Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Realistic plan to pay school fees or not?

214 replies

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 09:08

Hope to save 60k by the time ds is 5, hes 2 at the moment and I have 24k.

I am able to save around 1k a month towards this at the moment (I do this without factoring in the cms below and can manage).

it would mean when school fees start that I could pay half from the 60k and half from my own income. I haven’t included cms in my calculations as I don’t want to ‘rely’ on it (insane that that’s the state of this country but I’m working on worst case scenario). That said, ex currently pays 700 maintenance and he is a workaholic so I suspect it will go up. He works in the nhs so can’t really get out of it.

do you think my plan is doable? Should I be doing more? Is it totally unrealistic? I have assumed fees will be around 18k a year when dc starts, taking account of inflation.

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 28/01/2024 22:00

We were thinking about private schools but decided we just couldn't make the numbers work without living pretty frugally and we just didn't think it was worth it.

Same here. We dcided to use a tutor instead should it have been necessary, and it was - just for GCSE maths. It meant that we were able to support DD through university.

Take no notice of the ‘state’ school fanatics that will try and vilify you, it’s a typical mumsnet thing. If they could afford they would, I mean who wouldn’t want the best for their children. Who wouldn’t want a class of ten rather than 40.

Take no notice of the state school haters, and go and visit some and see for yourself what they are like. And BTW class sizes at primary school are smaller than 40.

Another expense to consider is exam fees. I was surprised when my friend had to pay entry fees for GCSEs and A level exams on top of the school fees.

Wouldyouguess · 28/01/2024 21:42

Your comments about state schools are very naive and you don't seem to know that much about the independent schools, but you hope it's better then your personal experience in one school 20 years ago or whenever. Please go out there and do some research before you waste all that money in something that may not be greener...

cargear01 · 28/01/2024 21:34

@Pipsquiggle thanks that’s really interesting. I am trying to get my head around state for primary and your comment is reassuring and makes a lot of sense.

OP posts:
Pipsquiggle · 28/01/2024 21:31

OP I do think you need to check out the state schools near you.
It sounds like are making a lot of assumptions based on your own negative experiences. Primary schools, teaching, enrichment trips/ lessons and standards have changed a lot since we were little.

In terms of good / bad influences, at primary school, you are their moral compass, you are the person that matters most. At secondary school, their peer group becomes more important. These are not just my thoughts, an educational psychologist told me this when we were thinking of private primary schools.

We were thinking about private schools but decided we just couldn't make the numbers work without living pretty frugally and we just didn't think it was worth it.

FirstFallopians · 28/01/2024 21:09

I think you have to remove your rose tinted glasses when it comes to private schooling. Just because you’re paying for something doesn’t mean it’s value for money for your specific situation.

My kids are at prep in a different part of the U.K. where fees are much, much cheaper. Class sizes are smaller, SEN support is great, afterschool provision is very handy etc etc. But would I be sending them if it meant we’d be living on super noodles and reused teabags, no emergency fund, no holidays, constantly worrying about next terms fees? Absolutely fucking not.

There’s no point spending every spare penny on fees and not being able to share in actually enjoyable experiences with your son. Spending that money on trips and hobbies, and exploring his interests together is much more likely to build his cultural capital in a way that motivates him to learn.

Trishthedish · 28/01/2024 20:53

@Patchworksack the ridiculous charitable status of private schools is a phrase bandied around. Everybody knows that state schools are badly underfunded. What do you think would happen if private schools closed and all those children had to go into the state system? Also parents of privately educated children pay for their children to be educated by the state through taxation, and then pay schools fees on top.

threatmatrix · 28/01/2024 20:42

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 09:08

Hope to save 60k by the time ds is 5, hes 2 at the moment and I have 24k.

