Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Realistic plan to pay school fees or not?

214 replies

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 09:08

Hope to save 60k by the time ds is 5, hes 2 at the moment and I have 24k.

I am able to save around 1k a month towards this at the moment (I do this without factoring in the cms below and can manage).

it would mean when school fees start that I could pay half from the 60k and half from my own income. I haven’t included cms in my calculations as I don’t want to ‘rely’ on it (insane that that’s the state of this country but I’m working on worst case scenario). That said, ex currently pays 700 maintenance and he is a workaholic so I suspect it will go up. He works in the nhs so can’t really get out of it.

do you think my plan is doable? Should I be doing more? Is it totally unrealistic? I have assumed fees will be around 18k a year when dc starts, taking account of inflation.

OP posts:
MojoMoon · 27/01/2024 09:34

Also you need to look carefully at this property in trust for your son and the terms of it
When is it held in trust to? It might be 21 or 25 years - but he would need to be able to access it at 18, sell it and have the cash available by September after turning 18 to pay uni fees and housing costs.
Is that possible? You won't have any cash savings to help bridge any gap or delay in monetising the property under your current plan.

Also bear in mind it would be his money and he could fritter it away whereas if you save cash in your own name for him then you can choose when and under what circumstances he gets it (eg paying for uni)

Moonshine5 · 27/01/2024 09:32

Depends where you live but primary school fees can be anything between 8-20k.
Upper schools 15-40k

Rosesanddaisies1 · 27/01/2024 09:32

Private school at primary level is unnecessary (but I am opposed to it altogether). And it’s very unfair to enrol your kid if it’s going to be tight, then you’ll have to change schools. Plus all the other expenses beyond the fees. Why not actually enjoy your lives together with holidays, hobbies, fun weekends, then stretch to private school. He’ll always be the ‘poor’ one unfortunately

WASZPy · 27/01/2024 09:30

I think at this point, most people are assuming the 20% is coming. At least you have a few years to wait and see what happens.

We only have 4 years to go, but we are assuming it's likely to be 4 years of beans on toast to make it.

LittleMousewithcloggson · 27/01/2024 09:30

I think you are being incredibly unreasonable to send him to a private school based on your own experiences
I went to private school and my best friend didn’t. Both got into same university and she got a first. (I got 2.1)
She loved her school, I felt academically pressured and inferior to others who had huge houses, several holidays a year, ponies etc
i sent both of mine to state schools - with a plan to look into private schools only if state let them down - and have been pleasantly surprised as to the quality of work they do, the opportunities there and more importantly, how much they love it.
I would do a lot of research and use any savings to move into the catchment areas of schools I loved. You also then have the security of money in your house as opposed to money you will never get back.
in regards to your plan, its going to be tight. Fees are rising ridiculously. What happens if you are ill and can’t work, lose your job or something else. What about all the extras that come with private school and childcare as you are working more?
You could have a nicer house in a better area, still work part time and see your child more and have your child in a good state school, with local friends around

3WildOnes · 27/01/2024 09:29

Wouldyouguess · 27/01/2024 09:24

I taught across public schools, most were good/great and most kids have a good/very good experience. Don't let your own experience cloud your judgement, public system is not evil and bullying etc happen in private schools as well, you'll just be paying for it. Do visits, do your research, maybe save for private secondary if you think it will be beneficial (and it will have more impact on educational outcomes).

Are you in the US? In the UK we usually say state schools. Public schools are boarding schools.

MojoMoon · 27/01/2024 09:28

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 09:21

@MojoMoon thanks this is helpful! I do save into a pension. I have no other savings, but ds does has a property on trust from grandparents so I am hoping that can play into his university fees and house deposit etc. This side of things does worry me though

Then don't put him into private prep school.
Start in state primary. Reassess when approaching secondary age.

You don't have enough money saved to get through to 18 unless you are able to save £1k a month while he is at prep, which you admit yourself is going to be very difficult.

You have no fall back savings to cover emergencies. Are you renting or paying a mortgage?

It sounds like you've got little other fall back money plus you would need to live very frugally to save £1k a month throughout the primary years.

The stress of dealing with an emergency (you are sick/injured, ex can't work, house damage that is required to be fixed, a sick child stops you working) with zero savings is immense.

Plus - don't you want to enjoy his childhood with holidays, days out, whatever hobbies or activities he might want to do and other fun (including fun things for you) rather than watching pennies just to send him to private school?

The outcomes for children are primarily dictated by the wealth and education levels of their parents, not the school they attend.

WinterTreacle · 27/01/2024 09:26

Public schools in the UK are fee paying schools much the same as private. You mean state schools.

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 09:24

WinterTreacle · 27/01/2024 09:23

As previous have said, you won’t have enough for 14 years of private education by a long shot. You will have plenty for private school post-primary if you carry on saving like you are now. I think there is much greater value in private education in secondary school aged children - the GCSE/A level years.

@WinterTreacle yes I think secondary only would be the most comfortable option. The state schools here are absolutely dire though and as a single parent I don’t want to more from my support network

OP posts:
Wouldyouguess · 27/01/2024 09:24

I taught across public schools, most were good/great and most kids have a good/very good experience. Don't let your own experience cloud your judgement, public system is not evil and bullying etc happen in private schools as well, you'll just be paying for it. Do visits, do your research, maybe save for private secondary if you think it will be beneficial (and it will have more impact on educational outcomes).

WinterTreacle · 27/01/2024 09:23

As previous have said, you won’t have enough for 14 years of private education by a long shot. You will have plenty for private school post-primary if you carry on saving like you are now. I think there is much greater value in private education in secondary school aged children - the GCSE/A level years.

