Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think a holiday with my childless friends wouldn't work anymore

115 replies

TooIntrovert · 26/01/2024 21:58

I've got some friends who I've been close with since high school.
We've been on lots of holidays together.
But now I'm the only one with a child (4).
And I feel like on holidays, or even day trips, I end up in a sort of parallel world to them, in the same vicinity but not really part of the group as such.
Partly because my son has found it hard to share me - although that's getting easier as he gets older.
And partly because my friends don't really engage with him beyond the first "hello" (they are childless by choice and don't really like children) which understandably makes him even more attention seeking, so it's left up to me and me alone to include him in the day.

I don't really want to go away without him, as between his preschool and my work I don't actually spend loads of time with him.
I have a term time only contract, so I wouldn't mind going in the middle of the summer holidays without him, and would probably need the space by then, but only for a couple of days.

They REALLY want to keep up our going on holiday tradition. But none of us can think of any solutions (I've expressed all of the above to them and they didn't have any insight into how we could adjust things) .....for me it's easier to say "go without me"....but they keep saying they want the whole group there. I'm not bothered if they go without me, we still see each other for the occasional dinner etc, meet online for a chat regularly, and keep in touch via WhatsApp and to me it's okay if a group holiday doesn't work anymore. But the question still comes up....AIBU and lacking imagination in how it could work?

OP posts:
TooIntrovert · 26/01/2024 23:10

NoisyDachshunddd · 26/01/2024 23:06

Yeh, still sounds to me like you’re doing all the managing around your partner and your child.

what would happen if you said, hey, DP, I’m going away for a week with my girlfriends: isn’t that fabulous!?! ok I know it will be a bit of a juggle for you but I’m totally willing to do the same for you so you can have some time to yourself/ with your mates.

leave aside, for the moment, your discomfort about going away for more than 2-3 nights.

would he get in a sulk? Begrudgingly agree but make you feel bad? If so, that’s the real issue.

i know you said you don’t want to do it anyway. That’s fine! But I think if my suspicion is actually true, then that explains why this business and expectation from your friends grates so much: you know you’re actually not free to make the go/don’t go choice.

i apologise if I’ve completely got the wrong end of the stick but I think I’m probably at least partially right.

He'd be okay with it! When DC was younger he'd panic (with good reason..) but now he'd be fine. I'm not sure where you're getting this impression from....🤔

OP posts:
Brawcolli · 26/01/2024 23:09

Caggers · 26/01/2024 22:49

Ask yourself why you think a woman’s role is to be helpful.

You’re on a forum where someone’s asking for advice, the goal is to help the poster, not to start throwing insults around and making yourself look silly.

Logainm · 26/01/2024 23:07

We went on holiday often as a childfree couple with friends with children. It can work well. I wouldn’t do something expensive and longhaul, though. We used to rent a house in France or Italy and do a combination of exploring and loafing.

NoisyDachshunddd · 26/01/2024 23:06

Yeh, still sounds to me like you’re doing all the managing around your partner and your child.

what would happen if you said, hey, DP, I’m going away for a week with my girlfriends: isn’t that fabulous!?! ok I know it will be a bit of a juggle for you but I’m totally willing to do the same for you so you can have some time to yourself/ with your mates.

leave aside, for the moment, your discomfort about going away for more than 2-3 nights.

would he get in a sulk? Begrudgingly agree but make you feel bad? If so, that’s the real issue.

i know you said you don’t want to do it anyway. That’s fine! But I think if my suspicion is actually true, then that explains why this business and expectation from your friends grates so much: you know you’re actually not free to make the go/don’t go choice.

i apologise if I’ve completely got the wrong end of the stick but I think I’m probably at least partially right.

TooIntrovert · 26/01/2024 23:05

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 26/01/2024 23:01

It’s very difficult to understand how your friends could not realise you won’t be able to go to Japan or Canada with them, as though you had neither a husband nor child to think of. Unless you were minted or something, with loads of spare time off.

Sounds completely reasonable to say “I can only do a long weekend in Europe” or similar, and for them to do anything long haul without you.

Yeh I have never really understood this. I only used to get 20 days leave and would have had to use the majority of them on our group trips, not to mention the money.

OP posts:
Peaceandquietandacuppa · 26/01/2024 23:03

Book a nice 3 night holiday with your friends without your kid. I go away with a friend once a year and I swear it makes me a better parent, I come back so refreshed. Never more than 3 nights, that’s my max. Otherwise just tell them you will rejoin group trips in a couple of years. But it is important to maintain friendships and keep those bonds. Your son can also bond with DH without you for a few days.

ShouldGoToBed · 26/01/2024 23:02

They’re being unreasonable. Just tell them you’d love to do a long weekend in Europe, but you’re not up for long haul or more than 3 nights. They will have to get over it, and if they get huffy tell them not to be ridiculous. It sounds like there are still schoolgirl dynamics in the group, and that sounds like a pain in the bum.

