Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask teachers and parents if Covid still has an impact on kids four years on

289 replies

Backtoit123 · 26/01/2024 12:08

Just that really. Four years on don’t still notice a major effect on children from the pandemic. I’ve heard teenagers say they feel a few years younger due to their ‘pandemic age’ but my DC are grown up and I don’t work in teaching so it’s hard to know. Do you recognise a major difference in kids now compared to kids of the same age before Covid? AIBU to ask if the pandemic still has left a legacy on children’s development?
YABU- no it doesn’t
YANBU- yes it does

OP posts:
glusky · 27/01/2024 11:45

zingally · 27/01/2024 10:56

I work in education - 16 years now - and to be honest. No, not any more.

I feel like we turned the corner this past September, and had been well on the way for the previous 6 months.

I feel like a bit the lone voice though. But I can honestly say that the kids I see these days aren't any different to the kids I was teaching pre-covid.

@zingally what age group do you teach? Kids who were at secondary in lockdown, ones who were babies, or in between?

BlueRidgeMountain · 27/01/2024 11:28

for DS1 it’s triggered OCD. He was in school (keyworker), but the only one in his year for some time, so was very isolated, until they made the decision to put him with the year group above (still only 4 kids). He had to wash hands every 20mins as per government guidance wtf did they think he was touching in a classroom on his own with a teacher all day? His OCD escalated to the point his hands were red raw, and was an anxiety ridden mess - he honestly thought he was going to die and loved lockdown in fear. we had to access private counselling as CAMHS waiting lists were too long.

DS2 benefited from the small class size he had - is autistic so got a lot of 1-1, and frankly enjoyed the quiet in school. However, he’d been referred for ADHD assessment and thanks to lockdowns had to wait 3.5years to be assessed, and now a further 6 month wait for medication appointment.

totally agree with pp - it’s not covid that’s responsible but the lockdowns.

All2Well · 27/01/2024 11:26

I'm a university lecturer, wanting to get out now pretty much due to the fact I can no longer do my actual job as it now is more like being a mental health nurse/nanny.

I don't get lunch breaks or time to plan my lectures or do any research because students arrive constantly outside my office or lecture theatre door in states of blind panic/threaten self harm or suicide/or are extremely paranoid about someone looking at them funny or something they've seen on social media that may be aimed at them.

It has spiralled out of all control in the past 3 years and is getting worse.

They can't cope socially. They can't cope with deadlines. They can't not be on their phones and when I ask them to put them away while I'm teaching, I get a complaint made about me. They can't work together. They can't work independently. They want deadlines moved, attendance made optional, assessment methods changed. They complain about everything...from reading being online to reading not being online, to having to do their own research rather than going to the library themselves. It's not a minority, it's a vast VAST majority.

My job is unrecognisable. These are no longer young adults. They are adult children. Most of my 20 year olds are stuck at what age 13/14 used to be. And I can't be mother to all of them. I just can't anymore.

morechocolateneededtoday · 27/01/2024 11:20

As a professional (medical, not teaching) I can say with certainty there is still a cohort of society who are feeling the impact and will do for a while. We see it in patients and also more recently qualified staff who’s courses were affected by lockdowns (more other health professionals than doctors)

As a parent, I have been fortunate my children were on the younger side. It was hell juggling work with a 1 and 3 year old when we locked down almost 4 years ago. Fortunately the older one thrived and we had them back in nursery by lockdown 2021 to help catch up. They are however still suffering the consequence of a medical issue that was not diagnosed properly thanks to lockdowns. I did a lot of socialising with younger one when things opened up and really invested in trying to catch up with what they missed - I am lucky that I had the time and money to do this. At the point of starting school, I felt like they were on an equal footing to their older sibling.

zingally · 27/01/2024 10:56

I work in education - 16 years now - and to be honest. No, not any more.

I feel like we turned the corner this past September, and had been well on the way for the previous 6 months.

I feel like a bit the lone voice though. But I can honestly say that the kids I see these days aren't any different to the kids I was teaching pre-covid.