LIZS · 27/01/2024 09:22

Agree with @Candleabra . 60k won't last long, certainly not until secondary,

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 09:22

WASZPy · 27/01/2024 09:18

Have you factored in the additional 20% that may get passed on if Labour get in? Plus the extras on top of fees- we were lucky that DS's prep uniform was reasonable, but a full set of senior school uniform is nearly £1k. There were a couple of residential trips in the latter years of prep that were £600 each and we only got 5 weeks notice for one of those.

If you can cover everything, go for it. Do you have any relatives that can help you out with an unexpected cost if it happens?

@WASZPy if 20% issue arises then I think it’s a definite no, I wouldn’t be able to.

parents tend to gift 2k ish a year, sometimes more, but again wouldn’t want to rely on that

OP posts:
OneCornetto · 27/01/2024 09:21

I don't really understand cms etc....but if you both work then I would have thought things like nursery and school fees should be split equally unless one parent is paying the other to stay at home....I know that's not how it works but it should be.

But surely if one parent says 'no, I don't want him to go to private school for fourteen years' then they shouldn't have to pay for a private school.

Krystall · 27/01/2024 09:21

I work in the finance department of a private school and one aspect of my job is chasing parents for unpaid fees. I have a feeling you are quickly going to be one of those parents as I think your savings are going to run out much quicker than you think they will. Being chased three times a year is going to be a level of stress in your life that won’t be nice.

Have you picked out your school of choice already? If not what is your £18k estimate based upon, fees rise quite considerably over the years. I am at a school in the SE and our fees seem to be inline with many other schools nearby and it is more like £25k per year from the age of about 13/14. There is also the possibility of VAT on fees which is being taken seriously.

3WildOnes · 27/01/2024 09:21

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 09:15

@Patchworksack the plan would be to keep saving the 1k alongside it. I am not 100% confident I could do that but it might be feasible

I would start now saving £1750pm, which is what you are proposing you would be spemding when he goes to school. 1k saving and the 9k a year fees. See if you can do that first. Otherwise you will run out of money before secondary school.

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 27/01/2024 09:21

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 09:16

@Youcannotbeseriousreally thanks. i will definitely be raising it with him but he’s extremely self centred so it will depend only if he has excess money and lots of it. He might be in that position in a few years as he is very career driven. I’m trying to do it without his help so then I know where I am

It’s going to cost a minimum of about £75K id guesstimate ( excluding nursery provision) to finish prep school. Secondary is a whole other very very expensive kettle of fish.

you’d need more for all the extras but if you still get in 700 and save 1k it should be fine as long as your savings are working hard , I’d be separating them into pots so instant access for some but higher interest locked accounts for some for 3 years etc so you’re earning as much interest as you can.

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 09:21

MojoMoon · 27/01/2024 09:19

Do you have other savings? Are you saving into a pension? Are you saving for university fees and living costs? Do you have enough other savings to cover emergencies or if you or your Ex could no longer work and your income fell? Do you have income protection or sickness cover?

Private school fees have risen much faster than inflation so you would be using a higher assumption on future cost growth than just inflation.

@MojoMoon thanks this is helpful! I do save into a pension. I have no other savings, but ds does has a property on trust from grandparents so I am hoping that can play into his university fees and house deposit etc. This side of things does worry me though

OP posts:
Candleabra · 27/01/2024 09:20

I don’t think it’s enough. Not for 13 years of fees. They’ll go up every year.

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 09:20

LIZS · 27/01/2024 09:19

What fees are you expecting to pay? Preprep won't be 18k pa unless highly sought after London school. Factor in above inflation increases and the increments as they progress, uniform and extras. Long term it could be 200k +

@LIZS private primaries around here are around 12k a year at the moment. I’m looking at 18k aim to deal with worst case scenario when he starts in 3 years

OP posts:
MojoMoon · 27/01/2024 09:19

Do you have other savings? Are you saving into a pension? Are you saving for university fees and living costs? Do you have enough other savings to cover emergencies or if you or your Ex could no longer work and your income fell? Do you have income protection or sickness cover?

Private school fees have risen much faster than inflation so you would be using a higher assumption on future cost growth than just inflation.

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 09:19

Snowdropsarecoming · 27/01/2024 09:18

Have you factored in inflation, costs of uniform, school lunches, trips.

@Snowdropsarecoming yes, fees tend to go up 3-5% a year. 18k is a few grand more than the private primary schools round here so I am basing it on worst case scenario. Obviously secondary will be much higher

OP posts:
LIZS · 27/01/2024 09:19

What fees are you expecting to pay? Preprep won't be 18k pa unless highly sought after London school. Factor in above inflation increases and the increments as they progress, uniform and extras. Long term it could be 200k +

WASZPy · 27/01/2024 09:18

Have you factored in the additional 20% that may get passed on if Labour get in? Plus the extras on top of fees- we were lucky that DS's prep uniform was reasonable, but a full set of senior school uniform is nearly £1k. There were a couple of residential trips in the latter years of prep that were £600 each and we only got 5 weeks notice for one of those.

If you can cover everything, go for it. Do you have any relatives that can help you out with an unexpected cost if it happens?

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 09:18

Sul126 · 27/01/2024 09:16

Our LO starts next year. We’re looking at £1500pm for fees and lunch, with uniform costs being separate. We save £1000 per month towards fees and have £55,000 saved as a buffer in case anything happens. We won’t use our saving unless there’s an emergency, instead the £1000 we save will be used to pay for fees and I’ll pay the extra £500 by upping my very part-time hours.

@Sul126 thanks that sounds similar to my plan. I think I am possibly 400 or so short a month to do it from income alone and I would be stuck with asking family to bridge that gap which I don’t want to do

OP posts: