Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this poo situation is just ridiculous now?

219 replies

Alittlebitwary · 26/01/2024 18:19

Posting here for traffic to see if anyone else has any experience of the same, as I'm at the end of my tether with this and literally don't know what else I can do.

My 4yo just will do anything to avoid doing a poo.
Potty training was fine, this started sometime between age 2 and 3. She holds it to the point it starts to come out, so gets poo in her knickers, but won't go to the toilet. She will cross her legs, crouch on the floor, and though clearly desperately holding it in she flatly denies needing a poo.
We sit her on the toilet and she screams her head off saying she doesn't need one, despite the repeated pooey knickers. She'll then go off and play, then repeat. More pooey knickers and toilet refusal. I'm absolutely sick to death of it now.

We've tried everything.
Poo apps recommended by HV.
Ignoring and letting her lead (she then holds so long - days - that it's eventually painful when she finally does do one then is even more avoidant).
Forcing her to the loo (she refuses)
putting games and toys in the loo to keep her there / make it relaxed (she just plays and no poo comes out)
Positive reinforcement, sticker charts, rewards. Huge praise for every poo.
Also tried not making a fuss so she didn't stop doing it just because she wasn't getting a fuss.
Increased fluids and fruit.
We make doing a poo part of bedtime routine and sit her on the toilet every night before bed.
We often have to spend 15 mins making her laugh to get her to relax enough to poo.
She ALWAYS denies needing to go, even while she's doing one!
However, occasionally she takes herself off to do one, and gets on with it no problem. I have no idea why sometimes she can and sometimes she can't.

We saw GP when she was 2 or 3 and she's been on laxido daily ever since and the poos are always soft now. It's possible she was constipated at one point and had a painful poo.

The thing is, we'll go round in circles having a period where she's going on her own no problem, every day with no issues!! and then suddenly there'll be another period where she is constantly holding and it's a constant battle to get her to be regular.

I am absolutely sick to death of the pooey knickers and her little sister is starting to copy this behaviour and I just can't!

She's at school now and comes home with poo knickers on the regular and she gets a sore bum.

Help me Mumsnet!!

OP posts:
littlejlr · 27/01/2024 17:32

I havent read all the comments posted, but please take a look at a website called Eric. They are a charity and there will be lots of advice and tips on toileting issues with your child and what you can do to help and support them. You can also talk to school and ask for support from the school nurse team who can refer you.

Calliopespa · 27/01/2024 13:40

Yes I think a bit of ignoring is probably extremely helpful ( perhaps with a sneaky slop of lactulose or similar in some juice just to keep things slippery).
I think my cousin seems to have weathered it ok; he’s a fairly forceful character and probably having his own Achilles Heel has not been the worst thing in terms of promoting some understanding of other’s frailties. He takes it in good humour but I can still see that aporoach was a gamble, and it could have been very damaging.

Waitingfordoggo · 27/01/2024 12:58

It’s been interesting for me personally to read the references to ASC and ADHD.

As detailed in previous posts, I had this same experience in childhood with bowel issues. As an adult, I have long suspected I am not completely NT and am now awaiting assessment for ADHD. Never would have occurred to me that there could be a link between the two.

Willyoujustbequiet · 27/01/2024 12:50

Calliopespa · 27/01/2024 09:45

I actually think there have been lots of comments about that. I’m not disagreeing that it could be behaviour fitting those profiles; but I also think it’s a “ thing” in itself. It is likely sensory in nature in the sense that it involves physical sensations and visual aspects and smell aspects that probably play a part. But I’m pretty sure it can exist as “thing” without a corollary diagnosis and that some children can have an issue with it but not display other behaviours warranting a diagnosis.

Edited

Yes, absolutely a thing in itself.

I just wanted the OP to possibly bear it in mind as it was our route to diagnosis when there were no other issues apparent.

Waitingfordoggo · 27/01/2024 11:15

And to add- yes, I’m sure your aunt and uncle and my mum were doing their best. They weren’t deliberately cruel but were likely following the advice of the time from health care professionals who clearly at that time didn’t know the best way to approach the problem.

