Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask teachers and parents if Covid still has an impact on kids four years on

289 replies

Backtoit123 · 26/01/2024 12:08

Just that really. Four years on don’t still notice a major effect on children from the pandemic. I’ve heard teenagers say they feel a few years younger due to their ‘pandemic age’ but my DC are grown up and I don’t work in teaching so it’s hard to know. Do you recognise a major difference in kids now compared to kids of the same age before Covid? AIBU to ask if the pandemic still has left a legacy on children’s development?
YABU- no it doesn’t
YANBU- yes it does

OP posts:
Naptrappedmummy · 26/01/2024 19:07

Rycbar · 26/01/2024 18:59

Of course. For me the biggest thing is not being able to give things a go. ‘I can’t do it’ being said before absolutely everything without even trying. Giving up as soon as something is a bit difficult. We had children throwing pencils and books across the room because we’d asked them to complete a writing task (with support of course) and their confidence was so low they would
lash out. I sat in the corridor one day last year with a child repeatedly shouting no at me because I’d asked them to try and zip their coat themselves. And I emphasise the word try. That’s all I ask from my children - they try and still find it hard of course I’d step in. Another thing was the constant bickering. Little children are learning to share but the amount of ‘this person won’t do this or give me this’ was on another level! Someone brushing past them in the cloakroom would end up with them on the floor like they’d been shot saying they’d been pushed.

Gosh. No she wouldn’t throw anything in class, she would be too scared of being told off. Like I said in my PP I had noticed that a lot of her classmates seem quite passive, and ‘flat’ - I don’t know many children really but assumed they would usually be laughing/giggling/chatting, but her peers seem to be quite quiet and in a low mood a lot of the time. At her school disco hardly any of them danced, there were a lot of kids sat at the edges crying because of the loud music. I was worried they were more typical and DD was a bit ‘much’ but maybe this is the effect of the pandemic that’s being discussed on here.

Namechangeforadhd · 26/01/2024 19:07

Covid, no.
But lockdowns, yes definitely.
Ruined the last years of DD's relationship with DGM whose dementia got exponentially worse as everyone was too fearful to visit.
Made 1st and 2nd years of secondary school really hard in terms of friendships, as well as academic work (not that I cared about that by the end of it all - I just wanted her to be OK)
ADHD spiralled out of control but masking got better and better because of fewer social interactions to use up her energy. So we didn't see the issues. Dealing with the consequences now.
I can't believe I could see what a disaster it was going to be, for DM and DD and all the others like them, but I still complied. Will never forgive myself for being so pathetic.

Naptrappedmummy · 26/01/2024 19:01

Rycbar · 26/01/2024 15:38

Do you mean specifically what issues we’re having? The children can’t play. They don’t know how. Their social interactions are very immature. I have experience across all early years ages and the level of social and emotional development I’m seeing in my classes now would be on par with just going into preschool or even toddler rooms! We also have a significant rise in speech and language referrals going in. This obviously doesn’t go for all of the children in our class - some of them are absolutely fine but overall the number of issues like this is much much higher.

Sorry, I’ve just seen this, ignore my last post. DD’s play skills are great but she can be a little overwhelming to other children I’ve noticed - she wants to be in charge, come up with the game and assign their roles 😳 she also seems to joke a lot with them and it lands flat, and then she gets confused as to why they don’t find her ‘jokes’ funny (just usual 4 year old toilet humour). Not sure if it’s a her thing or a them thing?

Rycbar · 26/01/2024 18:59

Naptrappedmummy · 26/01/2024 18:50

What do you mean emotional wrecks? Can you give a sort of example as to when you would expect a 4 year old to show resilience and they don’t? I’m not being facetious, just curious as I have a 4 year old and I don’t actually know that many kids so wondering if she would fall into this description.

Of course. For me the biggest thing is not being able to give things a go. ‘I can’t do it’ being said before absolutely everything without even trying. Giving up as soon as something is a bit difficult. We had children throwing pencils and books across the room because we’d asked them to complete a writing task (with support of course) and their confidence was so low they would
lash out. I sat in the corridor one day last year with a child repeatedly shouting no at me because I’d asked them to try and zip their coat themselves. And I emphasise the word try. That’s all I ask from my children - they try and still find it hard of course I’d step in. Another thing was the constant bickering. Little children are learning to share but the amount of ‘this person won’t do this or give me this’ was on another level! Someone brushing past them in the cloakroom would end up with them on the floor like they’d been shot saying they’d been pushed.

BogRollBOGOF · 26/01/2024 18:57

DS1 is now y8, so y4&5 were wiped out/ heavily affected... plus school dragged it out into y6 so they lost out on events and residentials for a bonus year. In his favour, he'd got his SEN diagnoses in 2019 before waiting lists went beserk. He's very bright but has some specific difficulties but academically caught up. He grudgingly functions through school, but would love to get away with living through a screen if he could get away with it. He's been taught at the age of 9-10 that socialising is some extraneous option in life despite the fact that I broke the law to take him and his friend out to play. Clearly it's not an important aspect in life if it can be prohibited.
I got him back into his extra-curriculars as soon as was viable.

