Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents buying somewhere for DD - is it a good idea

244 replies

ctownsie · 26/01/2024 11:06

Hi, mainly looking to see if this a good idea or not as I'm clueless.
DD is 18, in her first year of med school in London - 6 year course.
My parents recently sold their London home the area went through a lot of gentrification in the time they lived there (over 50 years) so the house ended up selling for over 2 mil.
They relocated, downsized and have a lot left to play with. They've topped up their already pretty good pensions.
I have 2 kids and im an only child. DD18 and DS15.
My parents are now wanting to buy DD a flat in London that she can share with friends. They've found a 4 bed they and DD like near uni and friends, for a little over a million.
They are planning to put down a deposit of £500,000 or so, this will be all of DDs inheritance. Then she can rent the other 3 rooms for roughly £1250-£1350. My parents said they will deal with all the landlord related tasks. They are 74 and 75 so I'm not sure that's the best idea but ok.
DD says she already has 2 friends who would be able to stay there.
My parents think this is a much better alternative to DD looking for somewhere to live for the next 5 years.
AIBU to be worried this might not be the best idea? Are there any flaws they might not have considered?
They'd still have money left should DS want the same though DS hates London and would never go to London again if he would so I doubt he would need somewhere so expensive.

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 26/01/2024 12:19

If she ever wants/needs to sell she doesn't want to evict a friend!

minipie · 26/01/2024 12:19

I would absolutely advise against DD and friend buying together - I know two sets of siblings (both close, get on well) who bought together and it was really complicated trying to work out when to sell, who owed/owned what etc. Even decor choices 😆 I wouldn’t want to do that with anyone who wasn’t family.

Realistically if both friends want and are able to buy then they should each buy their own place and find other friends to be tenants. Or they choose to rent together and the GPs find another outlet for their spare money.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 26/01/2024 12:18

ctownsie · 26/01/2024 11:24

This might actually be the best idea!
DD doesn't want to live alone but if it's a 2 bed she can still have a friend stay (and profit from the rent) without being reliant on them. Off to suggest this.

If she does this please advise her to get a 2 bedroom flat with share of leasehold, not in a block with service charges.

As others have said, do not buy with friends. I've known men do this when younger and it's gone well (more of a doer-upper situation) but generally it doesn't end well.

Seaweed42 · 26/01/2024 12:17

Where is DD living now?
There is a lot to be said for living in student accommodation as there is a big sociability factor in that.
Living with just one other person for your entire student time is fine, if you are very social. But if herself and the other girl are quiet and reserved then, dunno...

Sometimes quiet and reserved people do better being put into situations where there are ready made flatmates so they are thrown into a social group as such.

The way I'd put it to my parents is - 'forget about DD for a minute, this is a flat YOU want to buy to rent out. DD might decide she's moving out in 3 years to move in with a partner - then are you guys happy to rent to strangers?'

It sounds like a stressful headache for all concerned.
Where the hell will a 74 year old get a mortgage though? It's just not possible.

Gymnoob · 26/01/2024 12:17

DdraigGoch · 26/01/2024 12:13

I would seek professional advice

Yes I would. Just been playing around with this. If she prefers the two bed. Take the 500,000. Put less than half in the flat. Put the rest in investments. Then after 25 years you have a flat probably worth a million. Plus over a million in investments for the measly contribution of £500 a month when she’s living rent free. So she could contribute more. This is life changing money. Make sure you use it so her life is changed for LIFE. How exciting 🥰

https://www.hl.co.uk/tools/calculators/regular-investing-calculator

Regular investing calculator

Use our investment calculator to find out: How much could your savings be worth? How much do you need to invest and how long do you need to save? Our regular investing calculator is free to use.

https://www.hl.co.uk/tools/calculators/regular-investing-calculator

Whatineed · 26/01/2024 12:17

One of my colleagues rented a room in exactly this scenario OP. The house owners parents gave her a deposit on a 4 bed town house in Surrey Quays, and it was her job/responsibility to keep paying the mortgage by making sure the rents covered her monthly outgoings.

