Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Living with DD was awful, but now that she's moved out I worry about her constantly

64 replies

Mastmw7g · 27/01/2024 08:35

My 20 year old moved in with us mid December and it was not a good living arrangement. She moved out two weeks ago and I expected to feel relief. Instead I am anxious. My husband has told me that she can't move back in with us and I'm so afraid she won't be successful at this attempt of independence and will find out this is his stance. I could see it irrevocably changing our relationship. But she only moved out two weeks ago. Shouldn't I simply believe in her and not fret about her potential failure?

OP posts:
CoralPinks · 28/01/2024 00:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ghentsummer · 27/01/2024 23:19

CoralPinks · 27/01/2024 12:52

I have taken the time to sit and write several helpful suggestions to the poster in how she can better support her daughter.

Have you done the same apart from engaging in some unofficial moderating and silencing of differing opinions? This forum is called AIBU, naturally some answers may find the OP unreasonable.

You say that I am projecting, are you closely identifying with OP?

Parenting that does not take enough responsibility can be damaging and dangerous and I won’t sugar coat that I’m afraid.

In the meantime, do you have any useful suggestions for the OP?

Edited

My useful suggestion would be that she doesn't take your vitriol to heart. Perhaps therapy would be a better place for you to unload.

user1492757084 · 27/01/2024 22:53

I think you are right to support your daughter in moving out. She needs to try and it will be so good if she succeeds. A road to independent adulthood.
For her, it seems, she is destined to live alone because of her personality. It's fine that she takes a while to adjust and fine that you visit. See the big picture, the long term picture.
Take it one day at a time.
Don't over parent her but visit like a friend once per week.
She has a job. Compliment her on her small successes but don't be a walkover.

NewbieSM · 27/01/2024 22:43

I remember your previous posts OP, your relationship with your daughter sounds very difficult and I'm not sure apportioning 'blame' is helpful. That said all three of you adults need to take responsibility for their actions and make a plan to resolve the issues going forward. Your daughter is an adult now, working a full time job and living on her own, she does need to learn to be self sufficient. By all means support her, visit her regularly and keep her involved with your family but don't accept abusive behaviour from her towards you or anyone else. Actions have consequences and if she continues to act like a helpless child and scream and insult people she will push everyone away. You need to make it clear to her that you will always love her but won't tolerate shitty behaviour. She will figure it out eventually.

Persimmon23 · 27/01/2024 18:58

CoralPinks · 27/01/2024 12:52

I have taken the time to sit and write several helpful suggestions to the poster in how she can better support her daughter.

Have you done the same apart from engaging in some unofficial moderating and silencing of differing opinions? This forum is called AIBU, naturally some answers may find the OP unreasonable.

You say that I am projecting, are you closely identifying with OP?

Parenting that does not take enough responsibility can be damaging and dangerous and I won’t sugar coat that I’m afraid.

In the meantime, do you have any useful suggestions for the OP?

Edited

coral I’m showing some compassion and solidarity to a lady who is struggling and trying to do her best. Please dont hide your venom behind the cloak of being helpful - taking the time as you put it to write helpful suggestions will not negate the earlier suggestion that the OP is parenting poorly or a slave to her “lord and master” as you put it.

OP it’s so difficult to find yourself in a position such as this. Whilst you want your daughter to be happy and independent you still must have such anxiety about it especially if you feel she is struggling. I don’t have any experience of this but I wanted to acknowledge your dilemma and say I think you are doing the best you can. Could you perhaps talk through the issue with an independent person who knows you both?

Mastmw7g · 27/01/2024 16:58

Menomeno · 27/01/2024 10:52

Did she leave this time round because she was (or felt) pushed out? It’s really difficult when they leave and then return, even when there’s no bad behaviour or acting out. I find ours revert to childish behaviours (just minor things like expecting to be waited on and cooked for, or never mucking in around the house), even though they’ve lived perfectly well and independently previously, and it can cause a lot of resentment. Is she playing up to try to guilt you because she feels unwelcome?

My husband did most of the work of getting her to move out. She may think it was her idea, but I feel like he manipulated her. He said it's not like that, and more like dealing with a difficult client at work. But I did the same thing with making her get a job, so I shouldn't fault him for finding a way to do it that leaves her in a good mood whereas my efforts resulted in a lot of conflict.

