Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask teachers and parents if Covid still has an impact on kids four years on

289 replies

Backtoit123 · 26/01/2024 12:08

Just that really. Four years on don’t still notice a major effect on children from the pandemic. I’ve heard teenagers say they feel a few years younger due to their ‘pandemic age’ but my DC are grown up and I don’t work in teaching so it’s hard to know. Do you recognise a major difference in kids now compared to kids of the same age before Covid? AIBU to ask if the pandemic still has left a legacy on children’s development?
YABU- no it doesn’t
YANBU- yes it does

OP posts:
jamimmi · 27/01/2024 00:17

Mine have been effected yrs 8 and 12 in school. The year 8 now year 12 lost out on the social skills and friendships she would have made at secondary. She basically hit year 10 with no fixed friendship group and all the year 8 friends had changed in lock down. I remember her looking at me as if I was mad when I suggested a cinema trip alone with a friend in year 11 . She thought she couldn't go alone with no adult. Her prom last year was the first the school had had since her brothers 4 years before. The year 12 missed out on being a young adult at 6th form. No a.level exams , no parties, no little job. It impacted his uni years, made him less out going and unsure. He is now just about their in his last year. The damage to thos group is so obvious and often unseen. I think the result is a very different view on what's important in life and to achieve them.

NewYearNewCalendar · 26/01/2024 23:25

@Lovelydaytomorrow

I think it's really hard to say because so many of the things mentioned above were already being seen in education before covid, so I do wonder if covid is just being blamed for quite a bit.

Decline in behaviour at all age groups, lack of resilience, increase in anxiety, etc were all being flagged with all teachers I know before Covid even came into existence.

In particular, my lecturer friends were all agast at their fresher cohorts around 2018/19 with how much more parents were becoming involved in university education, lack of commitment, interest, stamina, resilience, and so on.

I think this is part of it too. I was managing fresh graduates in 2019-20, and it was really notable that compared to previous years their cohort struggled with resilience and motivation. I think a lot of these were existing trends, but much heightened and speeded up in 2020.

slithytoveisascientist · 26/01/2024 23:16

Affected my kids massively and we are still seeing the effects

DS11 struggles with being away from home / us - he was never like that before

DD9 was discharged from CAMHS as the service she was receiving was stopped, as a result her phobia and anxieties increased massively and our progress to a dx for neurodivergence was halted as she wasnt in school.

ProfessorPipsqueak · 26/01/2024 23:00

I can only speak for my children but no I don't think it has had long term effects on them. One is 14 the other almost 17. The eldest has asd and loved homeschooling but equally is doing well at school now. The youngest went a little bit loopy at some points during lockdown but is now a social butterfly living her best life, she isn't a fan of school for anything other than social reasons but that's just her nothing to do with lockdowns.

TrixieFatell · 26/01/2024 22:57

My eldest developed severe anxiety during the pandemic, she was 14 when it started. There was so much pressure on her year (the first year to take GCSE exams after the pandemic) to catch up and do well. She is doing great academically, she was always a high achiever but she felt the pressure.

My middle child not as affected, she was 11 when it started. Missed a lot of year 7, there were some issues with friends (she had some mean friends) but she has bounced back. No concerns academically or socially

My youngest would have been 4, had just started nursery before it all stopped. We had delays in getting seen by speech and language (his issues weren't caused by the pandemic, he has a stammer and was struggling to pronounce some sounds but it was hard to get seen as a result of the pandemic). By the time he was seen he had managed to pronounce sounds better. He has not been affected at all, is sociable and happy. Loves school.

Spangler · 26/01/2024 22:49

Rycbar · 26/01/2024 15:38

Do you mean specifically what issues we’re having? The children can’t play. They don’t know how. Their social interactions are very immature. I have experience across all early years ages and the level of social and emotional development I’m seeing in my classes now would be on par with just going into preschool or even toddler rooms! We also have a significant rise in speech and language referrals going in. This obviously doesn’t go for all of the children in our class - some of them are absolutely fine but overall the number of issues like this is much much higher.

Thank you, that is really interesting especially the part about being unable to play. I don’t see this with my DC or their friends/peers - though I’m not looking at it through the lens of someone who really knows what to look for.

