Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask teachers and parents if Covid still has an impact on kids four years on

289 replies

Backtoit123 · 26/01/2024 12:08

Just that really. Four years on don’t still notice a major effect on children from the pandemic. I’ve heard teenagers say they feel a few years younger due to their ‘pandemic age’ but my DC are grown up and I don’t work in teaching so it’s hard to know. Do you recognise a major difference in kids now compared to kids of the same age before Covid? AIBU to ask if the pandemic still has left a legacy on children’s development?
YABU- no it doesn’t
YANBU- yes it does

OP posts:
Rycbar · 26/01/2024 15:38

Spangler · 26/01/2024 12:50

Can you say more about this?

DD1 is nearly four and in preschool/nursery. To me she seems pretty well adjusted and she appears to be thriving. I’m curious about whether I’m missing something.

Do you mean specifically what issues we’re having? The children can’t play. They don’t know how. Their social interactions are very immature. I have experience across all early years ages and the level of social and emotional development I’m seeing in my classes now would be on par with just going into preschool or even toddler rooms! We also have a significant rise in speech and language referrals going in. This obviously doesn’t go for all of the children in our class - some of them are absolutely fine but overall the number of issues like this is much much higher.

Acrosstheeuniverese · 26/01/2024 15:38

scalt · 26/01/2024 15:35

These harms were not caused by covid.
Nor were they caused by a pandemic.

They were caused by cruel and inhumane LOCKDOWNS, and an equally cruel and massively unnecessary campaign of fear, both of which went too far.

It is vital to remember this when anyone (especially the government) says “because of covid” or “because of the pandemic”. Nope, because of LOCKDOWNS. This is a hill I will die on.

Agreed.

Ohhbaby · 26/01/2024 15:35

Cramps23 · 26/01/2024 12:50

I'm a primary teacher and I sometimes think too much is attributed to the pandemic. The current Receptions were babies during the pandemic, not really nursery age. My own child is the youngest in Y1 and they were too young in March 2020 to even realise life had changed. Nurseries also reopened in June 2020. They missed about 3 months of nursery but weren't even 2 so the time they missed was time many children aren't even in nursery if their parents don't work.

I do think some of the current Y4s and probably Y5s (so R and Y1 in March 2020) suffered by not being taught proper letter formation when they were learning at home. There are definitely some bad habits! Attitudes to attendance have also changed. But I think a lot of learning has levelled out now.

I can say though, that in my practice I saw definite speech delays and problems in the younger kids (nursery age, so 1-3).
Which they (and I agree with) attribute to the mask wearing

scalt · 26/01/2024 15:35

These harms were not caused by covid.
Nor were they caused by a pandemic.

They were caused by cruel and inhumane LOCKDOWNS, and an equally cruel and massively unnecessary campaign of fear, both of which went too far.

It is vital to remember this when anyone (especially the government) says “because of covid” or “because of the pandemic”. Nope, because of LOCKDOWNS. This is a hill I will die on.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 26/01/2024 15:28

I think that's a huge issue, people claim kids saw lockdown as school being optional but that's completely down to shitty parenting during that time and not the lockdowns and schools themselves.

This is just plain wrong. And a very privileged take.

Some schools provided virtually nothing, some parents had much less time and ability to devote to homeschooling than others. Some DC didn't even have sufficient internet access and devices. So even assuming you're conflating education with school here, and they're not synonymous, the idea that it was shitty parenting is not one that survives even cursory examination.

JassyRadlett · 26/01/2024 15:26

I always feel a bit guilty when this question is asked because individually I think DS1 is better off as the result of the lockdowns - he was in Y3 at the start and hated home learning with a passion, his school were totally crap especially through 2020 and we got basically nothing from May onwards. He had been extremely shy and quite passive and just went with the flow before Covid but once school went back and especially once activities started up again he threw himself into everything on offer, worked very hard to overcome his shyness and discovered new talents and passions as a result, which has really eased his transition to secondary and has set him up really well. He's determined to squeeze everything he can out of school life, and that's a result of valuing it so much more now.

But I'm so so aware that we've been incredibly lucky and our experience has been unusual and tbh the picture for DS2 has been more mixed but he's pretty much ok now and his cohort at school are on track, largely thanks to a brilliant (but quite intense) Y1 teacher. And I know that overall so many kids have been so badly impacted by it, either individually or in terms of their peer group.

Hetty2507 · 26/01/2024 15:23

Absolutely. Kids now are very immature (for their age), being silly in class which they didn't do before. This is secondary school age.

