Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say "eat it or be hungry"

56 replies

cheeseyeasy · 26/01/2024 19:20

My 11 year old son is incredibly fussy eater. His younger sibling eats anything. Both treated the same with food growing up.

I'm at my wits end. All he eats is about 3 different meals, I'm so fed up of cooking multiple meals each night.

Aibu to say eat it or lump
It, knowing full well he will indeed lump it.

OP posts:
Twitch45 · 26/01/2024 20:27

There are certain foods I'd rather starve than eat, and I'm an NT adult.

In my house we have a vegetarian, three meat eaters, allergies to nuts and eggs. I often make two or three different meals, but I do it at the same time so it's not really a massive deal. I obviously don't make a lot of elaborate dishes, but we all eat healthy food and no one is faced with a meal that they find unpleasant.

Watercolourpapier · 26/01/2024 20:26

I never can understand what sort of parent does this.

Why try and starve your child into submission and make food into a battle?

Whyohwhywyoming · 26/01/2024 20:26

I don’t think this is a modern thing. My sister had sensory issues with food and was very picky and she’s nearly 40. My parents just made her food she would eat. She’d vomit if she tried to eat foods she didn’t like so it was pointless.

one of my children will eat anything, one is picky. The picky one will eat veg, just only specific ones. So that’s what he gets. I only cook and make him food he will eat, sometimes I’ll make myself something different and he will try a bit, often he won’t. His diet is limited in some ways but broad in others, ie he doesn’t just eat beige food, so I don’t worry from a nutrition perspective.

SENwoes · 26/01/2024 20:20

Mine were both like this and yes I cooked them the things they liked. They slowly and naturally came out of it by themselves, dd2 age 13 is just starting to want to try new things, and dd19 will eat or at least try pretty much everything now. I think they get to the age where they start to become a bit self conscious about their weird food habits, or maybe they finally get bored of those few meals! Either way they do seem to grow out of it. They both have ASD. I’m glad I just went along with it now because trying to fight them on it would have been a whole world of stress none of us needed.

UserNameChange6 · 26/01/2024 20:15

wageslavery · 26/01/2024 19:56

My kids ate anything growing up. I started them early on vegetables and different tastes and textures and they ate the lot. I was smug , and would like to go back in time and slap me.

Come early teens they started demanding sugary treats, and everything with chips, and sad beige dinners. I did it for a while - cooked 2 meals, until they started being even fussier. When a meal got sent back because the chips were "too fat" I threw in the towel.

They were given what we ate from then on. I made some tweaks to genuine personal preference - stopped doing liver, avoided kidney beans etc but it was eat it or be hungry. Took them off school dinners and onto packed lunches so they didn't just fill up on school crap.

Eventually they ate it. It wasn't fun. We had months of them trying to pick peppers out of paella and scraping nearly full plates into the recycling. They still moan about broccoli but I've just found it's nicer roasted so that helps. It's taken years to get them back to a stage when they eat a full range of balanced meals and 5+ servings but at 18 & 13 tonight they've just eaten chicken lentil and spinach curry and not moaned about the spinach or picked out the mushrooms or chickpeas.

I think it's like a lot of things with teens at the moment- there's too much choice, too much autonomy and I just took that away. No shouting, no arguing ( although they tried)- just presenting them food and they could eat it or not. I felt ok as they are NT and they'd eaten all this stuff happily a few years before so I just carried on.

Looking at pictures from "before" the epiphany they were both on the heavier side and I remember DS struggling to get regular school trousers. Eating better food more naturally has regulated things and they're now both fit and a good weight for their height.

That's lovely to read, well done! I think your approach was perfect. I do the same with mine but they are still little so I expect bumps in the road as they grow up but I am quite passionate about this.

As long as there is no ND at play, cooking different meals is bonkers and only makes kids fussier as proven by this post. It's more expensive, creates more work and means kids only eat unhealthy food. There is no benefit to it.

CaramelMac · 26/01/2024 20:12

The most important thing is not to make a big deal of it. I always say you don’t have to eat it if you don’t want to, but there isn’t anything else. Going to bed hungry for one night won’t do him any harm, obviously if it goes on and if he does prefer to starve than eat what you’ve made then you know it’s a problem that needs further investigation.