I wonder how this would happen on a large scale with children who were babies when the lockdowns were most severe (obviously children missing school is totally different) if they had otherwise engaged parents. Especially as nurseries were open in 2021.

Sometimeswinning · 26/01/2024 22:31

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 26/01/2024 20:14

I’m sure there are other factors. Some of this was probably coming for us anyway. And screens are probably a big factor. But I’d still link that back to Covid. We forced our kids onto screens for lessons. For older children and teenagers, screens were the only way they could keep in touch with their friends. At a formative age, we taught them that their main way of interacting with the world should be via a screen.

Edited

Screens probably saved people from isolation. We often had a screen going where kids could dip in and out of to chat to their friends. We used them properly. Used the online academy, used twinkl etc. Dh and I were anxious over the deaths on the news and our elderly relatives but our children were protected from it.

It’s not Covid anymore. Unless something terrible happened in that time it’s the environment we’re in now. Or I’m just really lucky and have super resilient kids.

Futb0l · 26/01/2024 22:30

My kids are 4 & 7 and are fine. Eldest missed about 3 months of nursery due to lockdowns, it was a warm spring and he didnt care, we had loads of fun in the garden. I was on mat leave with youngest and they developed a lovely bond with dad while he was wfh.

Lemonademoney · 26/01/2024 22:19

Yes. I have three children of various ages and I work in a primary school. There are definitely still so many after effects both developmentally and academically and not enough funding in place to provide sufficient staff to support. Schools are at breaking point and staff retention is awful.

Lovelydaytomorrow · 26/01/2024 22:13

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 26/01/2024 21:40

I've never understood why so many people are so keen on WW2 comparisons when it comes to covid. It's particularly strange the way people seem to set them up as either/or when there's a whole cohort who lived through both who we can actually just ask about it. My loved one who remembers WW2 disliked lockdown more, because of the erosion of community.

You genuinely can't understand why people compare a period in our very resent history (Covid), where people lost civil liberies, were thrown into unprecedented times (God I hated that phrase at the time and still do), were fearful of the unknown, and where 'normal' life was completely interrupted and altered with the other time within living memory where people's everyday normal lives were thrown into chaos in WW2?

And we are now at a time where those who lived through WW2 are VERY elderly. I find it absolutely incredible that your loved one found 6 years of war, the death of millions and the constant threat of German occupation more favourable to a few months of lockdown.

I really, really struggled with the second lockdown. I would say it was probably the lowest point in my life. But to actually say it was less favourable to living through the war... I mean I wasn't there so I can't, but that's just unimaginable to me.

ShoePalaver · 26/01/2024 22:07

Confrontayshunme · 26/01/2024 18:10

I work in Reception and this year's cohort are SO behind in speech and language. Every school in our area is struggling. They missed so much of that early speech that you get from social communication, and even the parents who read with their children every day are saying their kids are struggling with phonics blending. I think a lot of them saw masks for so long that they don't know how to make or imitate simple mouth sounds.

The mask excuse is odd. No one wore masks at home surely and neither did nursery staff.... Masks were for supermarket visits and medical settings. Babies of 0-2 aren't going to be learning speech from random strangers in the supermarket.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 26/01/2024 21:40

Lovelydaytomorrow · 26/01/2024 21:21

I think it's really hard to say because so many of the things mentioned above were already being seen in education before covid, so I do wonder if covid is just being blamed for quite a bit.

Decline in behaviour at all age groups, lack of resilience, increase in anxiety, etc were all being flagged with all teachers I know before Covid even came into existence.

In particular, my lecturer friends were all agast at their fresher cohorts around 2018/19 with how much more parents were becoming involved in university education, lack of commitment, interest, stamina, resilience, and so on.

My own child is 4 and very, very shy. I could easy look back to him being in lock down at 18 months and blame it on that. But actually, I was SO painfully shy, as was my mum. And most of his preschool class are very outgoing. I don't see any issues in his development either.

Now I'm not saying that no one was effected: I've seen issues with OCD which clearly come from covid - ten year olds obsessive over 'germs' (genuine OCD that has huge life impacts) and I can't imagine being in lock down over some years of my life: first year at uni; 30s and single and not able to date.

