Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you work or are a SAHP..

832 replies

DontBeTight · 26/01/2024 15:58

Just that really, those of you who have children under school age. Do you work, or do you stay at home? Or work part time? My youngest won't start school until 2026 so I'm considering giving up work and having the rest of the time full time at home with her as my income makes very little difference to the household.

Those who stay at home, do you enjoy it?

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 03/02/2024 16:40

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 16:29

I would never entertain a relationship with children and separate finances. To me, it's a contradiction in terms. It's also very limiting, possibly abusive, for women with children, in my view, even if they are the higher earner.

I would never entertain a relationship, with or without children if finances were expected to be combined.

I don't understand how it is limiting and potentially abusive when the woman is the higher earner?

Thepeopleversuswork · 03/02/2024 16:35

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 16:29

I would never entertain a relationship with children and separate finances. To me, it's a contradiction in terms. It's also very limiting, possibly abusive, for women with children, in my view, even if they are the higher earner.

Why is it limiting and potentially abusive to have separate finances if the woman is the higher earner? Surely for the higher earner, regardless of sex, combining finances is always risky?

I mean there are plenty of sound and noble reasons to do it but the person with more assets and money always has the most to lose surely?

The rationale for combining finances makes sense if one partner isn’t working but if both are generating income and there’s no wild disparity I can’t see the upside.

I would never combine finances.

0rangeCrush · 03/02/2024 16:30

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 16:29

I would never entertain a relationship with children and separate finances. To me, it's a contradiction in terms. It's also very limiting, possibly abusive, for women with children, in my view, even if they are the higher earner.

How would it be abusive to the woman if she was the higher earner?
If anything; there is potential to abuse of the lower earner; regardless of their gender.

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 16:29

I would never entertain a relationship with children and separate finances. To me, it's a contradiction in terms. It's also very limiting, possibly abusive, for women with children, in my view, even if they are the higher earner.

Whatdoy · 03/02/2024 16:28

5128gap · 03/02/2024 16:10

Genuinely...how? When I SAH I had less autonomy than at any point in my life. The 'work' was easy in that it didn't tax me mentally (which caused me to be very bored) but hard in that all my time was at the mercy of my DC demands. I have never been unfortunate enough to have a paid role where I didn't have at least some choice in what I did and when, to take breaks, to be on my own, or not, as I chose. How can anyone do whatever they want all the time while caring for children?

I can choose to go out or not, choose what time to get dressed or shower, when to eat, where to eat (I can go to the pub if I want or a nice cafe or whatever I fancy), I can meet up with friends wherever it suits me, go shopping or something. Go off on holiday tomorrow if I fancy it. I don’t have to live to anyone else’s timetable.

Obviously with kids they need to be fed and nap and bathed etc, but I always found that mine was pretty flexible with that stuff.

My job was one where you run your own diary, work flexi time, get toil, work from home or office etc so not a 9-5 at this desk situation, but there are statutory deadlines for things, millions of other professionals availability to work round, service user needs and availability etc, so there are constraints.

Thepeopleversuswork · 03/02/2024 16:27

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 15:15

I was joking @Thepeopleversuswork (well, mostly 😉). That stereotype is as daft as saying all SAHMs have to talk about is PlayDoh.

Both of the stereotypes are patronising and grossly misleading.

I have skin in the game as a working mum I guess but it does irritate me when work is presented as a kind of indulgence or a bit of “play acting” which women do though.

You get loads of comments about people “leaving their kids to climb the corporate ladder” as if we just dump our kids in childcare because we want to play at wearing shoulderpads or some such bollocks. When the majority of us do it to pay the bills.

Yeah it’s a sore point. But I find it insulting.

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/02/2024 16:23

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 16:12

@SouthLondonMum22 - that probably explains why you can't understand families with a SAHP. SAHP families have a totally different mentality and you're just not thinking as separate financial entities, regardless of who earns what.

