t want to share information with them that’s your right not to do so.

itsmylife7 · 27/01/2024 17:09

They are still treating you like a teenager.

Where, who ,why question aren't normal when you're a fully grown up woman.

Ringing you at work is ridiculous, unless it's an emergency.

Honestly OP you have my sympathy.

Infusedwithchamomileandmint · 27/01/2024 17:04

EC22 · 27/01/2024 16:58

Sounds like folk having a normal conversation.
Odd.

I don't think it does.
The odd question about an old friend etc but as an adult being questioned in a demanding way as the Op describes is overbearing
" busy with what" sounds snarky .
Context, tone and what the Op feels is happening eg over bearing, demanding and calling all the time suggest its over the top

EC22 · 27/01/2024 16:58

Sounds like folk having a normal conversation.
Odd.

Infusedwithchamomileandmint · 27/01/2024 16:56

beetr00 · 27/01/2024 13:05

@Fiddlesticks35

You are not unreasonable.

You are not overly sensitive.

They are intrusive.

And just because, on this thread, people don't necessarily agree with how you feel, you are absolutely, not wrong.

Set your boundaries, they are interested in your life, obviously, but their third degree approach irks.

Good luck🌻

Totally agree
You say this feels overbearing and intrusive.
That's how you feel THE END
That's fine, stick to your boundaries.
We all have the right to some degree of privacy or inner life.
They are treating you like a teenager who is out past curfew.
Where have you been,with whom etc

Stop giving an explanation

Bobbotgegrinch · 27/01/2024 16:56

Fiddlesticks35 · 27/01/2024 16:50

So it seems that most people seem to think these are normal forms of questioning in a conversation but some others can identify where I’m coming from and can see how it’s intrusive and exhausting. I guess I still have the right to share what I want and what I don’t want, it’s the balance I Need to find I ssuppose.

I think everyone on this thread thinks that these are normal questions to ask someone you know well.

If you didn't have completely overbearing parents, you probably would too.

The problem is that you know what these questions lead to, so you're getting stressed the moment you hear the initial innocuous question

Fiddlesticks35 · 27/01/2024 16:50

So it seems that most people seem to think these are normal forms of questioning in a conversation but some others can identify where I’m coming from and can see how it’s intrusive and exhausting. I guess I still have the right to share what I want and what I don’t want, it’s the balance I Need to find I ssuppose.

OP posts:
Silverbirchtwo · 27/01/2024 16:50

I had a friend like that every conversation turned into an interrogation. They just asked question after question, I don't know if they were nervous, socially awkward, or just a busy body, but it felt very intrusive. Friendship didn't last long.

Parents I would give the benefit of the doubt, genuinely interested and concerned if you don't answer calls.

LauderSyme · 27/01/2024 16:46

It's only normal conversation if it is a two way dialogue that both people want to be part of.

I have a relative who makes it clear that much of their life is private and out of bounds for conversation. Although this can sometimes feel like a slap in the face (who they had lunch with is hardly a state secret) I respect their right to their privacy and don't ask for details.

Infusedwithchamomileandmint · 27/01/2024 16:45

Fiddlesticks35 · 27/01/2024 11:42

Maybe I am being over sensitive

You aren't
They are being intrusive

"Hi DPiL
Calling you back as I was busy earlier "

DPiL " no worries just wondered if you were free for a pub lunch on Sunday"

It isn't normal to get you to justify or explain everything.
These types it's best not to give them too much info
So
"Hi DPiL just returning your call"
DPiL reply

Maddy70 · 27/01/2024 16:39

You are odd. This is normal conversation

LauderSyme · 27/01/2024 16:39

YANBU. This is intrusive and irritating if it's their habitual modus operandi.

Someone in my life does these exact same things your parents do and I hate it.

I don't feel obliged to be available to talk whenever they decide I should be, nor to tell them every little detail about my life.

But if I don't answer the phone or answer their questions, then I become the baddie who is being unreasonable. It's not that things are secret or private, they are simply not that person's business, but it turns into an argument if I fail to immediately divulge everything they ask of me.

I haven't worked out how to deal with it either, so am sorry I have no advice, just solidarity with you OP.

Theluggagerules · 27/01/2024 16:36

Feel your pain, I'm a grown woman who deals with those kind of calls at least once daily but usually more, much more 😬
I so want to say "it's none of your business!" Or even just ditch the call but it won't go down well and they will just keep calling until I answer.
I'm sure they didn't get this from their parents, it's as if having a mobile means you have no right to privacy. No solution I'm afraid but you are not overreacting or being odd

Nanny0gg · 27/01/2024 16:35

Fiddlesticks35 · 27/01/2024 15:59

@easylikeasundaymorn yeah they don’t know any of my current friends as most of my long term friends live abroad except 1 and if I met up with her then I would just say it was her. Most friends I have now are through work or hobbies…they don’t know my parents etc

I don't know most of my DC friends as they are adults with their own families.

But they talk about them and so I 'know' them that way. And I am interested. So I will ask questions