But many generations before went through so much worse. Can you even imagine the impact of war on children? WW2 the country shut down 6 years: fathers left and never returned, teachers had 40-50 in a class; the terror of air raids and sleeping in shelters; evacuation. And yet, 20 years ago we weren't questioning how impacted the older generation were by this, they were just stories to recount.

I've never understood why so many people are so keen on WW2 comparisons when it comes to covid. It's particularly strange the way people seem to set them up as either/or when there's a whole cohort who lived through both who we can actually just ask about it. My loved one who remembers WW2 disliked lockdown more, because of the erosion of community.

Swishswish26 · 26/01/2024 21:36

@scalt I literally couldn’t agree more. Lockdowns caused all of this harm to children when they were the ones who were largely unaffected. I can barely think back without feeling so much anger. My ds and dd are reasonably fortunate in that they have bounced back fairly well-both socially and academically. However there are so many children in their year groups (I have one dc in primary and one dc in secondary) that are still suffering hugely from eating disorders and anxiety which were absolutely a direct result of lockdown. Interestingly the worst children affected had parents who wouldn’t allow them to see other dc at all during lockdowns when rules relaxed a little- for a walk, for a play in the park etc and were shadows of themselves when rules were eased completely. Lives ruined and for what?!

Lovelydaytomorrow · 26/01/2024 21:21

I think it's really hard to say because so many of the things mentioned above were already being seen in education before covid, so I do wonder if covid is just being blamed for quite a bit.

Decline in behaviour at all age groups, lack of resilience, increase in anxiety, etc were all being flagged with all teachers I know before Covid even came into existence.

In particular, my lecturer friends were all agast at their fresher cohorts around 2018/19 with how much more parents were becoming involved in university education, lack of commitment, interest, stamina, resilience, and so on.

My own child is 4 and very, very shy. I could easy look back to him being in lock down at 18 months and blame it on that. But actually, I was SO painfully shy, as was my mum. And most of his preschool class are very outgoing. I don't see any issues in his development either.

Now I'm not saying that no one was effected: I've seen issues with OCD which clearly come from covid - ten year olds obsessive over 'germs' (genuine OCD that has huge life impacts) and I can't imagine being in lock down over some years of my life: first year at uni; 30s and single and not able to date.

But many generations before went through so much worse. Can you even imagine the impact of war on children? WW2 the country shut down 6 years: fathers left and never returned, teachers had 40-50 in a class; the terror of air raids and sleeping in shelters; evacuation. And yet, 20 years ago we weren't questioning how impacted the older generation were by this, they were just stories to recount.

ASundayWellSpent · 26/01/2024 21:14

I don't find my own daughters to be particularly impacted, but I believe that is due to the way that they experienced the lockdowns etc.

However the Year 4 class I teach are MASSIVELY affected. Of course, it is not all of them but a good 80%. There is no easy comparison as we can't see what they would have been like without the pandemic. But you can absolutely tell that they missed Reception and a good chunk of year 1 both in their academic level, resilience, emotional intelligence and addiction to screens.

AuntMarch · 26/01/2024 21:09

I was on maternity leave when lockdown started, I'd been working in a school with eyfs/ks1 children before that. I didn't go back for long (changed jobs to be nearer home).

I just recently started a similar job in a different school with ks1. These children just seem young compared to the same age group before. Particularly socially and as far as speech and language development goes.
Of course it's a tiny sample size and purely anecdotal, but the teaching staff say the same when considering their pre-covid classes in comparison to their current ones.

Particularly, the gap between disadvantaged children and their peers seems wider than ever.

TitusMoan · 26/01/2024 21:08

AnnieRegent · 26/01/2024 19:59

Genuine question for those who work with kids/young people. From reading threads like this, it seems clear that behaviour, resilience, anxiety etc has all noticeably changed in the last few years. I can’t help but wonder how much of this is a result of how much time both parents and teens are spending on the internet and social media.

e.g. Some people are mentioning long waits for autism assessments- presumably this is partly a result of higher parental awareness?

Uni students unable to engage - is this partly because they’re very used to staring at screens all the time, much more than previous generations did?

Four years olds without resilience - anything to do with current parenting trends?

I have no doubt that lockdown has had an effect on certain cohorts, but I do wonder if a lot of this would have happened anyway. The way people communicate and consume information has changed. However I don’t have kids - would love to hear what the professionals think.

