Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give DD a boy's name to appease DH gender disappointment?

320 replies

Afrikaaner · 26/01/2024 14:09

I have posted somewhere else, but I don't know how to delete posts on MN. I feel like this is the most appropriate sub.

I have 3 girls and I am pregnant with the last who is also a girl. DH is very very disappointed, he doesn't want to mention her or the pregnancy. In his culture, having a boy is the most desirable; women who can't make babies are not seen as a real women ( his words, not mine).

A week ago, he suddently started telling me we should name her a boy's name. It would be the only way, according to him, to bond with his daughter. Not gender neutral, but male name. I said no, and since then , he won't talk to me. I feel guilty, and sad and I am thinking to go with his plan. I absolutely dislike his choices. Will I be unreasonable to find a male name I like and name her that?

OP posts:
Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 26/01/2024 17:10

Tengreenbottles2 · 26/01/2024 17:00

Wasn't that just the standard style for little boys in Victorian times?

Anyway, if they stopped when he was 5 or 6 then that's one thing (and indeed, I'm not suggesting that, in and of itself, having an androgynous name or wearing clothes usually associated with the opposite gender will harm a child), but the fact is there are parents who spend their child's entire childhood sulking that they were the born the "wrong sex", and who make sure the child knows it, and that definitely has an affect on the child.

As far as I know, from what grandad told me, it was more because they'd wanted a girl but had 3 boys (and his 2 older brothers). His 2 older brothers weren't dressed this way and there are no photos of them dressed this way.

I don't think it really affected my grandad though, but he did remember it.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 26/01/2024 17:02

OP will be unlikely to get away with returning to SA with her born DDs because their father will be able to force their return under the Hague Convention on Child Abduction.

PieAndLattes · 26/01/2024 17:01

So he’ll only like her if she’s called Bob? He’s a thick twat. His sperm determines gender. It’s nothing to do with acidity or anything else. xx=girl, xy=boy. A girl called Bob is still a girl. Does he want her to be teased or misgendered?

Namechangesab · 26/01/2024 17:00

EnfysPreseli · 26/01/2024 16:50

I used to know someone whose father did something similar. She was a generation older than me, so I think her dad would have been born in Victorian times and maybe had attitudes to match. Even though her registered name was a girl's name, he insisted on calling her Peter. Her whole family started to use it as a nickname and as an adult she went by Peta, with that spelling. She joked about it, but I can't imagine it was pleasant to know that your father was so disappointed in your sex that he pretended you were the opposite one anyway.

I'm now wondering if you're talking about my aunt 😅

All three of my aunties were given boys names. Auntie Peta married uncle Peter which was a bit of a running family joke.

For some reason when he did finally get the much desired boy (my dad) he decided to name him the least manly/attractive name ever... Nigel.

Tengreenbottles2 · 26/01/2024 17:00

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 26/01/2024 15:11

Years ago in Victorian times, parents did pretend their boys were girls if they wanted girls. My grandad was the third boy and was dressed as a little girl, lace frilly dresses, bows and long curly blonde hair. We have photos! I'm not sure it really affected him that much. I think they stopped when he got to 5 or 6.

Wasn't that just the standard style for little boys in Victorian times?

Anyway, if they stopped when he was 5 or 6 then that's one thing (and indeed, I'm not suggesting that, in and of itself, having an androgynous name or wearing clothes usually associated with the opposite gender will harm a child), but the fact is there are parents who spend their child's entire childhood sulking that they were the born the "wrong sex", and who make sure the child knows it, and that definitely has an affect on the child.

Don't freak out, but ALL little boys used to wear dresses and nobody cared!

Up until as recently as the 1940s, it was no big deal for boys to wear dresses and the little dudes happily frocked up!

https://babyology.com.au/lifestyle/beauty-and-fashion/dont-freak-out-but-all-little-boys-used-to-wear-dresses-and-nobody-cared/

Grapefruitsquash · 26/01/2024 16:59

SecondUsername4me · 26/01/2024 14:19

women who can't make babies are not seen as a real women ( his words, not mine)

Why would you even be with a man like this?

This!

I can't have children. Nice to know I'm not a real woman. Thankfully my husband is a decent man who doesn't agree.

ilovesooty · 26/01/2024 16:58

NonPlayerCharacter · 26/01/2024 15:10

I'm amazed someone who knows so little about women's bodies even managed to reproduce, let alone four times.

I'm amazed she could bring herself to have sex with him

indianwoman · 26/01/2024 16:56

Why don't you have a bank account? Don't you get child benefit paid into an account you can access?

Creatureofhabit87 · 26/01/2024 16:55

Why did you have any more children with this prick?

Namechangesab · 26/01/2024 16:54

SiobhanSharpe · 26/01/2024 15:25

When i worked in South Africa a few years ago many of the women i was privileged to meet were feisty , independent people who took no shit, especially from men.
That's your daughters' heritage, and it's equally as important as their heritage from their father.
Please don't let him belittle them in any way because of their sex, you are never lesser than a man, and neither are they. But they will need you to vehemently counter his sexist views.

Edited

Exactly this. Also Afrikaans and Dutch are very similar language wise (I've lived and worked in both countries) so why not choose a name that works for both cultures instead of a random Pakistani boy's name??