My kids usually decide about half an hour later that they will eat it after all.

AllTheChaos · 26/01/2024 20:08

youveturnedupwelldone · 26/01/2024 19:52

I was like this while my sibling ate everything, many years later I now know it's down to sensory issues. I went hungry rather than eat things I couldn't cope with and I still do rather than try and force feed myself.

I am / was the same. Some children are just being picky, others will be sick if you force them to eat something they just can’t handle. I remember being force fed something by my grandparent when I was about 7 and it just coming straight back up again. Mum tried the ‘eat or go hungry’ route, so I went hungry. Now discovering through DD’s route to diagnosis that am almost certainly ASD and probably have ADD also. Go figure!

wageslavery · 26/01/2024 19:56

My kids ate anything growing up. I started them early on vegetables and different tastes and textures and they ate the lot. I was smug , and would like to go back in time and slap me.

Come early teens they started demanding sugary treats, and everything with chips, and sad beige dinners. I did it for a while - cooked 2 meals, until they started being even fussier. When a meal got sent back because the chips were "too fat" I threw in the towel.

They were given what we ate from then on. I made some tweaks to genuine personal preference - stopped doing liver, avoided kidney beans etc but it was eat it or be hungry. Took them off school dinners and onto packed lunches so they didn't just fill up on school crap.

Eventually they ate it. It wasn't fun. We had months of them trying to pick peppers out of paella and scraping nearly full plates into the recycling. They still moan about broccoli but I've just found it's nicer roasted so that helps. It's taken years to get them back to a stage when they eat a full range of balanced meals and 5+ servings but at 18 & 13 tonight they've just eaten chicken lentil and spinach curry and not moaned about the spinach or picked out the mushrooms or chickpeas.

I think it's like a lot of things with teens at the moment- there's too much choice, too much autonomy and I just took that away. No shouting, no arguing ( although they tried)- just presenting them food and they could eat it or not. I felt ok as they are NT and they'd eaten all this stuff happily a few years before so I just carried on.

Looking at pictures from "before" the epiphany they were both on the heavier side and I remember DS struggling to get regular school trousers. Eating better food more naturally has regulated things and they're now both fit and a good weight for their height.

arethereanyleftatall · 26/01/2024 19:53

I went back to full time work as soon as my dds both were at secondary, which means I'm not back when they want their dinner, so they've been cooking for themselves since they were 11 & 13.
At 11, kids are capable of cooking for themselves, just need to be shown how.,

youveturnedupwelldone · 26/01/2024 19:52

I was like this while my sibling ate everything, many years later I now know it's down to sensory issues. I went hungry rather than eat things I couldn't cope with and I still do rather than try and force feed myself.

Globules · 26/01/2024 19:48

Sirzy · 26/01/2024 19:38

Sadly all they will say is “feed them what they will eat”. They no more have the power to force eating than parents do.

Agree.

Don't cook more than 1 meal. Try having sharing bowls with an element they will eat in them.

Reward them for kissing, licking or sniffing 1 unfamiliar item from a sharing bowl.

All the best

Ponderingwindow · 26/01/2024 19:46

It depends on the underlying reasons.

what is your experience with food refusal?

does he gag when he tries new foods or even when he tries to eat an ok food that isn’t quite normal? Does he struggle to eat enough? Are you worried about sufficient weight gain?

in our house we do anything and everything to keep dd eating. Our big concern is picky eating becoming a full blown eating disorder. All that really matters is that she eats. We absolutely make her separate food and I don’t even stress it anymore.

Ionacat · 26/01/2024 19:43

We adapt in our house. Everyone can input into meal planning (they never do so lose the right to complain!) So pasta instead of potatoes, things served separately, protein taken out before a sauce is added, frozen veg so everyone can pick what they want. I batch cook so some nights you just pick what you want from the freezer! I do ask if it’s something new that everyone tries it.

I was a fussy eater as a child and ended up going hungry and then binging which doesn’t set up good food habits so I’m trying to make sure that doesn’t happen with my DC.

OhmygodDont · 26/01/2024 19:43

The deal in our house is I won’t serve a dinner where you won’t eat any of it but it may not be your favourite and you might not want or like every aspect, but there will be plenty of veg / salad you do like with it.

