Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give DD a boy's name to appease DH gender disappointment?

320 replies

Afrikaaner · 26/01/2024 14:09

I have posted somewhere else, but I don't know how to delete posts on MN. I feel like this is the most appropriate sub.

I have 3 girls and I am pregnant with the last who is also a girl. DH is very very disappointed, he doesn't want to mention her or the pregnancy. In his culture, having a boy is the most desirable; women who can't make babies are not seen as a real women ( his words, not mine).

A week ago, he suddently started telling me we should name her a boy's name. It would be the only way, according to him, to bond with his daughter. Not gender neutral, but male name. I said no, and since then , he won't talk to me. I feel guilty, and sad and I am thinking to go with his plan. I absolutely dislike his choices. Will I be unreasonable to find a male name I like and name her that?

OP posts:
Trulyme · 26/01/2024 15:43

ContinentalBreakfast · 26/01/2024 15:18

I had a friend who was given a boy's name as a middle name because her father was disappointed that the long-awaited child was female. It was not a good thing to do, and it was a constant reminder that she was less valued than her (arrived a few years later) brother. That is a damaging thing to do to a child.

Exactly this!

Not only will she be ridiculed and embarrassed by her classmates or teachers/parents/employees who accidentally misgender her but as this poster says it will be a constant reminder that her own dad didn’t want her, simply because she is a girl.

He may as well just name her ‘not wanted’

JamJar59 · 26/01/2024 15:40

It seems like MN always has a point of calling the husband a dick regardless of what he has done or whether he’s right or wrong. In this case though, I think your husband is out of line.

FlowerBarrow · 26/01/2024 15:39

Gender disappointment is a real thing and I’m pretty sure posters would have more sympathy if a woman was posting these feelings about herself.
He probably would benefit from counselling. I don’t imagine going along with any pretence that it’s a boy will help anyone.
Did he or you know he felt this way before trying for a 4th? You could have considered ivf with genetic testing. Or just not had another.

Munchyseeds2 · 26/01/2024 15:39

If you stay you are going to mess your kids up for ever
You can't educate stupid and giving the poor baby a male name will not make things better!

Outliers · 26/01/2024 15:38

I think it's understandable to be a bit disappointed. Most aspiring fathers naturally want to experience a father son bond, as well as a father daughter bond.

I'd say compromise on a gender neutral name, like Danny, or Sam

GingerIsBest · 26/01/2024 15:36

Go home. Your dd may well be sad to lose out on their father, but I can promise you that growing up with this misogynist, uninterested man in their lives will be 100x worse.

Get back to South Africa as quickly as you can. I'd go now, before this baby is born.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 26/01/2024 15:35

Afrikaaner · 26/01/2024 15:25

Thank you everyone. I don't want to damage her, or made her a target for bullying.
I feel guilty because he doesn't eat, spend his time drinking and doesn't talk to me or play with his girls.

My oldest (13yo) is picking up on it and I can tell she goes to great lengths ( such as lying) to get her attention. I feel like it's all my fault and even regret trying for a 4th. It is horrible I know.

No, I have no bank account. When I decided to leave S.Africa for him, he was charming. Very much open minded. All my children have S.African citizenship and I miss the times there. With my family, working, the weather. But if I leave, I am afraid my daughters will hate me for depriving them from a father.

Yes, I made poor choices and I am trying to fix it it as much as possible.

He is the one depriving them of a father.

Differentstarts · 26/01/2024 15:35

Why would you have 3 children with a person like this your poor kids

simonlebone · 26/01/2024 15:34

Frankie is both male and female.

Mnetcurious · 26/01/2024 15:33

WiddlinDiddlin · 26/01/2024 14:12

He won't talk to you, he believes you have any control over whether a baby is a boy or a girl (he needs a lesson in human reproduction, its HIS swimmers that determine X or Y chromosome, nothing to do with you at all!) - why are you still with this absolute arsehole?

This, absolutely. Your poor daughters.

badwolf82 · 26/01/2024 15:33

Afrikaaner · 26/01/2024 15:25

Thank you everyone. I don't want to damage her, or made her a target for bullying.
I feel guilty because he doesn't eat, spend his time drinking and doesn't talk to me or play with his girls.

My oldest (13yo) is picking up on it and I can tell she goes to great lengths ( such as lying) to get her attention. I feel like it's all my fault and even regret trying for a 4th. It is horrible I know.

No, I have no bank account. When I decided to leave S.Africa for him, he was charming. Very much open minded. All my children have S.African citizenship and I miss the times there. With my family, working, the weather. But if I leave, I am afraid my daughters will hate me for depriving them from a father.

Yes, I made poor choices and I am trying to fix it it as much as possible.

What country are you in? If in England or Wales you should know that coercive control
is a crime.