Pippim · 26/01/2024 15:09

DS is a secondary school teacher. He says behavior is massively worse but he puts a huge amount down to TikTok reducing attention span to seconds. This could of course be indirectly exacerbated by lockdown.

Acrosstheeuniverese · 26/01/2024 15:07

My son 17 and was a first year apprentice electrician when the first lockdown hit and should have qualified last summer (qualified 2 days ago!) it's been so hard to watch all the anxiety that covid caused.. cancelled exams, cancelled jobs, witnessing friend after friend be let go. There were originally 32 apprentices on his course and only 9 made it the four years it takes to qualify. While this shitty government had parties and laughed in their faces.

JassyRadlett · 26/01/2024 15:07

The primary teachers I know say that while they've seen effects in all kids, the biggest effects are in the current Y2 and below. The current Y3 didn't miss early socialisation and while lockdowns affected them, they missed at most a term of nursery and less than a term of Reception. For the years below, the effects of lockdowns were a lot greater, a lot of nurseries took fewer children (especially private nurseries), had a lot of closures due to staffing issues as well as outbreaks within the setting, a lot of playgroups and other junior classes were closed and the disruption to their socialisation overall at a crucial time took a greater hit.

The other group I hear people talking about a lot is the cohorts that started year 7 in 2020 and 2021, where the transition to secondary was a lot more difficult and disrupted and there are still lasting effects. I can imagine the transition to higher/further ed might have seen similar impacts.

TooBigForMyBoots · 26/01/2024 14:59

DS2 was 2yo when Covid hit. Over the course of lockdown he became "strange", backing away when family members would visit at the gate. He's is better but describes himself as an Indoor kid.😒

ParentsTrapped · 26/01/2024 14:55

Fluffyc1ouds · 26/01/2024 14:09

When it comes to younger children, currently aged 4-6, I'm confused as to why teachers keep blaming covid for things. My DC had no idea what was going on and nursery was only closed for 3 months. As far as my child was concerned it was business as usual. I would think that older children would be more impacted.

But not all kids had exactly the same experience as yours?

My 5yo was 23 months in the first lockdown and due to start nursery (for the first time). I found out I was pregnant the week we went into lockdown. Due to a medical condition we had to shield which meant that DC1 couldn’t go to nursery until he was 3.5 and he was basically completely isolated from other kids until that time, for an 18 month period at just the point when he should have been starting to engage with and interact with other kids. It has had a massive impact on him.

He was so nervous and shy around other kids when he first started nursery that they suspect he had ASD (he doesn’t).

Mumof2NDers · 26/01/2024 14:50

Absolutely had an effect.
DS2 is 16 now. He has hated school since primary. Started refusing to go pre Covid but could usually be coaxed into going for maybe half the week. Post Covid I couldn’t get him in at all. So from about year 10 he didn’t go.
He suffered from extreme anxiety and was actually at one point had a suicide risk assessment ( other factors played into this including one of his friends aged 14 taking his own life)
He’s on the whole much better now and will be enrolling in a military college very soon.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 26/01/2024 14:49

Not a teacher but volunteer with children and the other day we commented how we could tell the "Covid kids"

They are general noisier, feel like they are younger than they are, more anxious to be away from parents...

OpposableThumbs2 · 26/01/2024 14:49

My year 3 DD seems fine academically but her and her peers seems behind socially to me. They seem unable to negotiate what they are going to play without there being an argument or tears or both. There is no ability to compromise.

My year 8 DD is now on the waiting list for an ASD assessment. We had suspicions before lockdown although that time really changed how she felt about school and how she interacted with her peers. She changed schools during that time (3 tier system so lower to middle) so its really impossible to separate the school change, lockdown and the ASD on how she is but my feeling is that it has had an effect.

Fullofeffingjoy · 26/01/2024 14:44

Yes. My son was in reception when lockdown happened, he's year 4 now and him and the majority of his peers are so much more immature and behind compared to how kids normally are in year 4

FayreIsle · 26/01/2024 14:43

I had a pretty normal teenage girl. She hated the isolation and the homeschooling. She became anxious as she was left alone with her thoughts and a screen during the day. It affected her eating and mental health, and she has never been the same since.

I feel so angry at how long schools were shut for. We are a pretty robust family and lived life as ‘normally’ as we could whilst keeping to the rules, but the effect of schools being shut left its mark.

petitetiti · 26/01/2024 14:43

I have 3 DCs: 7, 5 & 1 (post covid baby).

I don't think that there has been an impact on my family. I am self employed and worked from home anyway. If anything, home schooling and 1-1 learning helped the eldest.

Cousins who are the same age are also fine.