Also of course lockdown and the internet are connected, as people spent a lot more time indoors!

This is such a great post with so much to think about, as is the subsequent one mentioning the possibility of screen withdrawal. The lockdowns forced everyone on to screens for much longer than previously. Work, school, news, leisure - hugely reliant on internet.

Abbimae · 26/01/2024 21:05

No . This media rubbish adding a year every year ‘oh they have missed 3 years of school’ is garbage. Mollycoddling kids most have forgot it even happened.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 26/01/2024 21:04

Sometimeswinning · 26/01/2024 20:56

It’s relevant because there are many who for some reason thrived. My 3 loved it. I enjoyed homeschooling so much I became a TA. The op was not asking for all negative responses. I look around my friendship and family group with their children and there are no after effects.

I thought we had very few after effects too, until recently. I think some of the longer term effects were not immediately obvious, and I think we’ve probably got more to come. Children missed out on chunks of development. The effect that has on their ability to cope with life as they get older may only become apparent as they, well, get older. I don’t mean that to sound dismissive by the way - I’m sure not all children were negatively affected. But I really do think that the knock on effects of lockdowns will be with us for years to come. We did a proper number on our kids, and on ourselves.

BoPeepsSheep · 26/01/2024 20:57

Perhaps none that you know about.

I can say with confidence that our friends have very little idea what we have been through with DD2.

Sometimeswinning · 26/01/2024 20:56

Doppelgangers · 26/01/2024 12:46

Then I'd consider you and your children very fortunate but I'm not sure why you think your tiny sample size is relevant or pertinent to the question asked?

It’s relevant because there are many who for some reason thrived. My 3 loved it. I enjoyed homeschooling so much I became a TA. The op was not asking for all negative responses. I look around my friendship and family group with their children and there are no after effects.

BoPeepsSheep · 26/01/2024 20:39

A 300% increase in the number of referrals for autism assessment has not been accompanied by any increased funding for staff. And even if it could be staffed, there are no extra clinic rooms for the appointments.

There are a great many reasons for this increase. The sorry state of CAMHS means that people are referring to paediatrics because there’s no hope of being seen by CAMHS, or because they’ve waited so long that the mental Heath issues have worsened so that it may look like a neurodevelopmental condition when it’s actually untreated MH.

Also, a combination of increased screen use and decreased social interaction has led to greater prevalence of social communication difficulties, again that can look like autism and is indeed one of features of the condition.

Parents are ‘internet savvy’ and ‘know their rights.’ They get their children referred in, and when they are found not to have a diagnosis, parents go down lengthy complaint routes to say that they disagree with the clinicians who made the decision. And rather than being able to turn around and nip that in the bud with ‘we are qualified to make that decision, and you are not’ the clinical teams are instead forced to spend untold numbers of hours dealing with their complaint, to the detriment of the children who need their turn to be assessed.

The ‘second opinion’ then agrees with the findings of the original team, which proves what a stupendous waste of time the whole ‘respond to this complaint’ charade was. And so the waiting list grows.

Lastly, the huge increase in immigration has an effect.

lieselotte · 26/01/2024 20:37

Jonahseyebrows · 26/01/2024 20:36

I agree with this and thank you for saying it.

I also agree.

lieselotte · 26/01/2024 20:37

Fitandfree · 26/01/2024 18:44

I'm a community worker. There is a marked difference between those whose parents stuck to the rules re socialisation, and those who didn't. I wish I hadn't.

Also between elderly people who ignored the rules, went out, and saw people, and are still functioning well for their age, and those who hid indoors or were forced indoors (care homes) and now have dementia, anxiety and lack of physical ability.

Jonahseyebrows · 26/01/2024 20:36

scalt · 26/01/2024 19:27

I feel so angry about the way it was so obvious from the very beginning that everything discussed here would happen, yet it was all brushed aside; and anybody who dared to speak up was instantly labelled a granny-murdering psychopath, including (and perhaps especially) on Mumsnet. Yet, here we are. I feel incandescent with rage about this every day. The only government I will consider voting for is one which admits that lockdowns caused massive damage; which will probably be none of them. Meanwhile, the inquiry (vomit) appears to be setting out to cement the narrative of "we should have locked down harder, faster, longer, and we will next time, because there will be a next time".

I agree with this and thank you for saying it.