Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband asking me what will happen to him and kids when I die??

291 replies

Justawoman88 · 26/01/2024 23:43

Was in the car driving home and my husband said as an statement that if I died then him and our 3 children would be out on the streets and that I need to sort out a will. If he died still I would have money and I can live happily .
To give context, he's never been the provider, never had money . 10 years married and I've been the provider and the reason we have a roof over our heads. Truth is , I have nothing to my name. Years of spending my savings plus working and giving my family everything. I'm tired of having the world on my shoulders. I think this comment is sickening. I don't know, if I confront him I know he'll gaslight me or make me feel silly .

OP posts:
DreamTheMoors · 27/01/2024 05:28

muggart · 27/01/2024 04:24

My DF was our main provider and died suddenly and unexpectedly age 36. Thank god he had been thoughtful enough to put in place life insurance. My childhood would have been very different without it.

I think the OP has some resentment towards her DH which is clouding her judgement on an important issue.

Wow, @muggart
OP may very well be resentful - she may very well not be.

It’s not for any of us to decide how @Justawoman88 feels or to gage her judgment.

So much for armchair shrinks.

DreamTheMoors · 27/01/2024 05:07

He says you need to make out a will?

Why? Is he planning to murder you?

I’m only half-joking. Besides - everything should go to provide for your children and let your husband provide for himself.

I’d look into getting a life insurance policy though - and naming your kids as beneficiaries - with your parents or a trusted sibling or friend as conservator.
The monthly payment should be relatively inexpensive if you’re young.
I was foolish and waited until I was retired. Don’t be like me.

My apologies @TempleOfBloom - just saw you recommended the same thing. I should’ve quoted you.

Passingthethyme · 27/01/2024 05:03

Gowlett · 27/01/2024 05:00

I’m the one who holds the financials together in our house. I look after everything official (bills, house, tax etc…). DH isn’t able to handle money, his whole family is the same. It’s exhausting worrying about it all. But, I figure a lot of men must feel the same. In my family, the males sort all of this stuff out.

She doesn't just handle the finances, she is the finances. He's got no money, never did

Gowlett · 27/01/2024 05:00

I’m the one who holds the financials together in our house. I look after everything official (bills, house, tax etc…). DH isn’t able to handle money, his whole family is the same. It’s exhausting worrying about it all. But, I figure a lot of men must feel the same. In my family, the males sort all of this stuff out.

HollyKnight · 27/01/2024 04:43

There is not enough information here.

But really, as parents, you both are responsible for ensuring that your children don't end up homeless or in care if either of you should die.

NotMarriedToAHouse · 27/01/2024 04:34

Everyone needs a will. It is challenging and lengthy to sort an estate without one.

Every parent needs to appoint guardians for their children, get life insurance and make a will.

muggart · 27/01/2024 04:24

My DF was our main provider and died suddenly and unexpectedly age 36. Thank god he had been thoughtful enough to put in place life insurance. My childhood would have been very different without it.

I think the OP has some resentment towards her DH which is clouding her judgement on an important issue.

Whydosomanywomensleepwithsuchlosers · 27/01/2024 04:16

Am I missing something here? OP doesn't say he doesn't work, she says he's not "a provider". He could just be a low earner?

If you're married he'll inherit everything you own anyway, whether you have a will or not?

Would probably set up life insurance for the kids in this situation. I wouldn't feel the need to provide for him if you die though.

Weenurse · 27/01/2024 04:14

Both of you need insurance in case of death or incapacity.
Both of you need wills.

Luckycloverz · 27/01/2024 04:09

I'm not sure if you already have life insurance in place but really with children you both need it. However thoughtlessly mentioned by him it's not worth the worry that either of you or your children should have to struggle if the worst possible scenario was ever to happen.

RogueFemale · 27/01/2024 03:34

Justawoman88 · 26/01/2024 23:43

Was in the car driving home and my husband said as an statement that if I died then him and our 3 children would be out on the streets and that I need to sort out a will. If he died still I would have money and I can live happily .
To give context, he's never been the provider, never had money . 10 years married and I've been the provider and the reason we have a roof over our heads. Truth is , I have nothing to my name. Years of spending my savings plus working and giving my family everything. I'm tired of having the world on my shoulders. I think this comment is sickening. I don't know, if I confront him I know he'll gaslight me or make me feel silly .

If you don't make a will, and you die before your husband, the default is that your husband will inherit your assets, tax free. So he needn't be worried. Assuming you are legally married.

What is there to "confront" him about?

He sounds like a dick, though.

kkloo · 27/01/2024 03:21

Does he mean that you need to sort out life insurance?

What's the housing situation? Presumably you're renting or else you'd have mortgage life insurance and so the house would be paid and go to him and the kids anyway.

RiderofRohan · 27/01/2024 02:57

Well, I sort of agree with him. What will happen to your kids if you die? Are you willing to risk they grow up in poverty?

You have no savings, that's fine. It just means you need to take out a basic life insurance policy so that at least if something happens, they'll be able to survive until your husband can get on his feet.

Had the same convo with my DH. Never cared before but now we have a baby on the way it's important to consider things. Death isn't an abstract concept.

