Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you work or are a SAHP..

832 replies

DontBeTight · 26/01/2024 15:58

Just that really, those of you who have children under school age. Do you work, or do you stay at home? Or work part time? My youngest won't start school until 2026 so I'm considering giving up work and having the rest of the time full time at home with her as my income makes very little difference to the household.

Those who stay at home, do you enjoy it?

OP posts:
Whatdoy · 03/02/2024 18:50

LorlieS · 03/02/2024 17:25

@BreeBacon The big difference is I still work and could always push up my hours if the shit hit the fan.
Which is exactly what I did when I left my first husband.
That's not the same for ft SAHMs.

How can you work more hours as a ta? The hours are dictated by the length of the school day.

Whatdoy · 03/02/2024 18:35

5128gap · 03/02/2024 17:59

You're very fortunate in the flexibility your DC allowed you. There is no way I could have chosen when to get up, it was when the DC did, and showers had to be taken before that, or in a tiny window where I hoped they would be happy playing independently. Pubs and cafes with DC did not make for relaxing lunches, and everyone I'd want to meet up with was at work anyway. Being able to go on holiday when you like is great, but stops at school age. I find your perspective interesting, as its so different from my experience and I've always wondered how long term SAHMs cope with the lack of freedom. I guess it's about perception.

My son is home educated, so we aren’t tied to school timetables.

I took him in the shower with me from birth and added a box of toys too when he got bigger, and I obviously had to get up if he left the bedroom but I didn’t have to be up and dressed up, I could lie down in the playroom while he pottered around (I suddenly became disabled overnight more or less when he was 9 months so I had to learn to adapt everything to my reduced mobility)

It wasn’t always relaxing when he was small- he once managed to knock a whole table over on the balcony of a weatherspoons, sending 2 all day breakfasts over the balcony railing onto the people below 😬, all the usual SEN toddler stuff, but given space and quiet he will amuse himself for hours.

I want to read my book? Take him to the park and he will run laps for 45 minutes, eat an ice cream and do it again! And now he is 10 he is actually really good company, we enjoy doing all sorts together.

I had loads of sah parent friends for the first 6/7 years too.

My line of work really isn’t relaxing either so I’d rather be stressed on my own schedule!

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/02/2024 18:16

Ouchmyarse · 03/02/2024 18:02

I’ve had friends who have had a hard time in marriages/relationships due to finances, a couple of friends in the past who didn’t have shared finances and were left with nothing paying half the bills while their partners/husbands had lots of money.

I married someone with a similar outlook to me. We both came from families where finances were pooled, both our mothers were at home until the youngest went to school, both our mothers were the ones who dealt with the family finances regardless of if they worked or not. Our fathers were both very hands on with housework.

We discussed before we lived together what we would do with finances and we both agreed on what we wanted k it lives to look like (everything shared, I wanted to be at home with the children, dh didn’t expect me to take on all the housework etc).

People need to be clear what they want out of a relationship. If that doesn’t match up, well, they aren’t the person you should build a life and family with.

Ultimately, if you don't agree on big things such as finances then there will be issues no matter if they are shared or not. We've never had any issues with finances because we have a similar mindset when it comes to that.

I grew up with a SAHM and knew that wasn't what I wanted from as long as I could remember so met and married someone who was happy for both of us to continue working FT after DC.

Like you said, people need to be clear and there needs to be a lot of good communication.

Ouchmyarse · 03/02/2024 18:04

Dh would obviously been happy if I wanted to work too - he didn’t insist I stay at home as his mum did. He just wants me to be happy. If I wanted to go and find a job tomorrow, he would support me and we’d make childcare work together.

He would also have loved to have been the parent who stayed at home. But he’s the one with the fabulous education and earning potential.

Ouchmyarse · 03/02/2024 18:02

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/02/2024 17:48

Well, exactly.

Wanting to marry someone with the same or a similar mentality doesn't make someone abusive just because it wouldn't be what you didn't envisage or want.

DH is exactly who I want as a husband and as a father or I wouldn't have married him or had DC with him.

Edited

I’ve had friends who have had a hard time in marriages/relationships due to finances, a couple of friends in the past who didn’t have shared finances and were left with nothing paying half the bills while their partners/husbands had lots of money.

I married someone with a similar outlook to me. We both came from families where finances were pooled, both our mothers were at home until the youngest went to school, both our mothers were the ones who dealt with the family finances regardless of if they worked or not. Our fathers were both very hands on with housework.

We discussed before we lived together what we would do with finances and we both agreed on what we wanted k it lives to look like (everything shared, I wanted to be at home with the children, dh didn’t expect me to take on all the housework etc).

People need to be clear what they want out of a relationship. If that doesn’t match up, well, they aren’t the person you should build a life and family with.

5128gap · 03/02/2024 17:59

Whatdoy · 03/02/2024 16:28

I can choose to go out or not, choose what time to get dressed or shower, when to eat, where to eat (I can go to the pub if I want or a nice cafe or whatever I fancy), I can meet up with friends wherever it suits me, go shopping or something. Go off on holiday tomorrow if I fancy it. I don’t have to live to anyone else’s timetable.

