Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give DD a boy's name to appease DH gender disappointment?

320 replies

Afrikaaner · 26/01/2024 14:09

I have posted somewhere else, but I don't know how to delete posts on MN. I feel like this is the most appropriate sub.

I have 3 girls and I am pregnant with the last who is also a girl. DH is very very disappointed, he doesn't want to mention her or the pregnancy. In his culture, having a boy is the most desirable; women who can't make babies are not seen as a real women ( his words, not mine).

A week ago, he suddently started telling me we should name her a boy's name. It would be the only way, according to him, to bond with his daughter. Not gender neutral, but male name. I said no, and since then , he won't talk to me. I feel guilty, and sad and I am thinking to go with his plan. I absolutely dislike his choices. Will I be unreasonable to find a male name I like and name her that?

OP posts:
Musntapplecrumble · 26/01/2024 22:44

Is he Henry VIII?

Ofcourseshecan · 26/01/2024 21:30

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 26/01/2024 14:14

The only unreasonable thing you did was have children with this man in the first place.. imagine being so disappointed in the gender you refuse to even acknowledge the pregnancy and demand you all basically refer to her as being a boy?!

Bonkers.

Yes, and not just bonkers but a very nasty piece of work.

Caerulea · 26/01/2024 21:25

OP this is heartbreaking to read. Go home to your family, this man can be no father at all to girls when he thinks so little of women.

Take your girls & raise them to be strong women who will walk away from shit like this.

fleurneige · 26/01/2024 21:02

Choochi · 26/01/2024 16:25

Sounds like he is taking on his Pakistani culture to want a boy and yet doesn't mind drinking which is so looked down upon by that same culture! It is infuriating how they cherry pick bits from culture to suit them. I would stand for my girl, and call her nothing but a girls' name. What's the point of him in their lives if he doesn't have the balls to accept the sex of his children.

Pakistani or Cape Malay? One of our best friends is Cape Malay and he has 4 daughters- he could not be more proud of them or love them more- and same for his whole family. So 'culture' is just an excuse- and if he is Muslim, and a traditional Cape Man, he should certainly not be drinking.

How very difficult for you. Those who say 'just leave him' are probably not aware of our difficult this is in certain cultures, as women often become totally ostracised if they leave.

bluefrog11 · 26/01/2024 20:47

He does know that HE makes the sex of the child yes?? Tell him to grow up or fuck off.

Bex5490 · 26/01/2024 20:45

IncompleteSenten · 26/01/2024 20:33

Can you imagine how much worse it would have been for them if this last child had been a boy?

God knows how much damage is already being done but some small mercy is they will never have to see him love a sibling in a way they know they'll never be loved by him.

So true.

IncompleteSenten · 26/01/2024 20:33

SleepingStandingUp · 26/01/2024 19:48

What father?
He doesn't talk to them, play with them, share meals with them. He is just a man who lives in the house who resents them.

Can you imagine how much worse it would have been for them if this last child had been a boy?

God knows how much damage is already being done but some small mercy is they will never have to see him love a sibling in a way they know they'll never be loved by him.

Mydogmylife · 26/01/2024 20:06

Op , you say you have made poor choices and are trying to fix then - what if anything have you done to sort the situation ? Are you planning to leave , get him counselling - what? I doubt he’s going to change and all your daughters look set for a pretty miserable life with this useless specimen

SleepingStandingUp · 26/01/2024 19:48

Afrikaaner · 26/01/2024 15:25

Thank you everyone. I don't want to damage her, or made her a target for bullying.
I feel guilty because he doesn't eat, spend his time drinking and doesn't talk to me or play with his girls.

My oldest (13yo) is picking up on it and I can tell she goes to great lengths ( such as lying) to get her attention. I feel like it's all my fault and even regret trying for a 4th. It is horrible I know.

No, I have no bank account. When I decided to leave S.Africa for him, he was charming. Very much open minded. All my children have S.African citizenship and I miss the times there. With my family, working, the weather. But if I leave, I am afraid my daughters will hate me for depriving them from a father.

Yes, I made poor choices and I am trying to fix it it as much as possible.

What father?
He doesn't talk to them, play with them, share meals with them. He is just a man who lives in the house who resents them.

Toomuchgoingon79 · 26/01/2024 19:27

Malika is pretty. Please don’t give your child a male name unless it’s unisex- Frankie, Alex, Robin etc

Northernsouloldies · 26/01/2024 19:27

No bank account suggests finances are controlled by the husband and she's at his mercy financially.

WaterHound · 26/01/2024 19:20

WiddlinDiddlin · 26/01/2024 14:12

He won't talk to you, he believes you have any control over whether a baby is a boy or a girl (he needs a lesson in human reproduction, its HIS swimmers that determine X or Y chromosome, nothing to do with you at all!) - why are you still with this absolute arsehole?

THIS.

tennesseewhiskey1 · 26/01/2024 19:19

I am gobsmacked 27% think agreeing with your insane husband is the way to go.

Nanny0gg · 26/01/2024 19:19

I don't understand how you have no bank account.

Have you never worked? How do you get money?

Where are you living now?

tennesseewhiskey1 · 26/01/2024 19:18

Christ your poor daughter. Leave this guy. Imagine if your daughter’s husband did this to them? What kind of example are you setting here? Divorce him - your children will respect you more.

RobinStrike · 26/01/2024 19:08

OP, is your family in SA supportive? Would they help you buy tickets to go for an indefinite visit? If you can, take your children and go. When you are surrounded by family who love and appreciate your girls they will see the difference in how their father treats them and how other male family members support them.
I think at that point you may find it easier to decide whether staying there is the right thing to do. I suspect you will find life better without him, but time away in a different environment will give you clarity.

emilysquest · 26/01/2024 19:07

Call her whatever name you want and get rid of him.

angsty · 26/01/2024 19:06

When you say he "doesn't eat" what do you mean?

Sceptre86 · 26/01/2024 18:56

He is an arse and has a warped sense of culture. If he indeed followed pakistani culture then he shouldn't have married outside of his religion or race and nor should he be drinking. Yet those things are acceptable to him but having girls isn't? The man is a waste of space and you've had not 1 but 4 kids with him. I despair I really do. He's hiding behind 'culture' which might be easy enough to do as it's alien to you but it's insulting to suggest all pakistani dad's behave this way.

I'm asian and thankfully have never dealt with this prejudice. My dad, dbro, dh and cousins are loving men to their girls and boys. My dad once said that his son is his life but his girls have his whole heart. He has always championed us and is my greatest supporter. He set an example to me of valuing myself, always knowing my self worth. That led me to dh who lovingly learnt how to do different hairstyles on our little girls and is an equal partner.

Not being able to bond with your child because she's a girl and then wanting to call her a make name is batshit.

Northernsouloldies · 26/01/2024 18:53

She's a daughter not a disappointment, he needs dragged into this century.

IncompleteSenten · 26/01/2024 18:50

Even if you give her a boys name, she'd still be a girl
What then? He'll raise her as a boy?
Claim she's trans and start her on hormones?

Fangisnotacoward · 26/01/2024 18:34

Tell him he shouldn't have made so many X chromosome swimmers. If he was so adamant about having a boy he should have made more Y's. 🙄

I wouldn't give your daughter a male name, it won't resolve the problem, she'll never be a son. All it will do is make a core part of her identity a constant reminder that she wasn't "good enough".

ASGIRC · 26/01/2024 18:25

Afrikaaner · 26/01/2024 15:25

Thank you everyone. I don't want to damage her, or made her a target for bullying.
I feel guilty because he doesn't eat, spend his time drinking and doesn't talk to me or play with his girls.

My oldest (13yo) is picking up on it and I can tell she goes to great lengths ( such as lying) to get her attention. I feel like it's all my fault and even regret trying for a 4th. It is horrible I know.

No, I have no bank account. When I decided to leave S.Africa for him, he was charming. Very much open minded. All my children have S.African citizenship and I miss the times there. With my family, working, the weather. But if I leave, I am afraid my daughters will hate me for depriving them from a father.

Yes, I made poor choices and I am trying to fix it it as much as possible.

Why dont you have a bank account? You live in the Netherlands, I am assuming. So just go to the bank and open one up.
And then find yourself a job.
You dont have to go back to SA, you just have to leave your dick of a husband.

And no, this is not your fault. It is his.

Gender disappointment is all well and good. It happens, its terrible... But his position is awful!

GingerIsBest · 26/01/2024 17:24

urbanbuddha · 26/01/2024 17:10

OP will be unlikely to get away with returning to SA with her born DDs because their father will be able to force their return under the Hague Convention on Child Abduction.

That seems unlikely tbh. It doesn’t sound like he’d miss them.

Yes, and while he could probably fight, as the children have SA citizenship (and if OP gets back quickly, the 4th child will be born there and therefore her habitual place of residence will be South Africa) tat would make it harder of him.

But mostly, he wouldn't bother as he clearly doesn't want girls anyway.

urbanbuddha · 26/01/2024 17:10

OP will be unlikely to get away with returning to SA with her born DDs because their father will be able to force their return under the Hague Convention on Child Abduction.

That seems unlikely tbh. It doesn’t sound like he’d miss them.