I am able to save around 1k a month towards this at the moment (I do this without factoring in the cms below and can manage).

it would mean when school fees start that I could pay half from the 60k and half from my own income. I haven’t included cms in my calculations as I don’t want to ‘rely’ on it (insane that that’s the state of this country but I’m working on worst case scenario). That said, ex currently pays 700 maintenance and he is a workaholic so I suspect it will go up. He works in the nhs so can’t really get out of it.

do you think my plan is doable? Should I be doing more? Is it totally unrealistic? I have assumed fees will be around 18k a year when dc starts, taking account of inflation.

I really hope you succeed. But secondary private schools are very expensive. Take no notice of the ‘state’ school fanatics that will try and vilify you, it’s a typical mumsnet thing. If they could afford they would, I mean who wouldn’t want the best for their children. Who wouldn’t want a class of ten rather than 40.

threatmatrix · 28/01/2024 20:39

Patchworksack · 27/01/2024 09:13

You’ll run out if your ‘paying half’ savings before he gets through primary school. Then what? Fees will only have gone up, massively if private schools lose their (ridiculous) charitable status.

It’s not ridiculous at all. And if they lose you you will see a massive influx into the state system that is already overcrowded and underfunded.

cargear01 · 28/01/2024 20:34

Justontherightsideofnormal · 28/01/2024 20:20

Your DS already sounds like his life is planned out with the gifted house……. Can I ask what your reasons are about not using a state school? Just curious more than anything.

@Justontherightsideofnormal Its not about academics for me, it’s about the overall experience. Smaller classes, more activities, teachers not under the same pressure as in state, wider travel/trip opportunities, a longer school day to enable me to work longer and have da in one place alongside ALL his peers, rather than having to attend after school classes/activities that not all attend in state sector. Things like that.

OP posts:
Justontherightsideofnormal · 28/01/2024 20:20

Your DS already sounds like his life is planned out with the gifted house……. Can I ask what your reasons are about not using a state school? Just curious more than anything.

LilySLE · 28/01/2024 20:15

I would really examine your reasons for wanting to privately educate from age 5. Most state primaries are absolutely fine. It’s a lot of money that you may not need to spend, giving you more money to go private later on if that’s what you choose at the time.

BananaPyjamaLlama · 28/01/2024 19:51

@RampantIvy yes that too! One of our local secondary schools (not a private school but in a "better area" is notorious for having a high percentage of kids who take drugs of some sort.
Because those kids have a higher disposable income.

RampantIvy · 28/01/2024 19:48

Parents having a bigger bank balance does not immediately equate to nicer children.

More money for drugs.

The university group Facebook page I'm on is littered with posts from parents who are saying "Oh shit, I didn't realise I had to top up my DC's maintenance loan"

Sunnydays0101 · 28/01/2024 19:44

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 19:33

Thanks for some really helpful responses.

I am not concerned about academic success, what will be will be on that front and I believe that’s largely down to parental input regardless of the school. It’s more about the wider experience and to avoid ds being exposed to bad influence. I’m well aware that there’s scope for bad influence at a private school, and that there are millions of great people at state schools, but if we looks at the odds on that score, he’s likely to have an easier time at a private school.

Will he have an easier time though, given you say you are living a basic life at the moment so you can save for school fees? Will your DS be mostly surrounded by other kids who have lots of nice holidays, interesting hobbies, large houses, cars, tutoring, etc.

LalaPaloosa · 28/01/2024 19:43

I pay £7.5k per term for fees and school lunches. This does not include school uniform, PE kit (summer and winter for both), instruments, music classes, after school clubs, wrap around care, or other extracurricular activities etc. If VAT comes in I’ll be paying an additional 20%. The school has already told us it will be passed on to us.

So think very carefully if you are needing to budget and set money aside to cover it. It may be better to invest that money to cover private high school fees.

BananaPyjamaLlama · 28/01/2024 19:41

"he’s likely to have an easier time at a private school."

Thats just not true. Hugely sweeping statement.
A friend of mine - her child was sexually assaualted in the playground by a fellow private school child. Friend complained but the school essentially refused to do anything because the kid who assualted her, her parents were donated huge sums of money to the school.
For sure, state schools arent perfect but private ones arent either. And there are plenty of "bad" "undesirable" influences within private schools.