Probably. It's also a big reason why I'd never be a SAHP myself or agree for DH to be one if he wanted to even though he's the lower earner.

Whatdoy · 03/02/2024 16:19

Thepeopleversuswork · 03/02/2024 14:46

I’ve stayed out of this thread because it’s degenerated into the predictable knee jerk slanging match and I find them exhausting and counterproductive.

And for the record I do not believe staying at home with kids is boring or makes people stupid or dull.

But it does piss me off beyond belief when people characterise all jobs as being playgrounds for anal corporate bores and all people who have jobs as tiresome solipsistic automatons.

You do realise, right, that the vast majority of people who work don’t work in corporate offices and spout corporate jargon? Particularly the female workers, a large number of whom work in the NHS, teaching, academia or caring professions? There’s a vast panoply of jobs people can do in a vast range of industries.

I do think people owe it to SAHMs not to stereotype them as brainless but it cuts both ways. Just because you work doesn’t mean you can’t be normal or speak English and please stop with the reductive stereotypes about people who work too.

I’m not sure one can be a ‘solipsistic automaton’, I’d have thought that was a contradiction in terms.

@SouthLondonMum22 this is what I meant by individual perception of risk.

I look at a car, I know statistically it’s a very dangerous way to travel, so I mitigate that risk in a way that feels proportional to me- I wear a seatbelt, I don’t speed or use a phone or smoke while I’m driving. However I don’t go as far as not driving at all, and walking when I don’t want to, because it would be massively inconvenient to me and I feel it would be disproportionate.

Work is the same. Not working carries risks, so I mitigate those by having private pensions, my own home I can’t be turfed out of, savings, life insurance and critically by choosing my partner very carefully- but I don’t go as far as working when I don’t want to because it would be massively inconvenient to me and I feel it would be disproportionate.

You have 1 job (as far as I can tell), you feel this is a necessary safeguard against adversity if you get divorced. Fair enough. But your perception of that risk doesn’t go as far as “what if my bloke fucks off and I get sacked as well? I’d better get a second job in case those two very possible events occur”.

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 16:12

@SouthLondonMum22 - that probably explains why you can't understand families with a SAHP. SAHP families have a totally different mentality and you're just not thinking as separate financial entities, regardless of who earns what.

5128gap · 03/02/2024 16:10

Whatdoy · 02/02/2024 22:05

I love it! I can do whatever I want all the time.

Genuinely...how? When I SAH I had less autonomy than at any point in my life. The 'work' was easy in that it didn't tax me mentally (which caused me to be very bored) but hard in that all my time was at the mercy of my DC demands. I have never been unfortunate enough to have a paid role where I didn't have at least some choice in what I did and when, to take breaks, to be on my own, or not, as I chose. How can anyone do whatever they want all the time while caring for children?

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/02/2024 16:09

Needmorelego · 03/02/2024 15:51

@SouthLondonMum22 the thing is for the sake of my mental health I had to leave my job and put my trust in my husband (then partner) to take care of me mentally and financially.
Being "protected" through a job will only protect you if the job isn't making your life miserable.
The whole "must be independent, must have own money" etc thing doesn't work for everyone.
If that makes sense ....

I can understand that.

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/02/2024 16:07

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 15:57

As your lives grow together @SouthLondonMum22, you'll be less reliant on income regardless. You'll have joint assets etc that are more significant than who earns what. You will build up a certain lifestyle together and that becomes self-perpetuating. (Unless you are one of those couples who have totally separate finances and that kind of thing)?

Our only joint asset is our house. Bank accounts etc are separate.

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 15:57

As your lives grow together @SouthLondonMum22, you'll be less reliant on income regardless. You'll have joint assets etc that are more significant than who earns what. You will build up a certain lifestyle together and that becomes self-perpetuating. (Unless you are one of those couples who have totally separate finances and that kind of thing)?

