Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask teachers and parents if Covid still has an impact on kids four years on

289 replies

Backtoit123 · 26/01/2024 12:08

Just that really. Four years on don’t still notice a major effect on children from the pandemic. I’ve heard teenagers say they feel a few years younger due to their ‘pandemic age’ but my DC are grown up and I don’t work in teaching so it’s hard to know. Do you recognise a major difference in kids now compared to kids of the same age before Covid? AIBU to ask if the pandemic still has left a legacy on children’s development?
YABU- no it doesn’t
YANBU- yes it does

OP posts:
Gazelda · 26/01/2024 14:23

My DD is Y11. Was Y7 at the beginning of pandemic.

She's struggling socially and desperately trying to cling to childhood because she feels she missed so much. She didn't do the trips and activities Y7 and Y8 traditionally do to encourage their independence. Guides, dance class etc stopped too, their social skills, team playing, fitness was taken away.

But she's doing OK academically.

One effect that irritates me is that she is very musical. Enjoys playing instruments. Her school didn't allow any instrument playing from the start of the pandemic right through to when she finished Y9. As a consequence, she hasn't done GCSE music. Exactly the same with food tech - she didn't do a single practical lesson at KS3. Both subjects she loved and would have done well at GCSE.

She can enjoy both as hobbies at home. But if they're important enough to be on the compulsory curriculum, they should have been taught.

HerculesMulligan · 26/01/2024 14:22

Your child was only out of circulation for 3 months, Fluffyc1ouds. That's not everyone's experience.

I'm a school governor and the teachers are seeing the impact right down to Reception - the youngest of those children would have been 6 months old when lockdown began. Primarily, it's showing itself as anxiety and delayed or unclear speech. The year following that seem to be less impacted, they think.

Mnetcurious · 26/01/2024 14:21

Lindy2 · 26/01/2024 13:04

DD13 - was in year 4 and 5 when we had the Covid lockdowns. She's academically able and sociable. I think she's fine. She's doing well at Secondary School and is top sets so I think any learning she missed is now caught up with.

Her main issue with home learning was that it didn't stretch her at all. She'd start her set work at 9am and be done by 10am/11am. She actually liked lockdown and all the time it gave her to do her crafts, watch TV etc. She still quite regularly has a pyjama day at a weekend to just stay inside and potter about.

DD15 was year 7 and 8. She's autistic and had just started to settle into Secondary School when lockdown hit.

All I can describe it as is an absolute shit show. I don't know if it's post Covid or her ASD. I think mostly ASD but with Covid exacerbating things. She can't cope with busy places, struggles to attend school and is persistently absent because she can't leave the house/her bedroom, can't cope with the stress or academic demands of GCSEs (not academically very able and has short term memory issues). She's an absolute shell of her younger self and it's heartbreaking. I think we would have encountered difficulties but the current situation is off the scale. The mental health and educational support just isn't there either.

One of mine was in y7/ y8 during covid too. I think this age was hit very hard. Just starting to get to grips with secondary school when it all shut down. Start all over again in y8 for the same to happen again after a term. So they essentially started secondary for the third time again in year 9. Now they’re taking GCSE’s having missed out on much of their first two years because they were bottom of the priority list as teachers were focusing on the more pressing needs of the older years (though they ended up not even taking exams). Mine definitely has a level of anxiety that I don’t think would be there without the covid years.

cordeliachaseatemyhandbag · 26/01/2024 14:20

Yes all of mine socially behind where they should be for their age and their peers are the same. I just think of them all as a year younger than they are.

Academically it has depended on exact age.

Fluffyc1ouds · 26/01/2024 14:09

When it comes to younger children, currently aged 4-6, I'm confused as to why teachers keep blaming covid for things. My DC had no idea what was going on and nursery was only closed for 3 months. As far as my child was concerned it was business as usual. I would think that older children would be more impacted.

Spendonsend · 26/01/2024 14:05

glusky · 26/01/2024 13:59

I wonder if that bubble has passed now. Current Y10s were in primary at the start of COVID and Y7 in second lockdown so this year's Y9s taking their options should be ok. Unless it is about MH and not managing a more demanding workload, rather than missed lessons.

I do think the kids who were in KS3 took a much harder hit than we recognised at the time. Old enough to manage at home without that much supervision but isolated at home for the massive explosion in emotional and social development that happens in Y8/9.

We are expecting this years 11 and next year 11s to sit less triple science across a number of schools in my area. Them it should be better.

I think people underestimate what school was like when it was open but self isolation rules were in place when they think about the impact.

It also doesn't help there is a teacher shortage for some subjects which just carries the issue on.