Obviously with kids they need to be fed and nap and bathed etc, but I always found that mine was pretty flexible with that stuff.

My job was one where you run your own diary, work flexi time, get toil, work from home or office etc so not a 9-5 at this desk situation, but there are statutory deadlines for things, millions of other professionals availability to work round, service user needs and availability etc, so there are constraints.

You're very fortunate in the flexibility your DC allowed you. There is no way I could have chosen when to get up, it was when the DC did, and showers had to be taken before that, or in a tiny window where I hoped they would be happy playing independently. Pubs and cafes with DC did not make for relaxing lunches, and everyone I'd want to meet up with was at work anyway. Being able to go on holiday when you like is great, but stops at school age. I find your perspective interesting, as its so different from my experience and I've always wondered how long term SAHMs cope with the lack of freedom. I guess it's about perception.

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/02/2024 17:48

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 17:44

I wouldn't have married a man who expected me to put my kids with a nanny. Because that is not what I ever envisaged or wanted.

Well, exactly.

Wanting to marry someone with the same or a similar mentality doesn't make someone abusive just because it wouldn't be what you didn't envisage or want.

DH is exactly who I want as a husband and as a father or I wouldn't have married him or had DC with him.

0rangeCrush · 03/02/2024 17:46

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 17:44

I wouldn't have married a man who expected me to put my kids with a nanny. Because that is not what I ever envisaged or wanted.

Who said the kids go to a nanny? You are just making stuff up now.

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 17:44

I wouldn't have married a man who expected me to put my kids with a nanny. Because that is not what I ever envisaged or wanted.

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/02/2024 17:36

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 17:29

"All of that is possible with separate finances."

A man who wants separate finances is far less likely to support his wife if she wants or needs to be with her baby for any period beyond the minimum. He would expect her to fund herself and feel no responsibility. This kind of man is not interested in 'equality' or feminism, he's a misogynist b***rd.

But as you said before, it's simply a different mentality. My husband wouldn't have married me if I wanted to be a SAHM, just as I wouldn't have married him if he wanted to be a SAHP.

We both expect each other to contribute financially if we are able to. Obviously illness, disability etc would be different.

0rangeCrush · 03/02/2024 17:36

Ah, shared paternal leave and men going part time/becoming SAHD’s and allowing their partners to continue their careers rather than throwing it all away. Such misogynistic bastards.

0rangeCrush · 03/02/2024 17:34

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 17:29

"All of that is possible with separate finances."

A man who wants separate finances is far less likely to support his wife if she wants or needs to be with her baby for any period beyond the minimum. He would expect her to fund herself and feel no responsibility. This kind of man is not interested in 'equality' or feminism, he's a misogynist b***rd.

We are talking about men who are low earners here, not men who are high earners. It’s obviously unrealistic that the woman takes extended time off if she is the higher earner. I took 8 months off and then transferred my leave to my partner. In these instances; the man would be the one to cut his hours or take time off with the baby/child. Common sense.

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 17:29

"All of that is possible with separate finances."

A man who wants separate finances is far less likely to support his wife if she wants or needs to be with her baby for any period beyond the minimum. He would expect her to fund herself and feel no responsibility. This kind of man is not interested in 'equality' or feminism, he's a misogynist b***rd.

LorlieS · 03/02/2024 17:25

@BreeBacon The big difference is I still work and could always push up my hours if the shit hit the fan.
Which is exactly what I did when I left my first husband.
That's not the same for ft SAHMs.

0rangeCrush · 03/02/2024 17:23

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/02/2024 17:21

pp seems to be assuming that it's always the man who doesn't want to pool finances and it is the least he can do because it is the woman who gets pregnant and gives birth. Apparently not doing so is abusive in her opinion.

Which makes no sense if the woman doesn't want to pool finances anyway and it's a mutual decision.

Ah yes, big powerful men and little weak ladies.

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/02/2024 17:21

0rangeCrush · 03/02/2024 17:10

But how is the woman prone to being abused? The lower earner is always the partner more susceptible to financial abuse in relationships where the money isn’t pooled. That is usually the female; but not exclusively.

And let’s not pretend that the majority of parents who are trapped with a partner they no longer want to be with are the SAH parent or the lower earner. Usually the female; but only because of gender pay disparity and sexist attitudes where SAHD’s are viewed as “feminine” or “wimpy” (thus making it harder for them to seek help against abuse than for women to seek help)

pp seems to be assuming that it's always the man who doesn't want to pool finances and it is the least he can do because it is the woman who gets pregnant and gives birth. Apparently not doing so is abusive in her opinion.

Which makes no sense if the woman doesn't want to pool finances anyway and it's a mutual decision.

