Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask teachers and parents if Covid still has an impact on kids four years on

289 replies

Backtoit123 · 26/01/2024 12:08

Just that really. Four years on don’t still notice a major effect on children from the pandemic. I’ve heard teenagers say they feel a few years younger due to their ‘pandemic age’ but my DC are grown up and I don’t work in teaching so it’s hard to know. Do you recognise a major difference in kids now compared to kids of the same age before Covid? AIBU to ask if the pandemic still has left a legacy on children’s development?
YABU- no it doesn’t
YANBU- yes it does

OP posts:
DappledThings · 28/01/2024 13:35

I don't think my own children were affected at all. They are year 1 and year 3 now. DC1 missed a bit of reception due to lockdown but we did OK.

But on a population level I'm sure it's different. Not sure why the current year R that are being referenced would affected though. They were still really little when everything was open again.

TempsPerdu · 28/01/2024 13:30

DD is 6 and thankfully largely unscathed. We were lucky; DP and I took a very laid back (some would say lax) approach to covid, and as an ex-teacher with a good grounding in child development I was hyper aware of the potential impact of lockdown, so we did everything we humanly could to mitigate this. I consider myself incredibly fortunate to have been able to be at home with DD during this period.

But for the other children we know it’s a very different story. I am a governor and volunteer at DD’s school. They are massively struggling with the children across the whole age range - lots of anxiety/MH issues at the upper end, and lots of social and developmental issues and undiagnosed special needs (especially speech delay etc) at the lower end.

Observing parties and play dates with DD it often feels like the other children are 1-2 years younger than her in terms of social development and general maturity - still lots of meltdowns and tantrums, children unable to communicate their needs effectively or cope with change etc.

crochetmonkey74 · 28/01/2024 13:24

This thread is making me feel better. I'm in secondary and the amount of parental complaints is through the roof about perfectly normal things , like a late detention.
Also students email staff directly with complaints or perceived slights from other students , but they report it as really dramatic. I have never known anything like it. Its making the job unsustainable

EasternStandard · 28/01/2024 13:11

This thread is like seeing sanity return, I would have loved more of this at the time. It was horrendous if you spoke up

Singlepringle1980 · 28/01/2024 12:33

Teens who couldn’t socialise for 2 years have missed a huge amount of key milestones. I have two who are much less independent than I was at the same age. The little things that help build confidence in early teen years (days out with friends, using public transport, mixing in groups, part time work, learning to drive) were delayed and they’re catching up on things now and doing some for the first time that should have been regular occurences. I feel lucky mine haven’t suffered major mental health issues - I know lots have, but there is an underlying anxiety that my generation never experienced. The day schools closed left my eldest in shock and unable to sleep for days. The pandemic was unsettling for many adults who had much more life experience than kids to draw on.

Irishmama100 · 28/01/2024 12:32

My son thrived in lockdown and because my business was closed I dedicated all my time to educating him one on one he went back to school in a much better place with his reading/writing/ spelling being improved dramatically. It gave him a new confidence. I really feel for parents who just couldn’t do this. My husband was frontline worker and worked flat out and if we both had been in that position it would have been a very different story. So can see how different situations would impact children differently.

CoalCraft · 28/01/2024 10:20

I had one baby in Nov 2020, so right in the middle of the pandemic, and one in Aug 22 so after most restrictions had lifted. The difference in the pregnancy /birth and postnatal experience was huge but I wouldn't say it's had a lasting effect now.

Am sure it'd have a much greater impact on older children that were more aware of it.

napody · 28/01/2024 10:14

Illstartexercisingtomorrow · 27/01/2024 22:04

I feel so sorry for the kids who were starting secondary school or university when lockdown came. My friend’s daughter basically met no one and had zero university experience. So much of school and education is also about socialising and having opportunities outside of academics. Of course it must still affect many of them.

I thought at the time and still think the great harm from lockdown outweighed the benefits- which we will pay for in many ways for years.

Regarding school, I have gone from being a parent who would never ever let the kids be off school to simply not caring that much. After all it was suddenly deemed acceptable that they lost huge chunks of their education so quite frankly if that’s ok then it’s also ok for me to let the kids have days off more easily. I don’t play truant, but I am quite happy to take them on holiday in term time, and certainly softer on them if they are under the weather in allowing them to stay at home. They are primary age though, so perhaps I’ll feel differently at secondary.