ShazzaF · 26/01/2024 14:03

My eldest was born in late 2021. I think he's too young for the lack of socialisation to have affected him - by the time he was 6 months old, most groups around me were back up and running.

However, being pregnant during the pandemic caused me an enormous deal of stress and poor mental health during pregnancy and for about 6 months postpartum. I am totally convinced that the poor mental health I suffered during pregnancy and the first portion of my baby's life has impacted him. He's a very anxious soul, he's just fearful of the whole world.

Londonrach1 · 26/01/2024 14:01

Massive effect still now. In all the years.

crumblingschools · 26/01/2024 13:59

I wonder how children in Spain have been impacted as they had more draconian measures to start with, with children not even being allowed outside

glusky · 26/01/2024 13:59

Spendonsend · 26/01/2024 13:25

One impact is less pupils are expected to enter for triple science for a few years as it builds on what is covered in key stage 3 and this has been impacted by covid provision. No just the big when schoools were closed, but the bit after when they were open but everyone kept having to isolate and the younger years got more cover to concentrate on exam years.

I wonder if that bubble has passed now. Current Y10s were in primary at the start of COVID and Y7 in second lockdown so this year's Y9s taking their options should be ok. Unless it is about MH and not managing a more demanding workload, rather than missed lessons.

I do think the kids who were in KS3 took a much harder hit than we recognised at the time. Old enough to manage at home without that much supervision but isolated at home for the massive explosion in emotional and social development that happens in Y8/9.

Tabletable · 26/01/2024 13:51

Massively still impacted. Not all children by any means but the current 8-10 year old have some large gaps - especially in English. Spelling is atrocious! There are also high levels of anxiety and this is true of the parents too.

JoeyJojoJnrShabadoo · 26/01/2024 13:48

YANBU. I've working in primary schools since 2020 and you can see a huge difference in children, particularly those who missed their time in Nursery as a result of it. Their attention spans are noticeably shorter and I think socially they're less mature than they would have otherwise been.

parrotonmyshoulder · 26/01/2024 13:46

Research needs to be done into the correlation between lockdowns and changes in online behaviour from children. In the absence of being allowed to play with other children and interact in person, children learned to communicate online.
Some had more supervision and monitoring than others around what they were able to access and continue to access now.

Combattingthemoaners · 26/01/2024 13:41

Doppelgangers · 26/01/2024 13:15

How does turning it around help those children who have been impacted though? It's not an excuse it's a very reasonable explanation for the difficulties so many children have.

I’m not saying language alone fixes the issues because many of the issues began way before Covid. It may be a contributing factor but it is not the only reason we are seeing a mental health crisis, poor attendance and behaviour in schools, poor socialisation or delayed development.

There is too much emphasis on Covid. We are seeing it as a before and after when it is far more complex than that. I do think the language we use with our young people frames their mindset. If they hear from a young age Covid caused this, they fell behind in Covid, Covid has made them hate school, Covid has caused anxiety then it isn’t helping anyone.

User4653566 · 26/01/2024 13:38

My own child is the youngest in Y1 and they were too young in March 2020 to even realise life had changed. Nurseries also reopened in June 2020. They missed about 3 months of nursery but weren't even 2 so the time they missed was time many children aren't even in nursery if their parents don't work.

Agree with this for very young children. There was no way they could have even been aware of what was going on. However I do believe that seeing people in masks was quite spooky, and some may have absorbed the negative vibes from older adults or siblings in the same home.

DD was only 1 when it started and sailed through most of it. However we decided to delay nursery for a while and she started with 3 which was not great. You could clearly tell she missed out on a socialisation period (despite us having reasonably regular contact and play dates with neighbours and cousins). She really acted out, was unhappy and struggled finding friends.

We changed nurseries, she got a bit older and things improved dramatically. Thinking back to the pandemic feels almost a bit like a fever dream. Things that you can't fathom happened but where absolutely real. Even though it was immensely difficult dealing with a toddler during that time, I'm grateful that it was an age the after-effects have faded without any permanent mark in her memory.

I can't begin to imagine how it was for older children/teens who were fully able to understand what was going on but without the psychological skills to process it. I was hypochondriac as a kid and something like the pandemic would have broken me.

GreekDogRescue · 26/01/2024 13:34

It wasn’t covid that was the problem, it was draconian lockdowns

crumblingschools · 26/01/2024 13:32

Y10 and Y11s seem to be quite badly hit behaviour/mental health wise.

Parents attitudes to attendance have really hit attendance rates in a bad way.