Flyhigher · 26/01/2024 23:02

Don't see why good friends would exclude a child.

easylikeasundaymorn · 26/01/2024 23:01

TooIntrovert · 26/01/2024 22:13

No. I'm expecting them to either agree to a weekend away, or go away themselves for a longer time, or stop asking the same question of me expecting a different outcome.

I was surprised when you said you bought your son with you on holidays, and tbh it's unsurprising that doesn't work - having a child totally changes the vibe. I know groups of friends who still on on holidays all together and leave the kids at home, or groups who now all bring kids, so it's become a completely different type of holiday, but just one child is never going to work.

But with your update I think you're being fair enough - there's no other magic solution you can suggest is there? You've said they can go without you, ball's in their court.

Your title is misleading - there's no reason why a general holiday (a long weekend or whatever) with your childless friends wouldn't work.
Your AIBU is if your friends are U to not accept you don't want to go on a specific type of holiday. Your reason for not wanting to is because you don't want to be away from your child that long but it could be any other reason, they just aren't accepting your refusal and either planning something else you do want to do, or going without you, as you've suggested. I'm surprised they are so inflexible - in my experience it's normal for someone to not be able to make different events for lots of reasons, not just children - can't afford it, busy time at work, don't have enough leave, etc.

The only U bit about your actions is being a bit rude to suggest just because your parents didn't go away for a week without you it's "weird". Its fine that you don't want to do it, but if someone else does and has suitable childcare it's a perfectly normal thing to do.

Sarvanga38 · 26/01/2024 23:01

God, I’m all for grabbing any opportunities for travel with friends that I can but Japan? Canada? Even I wouldn’t pull that on my husband, for experiences he’d miss, time off or money spent!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 26/01/2024 23:01

It’s very difficult to understand how your friends could not realise you won’t be able to go to Japan or Canada with them, as though you had neither a husband nor child to think of. Unless you were minted or something, with loads of spare time off.

Sounds completely reasonable to say “I can only do a long weekend in Europe” or similar, and for them to do anything long haul without you.

Flyhigher · 26/01/2024 22:58

Your child needs other kids on holiday with them. Not adults that don't like children.

Either take another child family with you.

Or you start holidaying with his school friends.
These holidays are precious. Or go with family.

MarshaMarshaMarshmellow · 26/01/2024 22:58

TooIntrovert · 26/01/2024 22:55

Thank you for explaining! I was confused as were several other people.
But I have opted not to go. Several times. I've said to them over and over it doesn't work for me any more and please go without me.
They then don't plan anything without me because they'd rather the whole group go. And re-ask the question every year.

Your friends sound insufferable, to be honest.

But look, they're big girls, you've been clear with them. If they haven't gone on holiday, they can't be that motivated. Sounds like they like the idea of reliving the old days, but not enough to really do something about it anymore. If they have any sense they will know that.

TooIntrovert · 26/01/2024 22:58

YankeeDad · 26/01/2024 22:54

My kids are a lot older now, but 4 is getting close to the age where your child could potentially do something with their dad for multiple days and form a real connection with him.

This may not work as an idea if annual leave allowance or holiday fund availability is too tight, but I thought I’d put it out there: what if your child were to spend a few days with their Dad while you go with your friends? If your friends go somewhere geographically that the Dad also wants to go, you could split out a 2-week trip so that you spend most of it with your partner and your child, but 4-5 days with your friend while the Dad has some alone time with your child. If this sort of idea has not been in the cards before then he may need your help and prompting to identify an activity or activities that he and your child would enjoy doing together, but it could strengthen their relationship

Obviously this idea only makes sense if you want to spend time with your friends in this way and are willing to give up some time with your child. But, although I have a strong bond with my kids now, I wish I had done that myself when my kids were younger.

We split our week so actually 2 days a week I'm working and he's with his dad (after preschool which finishes at 1230).
They have a lovely bond and I'm glad for our arrangement.
I think your idea would work although co-ordinating what my family would want from a trip and what my friends would want from a trip sounds like hard work 🙈
I've suggested a weekend away for now. If they come back with a "can't we go longer/further" I'll think about doing this and whether the budget would stretch to it etc.

OP posts:
mollyfolk · 26/01/2024 22:57

Honestly a long haul 10 night holiday would be completely out of reach for me as a mother. It would take funds away from our family holiday and it would take my annual leave away. Suggest a short (child free) break.

mrlistersgelfbride · 26/01/2024 22:56

I'm have a child but have a lot of childfree friends. Your friends are being unreasonable and inflexible. Why can't they go to a European break where you can come this year, and then maybe the following year they can have a Japan/Canada type holiday...
Alternate years?