DS2 is now y6 and just recovering this year. He lost half of y2 and chunks of y3. He's also had health issues through y4 & 5 that hit his attendance. Despite his brother's diagnoses, it's been a slog to get my concerns about his literacy difficulties taken seriously. We finally managed to get a dyslexia diagnosis in y5 and some support plus paying for a tutor this year- in comparison his brother was recieving targeted support from y2- just the point that DS lost access to education. There was online learning in y3- he sobbed on my lap daily throughout it, unable to follow the work and taunted by half the class being visible on screen. The other half of the class could be heard in our back garden during their break/ lunchtime just to rub it in. Being younger, he hadn't got a secure cluster of friends whose parents I could approach to ask about a spot of illegal socialising. It was y4 before he really had a best friend. That's just brought back a memory of him sobbing that he wanted best friends like he saw on the Pokémon cartoon. He started y3 unable to remember the people in his class, and the winter lockdown re-opened the split between children allowed to socialise or not.

I notice that DS2's class moved onto online communicating sooner than DS1's class. DS2 has just got a phone aged 10 and is one of the last if not the last. That's immediately opened up cans of worms, and I'm glad he wasn't younger, but it does reach a point that not having one becomes socially harmful anyway.

If your child isn't directly affected, that's great, but they are indirectly affected by children in their cohort who have lost education, have poor social skills etc. The toll of all the impacts of the lockdowns and social restrictions is then aggravated by the state of public services and support, that were already creaking and now seem to be beyond recovery. DS2's school attendance was affected until he saw a paediatric consultant. "Coz Covid" masked his underlying learning difficulties. Lack of assessment made him look average with weak spelling and masked his true profile of strengths, difficulties and masking. Keeping parents out of the school for 2½ years made it bloody difficult to have productive conversations to move the situation forwards.

My children are lucky that they've had security, time, parents that push and have resources. Many don't have those advantages and the lasting toll of the restrictions is far harder to heal.

Naptrappedmummy · 26/01/2024 18:50

Rycbar · 26/01/2024 12:36

Enormously. I teach Reception.
Last year the children had absolutely no resilience whatsoever. They were emotional wrecks - I felt like a social worker more than a teacher. This year it’s worse and next year is on a whole other level (I have them for nursery too). These were all babies during covid! My current nursery were born into it!

What do you mean emotional wrecks? Can you give a sort of example as to when you would expect a 4 year old to show resilience and they don’t? I’m not being facetious, just curious as I have a 4 year old and I don’t actually know that many kids so wondering if she would fall into this description.

Doppelgangers · 26/01/2024 18:47

Fitandfree · 26/01/2024 18:44

I'm a community worker. There is a marked difference between those whose parents stuck to the rules re socialisation, and those who didn't. I wish I hadn't.

I'll agree to that! Those who said fuck it to the rules definitely had the right idea in the long run, it's just a pity that anyone doing so at the time was shouted down and accused of being a granny killer, hindsight is a wonderful thing and I suspect many of those with children who have struggled since lockdowns wish they'd ignored the rules too. Sad

Fitandfree · 26/01/2024 18:44

I'm a community worker. There is a marked difference between those whose parents stuck to the rules re socialisation, and those who didn't. I wish I hadn't.

Baircasolly · 26/01/2024 18:31

Of course. Not just from lockdown, but from the bits in between lockdowns.

Teachers were so worried about how kids would cope back in school, we were possibly "too kind" to them. They are now finding it hard to adjust back towards "normal" rules.

They were "bubbled" away from older kids, so they didn't have role models, and they couldn't visualise past their exact age.

With some breathing space away from school, everyone started questioning everything that used to just be taken for granted (like school uniform, hair styles etc). Not necessarily a bad thing, but it leads to uncertainty in the short term at least. And it leads to a feeling that the adults aren't fully in charge, which is unsettling.

Then of course many kids had significant turmoil at home. And now there's a lot of financial uncertainty for many families. Most people's lives have changed significantly since 2019.

PTSDBarbiegirl · 26/01/2024 18:25

Huge issues in 5 & 6 year olds, speech and language issues, social communication issues, many more coming to school in nappies, mental health issues observable in the parents too.

Zanatdy · 26/01/2024 18:23

My daughter is about to sit her GCSE’s in spring and was in year 7 when covid hit. At the time she was 100% impacted from missing classes, and she developed a deep fear of online learning. So much so a week of online lessons a couple of months ago I had to lie and say she was sick as she stopped eating. She does have some anxiety though even prior to covid but I think social anxiety has been made worse. Academically though she’s flying now but a lot of that is from work she does herself, I’m literally trying to stop her studying so much rather than having to nag. I think covid will always have an impact on her.

My eldest who was in GCsE year when covid hit had his exams pulled just like that and seeing how hard DD is working now reminds me how hard he took it. He got all great grades but will always have people say it was because his grades were handed to him on a plate. Hopefully the fact he smashed his A levels with top grades proves that. My work colleagues and I also say we all feel like our life was on hold for a couple of years

MartinsSpareCalculator · 26/01/2024 18:22

I'm not a teacher but I volunteer with young people in secondary schools. The biggest difference I see is in communication skills and the ability to hold a conversation and make eye contact. Its now very refreshing to meet a 14yr old who can speak with some confidence. I think some children probably thrived in an online learning environment and for others it was just wrong in every way because they need the interaction.