Needmorelego · 03/02/2024 15:51

@SouthLondonMum22 the thing is for the sake of my mental health I had to leave my job and put my trust in my husband (then partner) to take care of me mentally and financially.
Being "protected" through a job will only protect you if the job isn't making your life miserable.
The whole "must be independent, must have own money" etc thing doesn't work for everyone.
If that makes sense ....

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/02/2024 15:45

Needmorelego · 03/02/2024 13:11

You can't really live your life in constant fear of something happening to your spouse (death, serious illness, unexpected disability) or that your spouse might leave you.
Marriage is about combining two lives and for that you must have trust. If you are marrying someone you have to have that trust otherwise what's the point?
People who feel they "must" work because of "what if...." - it must be a fairly stressful life to be worrying about that all the time.

Edited

It isn't a constant fear or constant stress. It's a relief that should the worse happen, I'll be fine financially because I'm not solely relying on someone else.

It's just like always wearing a seatbelt in the car, I'm not constantly worrying about the car crashing but should something go wrong, I'm protected.

Whatdoy · 03/02/2024 15:44

Needmorelego · 03/02/2024 14:37

@indigoskies 😂
Most jobs are really only interesting to others who do those jobs.
Even a spouse won't find it that exciting.
Although my husband's job had a visit from a sausage dog yesterday and I admit I enjoyed seeing all 3 gazillion photos of the dog.

This is true. I am interested in my wife’s work but that’s because she’s in the same field as me- so I get to do the interesting discussions without having to do the annoying actual work bit. She is doing a postgrad/post qualification course type thing at the moment so I’m enjoying doing research and reading for her… it would not be so interesting to me if she worked in admin or accounting or something.

Needmorelego · 03/02/2024 15:42

@indigoskiesI miss playing with Playdoh.
I think we still have some but whether it's still usable 🤔
My favourite was the hairdresser set with the spinning seat and then you cut their "hair".
Hours of fun.
Playdoh was originally a made as a wall cleaner don't you know 😂😂😂

Rubyupbeat · 03/02/2024 15:20

I stayed at home with mine, wouldn't have done anything else. Made lots of friends and studied for a degree, then a masters, then a doctorate.

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 15:15

I was joking @Thepeopleversuswork (well, mostly 😉). That stereotype is as daft as saying all SAHMs have to talk about is PlayDoh.

Ouchmyarse · 03/02/2024 14:50

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 14:32

'relationship with DP is better as we have our own things to talk about instead of it just being ‘I played with the kids all day'

I know. In any normal respectable home there should be real, proper things to talk about like -

...reached out to Mike and Sue to suggest deep-dive into core competencies. Drilled down on deliverables, keen to move the needle. Brief segueway into strategies to break down silos. Just running ideas up the flagpole - Mike said let's circle back on that when he has bandwidth to pivot and identify low hanging fruit. Sue said it's above her pay grade. I said, ‘take it offline, put a pin in it and run the numbers.’ Game changer. Hard stop at 1pm for Pret A Manger. '

So much more fascinating than Tumble Tots.

This is what I was talking about the other day.

Me and dh have loads to chat about even though I don’t work. He doesn’t discuss work at home (unless he’s pissed off at someone and wants to vent).

I don’t sit and tell him about playing with the children.

We have loads of shared interests, we like to joke about the same daft stuff. We talk about what we would like to do to the house next and stuff like that, laugh at things on the internet together, talk about something we’ve read that day or heard on the radio.

The idea that you would have nothing to talk about because you didn’t go to work is crazy.

Thepeopleversuswork · 03/02/2024 14:46

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 14:32

'relationship with DP is better as we have our own things to talk about instead of it just being ‘I played with the kids all day'

I know. In any normal respectable home there should be real, proper things to talk about like -

...reached out to Mike and Sue to suggest deep-dive into core competencies. Drilled down on deliverables, keen to move the needle. Brief segueway into strategies to break down silos. Just running ideas up the flagpole - Mike said let's circle back on that when he has bandwidth to pivot and identify low hanging fruit. Sue said it's above her pay grade. I said, ‘take it offline, put a pin in it and run the numbers.’ Game changer. Hard stop at 1pm for Pret A Manger. '

So much more fascinating than Tumble Tots.