OP posts:
Mastmw7g · 27/01/2024 16:50

@EmilyTjP She got a regular job where she's an employee. She feels like I pestered her into that and I was very selfish to do so, but it was important to me. As far as I know, she plans to continue doing onlyfans.

OP posts:
EmilyTjP · 27/01/2024 16:42

Is your daughter still doing her webcam/only fans work or does she have a different job now?

Mastmw7g · 27/01/2024 16:40

dapsnotplimsolls · 27/01/2024 10:58

Why won't he repeat the experience? Was he told some hard truths?

I don't think so. I think he doesn't want to spend extra time with her. Even though he spends more time with her than I do. I know it's only been two weeks but she keeps asking him to help her with things instead of asking me. Installing things, building furniture. But he doesn't stay longer than he has to. I always spend at least two hours talking with her and keeping her company.

OP posts:
CoralPinks · 27/01/2024 12:52

Persimmon23 · 27/01/2024 11:31

coral you are emotionally battering this lady who has simply asked for help. She’s not neglecting her daughter - she’s trying to support her as best as she can. Lord and master comments aren’t necessary and smack of projecting. Stop bullying the OP please - it’s cruel and unnecessary

I have taken the time to sit and write several helpful suggestions to the poster in how she can better support her daughter.

Have you done the same apart from engaging in some unofficial moderating and silencing of differing opinions? This forum is called AIBU, naturally some answers may find the OP unreasonable.

You say that I am projecting, are you closely identifying with OP?

Parenting that does not take enough responsibility can be damaging and dangerous and I won’t sugar coat that I’m afraid.

In the meantime, do you have any useful suggestions for the OP?

Persimmon23 · 27/01/2024 11:31

coral you are emotionally battering this lady who has simply asked for help. She’s not neglecting her daughter - she’s trying to support her as best as she can. Lord and master comments aren’t necessary and smack of projecting. Stop bullying the OP please - it’s cruel and unnecessary

dapsnotplimsolls · 27/01/2024 10:58

Mastmw7g · 27/01/2024 10:26

@dapsnotplimsolls We did family therapy when she was a teenager. I think it was useful, but my husband says he won't repeat the experience again. We do pay for her individual therapy. She's been in therapy nine years, but she changes therapists often.

Why won't he repeat the experience? Was he told some hard truths?

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 27/01/2024 10:58

If your 20 yo daughter was a 20 year old son who moved out of a flat share where he didn;t get along with the other resisents and it was mutual Hmm .Red Flags there eh? Then moved in and had frequent episodes of uncontrolled weeping , fist thumping and argueing , to the point that the younger siblings took themselves out of the room unprompted .
Didn't care if the siblings were witness to temper and swearing .

I wonder how the replies would differ .

They'd be get this narcissist voilent ManChild out of your house . He's an ADULT. Cut the ties . Send him a supermarket delivery if you must but only meet outside your home . Protect your children

<sigh>

Menomeno · 27/01/2024 10:52

Did she leave this time round because she was (or felt) pushed out? It’s really difficult when they leave and then return, even when there’s no bad behaviour or acting out. I find ours revert to childish behaviours (just minor things like expecting to be waited on and cooked for, or never mucking in around the house), even though they’ve lived perfectly well and independently previously, and it can cause a lot of resentment. Is she playing up to try to guilt you because she feels unwelcome?

Mastmw7g · 27/01/2024 10:26

@dapsnotplimsolls We did family therapy when she was a teenager. I think it was useful, but my husband says he won't repeat the experience again. We do pay for her individual therapy. She's been in therapy nine years, but she changes therapists often.

OP posts:
Menapausemum1974 · 27/01/2024 10:25

CoralPinks · 27/01/2024 09:21

Instead of obeying a man who seems to be your lord and master, have you tried to communicate with (a two way conversation), understand, and support your child properly?

If you are genuinely worried, gently easing her into moving out may be helpful, one day a week to start with, then two, then three, and so on, while she gets used to it.
I would then also allow her to visit often on her days off, come round for dinners etc.

Many vulnerable young people are subject to grooming, exploitation, drugs, crime, unwanted pregnancies and so on.

You need to make sure she has the proper tools and awareness to look after herself before shoving her out unceremoniously.

If she is crying when you visit for a couple of hours and then leave, does that mean the lord and master has completely banned her for the home? Are you on a curfew yourself?