Arbor · 27/01/2024 10:43

ParadiseLaundry · 27/01/2024 09:20

@Arbor were you in favour of shutting schools then?

I think it was a reasonable measure at the time, yes. The shorter the closure period, the better, of course.

buckeejit · 27/01/2024 09:47

This is interesting. My dd10 is a completely different child-she was diagnosed with inflammatory bowel disease towards the 'end' of Covid, symptoms started around beginning of Covid & both my parents died during & then a year ago so she had a lot of stress & I'm really hoping she's starting to improve & get back to some of the happy child she once was

ParadiseLaundry · 27/01/2024 09:20

@Arbor were you in favour of shutting schools then?

Arbor · 27/01/2024 09:18

@scalt

And if anyone says to me "you sound angry": yes I am, and I am not ashamed of that at all. And I expect millions of other people are as well. Widespread public anger is one of the many legacies of those lockdowns which some people pleaded for.

Did they? I didn't see evidence of that. Re: the rest of your post, you're aware that the measures were largely the same - if not more lax - than countries elsewhere?

EasternStandard · 27/01/2024 08:57

scalt · 27/01/2024 08:55

Anger might not change what happened. But it might change a future government’s approach. This is why I think that it is vital that we show our anger about this, and not simply say “oh well”. I think there should have been much more anger about the consequences of lockdowns at the time. What I found far more terrifying than any virus was how easily the public keeled over, and allowed the government to treat us like this; and how lockdowns were instituted with no parliamentary scrutiny, no cost benefit analysis, no exit plan, no acknowledgement of the massive harms which were staring everybody in the face.

There’s a Covid page to feedback. I know it’s not much but let them know the damage. It’s better than just on here

Did you see mn at the time btw? Generally the effort was to close people down, it was bad

scalt · 27/01/2024 08:55

PuttingDownRoots · 27/01/2024 08:19

I will admit I am angry at the government. Not for the initial March 2020 lockdown... that was inevitable with the fear sweeping the world not just UK.

But for the mismanagement that cam afterwards. For not prioritising education... and when they did, just a small number of year groups. For underfunding education and health care prior to 2020. For the stuff that emerged afterwards like the parties and so on. Then closing the schools again.

However being angry won't change that. It happened, we have to deal with the consequences.

Anger might not change what happened. But it might change a future government’s approach. This is why I think that it is vital that we show our anger about this, and not simply say “oh well”. I think there should have been much more anger about the consequences of lockdowns at the time. What I found far more terrifying than any virus was how easily the public keeled over, and allowed the government to treat us like this; and how lockdowns were instituted with no parliamentary scrutiny, no cost benefit analysis, no exit plan, no acknowledgement of the massive harms which were staring everybody in the face.

PuttingDownRoots · 27/01/2024 08:19

I will admit I am angry at the government. Not for the initial March 2020 lockdown... that was inevitable with the fear sweeping the world not just UK.

But for the mismanagement that cam afterwards. For not prioritising education... and when they did, just a small number of year groups. For underfunding education and health care prior to 2020. For the stuff that emerged afterwards like the parties and so on. Then closing the schools again.

However being angry won't change that. It happened, we have to deal with the consequences.

wonderinglywondering · 27/01/2024 08:09

I'll add as well it's not just kids as others have said - it's young adults who were late teens when this happened. In my work we hire graduates - the overwhelming majority flat out refuse to attend an office (i don't want to, but it's in my contract so I have to suck it up!) have no respect for deadlines, never have their cameras on, always on mute, basically no real idea how work, works. I think it's because they went through the end of uni on Zoom/had exams cancelled, so haven't really had the introduction to the adult world properly? So you can't just say you couldn't get the work done, and there be no consequences whereas in lockdown we all kind of got free passes (I know I did, becsuse we were all in a difficult situation). I'm not blaming them, it's just the effect the lockdowns had on that age group.

wonderinglywondering · 27/01/2024 07:56

Yes. My DD started Reception in 2020 and because until 2022 she never did a full year in school thanks to lockdowns and people testing healthy children, therefore resulting in the entire class being sent home, she has severe separation anxiety and every day it's a battle of tears and meltdowns and shaking to get her into school.