I think the suggestion people have made about ignoring it for a period of time seems like a really good one. As a child, I hated the fact that every single day involved discussion about poo and bowels. Constant questions: ‘have you been?’ ‘Do you need to go?’ ‘Can you sit on the loo for ten minutes now please?’ It all just repeatedly highlighted the fact that I wasn’t normal and wasn’t like other children. Perhaps if everyone had relaxed about it a bit, it might have taken the pressure off and helped the problem resolve more quickly. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Waitingfordoggo · 27/01/2024 11:11

Thank you @Calliopespa for your kind post. Yes, the whole episode did cause some significant psychological damage which persists in some ways into adulthood. Some years ago while having counselling, the topic came up. It’s certainly had an impact on some of my behaviour. Talking about it all 40 years on is still embarrassing and difficult, even though I would have lots of sympathy for a child going through it now and would know they were not deliberately trying to be difficult. But it is hard to find that same sympathy for myself as a child- because the sense of shame is so firmly wedded to the whole thing. I know it wasn’t my fault but still sort of think it was, if that makes sense.

I read with interest your post about your cousin and a lot of it resonated with me! It was a very 80s approach to the problem that your aunt and uncle had, and my mum too! (My dad managed to stay out of most of it as he was at work so much of the time and otherwise I think just let my mum deal with it because she was a primary teacher and he probably thought she was better equipped to sort it out).

I hope your cousin hasn’t been left with any lasting MH impacts. By the sounds of it, he doesn’t mind the teasing, which is good. I would be mortified if anyone brought my issues up in conversation now- even if it was meant with kindness and humour. It might be that your cousin is more resilient than me!

Thank you again for your kind words.

Calliopespa · 27/01/2024 09:45

Willyoujustbequiet · 27/01/2024 02:06

I'm surprised there aren't more comments about sensory processing disorder/interoception disorder/ADHD etc... its not an uncommon problem to have toileting issues with them.

It may be worth considering OT input. They were amazing with us and started the diagnosis ball rolling.

Edited

I actually think there have been lots of comments about that. I’m not disagreeing that it could be behaviour fitting those profiles; but I also think it’s a “ thing” in itself. It is likely sensory in nature in the sense that it involves physical sensations and visual aspects and smell aspects that probably play a part. But I’m pretty sure it can exist as “thing” without a corollary diagnosis and that some children can have an issue with it but not display other behaviours warranting a diagnosis.

Calliopespa · 27/01/2024 09:34

Waitingfordoggo · 26/01/2024 20:37

I had this issue as a child. That was the early-mid 80s and I have to say I don’t think it was handled well by the GPs and consultants I saw at the time. I ended up in hospital for a week at one point under observation and taking daily medicines which I hated (no idea what they were). At the time (from potty training up to about age 6-7) I very much had the sense that this was my fault. That it was a behaviour I was choosing (this was the message I absorbed from overhearing conversations between my Mum and the consultant).

None of us understood it at the time but my take on it now as an adult and having read around the subject, is that the initial cause was probably physical- constipation most likely- resulting in a painful or difficult time going to the loo which then made me fearful and ashamed of having to go for a poo. The whole idea of it became completely taboo and disgusting. My memories of the time include a lot of shame, because unfortunately I was still having accidents for a time after starting school and although I had some lovely friends, there were obviously reactions from other classmates.

Actually shuddering writing that all out- it’s hard and embarrassing to talk about, but what I’m saying is that it seems to me that it often becomes a psychological issue which needs careful handling. I came out of that phase eventually- don’t know what the catalyst for that was, but even as an adult, I have issues with poo! Have a very slow and shy bowel so I have to be sure to get plenty of fibre and try to plan my ‘movements’ (which isn’t easy) because I can’t go anywhere other than my toilet at home!

