Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Realistic plan to pay school fees or not?

214 replies

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 09:08

Hope to save 60k by the time ds is 5, hes 2 at the moment and I have 24k.

I am able to save around 1k a month towards this at the moment (I do this without factoring in the cms below and can manage).

it would mean when school fees start that I could pay half from the 60k and half from my own income. I haven’t included cms in my calculations as I don’t want to ‘rely’ on it (insane that that’s the state of this country but I’m working on worst case scenario). That said, ex currently pays 700 maintenance and he is a workaholic so I suspect it will go up. He works in the nhs so can’t really get out of it.

do you think my plan is doable? Should I be doing more? Is it totally unrealistic? I have assumed fees will be around 18k a year when dc starts, taking account of inflation.

OP posts:
Heatherbell1978 · 28/01/2024 18:56

I think you'll be fine if you set your mind to it OP although do consider state primary and private secondary as obviously that gives you lots more time to save. DS starts private this year. DD will follow in 5 years. Both in state primary now. I've lost count of the posts I've read over the last year that suggest you shouldn't privately educate if you earn less than £400k a year, that fees will triple in a few years, that uniform and extras will cost you the same as the fees. Often posted by those who haven't done their research or could afford school fees if they didn't have a mortgage of £3k etc. It sounds like you're doing a good job of planning ahead.

MumMRM · 28/01/2024 18:49

I work at a private school. If Labour gets in at the next election they will be putting VAT on to private school fees, so that will be another 20% on top! We have parents worrying already! & do not forget extras like school uniform, which usually has to be purchased from the school or particular store and trips and extra curriculum activities, which private schools do a lot of.

Here4thechocs · 28/01/2024 18:46

I wish all folks, even those that can afford private schools would send their children to state funded ones just so the government is forced to improve the qualities of our state schools. This of course, includes the politicians’ children themselves but eh … we are where we are at.

All the very best with your plans, OP.

JuniperKeats · 28/01/2024 18:10

GRRRR.
send your child to a state school. Nothing better.

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 19:33

Thanks for some really helpful responses.

I am not concerned about academic success, what will be will be on that front and I believe that’s largely down to parental input regardless of the school. It’s more about the wider experience and to avoid ds being exposed to bad influence. I’m well aware that there’s scope for bad influence at a private school, and that there are millions of great people at state schools, but if we looks at the odds on that score, he’s likely to have an easier time at a private school.

OP posts:
CaveMum · 27/01/2024 17:45

If you are concerned about the local state primaries not prepping your son for the entrance exam for private secondary (and remember not all private schools are academically selective, our local small private just requires children to be at “meeting expectations” or higher) you can look at a tutor in the year before he’ll sit the exams. The main thing I’ve found is that when you get the child registered with the school is a key factor as it’s the next thing they look at after exam results.

WaterHound · 27/01/2024 15:27

RampantIvy · 27/01/2024 14:05

@Heather37231 one of my friends did this with her son. As he had had no experience of starting again by going from nursery to primary then primary to secondary he really struggled with going to university and was on the verge of dropping out. He ended up having to resit one of his years at university. At the time my friend said that she regretted taking the all the way through option for his education.

How unusual.

Heather37231 · 27/01/2024 15:19

RampantIvy · 27/01/2024 14:05

@Heather37231 one of my friends did this with her son. As he had had no experience of starting again by going from nursery to primary then primary to secondary he really struggled with going to university and was on the verge of dropping out. He ended up having to resit one of his years at university. At the time my friend said that she regretted taking the all the way through option for his education.

My son’s school is 3 separate schools but under the same brand and the right to be admitted carries through from one to the next. At each stage new kids join from other places and the numbers increase. It’s no different to everyone moving from state primary to the local state secondary based on where they live. In fact there is an extra transition between years 2 and 3 that a child in state primary that goes R to 6 would not get.

(and it doesn’t offer nursery).

I still believe that 7+ and/or 11+ are worth avoiding if possible.

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 27/01/2024 15:19

I was privately educated until my parents ran out of money. Got GCSEs and A levels at state school. There's lots of good stuff about private education. But private schools are highly commercial and ultimately unless you qualify for a bursary they will not keep your child on roll if you can't pay the fees.

My daughter is at a small local academy school which is both nurturing and challenging. She's doing brilliantly, is close to home, putting down local roots and I don't have to pay a penny for it.