One of my good friends from SA is Danielle, goes by Dani. One of my good friends from Holland is Sasha, which can also be gender neutral. Amira is also lovely.

Loads of options out there. Please stick up for yourself, your background and your child. Your husband sounds like an abusive controlling arsehole tbh.

SwordToFlamethrower · 26/01/2024 16:54

Anyone else thinking this girl will have the mysterious boy feels at around 18 months and be transed?

Brightandbubly · 26/01/2024 16:53

Think of your poor daughter given a boy’s name because her awful father didn’t want her and tell the pillock it’s his sperm that’s responsible for the sex of baby

EnfysPreseli · 26/01/2024 16:50

I used to know someone whose father did something similar. She was a generation older than me, so I think her dad would have been born in Victorian times and maybe had attitudes to match. Even though her registered name was a girl's name, he insisted on calling her Peter. Her whole family started to use it as a nickname and as an adult she went by Peta, with that spelling. She joked about it, but I can't imagine it was pleasant to know that your father was so disappointed in your sex that he pretended you were the opposite one anyway.

FictionalCharacter · 26/01/2024 16:50

But if I leave, I am afraid my daughters will hate me for depriving them from a father.
You’ll be depriving them of nothing. He doesn’t give them attention, he wishes his youngest was a boy, he wants to pretend she’s a boy and give her a boy’s name. He doesn’t value them. He is not a good father. Far better for them to live without him than to endure being treated like this. And it will without doubt escalate as they get older.
Far better for them to have a new life in SA where they won’t have to be around a father who doesn’t value them.

Mumofoneandone · 26/01/2024 16:45

DH behaving very badly - maybe he needs some counselling to work through this but if you have to leave to protect your girls, then you have to.
I know of 4 boys, with the youngest knowing he wasn't really wanted, as he wasn't a girl! Always affected him growing up.

RedToothBrush · 26/01/2024 16:45

Afrikaaner · 26/01/2024 14:18

He knows that, but told me all BS about how the acidity of the vagina or my diet could have had an impact.

Ask him for the scientific study proving this. Then ask, why if this was true considering the number of people who favour boys, why there wasn't a scientifically proven treatment backed up with science that was available. Then ask why if theres no one of this is his abusing his wife for his own sperm.

Then tell him to get over himself, stop being a sexist prick and hurting his family because his male ego is damaged.

Seriously, do not put up with this shit. Culture is an excuse for sexism in 2024. It just being a prick.

Appleass · 26/01/2024 16:41

Stop enabling this monster to treat you like this. Like someone already said, it's the male sperm that determine sex ! The prehistoric bast ard !

2mummies1baby · 26/01/2024 16:40

Your husband is a world-class prick. Your poor, poor daughters.

Perfect28 · 26/01/2024 16:40

Yabu to have a child with someone who doesn't think you are a whole woman. Fuck that, culture or otherwise. Your poor girls 😔

twnety · 26/01/2024 16:39

Maireas · 26/01/2024 16:35

A fourth, no less.

yeah - saw that after I posted! (always the way) but cheers!

maybe I just couldnt undertand how OP didnt get a dusty fanny with a man like this

mkwar · 26/01/2024 16:38

stargirl1701 · 26/01/2024 14:13

It's the sperm that decides the sex of the baby. Does he know this?

Best comment ever 💪🏼 what a melt he is x

wronginalltherightways · 26/01/2024 16:38

FluffMagnet · 26/01/2024 14:26

Frankly for the sake of your older daughters, I am relieved you are having another girl. The favouritism of a son would have been horrendous for them. He is being abusive to you and all your daughters - don't lumber a baby with the most obvious continual reminder that her father despises the fact she is a girl.

This.

Enjoy your girls.
Tell him if he doesn't pull himself together and act stop being a total dick, then he can pack his bags and go. You will not having your daughter's raised by an ignorant misogynist.

Maireas · 26/01/2024 16:38

Maireas · 26/01/2024 16:35

A fourth, no less.

Just seen your edit! Unbelievable, isn't it.

BreatheAndFocus · 26/01/2024 16:37

What a sad, pathetic little man he is! His children are individuals not little Mini Hims who have to be, look and do what he wants! What the AF is wrong with him!

You've already said his attitude is affecting your girls. I’d seriously and secretly look into getting away from him - for your sake and for your daughters’ sakes. Wanting you to call your newest DD a boys name is creepy AF. It sounds like he’ll try to mould her into a ‘boy’. He’ll mess with her head big-time.

For all your sakes get away from him. Call your DD a normal girl’s name. You say you’ve made mistakes. That’s ok, but don’t make another one. Don’t let him affect your baby. Name her normally and plan your escape.

Scirocco · 26/01/2024 16:36

Choochi · 26/01/2024 16:25

Sounds like he is taking on his Pakistani culture to want a boy and yet doesn't mind drinking which is so looked down upon by that same culture! It is infuriating how they cherry pick bits from culture to suit them. I would stand for my girl, and call her nothing but a girls' name. What's the point of him in their lives if he doesn't have the balls to accept the sex of his children.

It's not a standard Pakistani thing. It's a him thing.