I don't like going away without my daughter. I used to with work for 3/4 nights, or with friends for a 2 night hen party. But I'm relieved those days are over- I'm soft and I really miss her 😂
I love a little break but a week's too long.
I think you sound like a lovely mum and friend by the way.
You need to be firm with them that you can't go on these long holidays. If they don't accept it, it's tough unfortunately.
If it's causing stress and a bit of a headache for you it's ok to back away from the group.
Yes I'm all for keeping friendships going but friendship is a two way street and about compromise.

apricotwheat · 26/01/2024 22:56

Caggers · 26/01/2024 22:52

She sounds insufferable because she’s making out that nobody can survive without her- her son or her friends.

All she needs to do is opt to not go. It’s no big deal, but she’s making it into one.

Nobody wants someone else’s four year old to join them on a girls’ holiday.

I mean she hasn't said this at all. She's said multiple times that she's happy for them to go without her but they still keep trying to persuade her. It shouldn't be a big deal to say no, you're right, but it probably feels like a big deal to OP because it highlights how her life differs from her friends and how they might not understand that.

OurfriendsintheNE · 26/01/2024 22:56

Long haul to Japan or Canada is a whole other ball game. Thought you meant a week max in Spain. Absolutely not being unreasonable to tell them (and keep telling them) this kind of trip isn’t feasible for you but they should knock themselves out.

Thereislightattheendofthetunnel · 26/01/2024 22:55

This happened to me OP.

I was the only one with 2 children and because I live abroad they wanted to spend time with them.

So I naively took my 2 children, buggy and all, only to realise that they exchanged pleasantries for 2 minutes and then it was up to me to keep my children entertained when they were having their meal quietly and relaxed while having an adult conversation.

That moment for me was a before and after and so I told them if they want to meet my children to arrange a playdate.

That has never happened. So now when I meet them is without children.

I too felt like I was living in a parallel universe. Nights out, meals out, nice shopping trips and cafes… I felt resentment and inadequacy.
Now they are starting to have children and they understand the difficulties now.

TooIntrovert · 26/01/2024 22:55

Caggers · 26/01/2024 22:52

She sounds insufferable because she’s making out that nobody can survive without her- her son or her friends.

All she needs to do is opt to not go. It’s no big deal, but she’s making it into one.

Nobody wants someone else’s four year old to join them on a girls’ holiday.

Thank you for explaining! I was confused as were several other people.
But I have opted not to go. Several times. I've said to them over and over it doesn't work for me any more and please go without me.
They then don't plan anything without me because they'd rather the whole group go. And re-ask the question every year.

OP posts:
Broodywuz · 26/01/2024 22:54

Agree with all the previous posts, it's not going to work taking your child. It's like that clingy boyfriend that comes along to the girls night out, not really fun for anyone!
I would just be firm and say I'd be up for a weekend here but until he's a bit older I'm not up for leaving him more than a couple of nights so if you guys want to go abroad just go without me.

YankeeDad · 26/01/2024 22:54

My kids are a lot older now, but 4 is getting close to the age where your child could potentially do something with their dad for multiple days and form a real connection with him.

This may not work as an idea if annual leave allowance or holiday fund availability is too tight, but I thought I’d put it out there: what if your child were to spend a few days with their Dad while you go with your friends? If your friends go somewhere geographically that the Dad also wants to go, you could split out a 2-week trip so that you spend most of it with your partner and your child, but 4-5 days with your friend while the Dad has some alone time with your child. If this sort of idea has not been in the cards before then he may need your help and prompting to identify an activity or activities that he and your child would enjoy doing together, but it could strengthen their relationship

Obviously this idea only makes sense if you want to spend time with your friends in this way and are willing to give up some time with your child. But, although I have a strong bond with my kids now, I wish I had done that myself when my kids were younger.

Caggers · 26/01/2024 22:52

apricotwheat · 26/01/2024 22:46

How on earth does she sound insufferable? She sounds like a lovely mum who wants to prioritise time with her son. She still sees her friends regularly and has stated she is happy for them to go on the trips they want without her.

She sounds insufferable because she’s making out that nobody can survive without her- her son or her friends.

All she needs to do is opt to not go. It’s no big deal, but she’s making it into one.

Nobody wants someone else’s four year old to join them on a girls’ holiday.

fuckssaaaaake · 26/01/2024 22:52

Oh wow! I love getting away for a bit without my kids . I can't believe you want to take your child away with your mates! Nowt as queer as folk , as they say 😂

Cherrysoup · 26/01/2024 22:51

You’ve moved in a different direction to them. Weekends would suit you, 2 weeks long haul is out of the question for most mums. If they’re being funny about, it they aren’t great friends and have zero understanding of your situation.