I wish I could give some useful advice but just to say- as a parent myself, I can see how exasperating it is for parents and I look back and feel so sad for my Mum who was working full time and then trying to deal with my issues while also looking after her dying father who lived with us! It’s no wonder I witnessed her frustration at times, but it probably added to my sense of shame about it all. So just tread carefully, she will come through it. I second the suggestion to get in touch with ERIC- which they’d been around when I was a child! Also don’t be afraid to go back to the GP though- they can and do refer for psychological issues too, although I imagine waitlists are long. Best of luck 💐

That was kind of you to post that. It’s clearly been quite a traumatic issue for you and good of you to want to confront it to offer solidarity. If I can offer a tiny bit myself, I have also posted about my cousin who also had this in the mid 80’s and despite his parents really trying hard, in retrospect it was completely mishandled. The “ advice” was that it was a behavioural thing which meant my uncle got cross and thought it was a disciplining thing, my aunt would plead and thought it was a stubbornness thing, and the rest of us ( who witnessed a fair amount of the drama) lurched between shock and toilet-humour hilarity. He still gets teased by his siblings today if things like figgy pudding or prune are served . So I think you were not alone in it being clumsily handled. I also know my aunt and uncle were doing their ( misguided) best.

CrabbyCat · 27/01/2024 08:50

DS's continence issues aren't caused by withholding so I have no suggestions there. However, as well as Eric, Bowel and Bladder UK also have a helpline - and they actually have a separate team for pediatric issues. I also struggled with getting through with Eric, and I didn't find the online form and advice I got in response that helpful because there just wasn't enough space on it to put enough of the relevant details in. Bowel and bladder I called and left a voicemail and after about 5 days a pediatric continence nurse called me back, and spent something like 30 minutes talking things through with me. It was incredibly helpful.

If you are on Facebook, the group Movicol Mummies is UK based. Even if you don't want to post, searching for past posts on withholding would give you a lot of information from people who were in a similar position.

PigsEnigma · 27/01/2024 07:14

I have no advice buy I'm right here with you. I am lost. We've tried everything. Literally everything. ERIC, laxatives (which weren't necessary but GP said they were which caused 'cosmocol-gate' where she exploded poo everywhere for days and days even on only one sachet and got even more worried about going because she couldn't control it). We've spoken to everyone. She's not constipated. She just won't go on the toilet or potty. I could cry.

Jifmicroliquid · 27/01/2024 07:09

I’m going to admit something weird here, that I’ve since found out is quite normal.
Around the same age, I got a weird thrill out of stopping myself going. So I’d need to go and I’d feel it moving and I’d crouch and sort of stick my heel in my bum. I liked the sensation of stopping it and being able to control it and I’d put off going, not for any real reason, but because I preferred the feeling of stopping it. It felt weirdly good.
I was fortunate to never soil my pants, but looking back it was a big deal for me. My mum would ask if I needed the toilet and I would say no.
I eventually grew out of it.

Look up Freuds anal stage. It was only when I learnt about this that I realised that’s exactly what I was doing and the feelings I got were weirdly pleasurable.

user1471446089 · 27/01/2024 06:57

My son was exactly like this. We tried everything as you have but then eventually got a referral to the bladder and bowl team which was what made the difference. They suggested doing a full disempaction with high doses of Movicol for a period of about 2 weeks which we then gradually reduced. We made a big thing of this with him and how it was going to help him poo on the toilet like a big boy now and we didn't have any accidents at all from the very first day. He had been completely backed up and it had been going on for so long that he had lost bowel control. After a few weeks we continued with lower doses of Movicol but wereprescribed pico sulfate alongside to help him understand his blowel impulses. He was able to come off all medicated about 9 months after we first started this process and he has never had a single issue since. This felt like a miracle to us after so long with him having accident after accident. I'd definitely push for a referral with your gp as the waiting list could be long.

Wowjustwow99 · 27/01/2024 06:47

Hello,

I feel you paint we had the same issue with my daughter who has grown out of it.

GP and heath visitor was rubbish basically blamed me for a poor diet. Kept food diaries and her diet was better than average (gps words)

I second blowing bubbles or blowing up balloons on the potty/toilet.

Definitely have a chat with this two charities I found both helpful and supportive

https://eric.org.uk/childrens-bowels

https://www.bbuk.org.uk/

Child holding tummy

Children’s bowels - ERIC

Find out what a healthy bowel and normal poo look like. We guide you through common children's bowel problems such as constipation and soiling, and how to identify and treat them.

https://eric.org.uk/childrens-bowels

CoconutSty · 27/01/2024 06:16

I could have written every word of your post OP! DS is 5 and I'm at my wits' end with this. School are also on my back about it saying it's not normal and they don't have the resources to clean him up when he has accidents there. Just want to cry and scream and hide in a hole.

sashh · 27/01/2024 03:58

I had terrible constipation as a child.