I’ve stayed out of this thread because it’s degenerated into the predictable knee jerk slanging match and I find them exhausting and counterproductive.

And for the record I do not believe staying at home with kids is boring or makes people stupid or dull.

But it does piss me off beyond belief when people characterise all jobs as being playgrounds for anal corporate bores and all people who have jobs as tiresome solipsistic automatons.

You do realise, right, that the vast majority of people who work don’t work in corporate offices and spout corporate jargon? Particularly the female workers, a large number of whom work in the NHS, teaching, academia or caring professions? There’s a vast panoply of jobs people can do in a vast range of industries.

I do think people owe it to SAHMs not to stereotype them as brainless but it cuts both ways. Just because you work doesn’t mean you can’t be normal or speak English and please stop with the reductive stereotypes about people who work too.

Needmorelego · 03/02/2024 14:37

@indigoskies 😂
Most jobs are really only interesting to others who do those jobs.
Even a spouse won't find it that exciting.
Although my husband's job had a visit from a sausage dog yesterday and I admit I enjoyed seeing all 3 gazillion photos of the dog.

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 14:32

'relationship with DP is better as we have our own things to talk about instead of it just being ‘I played with the kids all day'

I know. In any normal respectable home there should be real, proper things to talk about like -

...reached out to Mike and Sue to suggest deep-dive into core competencies. Drilled down on deliverables, keen to move the needle. Brief segueway into strategies to break down silos. Just running ideas up the flagpole - Mike said let's circle back on that when he has bandwidth to pivot and identify low hanging fruit. Sue said it's above her pay grade. I said, ‘take it offline, put a pin in it and run the numbers.’ Game changer. Hard stop at 1pm for Pret A Manger. '

So much more fascinating than Tumble Tots.

Flamme · 03/02/2024 14:15

When I had DC1, I was convinced no-one else could possibly look after him and I was going to be a SAHM throughout his childhood. However, I disliked being dependent on DH financially and was bored, so I took on a couple of part time jobs that I coulf fit around the baby and DH's working hours.

Despite eing besotted with DC1, as time went on I felt sort of diminished as opposed to being DH's equal. He was going out doing interesting work, and was very busy. It made sense for me to take responsibility for most of the housework, though it never came particularly naturally to me, and DH was also delegating all the home admin around paying bills, organising repair jobs etc, and he was getting into a nice comfortable habit of issuing instructions and leaving all these things to me. It made sense, but it made me feel as if I was the housekeeper/maidservant.

Ultimately for financial reasons it became unsustainable anyway and I had to go back to work part time. Initially I applied for a clerical job in a local hospital because I reckoned I wanted regular hours and it offered a creche. They were interested but took so long to go through the interview and recruitment process that I started looking for jobs in my former profession, and secured an offer that was much better paid, so I went for that. I've stayed in that profession through two more pregnancies and, though it's been pretty stressful and childminding was often a major juggling job, I didn't regret it. Instantly I felt that I was myself again, my self-respect returned and I felt more fulfilled.

I don't imagine it would be the same for everyone but I suppose the lesson is that no-one should assume the grass is greener as a SAHP. For OP, it seems to me that it would make much more sense to take a little time to build on her qualifications so that she can move to a job she enjoys and that is properly rewarded, and maybe consider doing that on a part time basis.

Fliopen · 03/02/2024 14:00

When my mum left my Dad she was left in the shit financially even though she had a good job. One of my family friends has just divorced his wife who has been a SAHM for 15 years and she got the house in the settlement (mortgage free) plus something like 2.5k a month in spousal maintenance, plus child maintenance, plus some of his pension. She was WAY better off financially than my mum with a career was.

Swipe left for the next trending thread