Read more here: https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/controlling-or-coercive-behaviour-intimate-or-family-relationship

Does this sound like your relationship? Have you been prevented from having a bank account, job, contact with loved ones etc?

Controlling or Coercive Behaviour in an Intimate or Family Relationship | The Crown Prosecution Service

https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/controlling-or-coercive-behaviour-intimate-or-family-relationship

Bex5490 · 26/01/2024 15:32

@Afrikaaner I just don’t understand what you expect anyone to say except leave him.

No1 on here is going to say yeah just call the kid a boys name and that will solve the problem…

What message does that send to your older 3 daughters?

Miyagi99 · 26/01/2024 15:31

There are lots of lovely names that were traditionally boys but can be given to girls but the reasoning behind this is sinister, I feel sorry for this poor child, unwanted by her father.

Playingintheshadow · 26/01/2024 15:31

padmo · 26/01/2024 15:24

What about a girls name that's a neutral nickname

  • Thomasina (Tommy)
  • Danielle or Danniella (Danny)
  • Nicolette (Nicky)
  • Francesca (Frankie)

Etc etc

No, definitely not - don't even entertain the idea at all!!!

She's probably going to grow up knowing that her father doesn't want her because he wanted a boy anyway. Is that not enough?!

RedRobyn2021 · 26/01/2024 15:31

He sounds quite horrible to me

Lilysienna1 · 26/01/2024 15:30

I think you should change the name of your husband.

SiobhanSharpe · 26/01/2024 15:30

If you can, go back to SA. He can come and visit them if he's bothered.

urbanbuddha · 26/01/2024 15:30

But if I leave, I am afraid my daughters will hate me for depriving them from a father.

You say that as if you would be denying them a good father. But you’d be freeing them from the destructive influence of a misogynistic bully.

Afrikaaner · 26/01/2024 15:29

HollyJollyRobin · 26/01/2024 15:22

I feel really sad for your daughter OP. Giving her a boys name won't change the fact she's still a girl and as you know, your DH needs to accept this and come to terms with it...preferably before she's born. It would be very sad if she grew up knowing she wasn't good enough...just as she is.
Your daughter should be the one behind your thinking of a name and not your husbands culture expectations.

You are absolutely right, with DD1 he tried to get on football and share traditional "boys" activities... But she is very much into girly things

OP posts:
Playingintheshadow · 26/01/2024 15:28

Afrikaaner · 26/01/2024 15:25

Thank you everyone. I don't want to damage her, or made her a target for bullying.
I feel guilty because he doesn't eat, spend his time drinking and doesn't talk to me or play with his girls.

My oldest (13yo) is picking up on it and I can tell she goes to great lengths ( such as lying) to get her attention. I feel like it's all my fault and even regret trying for a 4th. It is horrible I know.

No, I have no bank account. When I decided to leave S.Africa for him, he was charming. Very much open minded. All my children have S.African citizenship and I miss the times there. With my family, working, the weather. But if I leave, I am afraid my daughters will hate me for depriving them from a father.

Yes, I made poor choices and I am trying to fix it it as much as possible.

He's not much of a father anyway, is he?

God knows how he is going to treat this little baby when she's born.

Catsbreakfast · 26/01/2024 15:27

What an absolute prince you got yourself there 🙄

SiobhanSharpe · 26/01/2024 15:25

When i worked in South Africa a few years ago many of the women i was privileged to meet were feisty , independent people who took no shit, especially from men.
That's your daughters' heritage, and it's equally as important as their heritage from their father.
Please don't let him belittle them in any way because of their sex, you are never lesser than a man, and neither are they. But they will need you to vehemently counter his sexist views.

Afrikaaner · 26/01/2024 15:25

Thank you everyone. I don't want to damage her, or made her a target for bullying.
I feel guilty because he doesn't eat, spend his time drinking and doesn't talk to me or play with his girls.

My oldest (13yo) is picking up on it and I can tell she goes to great lengths ( such as lying) to get her attention. I feel like it's all my fault and even regret trying for a 4th. It is horrible I know.

No, I have no bank account. When I decided to leave S.Africa for him, he was charming. Very much open minded. All my children have S.African citizenship and I miss the times there. With my family, working, the weather. But if I leave, I am afraid my daughters will hate me for depriving them from a father.

Yes, I made poor choices and I am trying to fix it it as much as possible.

OP posts:
momonpurpose · 26/01/2024 15:25

TomeTome · 26/01/2024 14:12

No. He needs to make peace with his family and start changing his culture. That’s what a real father would do. Push back hard.

OP I get it. In my culture it's the same. I cannot tell you how hurtful it was for my dd. Just recently she said I wish I had been a boy so dad would have not gone crazy. (DV) Please try to get him to go to counseling

Disneyvillain · 26/01/2024 15:24

I have a female family member called Shahin, which is more commonly a boys’ name but it means Peregrine/falcon.