I totally get this from am individual level.

The problem is it doesn't work on a population level. We can only educate kids on ratios of 1:30 with massive levels of compliance and attending to that social contract.
Covid absence was different because they were all absent! If theyre all absent at different times it's impossible to get large groups like that to progress in the same way. If they had a 1:1 tutor that tutor would pick up where they left off. It doesn't work like that for whole classes. They need to be all in, or all out (I.e. homeschooled).

napody · 28/01/2024 10:10

ThatsGoingToHurt · 26/01/2024 12:56

It’s still having an impact on both my kids even though they are both very young as there are still massive NHS delays in treatment as they haven’t caught up.

I have a lockdown baby who is due to start school in September 2024. Pre covid the under 5’s autism waitlist was under a year. Now it is 3.5 years. DS has also been on the waitlist for for speech and language therapy for 2 years. I am imaging there will be a lot of children born between Sept 19 and Aug 20 have not received early help and will be starting school not ready as a result.

This is true, but austerity and cuts also come into this.

I think Covid has exacerbated things, school attendance is the big one. And many children (particularly y2-6 now) missed really sensitive periods in their development. We had reception kids starting immediately post pandemic that didn't understand pointing - that's a really distinct theory of mind development.

Teenage emotional problems were increasing pre pandemic (recent research on this) but yup, the pandemic has made it worse for some.

Some probably realised they were happier studying at home, hated school and even though they're now school avoiding their wellbeing is actually better- as it was for some during the pandemic!

But as for services being overwhelmed... we have to go back to austerity policies for that one. Sure start etc too.... infants from disadvantaged backgrounds were already losing out pre pandemic, and that effect becomes gradually apparent over a period of years.

It's complicated.

zingally · 28/01/2024 09:59

glusky · 27/01/2024 11:45

@zingally what age group do you teach? Kids who were at secondary in lockdown, ones who were babies, or in between?

I work across the entire primary phase. So my current receptions were babies, and my year 6 kids were Yr2/Yr3.

I had a Year 1 class at the time of the first lockdown, and they are in Yr5 now.

wonderinglywondering · 28/01/2024 05:56

Tooolde · 27/01/2024 20:45

@wonderinglywondering If a child (with an aunt ? With asd and adhd) is anxious about school to that extent it may not just be separation anxiety. ??
My dd1 did the 10d of into to reception ok after that it was drsgging her in. She got better after a few months. Bht still hates school and has asd/adhd referral...

Yes the lockdowns and in and outs of schools wont have helped many kids settle but if you do have ND relative it may not be the lockdowns

Edited

It's very interesting you say that as just this week I've met with a psychotherapist who agrees with you - I did try to raise this concern with a GP (when I could get an appointment) but she dismissed it as separation anxiety! Thank you, it is reassuring to hear that even strangers hearing a tiny bit about her can see the potential for her to be ND.

and it might have been picked up earlier if she'd had been in school solidly!

phlebasconsidered · 27/01/2024 22:19

As a teacher I could go on an on.about this, but will limit myself to saying that the cohort last year suffered from the grade boundaries being whacked right up again in Englans (Scotland and Wales were fairer). And they are likely going to go up again.this year. I find this quite heartless given that these are students who were at home for such a long time in the real building block years for maths and english.

The amount that failed last year was daft. Kidd that would have got the 4 in maths the previous year were suddenly 20 marks off. It has vastly limted what they can do and this will be the same for the next few years.

Illstartexercisingtomorrow · 27/01/2024 22:04

I feel so sorry for the kids who were starting secondary school or university when lockdown came. My friend’s daughter basically met no one and had zero university experience. So much of school and education is also about socialising and having opportunities outside of academics. Of course it must still affect many of them.

I thought at the time and still think the great harm from lockdown outweighed the benefits- which we will pay for in many ways for years.

Regarding school, I have gone from being a parent who would never ever let the kids be off school to simply not caring that much. After all it was suddenly deemed acceptable that they lost huge chunks of their education so quite frankly if that’s ok then it’s also ok for me to let the kids have days off more easily. I don’t play truant, but I am quite happy to take them on holiday in term time, and certainly softer on them if they are under the weather in allowing them to stay at home. They are primary age though, so perhaps I’ll feel differently at secondary.

