Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Split between siblings and grandchildren

82 replies

Wouldliketobeanon · 26/01/2024 12:43

I would like to be anonymous for this so have changed my name.

I am single and live in a privately rented home. I have no dependents and fully support all of my costs with a single income. I'm not skint but not wealthy. If I need more money I work more (cleaning or freelance). I work full time.

My mum (dad died 3 years ago) has a healthy sum in the bank and lots of bits of expensive jewellery plus dad's bits and pieces, it's all worth quite a bit. She's not been in the best of health and is looking to pass on some of her jewellery and dad's to us while she's still with us for us to enjoy and share that enjoyment with her. I support this if its what she wants.

I have one sister who has three children. She has a husband and they both work but they are spenders, drive lovely cars on finance, lots of work to house (no judgement). They are always asking mum for money and she gives it to them (again no judgement, it's mum's money) I'm saying this for background.

My AIBU mum is talking about splitting her belongings five ways, me, sister, three nieces. I think it should be split 50/50 between me and sister and then sister can give to her daughters if she chooses.

What do you think? I would NEVER say this to any of them and will go with whatever mum decides but just wondered if I was being unreasonable?

OP posts:
charabang · 26/01/2024 12:49

I can see where you are coming from . maybe point out that a 50/50 between you and your sister would be more apporopriate so her children can inherit that way. You may not have children now but what about the future? would she effectively want to exclude any unborn grandchildren? Unfortunately though ultimately it's her decision.

Wouldliketobeanon · 26/01/2024 12:48

I agree it's entirely mum's decision and as I said I will support whatever she decides and highly unlikely to say anything regardless of what she decides.

I just wondered if I was being unreasonable in thinking its unfair (not mum).

OP posts:
MrsKwazi · 26/01/2024 12:48

i agree with you. Unless there is a very very large estate, I don’t think inheritance should skip generations. Not talking about granny’s favourite brooch, vase etc.

Feelinadequate23 · 26/01/2024 12:48

In my family most people go with a halfway house between your desired approach and your mum's approach - in your situation they would split it 3 ways: a third to you, a third to your sister and a third split between the grandchildren. But there is no right or wrong way.

I think you have to accept that grandparents have a direct relationship with their grandchildren and love them for themselves, not just an extension of their parents, so it is completely fair and normal for grandchildren to get something directly from grandparents, rather than waiting for it to come down through the parents.

My sibling and I currently each only have one child but if he goes on to have more and I don't, I wouldn't expect my DC to get more from our parents, just because there's only one of them. I would expect equal amounts to go to all grandchildren, even if that means my brother's "family" gets more in total than mine. I see each person as an individual, not as smaller separate groups within a wider family, and luckily my parents and sibling agree.

Ponderingwindow · 26/01/2024 12:47

anything but a 50:50 split is going to cause resentment because it is unfair. Yes, it’s her money and she can do what she wants, but that doesn’t mean she isn’t being unreasonable in her decision.

MorrisZapp · 26/01/2024 12:47

Obviously fifty fifty would be 'fair' but your mum isn't obliged to be fair. I'd be annoyed if my mum did this.

Newbeginningsandhappy · 26/01/2024 12:45

I think it’s your mum’s decision to make.