Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The dad privilege checklist

203 replies

Iis · 26/01/2024 20:35

I saw this linked to on a Reddit thread and I see so many similar threads here I thought I’d share it. Many people advise to share with their husbands the blog post ‘my husband left his glass next to the dishwasher’ or something like this, but this may help as well.

If you don’t want to click an unknown link just google the dad privilege check list Zawn Villines.

https://zawn.substack.com/p/the-dad-privilege-checklist

The Dad Privilege Checklist

There are so many things that dads never have to think about, and never have to feel guilty for not considering.

https://zawn.substack.com/p/the-dad-privilege-checklist

OP posts:
Crispsandwichrock · 27/01/2024 16:09

I do all the diy, I book all the tradespeople. I sort my own car. Saying these are "men's jobs" ignore that a) a lot of men don't do them, and b) they are not equivalent to the emotional labour being described with raising children.
I saw a man at the dentist with his young boys recently. So, great he was at the dentist with them. He was asked their dates of birth and goodness he struggled with this. His own dc.

SwordToFlamethrower · 27/01/2024 16:02

C1N1C · 27/01/2024 15:24

If this is true for your partner, you have a sh!t partner.

But some of these are really stretching, and/or have an equal but opposite statement.

You do parties, he does DIY
You plan holidays, he'll do the driving
You don't get thanks for housework, does he?

You breastfeed... can he?
Lol, saying that him not doing that is a male privilege is a cheap shot.

6/100 of these are birthday-related, which happens one day a year.

Not knowing milestones (e.g. teething), is inconsequential.

And I don't know any man who let's their wife book tradesmen, DIY is a male pride thing.

Wrapping holiday presents, school committees, who does that?...

You don't know many men then do you!!

I do all the DIY, driving and towing caravan as dh can't drive and isn't confident with tools. I also research, plan and book the holidays.

You're entirely missing the point of the list.

It isn't that a man can't bf so how can he do it, it is that she does it and it is invisible labour. Women are just expected to do it with little or no recognition.

C1N1C · 27/01/2024 15:24

If this is true for your partner, you have a sh!t partner.

But some of these are really stretching, and/or have an equal but opposite statement.

You do parties, he does DIY
You plan holidays, he'll do the driving
You don't get thanks for housework, does he?

You breastfeed... can he?
Lol, saying that him not doing that is a male privilege is a cheap shot.

6/100 of these are birthday-related, which happens one day a year.

Not knowing milestones (e.g. teething), is inconsequential.

And I don't know any man who let's their wife book tradesmen, DIY is a male pride thing.

Wrapping holiday presents, school committees, who does that?...

Wishihadanalgorithm · 27/01/2024 14:26

Interesting. I don’t think I could have had a child if I thought the father was going to be like the one described in the checklist.

I generally sort play dates as I’m on the class WhatsApp and DP isn’t but he takes to all the parties, does a bit more cooking than me, has been known to shop for clothes and shoes for DD and replies to most of the school letters.

I think we have it 50:50.

Anyone who feels taken advantage of needs to try to address the imbalance as soon as possible.

Deafdonkey · 27/01/2024 14:11

SwordToFlamethrower · 27/01/2024 10:11

But you had to train him... did a man need to train you?

Just because the monkey was easy to train, doesn't mean he gets a special prize. Would he have just done it off his own back?

I agree, how bloody depressing.

Another woman thinking they have hit the jackpot but the reality is they are parenting a man child, who by luck happens to be biddable.

VinegarTrio · 27/01/2024 13:40

the patriarchy is bad for everyone, ultimately.

But there are men who derive advantages and status from having a wife who doesn’t work and lives a life of lunches and Pilates classes. That includes the ability to play the martyr and hold it over her that he works so hard so she can have nice handbags (or whatever).

There are trade-offs all over the place.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 27/01/2024 13:19

CoralPinks · 27/01/2024 13:10

Men like this work such unnecessary hours because of the power and control status and money affords them in every sphere of life.
They are certainly not hard done by little dears.

This is an area where men are expected to conform to giving 110% and going beyond and all that trash, a sort of corporate peer pressure, which I think is a situation where - if this is caused by what we might call “patriarchy” - ALSO disadvantages men.