MCOut · 27/01/2024 02:56

YABU this is a sensible conversation to have. Forget him and think about provision for your kids. I’m not sure of all the details, but I know someone who didn’t receive her husband’s pension or a life insurance payout because he passed suddenly without sorting things out properly. Your husband does need to be aware of any arrangements you’ve made.

There’s not enough of a story here for him to be written off as just lazy, so I’m not going to make that assumption.

Topseyt123 · 27/01/2024 02:49

You've given nothing like enough information about your DH for people to gain an accurate picture here, although some have decided that they know for sure he is a useless cocklodger. He might be, or he might be unable to work for some reason so has been a SAHP. We don't know and haven't been told.

Why is it sickening to be reminded that you need a will, especially as you have children? Of course you do. It is neither sickening nor silly. Why on earth would you not want to be sure your children at least would be provided for? Why not DH?

Meadowfinch · 27/01/2024 02:31

Simple answer. If you died, your lazy dh would have to get off his bum, go to work, and provide for his children, like decent parents do ! Like single mums everywhere do.

Make sure your will leaves your half of everything to your dcs. Or if you die first, he'll leave them with nothing.

Whattodowithit88 · 27/01/2024 02:05

His not wrong though is he. Him and your kids are either your family or not, why would you not have a will in place and protection for your family. He needs a will too, to protect you, extended family can be rough and if it’s in a will it can’t be argued (without costing them money anyways)

caringcarer · 27/01/2024 01:44

You both need to get life insurance as a matter of urgency to help protect your DC.

moomoomoo27 · 27/01/2024 01:41

"Good point, I'll set up funds for the kids that only they can access for when they turn 18, and make plans with the godparents/grandparents for how it would work re living costs and arrangements in the interim."

Also, I would make sure to set up a power of attorney person for yourself that's not him.

Nevermind31 · 27/01/2024 01:34

I think as a parent you do need to have a will, and life insurance. For both of you. So that the house will be mortgage free, and the surviving partner has enough to support themselves and the children. Maybe not enough so they don’t have to work, but enough so that childcare would be covered, and everyone would be ok.
BUT this is not just to sort out for yourself, but for both of you.

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/01/2024 01:32

Of course you need a will.

Why doesn't he work?

DeeCeeCherry · 27/01/2024 01:30

Well you are the main earner so why can't he ask? No different than a woman asking her husband. You've carried him for years so presumably you must have wanted to.

Latewinter · 27/01/2024 01:29

WhycantIkeepthisbloodyplantalive · 27/01/2024 00:40

Some of these replies are madness. Why is it okay for women(wives) to be looked after after death but not men(husbands)?

So basically any women that earns less than her husband, according to some of these posts logic are 'a useless waste of space', a 'useless fannylodger' and partner would be better of single!

...Well approx 75% of men in the UK need to leave our pathetic useless arses as they'd be better off being single.

Edited

V v rare a woman gets away with being as useless in the house/with kids as many men are though, or even tries to.

& like hell if she was a sahm everyone would be on her side, as someone said. They'd all be yelling at her to get a job and saying how hard it is to be the sole provider, "he's probably feeling the pressure." Why don't you retrain/earn more OP...blah blah.

Roiesin57 · 27/01/2024 01:28

@Aquamarine1029 how do you know that he's a Cocklodger? He maybe physically unable to work. Maybe when they had children they made a joint decision that he would be a sahp to their kids. That's what I was for a few years. I was looking after two babies & toddlers in their formative years & most certainly do not consider myself a sponger

WhereYouLeftIt · 27/01/2024 01:11

Justawoman88 · 26/01/2024 23:43

Was in the car driving home and my husband said as an statement that if I died then him and our 3 children would be out on the streets and that I need to sort out a will. If he died still I would have money and I can live happily .
To give context, he's never been the provider, never had money . 10 years married and I've been the provider and the reason we have a roof over our heads. Truth is , I have nothing to my name. Years of spending my savings plus working and giving my family everything. I'm tired of having the world on my shoulders. I think this comment is sickening. I don't know, if I confront him I know he'll gaslight me or make me feel silly .

Setting aside your hurt for a minute:

In practical terms, there is really little point in you making a will. If you die intestate (without a will) in the UK, there are rules about who would inherit. First dibs goes to the spouse, they get the first £322,000. Since you say "Truth is , I have nothing to my name" that would mean everything of your nothing would go to him anyway.

Rules here - https://www.gov.uk/inherits-someone-dies-without-will

Did he mean life insurance, rather than a will? It is always sensible for both parents to have life insurance. For a working parent, it can replace the lost income, for a non-working parent it can pay for childcare etc. to replace their non-financial contributions.

Now - you were hurt by his comment, and from your comments it sounds as if your marriage is not a happy place to be. You say he does not contribute financially - does he contribute to the family otherwise? Three under-10s is a lot of childcare. Does he run the domestic side of the household? Because there's a big difference between an engaged SAHD and a husband who spends all his waking hours on his XBox.

"I'm tired of having the world on my shoulders."
A family should be a team, what part of the load does he carry? Earning, housework, mental load - what does he contribute?

"if I confront him I know he'll gaslight me or make me feel silly ."
Has he done this to you before?

What do you think would make life work for you? Him sharing the load? Or him not being there?

Intestacy - who inherits if someone dies without a will?

Find out who is entitled to a share of someone’s property, possessions and money if they die without making a will

https://www.gov.uk/inherits-someone-dies-without-will