Anquiete · 28/01/2024 19:39

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 19:33

Thanks for some really helpful responses.

I am not concerned about academic success, what will be will be on that front and I believe that’s largely down to parental input regardless of the school. It’s more about the wider experience and to avoid ds being exposed to bad influence. I’m well aware that there’s scope for bad influence at a private school, and that there are millions of great people at state schools, but if we looks at the odds on that score, he’s likely to have an easier time at a private school.

Christ what have I just read. This thread isn’t real perhaps …

Anquiete · 28/01/2024 19:39

Insane.

  1. Find an outstanding state primary and out DS in it
  2. Top him up with all manner of sports, music, language and tech lessons and trips and travel with part of that money
  3. Pensions
  4. Savings
  5. University fund
  6. house deposit fund
  7. start a SIPP for him.

there you go - that’s your £1000 a month for his actual future.

My goodness - what an insane plan you’ve made to chuck all that money at private schooling when you’ve got no other savings!

BananaPyjamaLlama · 28/01/2024 19:38

Sorry OP but thats really silly logic. You had a bad time at primary school but that was you at your school - it doesnt mean your child will have a similar sort of time (different kid, different children, different school)
He is just as likely to for some reason have an awful time at private school.

riceuten · 28/01/2024 19:35

You need to factor in

  • inflation to fees
  • a fair amount of expensive side costs you probably haven’t budgeted for like trips and costly uniform requirements
  • fees inevitably increasing considerably when charitable status for schools is lost
  • any potential change to your circumstances - private schools will not stand idly by when you can’t afford the fees -for that term - out your child will go.

If you are sending your offspring to a private school because you yourself had a bad experience in state education, that’s really sad. There’s absolutely no guarantee they will do well at a private school - indeed their experience if not an A* pupil across the board is likely to be considerably worse.

Wonderfulstuff · 28/01/2024 19:27

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 19:33

Thanks for some really helpful responses.

I am not concerned about academic success, what will be will be on that front and I believe that’s largely down to parental input regardless of the school. It’s more about the wider experience and to avoid ds being exposed to bad influence. I’m well aware that there’s scope for bad influence at a private school, and that there are millions of great people at state schools, but if we looks at the odds on that score, he’s likely to have an easier time at a private school.

'to avoid ds being exposed to bad influence. I’m well aware that there’s scope for bad influence at a private school, and that there are millions of great people at state schools, but if we looks at the odds on that score, he’s likely to have an easier time at a private school.'

Wow - have you actually spent time in a private school? Parents having a bigger bank balance does not immediately equate to nicer children.

Wonderfulstuff · 28/01/2024 19:21

Personally I would use that £60k to move into the catchment area for an absolutely cracking state primary... despite your preconceptions they do exist.

pollymere · 28/01/2024 19:20

Look into bursaries and scholarships. My friend didn't pay anything for her first child and very little for her second to go to private school.

Teenagehorrorbag · 28/01/2024 19:17

cargear01 · 27/01/2024 09:11

@notknowledgeable thanks, I would prefer him to go to private school due to personal experiences

You may need to be realistic though. Secondary school is when it really can make a difference, and costs a lot more! I'd be inclined to save for that. There are usually lots of primary schools in an area so if the first one you try doesn't work for your DS you can always move him......

But if you are determined - it does sound doable at the moment. However, things may change - and you could end up moving DS back into state education later on. Surely that would be a worse scenario?

Lifethroughlenses · 28/01/2024 18:56

In the nicest possible way, you don’t sound like you can comfortably afford this. Start off in state. I honestly hand on heart do not believe my son would have had a better outcome or been happier at a private school. In fact he benefitted from having a decent number of kids in his class. Some kids do better, some worse. It’s not a given that it’s better at all. See how he gets on in a state school. They are genuinely much better at some things.

Swipe left for the next trending thread