Has she got a step so her feet are on something solid? Much easier to go when your feet are slightly higher.

Also try gently pushing her hips together.

Nofilteritwonthelp · 27/01/2024 03:33

Willyoujustbequiet · 27/01/2024 02:06

I'm surprised there aren't more comments about sensory processing disorder/interoception disorder/ADHD etc... its not an uncommon problem to have toileting issues with them.

It may be worth considering OT input. They were amazing with us and started the diagnosis ball rolling.

Edited

Ffs not everyone has ADHD! Clearly by all these comments poo anxiety is a thing

Willyoujustbequiet · 27/01/2024 02:06

I'm surprised there aren't more comments about sensory processing disorder/interoception disorder/ADHD etc... its not an uncommon problem to have toileting issues with them.

It may be worth considering OT input. They were amazing with us and started the diagnosis ball rolling.

Orangebadger · 27/01/2024 00:18

@TheFormidableMrsC really interesting video, never heard of interoception before

Stompythedinosaur · 27/01/2024 00:17

I really, really suggest you need to take a "holiday" from the stress of this. Your dd likely can't change, so you need to make the shift in how you are seeing things.

So, buy plenty of cheap pants, have an easy place in the bathroom to put pooey things (e.g. lidded bucket) and accept you will, for the foreseeable future, be doing a wash of pooey stuff each day. It's the dissonance between your thoughts about "I shouldn't have to be doing this" and the reality that makes it feel worse.

Your dd is going to need a good period with absolutely no stress about pooing to start her feelings. You need time together when you aren't fighting about going to the toilet to feel like you are on the same page supporting her to deal with a medical problem.

I think you have to be realistic about a 4yo's capacity to choose to do something willingly that they associate with pain and discomfort. It's a lot to ask if a child of that age. It's absolutely understandable that kids withhold poo when they have had a previous bad experience.

Waitingfordoggo · 26/01/2024 23:24

TrixieFatell · 26/01/2024 23:10

I can't believe people are suggesting you get her to clean her knickers, shaming is not a great parenting tactic.

Agreed. Having been the child in this scenario, I would warn that shame can have long-lasting impacts on the developing mind, which can manifest in surprising ways in adulthood.

And while withholding might be a ‘choice’ of sorts, the subsequent soiling is not. The soiling occurs because the child has got used to ignoring or avoiding the urge to go, so they become desensitised from signals from the bowel that they need to go. Making the child wash the pants or shaming them for the soiling is wrong- they actually can’t help it.

yaya83 · 26/01/2024 23:11

I’m in Ireland but @ pooandtheloo on Instagram is a bowel nurse in a children’s hospital here. She gives loads of advice for free on her page but you can also book in for a 1:1 to make a personalised plan for your daughter. Her free tips have helped us hugely and we’ve just had our first successful week of poos on the toilet, no bother. Can’t get over how many children seem to have this issue though?

TrixieFatell · 26/01/2024 23:10

I can't believe people are suggesting you get her to clean her knickers, shaming is not a great parenting tactic.

littleburn · 26/01/2024 23:03

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Sorry, wrong thread! I've reported it.

littleburn · 26/01/2024 23:02

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Hillsmakeyoustrong · 26/01/2024 22:54

If you think it could be a control issue, as it was with my DD, is there any part of her day to day where you could give her more perceived or real control to refocus that (very human) need? What we put into us and when we let things out is the control we have as children. I would say to DD what do you want to wear today x or y, what snack x,y or z, what shall we have for tea x or y, etc. You may already do this, as did I to a degree, but I found ways to increase her contributions and it worked. She is still a very strong minded girl and I'm really happy that she is! Very annoying at times but reassuring as well! Finally, if your DD is going regularly and is not constipated, and there is a chance there are sensory needs, would making her poo softer somewhat diminish the sensation and actually be unhelpful would be something I'd consider.

Swipe left for the next trending thread