LorlieS · 27/01/2024 22:00

I've been a primary teacher/HLTA for 20 years and absolutely - Covid has had an absolutely enormous negative impact across all year groups in so many different ways. More than I think most people realise.
I also had a baby in May 2020 and don't think it really affected her much because she was too young really at that point to be socialising or to understand. I do feel incredibly cheated of my mat leave which I will never experience again (I'm 43 now!)
I think to myself well we obviously struggled as adults to make sense of what the hell was going on, so is it any wonder our kids have been so badly affected?!

DoIHaveToBeAnAdult · 27/01/2024 21:53

My child was 10 when COVID hit and is still very highly anxious about catching COVID even though they've had it several times.

Just the mention of the word COVID has them on high alert almost and in a bit of spin.

All the focus on hand washing developed into quite severe OCD.

The rest of the family came out of it ok as far as I can tell. My then 9 year old is showing no signs of anxiety about it.

Belinda5 · 27/01/2024 21:45

Covid had a lasting effect on so many people; elderly people cut off and alone, immune compromised people afraid and abandoned, young people starting off in the world of work, middle aged people caring for elderly people, etc etc etc
Of course young children have been shaped by it as has everyone else. But I don't think they have suffered more than anyone else. There are so many people who suffered, who couldn't say a proper good bye to loved ones, whose already fragile mental health took a nose dive, whose businesses crashed. Society suffered and every age group was affected. Were children affected more than anyone else? I don't think so. But yes they were affected as were we all.

Ifhappylittlebluebirdsfly222 · 27/01/2024 21:31

My son was 3 in 2020.

He is doing OK in school but has a bit of a highly strung personality and I do wonder if that time period might have made him into a stressier person. But we can't really know for sure. He didn't really understand why we had to be locked down so it was hard for him to have grandparents/nursery etc.. taken away and a completely different routine. So that coupled with the fact he's a bit of a control freak now does make me wonder if it's due to the pandemic.

bakewellbride · 27/01/2024 20:57

@FuckOffTom my son is the same age and I always thought it was the worst affected age by miles. Interesting to hear that others think the opposite, thank you for a different perspective!

PriceMeByTheYard · 27/01/2024 20:50

I haven't RTFT, so apologies if this has already been mentioned. Behaviour has been massively affected. Kids whose only boundaries were provided by school had up to 6 months at home in an environment where they could do whatever they liked, either because parents were too busy working to parent or because they were pretty shite indulgent or neglectful parents to start with and school was doing most of the heavy lifting anyway with regards to teaching appropriate behaviour. Many are utterly feral, argumentative and disrespectful.

Tooolde · 27/01/2024 20:45

@wonderinglywondering If a child (with an aunt ? With asd and adhd) is anxious about school to that extent it may not just be separation anxiety. ??
My dd1 did the 10d of into to reception ok after that it was drsgging her in. She got better after a few months. Bht still hates school and has asd/adhd referral...

Yes the lockdowns and in and outs of schools wont have helped many kids settle but if you do have ND relative it may not be the lockdowns

FuckOffTom · 27/01/2024 19:35

I have a son in Y1 and I have often thought he was the ‘best age’ for the pandemic if that makes sense. He was in nursery and they only closed for 3 months during the first lock down and then remained open. I don’t believe he was affected and I don’t know any other parents who say their children are still suffering from the effects of the pandemic.
Obviously, this is just my experience and I do absolutely believe that other children have been negatively impacted - specifically those with SEN

Tooolde · 27/01/2024 19:05

Education wise
As i say y3 missed 8w of reception so over 1/6 40/190= 21%
Plus likely time on reduced hours - ours was at least 30min per day so
1235 became 1140. So 8% more lost
Every 14d isolation another 5%
So dd got maybe 66% of reception. Without adding all the extra covid processes

Mid mar to july of nursery missed 75/190 days 39%. If didnt go back.
No nativity for parents.
No trips reception or y1.
But will depend on whether key worker of not.

Ks2 results at school were better than ever. But behsviour for learning is very low.

The affects on y2 would not be on time on school. Nursery didnt close for their preschool year. The effects would vary greatly depending on parents wfh or not.

What would be the mechanism for many dc habving s&l issues from masks -- in Uk?

1 many children in nursery 1-4yo but what % of nursery workers wore masks. As it was specifically advised against
2 of children at home toddler groups were cancelled (not great for s&l but masks did come in later. However how many hours a week would average child have been there
3 likewise shops. Thats at most 20min a day
4 both my dc could speak words before 1yo. And pretty fluent by 18m. So with more tsking 12m mat leave. And many going part time. The window of children affected by masks would be pretty low not the claimed y3 downwards.

Much more likely it is the not going out as much so less conversation. Closed nurseries. And toddler groups. But also increased screen time. Who were 3.6yo+ when covid hit.

Logically if we do say masks are an issue?? Why? If it is unclear speech? Or not seeing mouth? Screens are as much an issue for this. Unclear speech and often cartoons with no mouths shown.
Parents wfh and childcare - less interaction again.

It maybe that children learnt not to look at adult faces/mouths.

Other countries with higher mask adherance in children at primary and nursery would have very high s&l issues.
If ours is higher then masks are better than isolation (which is obviously the case for education).

Anxiety otoh is isolation? Loss of friends and routine. Being behind academically.

Would be interesting if uk is generally much worse affected than most of the world?

Theatrefan12 · 27/01/2024 12:45

All2Well · 27/01/2024 11:26

I'm a university lecturer, wanting to get out now pretty much due to the fact I can no longer do my actual job as it now is more like being a mental health nurse/nanny.

I don't get lunch breaks or time to plan my lectures or do any research because students arrive constantly outside my office or lecture theatre door in states of blind panic/threaten self harm or suicide/or are extremely paranoid about someone looking at them funny or something they've seen on social media that may be aimed at them.

It has spiralled out of all control in the past 3 years and is getting worse.

They can't cope socially. They can't cope with deadlines. They can't not be on their phones and when I ask them to put them away while I'm teaching, I get a complaint made about me. They can't work together. They can't work independently. They want deadlines moved, attendance made optional, assessment methods changed. They complain about everything...from reading being online to reading not being online, to having to do their own research rather than going to the library themselves. It's not a minority, it's a vast VAST majority.

My job is unrecognisable. These are no longer young adults. They are adult children. Most of my 20 year olds are stuck at what age 13/14 used to be. And I can't be mother to all of them. I just can't anymore.

I recognise all this but from the perspective of graduate cohorts coming into the workplace over the last couple of years

As I mentioned on a previous post up thread, the maturity levels and general performance is so much lower than the groups that were educated pre covid

SeemsSoUnfair · 27/01/2024 12:39

It is different for everyone depending on combinations of age, circumstances, personalities, support available and many other factors.

Covid took my mum in traumatic circumstances, it financially screwed us as dh barely worked for almost 2 years and we had no government support, it fell over 2 school exams years for my teen ds when the little online learning he got was very poor quality. It was hard.

Now, I still miss my mum every day, financially we are surviving/slowly recovering.

For ds covid had some huge positives such as having to be more independent, taking responsibility for his school work and having less distractions during studying let him know what he was capable of if he works hard and it played a part in focusing him to get into his uni and course of choice. The peak teen "drinking in parks" years passed him by and by the time he came out of covid he was too old for it (I'm glad we missed them!). He kept his social connections alive with online games, long outdoor walks, or challenging each other with keep fit targets and sharing photos of meals they learned to cook. I said to him towards the end of pandemic years, he went into it a boy and came out a young man and I am proud of what he achieved during it.

If covid could appear to have such a positive impact on my teen ds, it stands to reason it could also appear to have significant negative impacts on others of the same age. Speaking to other mums I know, their dcs experiences vary greatly, those that had some issues with school and social interaction prior to covid, and/or needed more support from either schools or parents (who were not able give it for whatever reasons such as both parents being key workers and no other family support) seem to have been hit the hardest.

With the teens years already being very unpredictable and "normal" life known to throw in its own curve balls, I guess most of us will never know, individually, if our dc will have had significantly different long term outcomes if they hadn't lived through covid. Looking at what is happening around the world now, while it was hard and is still hard, there is much worse they could have gone through.

Kazzyhoward · 27/01/2024 11:46

I don't think anyone has mentioned the financial cost, especially of the over 3 million who were excluded from the support grants, mainly freelancers, self employed, etc.

I know of several families whose children have been massively affected due to their parent's losing their businesses, savings, in extreme circumstances, their home, etc., even for less extreme cases, many of the parents affected no longer have "spare" money for clubs, societies and hobbies, etc.