IgnoranceNotOk · 26/01/2024 13:31

IgnoranceNotOk · 26/01/2024 13:29

I agree as a parent as my 4&5 year old have been fine.
However this is why OP was asking teachers as the dynamic of teaching a large group is completely different to parenting.

Eldest DS (5) is thriving and went back to nursery after lockdown and had a good chunk there before school.
His teacher told me this year (we network) that her class this year are so different socially and resilience and behaviour wise to DS’s class and mainly because so many in his class didn’t go to nursery after lockdown.

So from what I’ve noticed and discussed it seems to be socially and emotionally for the younger ones and the older ones it’s academically as a well as mental health.

Sorry this should say as a parent of young children as I think it’s different the older they were going through lockdown.

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 26/01/2024 13:30

It's effected my kids very differently.

DD, neurotypical, aged 4 in 2020. She had a pretty frustrating lockdown. Spent a lot of it following me around whining and asking to play. Behaviour took a bit of a dip. She was the one I felt most guilty about at the time as I could see her needs were not quite being met. I signed up for the triple P course shortly afterwards. By the time a place came up, things had resolved by themselves and it all felt a bit irrelevant.
4 years on, It seems to have had no long term effect at all.

DS aged 7 in 2020, got his ASD diagnosis just after lockdown. Lockdown was his dream come true. Absolutely blossomed with home learning and never went back to school. We're now looking at getting him into a specialist unit for secondary after 4 years of home education.
He was more profoundly effected by lockdown but largely in a positive way.

I can well understand that behavioural problems and school refusal have become social issues. Because we navigated around those rocks as a family. I remember it feeling tough but manageable.
I imagine if we were already struggling it wouldn't have come out so positively.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 26/01/2024 13:30

Rycbar · 26/01/2024 12:36

Enormously. I teach Reception.
Last year the children had absolutely no resilience whatsoever. They were emotional wrecks - I felt like a social worker more than a teacher. This year it’s worse and next year is on a whole other level (I have them for nursery too). These were all babies during covid! My current nursery were born into it!

@Rycbar I'd agree with this based on my experience having my youngest in Reception this year. It's been quite eye opening.

LightSwerve · 26/01/2024 13:29

kiwiaddict · 26/01/2024 13:09

Why did they close the schools? I live abroad - schools didn't close here, but we had lower infection rates that the UK

It is bloody complicated, but the underlying reason is because our utterly shit PM didn't take appropriate measures and then had to over react.

If we hadn't had mixed messaging about things like masks and transmission, we could have got by without school closures.

Also the Tories wanted to open pubs more than schools Angry

IgnoranceNotOk · 26/01/2024 13:29

Aptique · 26/01/2024 13:08

This. I don't know a single person with children who are still using this as an excuse.

I agree as a parent as my 4&5 year old have been fine.
However this is why OP was asking teachers as the dynamic of teaching a large group is completely different to parenting.

Eldest DS (5) is thriving and went back to nursery after lockdown and had a good chunk there before school.
His teacher told me this year (we network) that her class this year are so different socially and resilience and behaviour wise to DS’s class and mainly because so many in his class didn’t go to nursery after lockdown.

So from what I’ve noticed and discussed it seems to be socially and emotionally for the younger ones and the older ones it’s academically as a well as mental health.

sleepyscientist · 26/01/2024 13:28

DS is year 5 and they have caught up with the work they missed. A lot of it is linked to how parents came out of lockdown ie still cautious so didn't allow socialising vs like us who had already had it so went out ASAP allowed friends round etc. It's also school based ours went for full time online lessons from after the supposed 2 week lockdown so they didn't miss much.

Lockdown shouldn't have happened and I think the older teens no this so it's having a mental effect

bookworm14 · 26/01/2024 13:27

My DD is in year 4, so missed chunks of reception and year 1 due to the lockdowns. I have heard that this cohort is among the worst affected as they missed a lot of the foundational work of key stage 1. My own DD has bounced back academically, although her maths is perhaps a bit behind where it should be. However she still suffers from anxiety which I’m convinced was exacerbated by having everything taken away from her overnight due to the lockdowns. It is slowly improving but it’s been a long road.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 26/01/2024 13:27

Aptique · 26/01/2024 13:21

I also think that. I was in a county with much, much harsher restrictions than the Uk and speaking to teacher friends and family they say kids have resumed life reasonably well. I really find it odd that people are still using this as some reason to anything now. We are years on from this now.

I find it odd that anyone thinks 'years on' is relevant when we consider what a huge portion of a child's life that is. It's not like we've done anything effective to try and fix the issues, either.

Swipe left for the next trending thread