My BIL works in SEN and he says the amount of children he sees with anxiety, behaviour issues or undiagnosed SEN has massively increased since the pandemic.

My sister has autism & ADHD and was doing her A-Levels. Because her routine was disrupted and she was locked in her house with no friends etc she became massively depressed, angry and unstable and attempted to harm my stepmother and herself.

I'll never lock down again.

Naptrappedmummy · 27/01/2024 07:49

The world wars were FAR worse than covid! Men being sent away to be brutally slaughtered in their hundreds of thousands, knowing a foreign enemy was looking to invade the country and likely commit mass murder/rape, evacuated children staying with families they barely (or didn’t) know, rationing of food, entire towns and cities absolutely levelled by aerial bombings campaigns.

Literally no comparison AT ALL.

EasternStandard · 27/01/2024 07:35

I would have liked more on this at the time. This site was very different. People couldn’t hear about this damage

And as pp mentioned the inquiry won’t help much either, it’s focussed on the same things not the damage

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 27/01/2024 07:35

Lovelydaytomorrow · 26/01/2024 22:13

You genuinely can't understand why people compare a period in our very resent history (Covid), where people lost civil liberies, were thrown into unprecedented times (God I hated that phrase at the time and still do), were fearful of the unknown, and where 'normal' life was completely interrupted and altered with the other time within living memory where people's everyday normal lives were thrown into chaos in WW2?

And we are now at a time where those who lived through WW2 are VERY elderly. I find it absolutely incredible that your loved one found 6 years of war, the death of millions and the constant threat of German occupation more favourable to a few months of lockdown.

I really, really struggled with the second lockdown. I would say it was probably the lowest point in my life. But to actually say it was less favourable to living through the war... I mean I wasn't there so I can't, but that's just unimaginable to me.

It's because it's invariably used as a way to try and relativise the negative experiences of lockdown. So actually, yeah, I suppose actually I do know exactly why it so often gets trotted out. Wartime analogies are like a reflex. This isn't the first thread where this has happened either. Yet the fact is that the experience of withdrawal of community during lockdown isn't at all like wartime. A lot of people's experiences during that period would've been more communal, if anything.

Still, I'll be sure to tell my loved one that someone on the internet says they're doing it wrong.

Mynewnameis · 27/01/2024 07:17

voxnihili · 27/01/2024 07:01

I’m a deputy headteacher in a secondary school. For us, and other schools locally, this year has been the worst. Mostly with the younger ones coming through. SEN that hasn’t been diagnosed - presumably because services were shut down and now waiting lists are so long. Behaviour is like nothing I’ve ever seen in my 20 years in schools.

I think we’ll be feeling the effects for many years. I remember at the time feeling really bad for our year 10s and 11s who missed out on so much in their GCSE years but I now think they’re the ones who probably were least affected.

I feel for secondary teachers. This September my daughter will start and her and many others in her peer group are far from ready. Just been referred to neurodevelopment pathway with a 3 year wait. Many things missed due to covid, then blamed on missing school. I'm trying to get her all the help I can before September but having to go private.

BurnoutGP · 27/01/2024 07:03

scalt · 27/01/2024 06:52

The government took measures to keep us "healthy and alive"????

Alive, maybe, at a stretch. Perhaps more "existing", but not living. For many, lockdown was an extremely miserable existence, especially granny whom the state seemed determined to keep alive, while she was forcibly separated from her own family. And as this thread shows, are our children now enjoying great mental and physical health?? What exactly do we have to show for the miserable months of lockdown, that made it so vital? Some people might have been spared dying of the virus (and I haven't forgotten the deliberate confusion of those who died "with covid" and "of covid"), but they are now dying of other things in massive numbers, including suicide, which the government is keeping very quiet about, when the government wiped out their thriving businesses in one day. NHS mental health services are now stretched even more than before, as a direct result of the beloved lockdowns which we were ironically gaslighted told were to "protect the NHS". The very same lockdowns which Boris Johnson and his staff thought were beneath them: perhaps they knew that something we didn't, such as the virus being nowhere near as deadly as they were telling the public.