Given how little resilience adults have shown themselves to have, it's hardly a surprise. The amount of kicking off and drama when an employer says they want people to return to the office, it stands to reason the same will be the case for children being in school.

HippoStraw · 26/01/2024 18:22

I’m not sure. I think it’s had an effect of course. However I think it lets the government off the hook for earlier austerity measures, underfunding of SEND, stopping of surestart etc.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 26/01/2024 18:19

GCSE results last year were lower than predicted and socially I feel my teens are behind as they missed out on so much socialising during the years they would normally gain independence.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 26/01/2024 18:16

She just gave up in year 11 along with many of her classmates, lots of them felt angry that they were still expected to carry on as normal when their GCSE years had been anything but.

Totally understandable.

loulouljh · 26/01/2024 18:14

Yes...so much learning missed which is very obvious now coming up to GCSEs. Kids think school is optional.

Confrontayshunme · 26/01/2024 18:10

I work in Reception and this year's cohort are SO behind in speech and language. Every school in our area is struggling. They missed so much of that early speech that you get from social communication, and even the parents who read with their children every day are saying their kids are struggling with phonics blending. I think a lot of them saw masks for so long that they don't know how to make or imitate simple mouth sounds.

Hecate01 · 26/01/2024 18:06

My dd is 18 now and was the first year not to get any leeway for exams despite missing year 10 completely and being off school more than in for year 11 due to the whole year having to isolate every time someone in the year had covid until track and trace did their stuff.

She just gave up in year 11 along with many of her classmates, lots of them felt angry that they were still expected to carry on as normal when their GCSE years had been anything but.

Her attitude towards education changed completely after covid and her personality in general has altered, she's a lot more anxious about life and I do believe her mental health has suffered as a result of lockdowns. She ended up with an ED and after counselling it emerged that she believed it was the only thing she had control of in her life at that time. Would it have happened if covid didn't exist? I can't answer that but I know she's not the same child she was before 2020.

MrsMurphyIWish · 26/01/2024 18:05

The worst cohort at my school is Yr 10. They lost Yr 6 at primary and spent Yr 7 in a bubble of 30 in the same classroom all year. Their behaviour is horrendous even now. I dread their exam results next year.

My own children are 12 (Yr 8) and 9 (Yr 5). They don’t seem affected at all and rarely mention Lockdown - they barely seem to remember it!

*DS’ autism diagnosis was delayed by two years but on a mental health point of view, he doesn’t seem to be affected.

bluesky45 · 26/01/2024 17:58

Forgot to say, I only have experience of primary years. I believe the mental health effects in secondary are massive too but no experience there

bluesky45 · 26/01/2024 17:56

Yes, seeing issues with current year 4s. Think they were reception/year 1 over the lockdowns. Friendship issues, DC still on wait lists for SEN referrals etc. They missed a lot of really key school time. Also lots of issues with current receptions. They were around their first birthday when the first lockdown hit. Lots of speech and development issues, lots of DC that missed out of those very early interventions etc. From my experience, those are the 2 most affected groups.

ParadiseLaundry · 26/01/2024 17:54

As for lockdown... doesn't anyone remember the shouting and insistence everywhere, including on here, that schools and nurseries were shut?

Absolutely. I'd be interested to hear what those people think now.

Allthecatseverywhereallatonce · 26/01/2024 17:51

My dd now 16 is in year 11and has been massively affected,she is anxious and has low moods,only has a couple of friends and much prefers to be alone. I am struggling to get her to go to school it is a daily battle. I am so worried about her GCSES she has missed some of her mocks this week.
I am pleading with the school to help me, I feel powerless. My 14 year old is not anxious but doesn't meet friends it is all online as per covid. He used to meet friends at the park but now he has no interest. Luckily I don't have to force him to school.
I really feel for the teachers it must be so hard on them working with these children.

PuttingDownRoots · 26/01/2024 17:47

There will be children that were fine before and fine after
There will be children who were fine but are still affected
There will be children who were fine, had a rough few years but are now back on track.
There are also children who weren't fine but now are

All are valid. But it happened. We can't pretend it didn't.

As for lockdown... doesn't anyone remember the shouting and insistence everywhere, including on here, that schools and nurseries were shut?

ParadiseLaundry · 26/01/2024 17:47

scalt · 26/01/2024 15:35

These harms were not caused by covid.
Nor were they caused by a pandemic.

They were caused by cruel and inhumane LOCKDOWNS, and an equally cruel and massively unnecessary campaign of fear, both of which went too far.

It is vital to remember this when anyone (especially the government) says “because of covid” or “because of the pandemic”. Nope, because of LOCKDOWNS. This is a hill I will die on.

100% this.

Most of us as a society (bar a few people who were shouted down) decided that all of the harm caused by the lockdowns was worth the trade off for 'keeping people safe from covid'