CoralPinks · 27/01/2024 13:10

Drosera · 27/01/2024 12:24

There was a thread a while back. Called something like 'If you dont work you're so lucky'. Quite a few posters came out the woodwork to say how they felt blessed to work PT (or not at all) and could do all their hobbies/gym etc due to having married a high earning partner/guy with his own business. Plenty of "my SIL is rich and hasn't worked a day in her life, I'm so jealous".

Also a fair few chipping in to say they couldn't work for health reasons and hated it, so it defo cuts both ways. But in cases where one partner is living the life of Riley and the other working 80 hours a week, the former is always a woman and the latter is always a man. No woman seems to want to bankroll an attractive male to chill and hang out with his mates all day.

So, I kinda see it both ways tbh. Can't be great fun being stuck in an office on a Wednesday while your wife enjoys her free time, knowing you've got another 35 years of this and you'll be able to join her one day, when you're a pensioner.

Edited

Men like this work such unnecessary hours because of the power and control status and money affords them in every sphere of life.
They are certainly not hard done by little dears.

OutsideLookingOut · 27/01/2024 12:56

Great list and why I'd make such a wonderful dad!

Crispsandwichrock · 27/01/2024 12:54

MoreDangerousThanAWomanScorned · 27/01/2024 12:37

Is this what most people call 'keeping an eye on your kids and making sure the toddler isn't putting stones in their mouth'? Because if so then again I agree that men are generally held to much lower standards for this and its a real and genuine inequality but again I find the overblown language unhelpful and think it undermines the case.

Why shouldn't we use "fancy" language to describe an important skill? Because women do it? If it was part of a man's paid employment you can bet it would have a fancy name!

SouthLondonMum22 · 27/01/2024 12:51

The list doesn't resonate with me at all but unfortunately, I think I'm definitely in the minority.

MoreDangerousThanAWomanScorned · 27/01/2024 12:37

Underthesea5 · 27/01/2024 11:14

I would add to the list:

Good parents constantly horizon scan and risk assess for serious threats to the child and take reasonable precautions to mitigate risk to the child.

Nobody notices when dads don't do this, even if there are terrible consequences.

Is this what most people call 'keeping an eye on your kids and making sure the toddler isn't putting stones in their mouth'? Because if so then again I agree that men are generally held to much lower standards for this and its a real and genuine inequality but again I find the overblown language unhelpful and think it undermines the case.

Drosera · 27/01/2024 12:34

Underthesea5 · 27/01/2024 10:53

I'd have gladly gone back to work FT if I had a DH who did the stuff in the list like many men do.

Personally, I see the ability to go back to work and sustain a career after having a child as an enormous privilege that many women do not have.

My god, I miss my career. I worked so hard for so many years thinking I could have a child and come back and balance everything.

In my experience, the working mothers who thrive are ones who have involved grandparents who pick up some of the slack. Or can afford an excellent nanny.

But he can't have forced you not to work? You made that choice.

Drosera · 27/01/2024 12:28

Aptique · 27/01/2024 12:11

And by people, you are speaking about women. I find women to be another woman's worst enemy.

Yup. This is actually pretty accurate IME. No bloke would give a shit unless the kid was downright dishevelled.

Drosera · 27/01/2024 12:24

Mercedes519 · 27/01/2024 10:10

But is it always a privilege? It’s certainly accepted and in many expected (men never get judged for strangers bringing up their children).

For many women it’s a compromise that bites all the ways. They compromise their earning potential and financial independence. Then at the same time they are expected to pick up all the household chores and childcare because they are part-time. So the worst of both worlds…

There was a thread a while back. Called something like 'If you dont work you're so lucky'. Quite a few posters came out the woodwork to say how they felt blessed to work PT (or not at all) and could do all their hobbies/gym etc due to having married a high earning partner/guy with his own business. Plenty of "my SIL is rich and hasn't worked a day in her life, I'm so jealous".

Also a fair few chipping in to say they couldn't work for health reasons and hated it, so it defo cuts both ways. But in cases where one partner is living the life of Riley and the other working 80 hours a week, the former is always a woman and the latter is always a man. No woman seems to want to bankroll an attractive male to chill and hang out with his mates all day.