Pipsquiggle · 27/01/2024 14:54

Hi OP.
How bad are the local primaries?
We were going to send DC1 to private primary as the one he was at was dire (mainly due to some of the parents) - here are just a few examples:
A fight broke out at pick up between 2 sets of parents, a police officer had to be stationed at the school gates for a few weeks
The sats results were poor.
There was a knife incident from a former pupil who tried to get on the grounds.

The teachers tried their best but when you deal with people who don't value education, it's very hard.

Fortunately he got a place at another local state primary school and thrived there. He's now at the local grammar.

I would put off private school for as long as possible as it doesn't sound you can sustain private education fees for 14 years. Ideally send your DC to a good / OK state primary and get tutoring in yr 5 for entrance exams. In the meantime keep saving and make sure your ex contributes now - he may not be able to in the future, if he meets a new partner and they have DC.

RampantIvy · 27/01/2024 14:05

@Heather37231 one of my friends did this with her son. As he had had no experience of starting again by going from nursery to primary then primary to secondary he really struggled with going to university and was on the verge of dropping out. He ended up having to resit one of his years at university. At the time my friend said that she regretted taking the all the way through option for his education.

minipie · 27/01/2024 13:52

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 10:03

I think the idea of state primary is probably something I will have to consider. The schools are not good round here. If I move then I leave my support network. I just don’t know what to do. I could try and save more but I’m already living in a quite a basic way to reach this 60k.

If you are using state primary and not saving so hard so have a bit more spare money, you might not be quite so dependent on support network? Plus you will hopefully make a new support network via nursery/school if you move. If it’s a well regarded primary school then hopefully has engaged parents and would be a good place to make friends.

I know it feels like a leap though.

FusionChefGeoff · 27/01/2024 13:47

I really do think only the super rich should bother with private primaries before they even try a local state. Ours has been outstanding for both kids and we've been able to give them loads of extra experiences / lifestyle benefits by not having fees to pay.

Agreed that's not everyone's experience but each school and each child is so different how do you know until you try??

Then that means a comfortable slide into private secondary which I definitely think is nearly always worth the big bucks

DaffodilsAlready · 27/01/2024 12:22

I looked at this when DD was little. I decided that with additional costs and wraparound care at the school, I would be better to buy a house in the catchment area of the best state school I could. Given life events which happened, this was the right thing to do. Also a single parent with no support where we live but I didn’t have that anyway (nor CMS as her dad did not pay).
An important point is that your child’s father also has a say in the school being chosen, especially if you decide to move. If private school is on the agenda, then he needs to be involved in that decision.

Calmdown14 · 27/01/2024 12:13

If you are not certain about the figures and affordability, I would start him in state.

There are many good primary schools and the early years are quite play centred.

Do the latter half of primary and secondary private where it makes more of a difference.

Running out of funds and having to change from a private to state school in upper secondary is much more difficult.

WaterHound · 27/01/2024 12:06

disappearingfish · 27/01/2024 10:56

it’s worth bearing in mind that he will have better university chances coming from a state school given how selection criteria are evolving.

This is an oversimplification of contextual offers. The overall effect of widening participation policies in higher education is impossible to predict on an individual child (in 14 years time!).

This.

VestaTilley · 27/01/2024 12:02

I’d save like mad and just do private secondary, maybe prep if you’ve saved a lot, but pre prep really isn’t worth it. Save your money.

ThroughThickAndThin01 · 27/01/2024 11:59

owlsinthedaylight · 27/01/2024 11:00

Not the point of the thread, but … all of those making tits of themselves nitpicking over @Wouldyouguess ’s word choice … you realise the U.K. isn’t just England?

In Scotland

private = paid
public = state / not paid

The OP is in England - surely not too hard to use the correct terminology.

Justaboutalive · 27/01/2024 11:57

I sent my DS along the private route.

When I first planned his senior school (he was aged 7) the fees 13-18 were £15k pa
when he completed his final year, the final fees were £15k per term.

As a general rule
fees 3-7 are £X
fees 7-12 are £2X
fees 13-18 are £4X

The school inflation rate is often higher than wage inflation, or general inflation.

We were lucky, as the fees to 12 were comfortable and there were grandparents who would have been prepared to step in and help in case of redundancy or illness etc. However, the last few years were comparatively tough.

On a positive note, you then find University costs easy <only partially spoken in jest and absolutely acknowledging the struggle many feel>

If you are going to struggle financially at the start, it might be worth using state schools to 11 (and saving, saving, saving while you do) and having enough money to choose the right secondary school, when DS is more”formed” as to his needs. Also, there were parents who truly struggled with the fees and I remember overhearing a conversation of boys in my kitchen. The boys were very aware of their parents has overly stretched their selves financially - they were appreciative, but oh so stressed by it.