Also, I haven't forgotten the constant government gaslighting about how long this full-frontal mental assault would last, and at times, there was no end in sight at all. "Reviewed in three weeks" became "in twelve weeks, we can send the virus packing" which became "we need to squeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeze the brakes on reopening" (Boris Johnson in August 2020 - I ditched Radio 4 after that) which became "normalish by Christmas" which became "it would be inhumane to cancel Christmas - oops, I've just done it" which became "significant normality by Easter" which became "irreversible roadmap to freedom in June" which became "oops, July". If, instead of all this, they had admitted early on that lockdowns could not control the virus, and were causing much more harm than good, and opted for a common sense approach of protecting the vulnerable instead while everybody else carried on, I would have far more respect for the government now. It might have made them briefly unpopular, but look at where they are now.

One impact that this has had on me is that it will be decades before I can believe, respect or trust anything that any government says again, because of the constant, constant lying and covering up from those at the top, now that this government has set such a massive precedent. In a world where people can be jailed for lying about who was driving a speeding car, you would think that those who had much greater responsibilities (i.e. the Prime Minister) should be imprisoned for telling far bigger lies than that.

And if anyone says to me "you sound angry": yes I am, and I am not ashamed of that at all. And I expect millions of other people are as well. Widespread public anger is one of the many legacies of those lockdowns which some people pleaded for.

I don't know about angry. You sound quite mad. Of course the covid conspiracies come out to play.
Ypu do know that both ca. Be correct. Covid was and is a seriously dangerous disease and lockdown at the same time was necessary and damaging.
Unless you have a particular knowledge of the initial covid modelling then you really can't comment.

voxnihili · 27/01/2024 07:01

I’m a deputy headteacher in a secondary school. For us, and other schools locally, this year has been the worst. Mostly with the younger ones coming through. SEN that hasn’t been diagnosed - presumably because services were shut down and now waiting lists are so long. Behaviour is like nothing I’ve ever seen in my 20 years in schools.

I think we’ll be feeling the effects for many years. I remember at the time feeling really bad for our year 10s and 11s who missed out on so much in their GCSE years but I now think they’re the ones who probably were least affected.

BurnoutGP · 27/01/2024 06:59

Oblomov23 · 26/01/2024 17:07

No. Not for any of the dc I know.

So you know all their personal difficulties? Self harm? Anxiety? Sleep? Physical issues?
Don't be daft.

BurnoutGP · 27/01/2024 06:58

Aishah231 · 26/01/2024 19:29

Covid itself hasn't left a lasting impact. The lockdowns absolutely have. We must never let that happen to our children again. Lockdowns were a choice not every government made.

Well ypu couldn't be more wrong. I'm a medic and I see the long lasting physical consequences of covid daily.
Let's not fall into the trap of pretending it was/is a benign disease.
I've been a doctor for 30 odd years and have never see anything like it.
Just because you escaped don't be foolish enough to believe everyone did.
One of my children really was damaged by lockdown. That doesn't mean it was wrong.

scalt · 27/01/2024 06:52

Arbor · 27/01/2024 00:39

You're so angry at the Government for taking measures to keep you and your loved ones healthy and alive?

The government took measures to keep us "healthy and alive"????

Alive, maybe, at a stretch. Perhaps more "existing", but not living. For many, lockdown was an extremely miserable existence, especially granny whom the state seemed determined to keep alive, while she was forcibly separated from her own family. And as this thread shows, are our children now enjoying great mental and physical health?? What exactly do we have to show for the miserable months of lockdown, that made it so vital? Some people might have been spared dying of the virus (and I haven't forgotten the deliberate confusion of those who died "with covid" and "of covid"), but they are now dying of other things in massive numbers, including suicide, which the government is keeping very quiet about, when the government wiped out their thriving businesses in one day. NHS mental health services are now stretched even more than before, as a direct result of the beloved lockdowns which we were ironically gaslighted told were to "protect the NHS". The very same lockdowns which Boris Johnson and his staff thought were beneath them: perhaps they knew that something we didn't, such as the virus being nowhere near as deadly as they were telling the public.

Also, I haven't forgotten the constant government gaslighting about how long this full-frontal mental assault would last, and at times, there was no end in sight at all. "Reviewed in three weeks" became "in twelve weeks, we can send the virus packing" which became "we need to squeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeze the brakes on reopening" (Boris Johnson in August 2020 - I ditched Radio 4 after that) which became "normalish by Christmas" which became "it would be inhumane to cancel Christmas - oops, I've just done it" which became "significant normality by Easter" which became "irreversible roadmap to freedom in June" which became "oops, July". If, instead of all this, they had admitted early on that lockdowns could not control the virus, and were causing much more harm than good, and opted for a common sense approach of protecting the vulnerable instead while everybody else carried on, I would have far more respect for the government now. It might have made them briefly unpopular, but look at where they are now.

One impact that this has had on me is that it will be decades before I can believe, respect or trust anything that any government says again, because of the constant, constant lying and covering up from those at the top, now that this government has set such a massive precedent. In a world where people can be jailed for lying about who was driving a speeding car, you would think that those who had much greater responsibilities (i.e. the Prime Minister) should be imprisoned for telling far bigger lies than that.

And if anyone says to me "you sound angry": yes I am, and I am not ashamed of that at all. And I expect millions of other people are as well. Widespread public anger is one of the many legacies of those lockdowns which some people pleaded for.

jernensi · 27/01/2024 01:16

My dd is 5 and she was just under 2 at the time of the first lockdown. I worried a lot about her missing out on social interaction at the time as she had been doing toddler classes every day, and made sure we got out to parks every day, and I enrolled her in a nursery in June 2020 (once they allowed non-keyworker dcs to attend) just to allow her to have social contact and structured activities (I'm a sahm so didn't need it for childcare). Once she was in nursery she was fairly unaffected by restrictions - they stayed open even when schools and other activities were closed. I was proactive in taking her to any activities that were open on non-nursery days.

She seems fine now and doesn't remember much about it at all. She attends a prep school in an affluent part of London and all her school friends are thriving, and behaviour and concentration isn't a concern. I expect that most of the dcs there attended nursery and were fairly unaffected by lockdowns, and some families have nannies so they wouldn't have been trying to wfh and look after toddlers themselves. There are a lot of international families so many of them might have been in countries with less restrictions too.

I think a lot of parents with dcs the same age chose not to send them to nursery (even free state school nurseries) as some local nurseries which used to be heavily sought-after were advertising vacancies in the past few years. So I expect those kids missed out on the socialisation and early years education and that would show an impact on current Year 1 pupils. But there was nothing in the restrictions or policies which forced that to happen - the nurseries were open and had places available.

Arbor · 27/01/2024 00:39

Swishswish26 · 26/01/2024 21:36

@scalt I literally couldn’t agree more. Lockdowns caused all of this harm to children when they were the ones who were largely unaffected. I can barely think back without feeling so much anger. My ds and dd are reasonably fortunate in that they have bounced back fairly well-both socially and academically. However there are so many children in their year groups (I have one dc in primary and one dc in secondary) that are still suffering hugely from eating disorders and anxiety which were absolutely a direct result of lockdown. Interestingly the worst children affected had parents who wouldn’t allow them to see other dc at all during lockdowns when rules relaxed a little- for a walk, for a play in the park etc and were shadows of themselves when rules were eased completely. Lives ruined and for what?!

Edited

You're so angry at the Government for taking measures to keep you and your loved ones healthy and alive?