Me personally I’d starve rather than eat certain things so I get it. I can’t eat mashed potatoes doesn’t matter if they are fresh or packet because one lump or bit of powder in it I couldn’t take the risk it’s not worth it. Peas/beans can’t stand the whole biting into thing. Fresh tomatoes I can’t do but canned is fine. It’s also it need to look ok smell ok before I will attempt a does it taste ok. So bbqs are hell as if it looks burnt too that’s it nope, no thank you. Where as dh says it’s chargrilled.

Missingmyusername · 26/01/2024 19:43

YANBU unless there’s more to this?

What a massive waste of food and time to cook all these meals - not everyone could afford to do this.

Moier · 26/01/2024 19:42

Is he ASD? My four Grandsons are. They each have about 6 food items they eat.. give them anything else and they would just starve..
My eldest makes 3 different meals every day.

Laurama91 · 26/01/2024 19:41

I was picky. When I got a bit older than your son is my gran used to make what ever she wanted me to try and just said if you don't like it you can make egg/cheese/what ever on toast. Worked for me. Some stuff I didnt like, 1 even made me throw up but others I had again

bakewellbride · 26/01/2024 19:40

I do the 'take it or leave it and there is no alternative' thing except for third meal of the day. If they fuss with that they get toast of something equally boring as I don't like the idea of them going to bed hungry.

TiptoeTess · 26/01/2024 19:38

I have indirect experience and it drives me mad too, OP.

Have you tried putting bowls on the table for people to help themselves with one element you know he’ll eat each night- so e.g. one bowl casserole, one bowl veg, one bowl potatoes etc?

Or fajitas: plain wraps, bowls of cheese, chicken, salad, salsa etc and then people make their own wraps? And so on?

Sirzy · 26/01/2024 19:38

Flickersy · 26/01/2024 19:35

Don't drive yourself mad cooking multiple meals. If he's willing to actually starve himself you need to seek professional help from a doctor or therapist.

Sadly all they will say is “feed them what they will eat”. They no more have the power to force eating than parents do.

Dacadactyl · 26/01/2024 19:38

nameychangerrrrrr · 26/01/2024 19:33

YANBU

Its ridiculous you’re cooking more than one meal. My family member’s kid was like this and his mum pandered to it, cooking seperate dinners and asking friends to do the same when they went over. He now only eats beige food aged 16. Won’t touch fruit or veg. No he doesn’t have a bloody eating disorder he’s just been allowed to get away with murder!

Make a meal, put some rice or bread on the table with it, and let the kids help themselves. Tell DS “you don’t have to eat it”. It’s up to him then.

I agree with this on the whole.

Is he involved in the meal planning? You could maybe say, he has to pick one new meal a week that he helps you cook. He has to make a really good effort with it and every week add a new meal in to try to find new flavours etc that he likes.

I absolutely wouldn't cook more than one meal.

questionoflust · 26/01/2024 19:38

What does he do if you make something he doesn't like?
What is his diet like outside of mealtimes? What sort of snacks does he have? What does he have for breakfast.
What about school lunches, does he have hot lunches or a packed lunch?

AtleastitsnotMonday · 26/01/2024 19:37

Will he try new foods? I'm with you on not cooking multiple meals but I couldn't see a child go hungry. Present the food with at least one element he likes. If he doesn't like it or refuses give something filling but boring. Is he able to cover the basic food groups with the meals he does eat? Is he healthy, does it effect his energy levels?

Flickersy · 26/01/2024 19:35

Don't drive yourself mad cooking multiple meals. If he's willing to actually starve himself you need to seek professional help from a doctor or therapist.

nameychangerrrrrr · 26/01/2024 19:33

YANBU

Its ridiculous you’re cooking more than one meal. My family member’s kid was like this and his mum pandered to it, cooking seperate dinners and asking friends to do the same when they went over. He now only eats beige food aged 16. Won’t touch fruit or veg. No he doesn’t have a bloody eating disorder he’s just been allowed to get away with murder!

Make a meal, put some rice or bread on the table with it, and let the kids help themselves. Tell DS “you don’t have to eat it”. It’s up to him then.