Are you able to enroll her in hobbies and activities to keep her happy and occupied and help her pay for them if she’s on a low wage? This way she can make friends with like minded young people, thereby escaping loneliness and staying out of trouble.

Does he consider the home his only?
Is it not your home too, since you live there?

Your daughter sounds vulnerable or troubled in some way, do you know why?

A mean step father can very easily mess a child up for life?

Are you able to afford a rented or bought small home for yourself where your own children are allowed to visit?

Are you financially dependent on this man?

Why did you have a child if you’re not willing to help her or standup for her?

Women like you make me so cross. You damage entire generations.

Edited

@CoralPinks you have made an awful lot of assumptions about this situation 🤷‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

dapsnotplimsolls · 27/01/2024 10:21

There's no quick fix to this. Family therapy seems like the best plan.

CoralPinks · 27/01/2024 10:20

Have you ever come across a concept called personal agency?

Everything is someone else’s decision or fault.

I give up.

I hope your daughter will get used to having her own space and grow and heal emotionally despite all this passing the buck or whatever it is that you actually do.

Mastmw7g · 27/01/2024 10:15

The reason she thought I was so evil when she was younger was because he and I would be at odds. He would want to do something for her or give her something and I would say no and he would do it anyway. We almost divorced, which would have been a waste since we love each other, have kids together, and both love my oldest even if we had different approaches.

OP posts:
CoralPinks · 27/01/2024 10:07

It is very sad that not only you have not had a good relationship with her for years, but that you have allowed important decision making and parenting to be done by your DH.

Sometimes, when you are speaking of her, it almost seems as though you are positioning her as a rival for your DH’s attentions.

Your first post made it sound as though he was being too harsh, now it seems he has been far too lenient.

Did you have a part to play in any of this at all? What were you doing when all of this spoiling or blanket decision making on whether she is allowed to return was happening?

Surely it is your child and you have the final say in her welfare?

HalloumiGeller · 27/01/2024 10:03

It gets to a point where your adult children need to stand on their own 2 feet, as let's face it, us parents aren't around forever! I left home at 20 and I was fine. I won't push my kids out of my house, but I will be encouraging them to prepare for that stage of their lives and that inevitably, it will happen.

Mastmw7g · 27/01/2024 09:55

CoralPinks · 27/01/2024 09:46

Everything seems to relate back to “my husbands”, what has been your input into your daughter?

She and I didn't get along at all when she was a teenager. She thought my husband was perfect and I was evil. From June to December she lived in the houseshare and we started to get along. We spoke on the phone every day. Her relationship broke down during that time with my husband. She only called when she wanted something, and would yell and call names when he said he was working. She'd call me after and say he hung up on her, and I'd just listen.

OP posts:
CoralPinks · 27/01/2024 09:52

Patchworksack · 27/01/2024 08:40

Probably the best way to handle it is to offer support with whatever she finds difficult (budgeting? loneliness? Chores? )and then work in the relationship in other ways - take her out for lunch, plan a shopping trip, spend some unpressured time together. Is your husband her father?Either way you can present it as encouraging her independence rather than not wanting her living with you.

We don’t know what actual support the mother has given, we do however know that she is “spoilt”.

The crying and not wanting to leave speaks volumes, my heart is breaking for her.

20 is still quite young, especially for this generation.

KL090 · 27/01/2024 09:52

I am not a psychologist but this is common in trauma children she is pushing him away to prove he doesn’t love her unconditionally. Hes had enough but much of this was of his own doing? She clearly really wants parents but is hurt and acting out. It’s ok for him to have boundaries but he has to remember that he created some of this situation it’s not all her fault. You also let this happen

Mastmw7g · 27/01/2024 09:49

CoralPinks · 27/01/2024 09:38

Your daughter seems to have the hallmarks of emotional instability, this is usually related to trauma.

Have the tried to get her psychological help either now or in the past? If not why not?

It seems a big leap from “my husband can’t say no to her” to “my husband won’t allow her to live with us”, how does that work?

She did experience a lot of trauma before her dad stopped seeing her. It wasn't under good circumstances that she started living with us 100% of the time, and I did get her in therapy where we were told she needed strong boundaries from my husband, but he never followed through on that. He said it was because she had been through so much. He acts like she's only become this unpleasant person since she stopped living with us the first time, because she doesn't respect his time, acts helpless about basic things she needs to do to take care of herself, and then yells at him and calls him names.

OP posts: