Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask teachers and parents if Covid still has an impact on kids four years on

289 replies

Backtoit123 · 26/01/2024 12:08

Just that really. Four years on don’t still notice a major effect on children from the pandemic. I’ve heard teenagers say they feel a few years younger due to their ‘pandemic age’ but my DC are grown up and I don’t work in teaching so it’s hard to know. Do you recognise a major difference in kids now compared to kids of the same age before Covid? AIBU to ask if the pandemic still has left a legacy on children’s development?
YABU- no it doesn’t
YANBU- yes it does

OP posts:
BlindurErBóklausMaður · 26/01/2024 17:46

Interesting thread and sometimes we often talk about both at school and home. I'll read all the replies later.

I am a secondary teacher and my daughter was 14 when COVID began. That's the age group that I think were most psychologically affected at the time.

As the years pass we are still picking up the pieces with the yearly intakes. They are still very very immature compared to what 11 year olds were like pre COVID.

I tutor some under 11s and tbh, it's like it never happened for them. They don't remember much, and as they were so young in school terms, it hasn't affected them academically.

This year's intake are more immature than last year's. These are the ones who what, would have been 6-7-8 so really starting to settle into school. Except it didn't happen. The ones who were at the top end of primary not so much.

With secondary kids who were already at secondary, MH issues are through the roof. At a time when they should have been out getting pissed for the first time, snogging and making plans, they were locked in their houses hearing about a fuckwit PM wanting them to sing Happy Birthday while they washed their hands, and watching their grandparents die. Eating disorders and anxiety are rife. I have 5 classes and there isn't one without at least 3 students with certified MH issues.

Cramps23 · 26/01/2024 17:40

Ohhbaby · 26/01/2024 15:35

I can say though, that in my practice I saw definite speech delays and problems in the younger kids (nursery age, so 1-3).
Which they (and I agree with) attribute to the mask wearing

Yes I agree with speech issues, which people commented at the time would be a problem and yet concerns were dismissed. SALT data does indeed show an increase in children who were babies/toddlers (so current R and Y1) at that time. It's not helped by the waiting lists now - I'm at SENCO and they are over a year long. That's huge when you're 5!

shreddednips · 26/01/2024 17:38

LightSwerve · 26/01/2024 12:41

It is still massively affecting adults too.

I speak to many people at work who say they don't feel the way they remember feeling before COVID. HR departments are often reporting the post-COVID impacts on health, mental health and engagement.

I myself find it harder to be bothered to book things in advance - a hangover of everything getting cancelled repeatedly.

Yes I definitely agree- I have homebody tendencies anyway and lockdown got me out of the habit of getting out and about. I noticed a few months ago that DS and I were spending far too much time mooching around at home and I've had to make a conscious effort to change, lockdown got me into terrible habits!

Orangeandgold · 26/01/2024 17:34

I feel grateful that my DD is back on track but I can tell that there is some anxiety and she is so so clingy! Very close to me. Sometimes we will go to restaurants and I will notice within minutes she has scooted her chair a few cm from me - same if we are at friends for lunch or dinner or something. It’s also hard to tell how much of her behaviour is part of being the generation with access to phones and information overload. She is 11.

When speaking to friends with children, I find some have been affected in different ways. One of my friends couldn’t cope with her covid baby as she was late to develop and her eldest has had more tantrums.

Friends that had children receiving support for mental health or neurodiversity feel like they are starting from scratch post covid.

A few teacher friend has said that many pupils can’t stick to deadlines, there is less respect for teachers and teaching because of behaviour has become a nightmare.

It’s such a shame that our education and healthcare systems also have massive cuts.

Soontobe60 · 26/01/2024 17:29

Doppelgangers · 26/01/2024 17:20

Yes but what good is a reply saying no my kids have not seen any impact, just be very grateful they were not affected. It's clear to anyone who sees more than their own children that COVID lockdowns categorically had an impact on children and the impact is still happening.

It's like those threads where people pop up and say well we never had seatbelts as kids and survived etc. Of course some kids won't have been affected but that doesn't mean it's not a very real issue.

You’re assuming that her experience is an isolated case so was being dismissive. It isn’t.
In my school, the current year 6 cohort is showing little signs of being impacted by lockdown. We worked hard to ensure all children had laptops and free internet access to engage in home learning. We delivered free lunches to every family every week day. We brought all classes back in to school as soon as possible and focussed on their emotional well-being once they fully returned rather than cramming in any learning they’d missed.
I truly believe that by taking an holistic approach, we have avoided putting children under unnecessary pressure to ‘catch up’ academically and thus reduced any impact lockdown may have had on their mental health.

LaPalmaLlama · 26/01/2024 17:25

My own kids, honestly no, and I’m kind of surprised as we were then living in a country with extremely draconian covid control measures. They therefore missed more school than they would have in the Uk and had to wear masks for much longer and had greater social restrictions and closed borders for 3 yesrs. However, possibly the difference is that there was never a stay at home order, albeit social pressure to do so. Therefore they didn’t completely miss out socially although obviously within a smaller pool of kids. I was always of the opinion that lockdowns would cause more problems than they solved so my approach to the restrictions was letter rather than spirit.

I know teachers generally think concentration spans worsened during covid but I wonder if that’s also a factor of massively increased screen time in covid which then “stuck”. A lot of teens do now spend most of their free time on screens so it’s little wonder that they don’t feel amazing - their thoughts and emotions are basically being guided by an algorithm.

Everanewbie · 26/01/2024 17:24

scalt · 26/01/2024 15:35

These harms were not caused by covid.
Nor were they caused by a pandemic.

They were caused by cruel and inhumane LOCKDOWNS, and an equally cruel and massively unnecessary campaign of fear, both of which went too far.

It is vital to remember this when anyone (especially the government) says “because of covid” or “because of the pandemic”. Nope, because of LOCKDOWNS. This is a hill I will die on.

Well bloody said. People need reminding it isn't because of COVID, it was the actions taken that is causing the problem.

WonderingWanda · 26/01/2024 17:23

Yes, massive gaps still skills and learning. Immaturity, less able to cope with things, anxiety, poorer social skills, way more absence, lack or resilience.

Doppelgangers · 26/01/2024 17:20

Soontobe60 · 26/01/2024 17:15

Eh? The OP literally asked if ‘teachers AND PARENTS…’. So a reply from an actual parent is very relevant and pertinent to the question being asked. I will point out though that ‘relevant’ and ‘pertinent’ are synonyms so you only needed to use one of them in your snippy reply.

Yes but what good is a reply saying no my kids have not seen any impact, just be very grateful they were not affected. It's clear to anyone who sees more than their own children that COVID lockdowns categorically had an impact on children and the impact is still happening.

It's like those threads where people pop up and say well we never had seatbelts as kids and survived etc. Of course some kids won't have been affected but that doesn't mean it's not a very real issue.

Soontobe60 · 26/01/2024 17:18

ThatsGoingToHurt · 26/01/2024 12:56

It’s still having an impact on both my kids even though they are both very young as there are still massive NHS delays in treatment as they haven’t caught up.

I have a lockdown baby who is due to start school in September 2024. Pre covid the under 5’s autism waitlist was under a year. Now it is 3.5 years. DS has also been on the waitlist for for speech and language therapy for 2 years. I am imaging there will be a lot of children born between Sept 19 and Aug 20 have not received early help and will be starting school not ready as a result.

I would completely agree that this is the biggest legacy of the covid era. The impact on NHS services is massive.

Soontobe60 · 26/01/2024 17:15

Doppelgangers · 26/01/2024 12:46

Then I'd consider you and your children very fortunate but I'm not sure why you think your tiny sample size is relevant or pertinent to the question asked?

Eh? The OP literally asked if ‘teachers AND PARENTS…’. So a reply from an actual parent is very relevant and pertinent to the question being asked. I will point out though that ‘relevant’ and ‘pertinent’ are synonyms so you only needed to use one of them in your snippy reply.

Bluevelvetsofa · 26/01/2024 17:08

I remember saying, when it became apparent that there was going to be significant disruption to life as we knew it, that the bigger pandemic would be the damage to the mental health of the nation and so it has proven.

From children and teenagers who missed out on key events in primary and secondary school, to key workers who put themselves as risk on a daily basis, to older people, some of whom are now unable to socialise, leave the house, take part in every day activities.

Oblomov23 · 26/01/2024 17:07

No. Not for any of the dc I know.

shreddednips · 26/01/2024 17:04

I don't think my DS has been particularly affected (he's just turned 5)- but we were very lucky in that our circumstances allowed us to work flexibly as we were both self-employed at the time. It would have been much harder if we'd both been working set hours at home and I really feel for everyone who was in that position, it was awful. I felt absolutely broken by the end because I ended up working at night once he was in bed so hardly had downtime, but he seems reasonably unscathed in terms of language and social skills.

That said, I'm homeschooling him as we're waiting to move house- maybe issues will become apparent when he starts school but he seems pretty confident and can navigate friendships ok for his age.

One area where I've noticed a difference is his physical abilities- when lockdown happened, he was just at the age where they're learning to climb etc and we didn't have a big enough garden for play equipment (the playgrounds near us shut for ages, I can't remember whether that was mandatory now). I've definitely noticed that his peers who had access to climbing frames etc in their gardens were very physically confident when lockdown ended, whereas he was very frightened to play on playground equipment and massively struggled to learn to climb ladders and climbing frames. He's also quite timid of other children rushing around near him- he's an only child too so didn't have another child to play with at home. Even now, if he's in the playground and another child is using the same piece of equipment he will panic and change course. Maybe it's nothing to do with lockdown and he'd be like this anyway, but I'm trying to take him to playgrounds and soft play as much as possible during quieter times to build his confidence.

Bargello · 26/01/2024 17:03

Very much having an impact here.

My eldest was 17 in March 2020, two weeks before the first lockdown. He didn't sit his Highers and grades were decided by an algorithm. His final year in school was hugely disrupted by isolating and lockdowns and god knows what other restrictions Nicola Sturgeon put onto us. No prom, no leavers days, no assemblies. No uni open days. First year of Uni 2021-22 entirely online because Scottish government didn't give two hoots about anything other than covid.

His mental health is on the floor, he was never the most resilient of kids but the pandemic almost finished him off. My other two younger children appeared more affected at the time, scared and angry about not being at school and not seeing friends but are better now.

weebarra · 26/01/2024 16:59

Just thought of another impact, but in a way quite positive.
I was pretty sure that DS1 had ASD but he masked incredibly well at school, and DH didn't see an issue. When home learning started, his stresses and issues with not having a timetable really became clear and he started having meltdowns. He's now in S2 and has an ASD diagnosis which has been positive for him.

TiredBefuddledRose · 26/01/2024 16:40

My now 14 year olds are absolutely fine, still happy well adjusted little people. Pretty sure that's down to their personality type and not anything I did though 😅

My eldest suffered with stuff as she was one of those uni kids who were basically tricked into moving into Halls with the promises of in person lectures only for them all to be moved online immediately after.

The real question is when do we all stop saying it's because of covid / lockdown etc and actually start fixing the issues?

There's some atrociously behaved kids in my youngest 2's secondary school which is constantly excused because they're 'lockdown kids' but very little down to actually address this & find a solution, they can't just be misbehaved forever, not fair on them or the people around them.

PonkyPonky · 26/01/2024 16:36

I have a year one child and his cohort seem very well rounded socially and academically. I imagine anyone with SEN massively missed out in this age group though due to the sudden stop in support and assessments. DS missed 4 months of nursery in total when he was 2.5 so I don’t think that age group is the worst affected as many are saying. Nurseries were not closed anywhere near as much as schools were. I do know from friends that the children who were in reception, Y1 and Y2 during the lockdown years are very behind academically. I know the Y6’s are currently being given spellings that they should have been doing in year 4 because they just can’t catch up. I think they missed so much of the foundation of primary school. My secondary school step children were affected in totally different ways. One went from being a dream student who excelled at everyone to being one who gets detention (may have happened anyway of course). The other one thrived academically in lockdown in a way she never did at school but became a social recluse and still is. Everyone has been affected in different ways. I just feel sad for any children who were at school during the pandemic.

Roadtripwithkids999 · 26/01/2024 16:31

I have 4. Aged 4, 6, 9 and 10. Still small. Older 2 missed a lot. 9 year old basically missed most of reception and year 1. But honestly, you wouldn't know. They are where they need to be. We'll behaved. No anxiety etc.

I'm.not sure about those who had Older kids though

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 26/01/2024 16:31

The way uni students were treated was appalling. Reeked of trying to ensure they all paid their fees and accommodation money.

Kazzyhoward · 26/01/2024 16:28

And massive impact on Uni students too! My son went to Uni in 2020 and despite the promise of "blended learning" from the Uni, none of his lecturers or teaching staff were even on campus for the full year, so everything was online only, which meant he barely left his Uni flat. Entire teaching blocks were closed, as were campus shops, eateries etc., and the library was mostly partitioned off and they weren't allowed to study/sit in that either - just go in, get the book, and get out again! Of course, clubs & societies were online only too. As he isn't a drinker/party person, there was literally nothing to leave his flat for, especially as the online lectures etc were all over the day so there wasn't time to go out for a walk/run/cycle between lectures most days either.

He turned into a virtual recluse. glued to his PC screen for lectures during the day and then homework/TV/gaming at night. He never recovered from it and left Uni having barely made any friends, never having joined clubs/societies, etc.

He's finally turning things around now that he's got a graduate job in a big firm, and he's throwing everything he has into it, the socialising etc to try to get back to some kind of normal living. But the 3 years of Uni were really awful for him and there's no doubt it affected him.

Mountainhowl · 26/01/2024 16:14

Surprised to hear that people see the impact on 3 year olds/nursery aged kids. I have a 3, nearly 4 year old who was born on the day lockdown first started, he is in the school nursery and seems completely normal/average, as do his little friends. They seem to engage with nursery and each other really well and talk in full sentences/as you'd expect 3 year olds to talk.

Mynewnameis · 26/01/2024 15:56

I'm sure it's contributed to my 10yo dd anxiety. She dislikes having people in her home, especially her room.

Alwaysgiraffe · 26/01/2024 15:53

I teach secondary. There’s definitely a lot less resilience and attendance has taken a big hit.
People had to isolate if tracked and traced, even with a negative test at one point so keeping kids off for a sniffle seems much more reasonable to parents now than it did before. There’s a lot more in-school truancy - skipping classes to wander the corridors. Not just the one or two we always had but many kids out of class and a huge amount of time spent looking for them and trying to return them to class.

Resilience is poor and it’s fairly common for kids to phone parents from a classroom if they are upset or told off (and for the parent to then contact the school and take the kid home)

On a personal level my previously out-going and confident child started university during lockdown. Staying in halls where having to isolate was common (3 times in the first term!) and being in a city which had additional strict lockdowns even beyond what the UK in general had. My child is now very anxious. Still wears a mask in public and given the option will attend lectures online rather than in person. Their anxiety is impacting them so much that they were put on medication for it by the GP.

Ohhbaby · 26/01/2024 15:38

scalt · 26/01/2024 15:35

These harms were not caused by covid.
Nor were they caused by a pandemic.

They were caused by cruel and inhumane LOCKDOWNS, and an equally cruel and massively unnecessary campaign of fear, both of which went too far.

It is vital to remember this when anyone (especially the government) says “because of covid” or “because of the pandemic”. Nope, because of LOCKDOWNS. This is a hill I will die on.

Preach sister!!!!
Speech delays, isolation etc weren't caused by an illness, but by the fact that we were forced to wear masks and stay in our own homes. While the government, mind you, held parties and went to visit their mistresses across town..

Swipe left for the next trending thread