Good luck to you and DS.

Potentialscroogeincognito · 27/01/2024 11:53

I have heard good things about Trent College also.

Wisenotboring · 27/01/2024 11:38

notknowledgeable · 27/01/2024 09:11

why are you intending to pay fees at all? Why not start out in state and see how it goes? The early years are not the ones you want to blow all your savings on, surely? Maybe keep your savings for the GCSE years if it isn't going well in state school at that time

Although state consideration is a viable one. I think most people know that and respectfully, it isn't what the OP asked. She was asking a financial question.
Anyway, the older children get rhe more tricky it can be to move them as they are settled with friends etc. Also, places may not be available at y10 and then you're a bit stuck.

Heather37231 · 27/01/2024 11:33

owlsinthedaylight · 27/01/2024 11:00

Not the point of the thread, but … all of those making tits of themselves nitpicking over @Wouldyouguess ’s word choice … you realise the U.K. isn’t just England?

In Scotland

private = paid
public = state / not paid

Nope. I am Scottish and went to school in the Scottish state system. I have never heard “public” used to mean state, and I have known that a “Public school” means Eton etc since I was about 10.

BusyMummyWrites01 · 27/01/2024 11:32

[Sorry long reply]

This sounds doable, but:

  1. I assume you are not planning on ever having a second child?
  2. School fees go up - both for each year group and in response to economic factors. Ours started at £12K per annum in the junior school and are now £22k at year 11. They will be nearly £29k in 6th form. This is before uniform, and any extras like school trips (some will be subject related and, thus, effectively compulsory like the BattleFields trip re ww1), music or drama lessons and uniform, the costs of DofE etc.
  3. My kids have been happy though and, as both ended up being diagnosed with ASD/ADHD or ASD alone, they struggled with large classes and year groups at the local state schools so the decision to go private was essential and informed by their needs. However, had they not struggled at state schools, I am not sure the value added on £20-27k pa is really there - we are moving our son to a state 6th form in September as it’s free, has the highest intake at Oxbridge of any non selective state school, great stats on students attending Russell Group Unis and medical schools (vis a vis both state and private schools in the area) - and he loved it, of course. Small private schools have fewer options for GCSEs and A Levels so that, for my son, going to a 6th form where the staff levels and timetable meant he can take 4 A Levels was a bonus.
  4. There is considerable disparity of wealth between the students. Some struggle to find the fees and live very modestly, others are children of A List actors/Tv personalities and film directors. My DS is completely unphased by this and is in a lovely year group; my DD had a lousy time in her year group as the girls were very focused (during Covid) of all this stuff. She developed a real chip on her shoulder (that she was so privileged, ironically, even though we are nowhere in the league of the celeb class 🤣 just boring professionals). Just something to be aware of if you are planning to invest all your income into school fees.
  5. I live in an area with both good and mediocre states schools, but most of my friends have been very happy with the state schools their kids have attended and the universities they’ve ended up in - which is shaped by the fact that they were a) heavily supported in all their out-of-school activities and b) that their parents could afford those activities due to no school fees (eg county tennis players, ice skating medalists, Royal Ballet Saturday school).
  6. Just a word of warning that private schools do not necessarily handle bullying, special educational needs or any other areas of conflict any better than state schools. Many of my friends, and myself included, have been deeply frustrated by the need to be forceful and proactive to get issues addressed and support put in place. In fact, in some private schools as they are a quarter to half the size of their state school counter parts, the provision of SEN services is often woefully lacking.

As others have suggested, saving in case you need to go private is great, but I’d advise you to look at the local state schools, catholic/church schools if those apply, and really be sure that you would be getting the experience for your child that you imagine.

WinterLobelia · 27/01/2024 11:20

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 27/01/2024 11:01

It appears your English is good enough for misogynistic insults. Well done or did you translate that from your mother tongue too.

hear Hear.

FFS engaging respectfully is an actual thing you know. As is using appropriate terminology in the actual context of the conversation and not using misogynistic slurs.

liverpoolgal82 · 27/01/2024 11:19

How bad can the local primaries be ? Could you not help his studying with a tutor if teaching is that bad in your local schools? Then a tutor to prep him for private secondary nearer the time? It’ll be much much cheaper than full primary fees and not eat up your savings as much and you’ll have more towards a private secondary then.
My daughter did state primary to year 5 then a year of home education then private secondary. It didn’t put her at a disadvantage at all- in fact she was ahead. Doing v well still and will go to uni after A levels.