Winnipeggy · 03/02/2024 17:19

I'm a SAHM and love it, don't get me wrong it can be hard and exhausting but I love spending this time with her and I have good support which I think is vital. If I was on my own with no extended family it would be extremely difficult. But my DD is 2 and I can't believe I only have 2 more years with her before she starts school. It really does feel like a magical time right now and if I was working it would literally make no difference to our income with nursery fees so entirely pointless.

0rangeCrush · 03/02/2024 17:14

And for the record we have completely pooled resources despite me being the higher earner. I’d be far better off financially if we didn’t pool our resources, so this isn’t a personal thing to me. I just don’t see how the main earner can ever really be vulnerable to financial abuse; and IMO the best way a high earner can protect themselves from abuse is by not pooling finances.

If my relationship began to deteriorate the first thing I’d do was uncouple our finances, which would impact my financial position positively and his negatively.

0rangeCrush · 03/02/2024 17:10

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 16:58

If I was a higher earner, I wouldn't be giving him 'pocket money' no, because that is disrespectful and demeaning. If you have a child, to me, that's is the priority for both of you. Obey dnd above d trying else. It's doesn't matter who earns what and who works more or less or who is a SAHP. You are a unit, an equal partnership, and both focused on the child's best interests. You decide what's best for them and organise according to that.

But how is the woman prone to being abused? The lower earner is always the partner more susceptible to financial abuse in relationships where the money isn’t pooled. That is usually the female; but not exclusively.

And let’s not pretend that the majority of parents who are trapped with a partner they no longer want to be with are the SAH parent or the lower earner. Usually the female; but only because of gender pay disparity and sexist attitudes where SAHD’s are viewed as “feminine” or “wimpy” (thus making it harder for them to seek help against abuse than for women to seek help)

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/02/2024 17:06

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 16:58

If I was a higher earner, I wouldn't be giving him 'pocket money' no, because that is disrespectful and demeaning. If you have a child, to me, that's is the priority for both of you. Obey dnd above d trying else. It's doesn't matter who earns what and who works more or less or who is a SAHP. You are a unit, an equal partnership, and both focused on the child's best interests. You decide what's best for them and organise according to that.

All of that is possible with separate finances.

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 16:58

If I was a higher earner, I wouldn't be giving him 'pocket money' no, because that is disrespectful and demeaning. If you have a child, to me, that's is the priority for both of you. Obey dnd above d trying else. It's doesn't matter who earns what and who works more or less or who is a SAHP. You are a unit, an equal partnership, and both focused on the child's best interests. You decide what's best for them and organise according to that.

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/02/2024 16:54

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 16:46

It's abusive, in my view, because how dare any man expect a woman to carry and give birth to a child if he's not even prepared to share finances with her?

Women bear the risk and the brunt of having children, physically and emotionally. You never know what can happen - I know women who had gestational diabetics, PND and worse than this. If you are sharing you DNA with someone, but not your bank accounts - what's that about? I would not compromise on that, ever, and I wouldn't entertain a man who wanted separate money. I could not respect that and I wouldn't trust him.

Why are you acting like it is the mans choice and the woman is just going along with it? My husband could be as prepared to share finances with me as he likes but it wouldn't be happening because I'd never agree to it.

0rangeCrush · 03/02/2024 16:51

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 16:46

It's abusive, in my view, because how dare any man expect a woman to carry and give birth to a child if he's not even prepared to share finances with her?

Women bear the risk and the brunt of having children, physically and emotionally. You never know what can happen - I know women who had gestational diabetics, PND and worse than this. If you are sharing you DNA with someone, but not your bank accounts - what's that about? I would not compromise on that, ever, and I wouldn't entertain a man who wanted separate money. I could not respect that and I wouldn't trust him.

Also, I don’t share any DNA with my partner. That’s just … odd.

0rangeCrush · 03/02/2024 16:50

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 16:46

It's abusive, in my view, because how dare any man expect a woman to carry and give birth to a child if he's not even prepared to share finances with her?

Women bear the risk and the brunt of having children, physically and emotionally. You never know what can happen - I know women who had gestational diabetics, PND and worse than this. If you are sharing you DNA with someone, but not your bank accounts - what's that about? I would not compromise on that, ever, and I wouldn't entertain a man who wanted separate money. I could not respect that and I wouldn't trust him.

Right; but what if the woman is the one putting £3.5k per month (or more) into the account, whilst the man contributes nothing? How is the woman being abused? She’s free to spend whatever she likes, and can give the man whatever “pocket money” she feels like providing him with.

indigoskies · 03/02/2024 16:46

It's abusive, in my view, because how dare any man expect a woman to carry and give birth to a child if he's not even prepared to share finances with her?

Women bear the risk and the brunt of having children, physically and emotionally. You never know what can happen - I know women who had gestational diabetics, PND and worse than this. If you are sharing you DNA with someone, but not your bank accounts - what's that about? I would not compromise on that, ever, and I wouldn't entertain a man who wanted separate money. I could not respect that and I wouldn't trust him.