However it has been hard on a teenage acquantaince. She suffers from social anxiety and self-harming. Her mother blames covid but who knows really.

crumblingschools · 26/01/2024 14:39

@Tarantella6 DS was in a class like that in Primary school and that was well before the pandemic!

Tarantella6 · 26/01/2024 14:37

DD2 is in Y4 and to be quite honest her class are a bunch of weirdos with no social skills. They cannot get on with each other in a group at all. The other 3 classes are the same by all accounts. Academically it is hard to know.

DD1 is Y6 and she's absolutely fine, they were old enough to have learned some social skills but young enough to bounce back afterwards.

crumblingschools · 26/01/2024 14:37

@MrsMiddleMother not always shitty parenting though. We were lucky in respect of homeschooling as we had a teenager who loved remote learning and attended every lesson and did all the work required, and needed no supervision.

Parents who suddenly had to WFH and supervise homeschooling younger children who would need supervision/help had a much harder time of it than we did as parents.

If we had discouraged DS to do his school work, when he was keen to do it, then we would have been shitty parents. Parents trying to juggle work and schooling younger children not so.

A consequence of the lockdown was that some children who would normally do well at school and have supportive parents helping with reading etc, suddenly fell behind if those parents were the one juggling everything at home, so the gap between attainment in cohorts grew but also children who wouldn't normally have been at the lower end of the scale ended up there.

C152 · 26/01/2024 14:30

I think it's impossible for it not to have had an effect on children. They effectively lost a year of education. I don't think on an individual level my child's social skills suffered, but he would certainly be further ahead with maths and english if he hadn't missed that period of schooling, and being forced to home school certainly raised both our stress levels and made us miserable at the time. He also missed seeing his friends terribly.

Given the total lack of interest and significant funding needed to make up this lost time, these kids are all going to be behind in at least one area, whether it's socially or academically. The ongoing reduction in funding just exacerbates these issues.

MrsMiddleMother · 26/01/2024 14:27

Yabu, there is no difference in my kids to precovid. Dsd13 ds1 5 and ds2 2. Ds1 had no disruption to nursery, had a speech issue which was due to hearing and has been corrected. Plays great with others, doing very well in reception. Dsd13 also doing very well in secondary, happy to go and doesn't get in trouble. School has never been optional. Plays on anxiety like a lot of her peers, I.e uses it to get out of things she doesn't wanna do. We made sure she did school work during lockdown, not full 9-3 buy still kept the routine going so once schools opened it wasn't a huge change. I think that's a huge issue, people claim kids saw lockdown as school being optional but that's completely down to shitty parenting during that time and not the lockdowns and schools themselves.

Tooolde · 26/01/2024 14:26

Schools were closed so much because
primary age never wore maks in uk. ( other countries did and had kids in more during the pandemic)

Current y3 missed jan-mar 21 so over 1/6 of reception
And mar -jun+ nursery

Y4 mar-jun? Missed Reception 2020
And jan-mar 8w y1

Y2 missed no school but some nursery possibly

Certainly my dc also missed several more weeks of whole class isolations.
Plus dc2 reception class missed 30+ min per day thw whole year -- this works out as weeks less altogether

In terms of younger year groups

the nhs was frankly quite crap (locally) 8years ago and dc i know of werent getting s&l etc it was all wait and see. Kids still in 2015 started school with severe issue related to asd one repeated reception then moved to a special school. The other repeated got a diagnosis in maybe y2 and has moved to special school for secondary.

Children struggling in reception 2016 got bounced bacl from diagnosis and now with the waot lists have been waiting 2yrs after peads referral.

Our school in 2020 reception said they had issues with speech - all the kids i knew were completely fine ( but there was a huge increase in bilingual kids at this school that year from 1/60 say to maybe 8 or 9. )
The recovery curriculum didnt help as delayed the start of usual work.

By sept 2020 people were taking kids to park meet ups and kids were playing together.

Some kids are more passive than others which impacts language aquisition.
My dc1 asd/adhd referral was so 'naughty' into absolutely everything her language was pretty amazing by 18m. And always clear. She demanded constant interaction.
A boy born that same week spoke several month later would sit in front of tv placidly.
But also his parents put him to bed very early - before his dad got home so missing all that interaction. Basically loads of factors including infections etc.

Blaming s&l issues in 4yo on covid may mean fewer interventions are made to stop following years getting even worse.

Metamorphosising · 26/01/2024 14:24

I’m struggling to counteract the damage. Every time I think I’ve made progress, something else comes up. It had a huge impact on their motivation, social lives, social development, interests in non-online things, expectations of themselves around doing schoolwork, so much damage. I feel upset when I think of how things could have turned out differently.