So, I kinda see it both ways tbh. Can't be great fun being stuck in an office on a Wednesday while your wife enjoys her free time, knowing you've got another 35 years of this and you'll be able to join her one day, when you're a pensioner.

Aptique · 27/01/2024 12:11

Deafdonkey · 26/01/2024 22:06

If the kids uniform is creased people judge the mother, same if the house is messy.

And by people, you are speaking about women. I find women to be another woman's worst enemy.

Aptique · 27/01/2024 12:09

greglet · 26/01/2024 21:41

Tbh this doesn't resonate with me. DH and I split that list pretty much 50:50, and where there are things on it that I do and he doesn't, there are equally things not on the list (but just as important to the running of a household) that he does that I don't do...

Doesn't resonate with me either. Tbh in our circle of friends, I can't say anyone is like this either. My ds is attending a party today, organised by the dad!

Patrickiscrazy · 27/01/2024 12:03

Meatymeatytimetoeaty · 26/01/2024 20:52

...and now I have the rage.

That's OK - I've had the rage since turning 42 and even child free....

ChiaraRimini · 27/01/2024 12:02

My ex ticked a lot of boxes on that list.
I would add the following:
"If my kids get sick someone else will take care of them"
"If I get sick someone else will take care of the kids"
"If my partner gets sick I will not be expected to take care of her"

VinegarTrio · 27/01/2024 11:30

The deadbeat dads identify as good fathers (and usually as previously fantastic husbands/partners) who are the victim of these evil women doing all the work and raising their children with no support.

All too often the rest of the world takes an entirely uncritical affirmation only approach to this self-identification and shrieks about burning the witch etc.

TorringtonDean · 27/01/2024 11:19

Obviously the deadbeat dads don’t call themselves that. They will just say how their crazy ex kicked them out and won’t let them see the kids - and people will accept that, even though it’s seldom the real story. Amazing how many “crazy women” there are who dads happily leave in sole charge of their kids. And the kids turn out fine.

Underthesea5 · 27/01/2024 11:14

I would add to the list:

Good parents constantly horizon scan and risk assess for serious threats to the child and take reasonable precautions to mitigate risk to the child.

Nobody notices when dads don't do this, even if there are terrible consequences.

Crispsandwichrock · 27/01/2024 11:09

MoreDangerousThanAWomanScorned · 27/01/2024 10:38

I find it interesting that for all the discussion about how much easier one or the other has it mostly men and women seem reluctant to swap. Shared parental leave shows that - the vast majority of men don't want to take it and the vast majority of women don't want them to. We did do it - and I honestly think it's one of the reasons that list doesn't speak to me much and we're the most equal parents I know - and I was really surprised at how much sympathy and even hostility I got, mostly from women. Women told me over and over that they wouldn't dream of giving up their leave, that it must be so hard for me working while DH got to stay at home and go to baby groups. We now both work four days a week and I've been told quite often - without exception by women - that it's a shame that I have to work so much because DH also has the time off. My experience hasn't been that many women actually find a 50/50 work and parenting split that appealing

We didn't have spl - not a thing then - but dp both was a sahd for a year and has also been pt when I was ft. This has had benefits in terms of his competence in looking after the dc, not needing instructions all the time. It didn't sadly change the dynamic of me being in charge of everything else, and rushing around after my ft job to do things that didn't occur to him needed doing.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 27/01/2024 11:03

I don’t think it is perceived as laudable to be a “deadbeat dad” - the term “deadbeat” kind of gives that away.

TorringtonDean · 27/01/2024 10:59

@CunkEverywhereOnEverything yes, it’s bizarre how lone mothers are stigmatised (not so much these days) but it’s fine to be a deadbeat absent dad. The mothers are the ones holding everything together!

I think the stigma is down to the idea that abandoned mums must be living off the state. But 1) the dad should be paying (often they don’t) and 2) many lone mums are working. I have always worked. Never was a SAHM. I did have to get an au pair when my ex-husband left and just had to pay for that too.