I thought this was absolutely amazing. She was never short of people wanting to rent, even had a cleaner.

The house was around 400k at the time (early 90's) I can't imagine what she walked away with. Lucky lucky girl.

SunshineAutumnday · 26/01/2024 12:16

Being a landlord is hardwork, you have constant tests to do and paperwork to complete. Plus students can be nightmare - DD is one (student).

Also if she's medical school - she maybe moving around alot due to placements - has this been considered.

A smaller flat, could release some funds and would probably be a good investment. I would suggest a having a contract agreement/lease written up by a solictor.

Also, would it be worth your parents talking to a finincial adviser as well regarding inheritance tax etc. They may benefit from start a trust fund for your children instead.

Avoid going into joint mortage with other families, complicates matters.

good luck

Dinosaurus86 · 26/01/2024 12:15

Noo don’t buy with a friend! Sounds like a disaster waiting to happen. Just get a 2-bed outright. A different friend can always live in if needed. We sold ours last year for just under £500k, zone 2, about a 20 minute cycle (nice proper cycle paths) from Bloomsbury.

DdraigGoch · 26/01/2024 12:13

I would seek professional advice

sunshinesupermum · 26/01/2024 12:13

Far too complicated to have DD and friend both owning the flat. At that age they could well fall out of their friendship.

thebestinterest · 26/01/2024 12:11

If they can afford it, why not? Housing is only going to get MORE expensive. Sounds like it’s a good investment. If she can cover her mortgage with rent from the let of other rooms I think that’s fantastic.

also, I don’t understand why anyone would pay rent (money pissed away) when you could be accruing wealth. lucky dd!

ctownsie · 26/01/2024 12:11

Thank you everyone.

Just had a group call with DD and my parents, all have agreed smaller = better.
Now DD has told us the friend who she wants to live with has inheritance money to buy too. The only issue is she plans to travel after her degree so wouldn't live there for a year, then would be in the workforce sooner so DD may need to buy her out.
That friend is going to talk to her dad.
May end up being my parents contribute half for DD, friend contributes half and they own together. But frankly it all sounds so stressful and I'm not money wise to know if that's a good idea.
Feel like im drip feeding but really I don't even know all the details myself !!

OP posts:
PutinSmellsPassItOn · 26/01/2024 12:10

Not a chance, especially when she could get a nice, one or two bed flat for half that.

Echobelly · 26/01/2024 12:10

I'd have thought a two bed with a smaller or no mortgage and renting out one room would work better - managing 3+ potential other people living there could be complicated, especially if they are lodgers as the legal side is much more vague than tenants. And presumably means more to share with other grandchild/allowing them to also be bought a place.

Also they won't always need the income from sharing in a smaller place - what if they finish studies, meet a partner and don't want to share with several people anymore?

I think giving a property to a young person as inheritance is a generally a good idea these days - they have an asset they can build stability on. But they do need to consider tax and legal issues around it, and again, I'd say a place where they share with just one other person is more sustainable.

GoldLash · 26/01/2024 12:09

Sounds amazing your DD is very lucky

NettleTea · 26/01/2024 12:09

well this is how friends of mine got on the houising ladder and were able to concentrate fully on their studies as didnt have to pay rent.
The friends got to live in a much nicer house than they would have done for the same rent, so they didnt have any problems like that - rents in London are astronomical!

Needmoresleep · 26/01/2024 12:08

It could be a good idea, but depends very much on your DDs attitude to the responsibility. Being a landlord is a job, and you need to make sure the legals are right.

The money should be gifted and she have ownership. Not least because this allows her to rent on a lodger basis. The will should be rebalanced so her brother does not lose out. Having a base in London is a huge advantage as it means she will be able to afford to stay there for her F1/F2, or buy in a cheaper area of the country.

Anycrispsleft · 26/01/2024 12:08

A few of my colleagues got a deal like this from parents and grandparents when we were students and I was and am very jealous! They were having a whole flat paid off for them while the rest ofbus were auditioning for the garden flat boxrooms...

Aside from the generous gift of the money, your DD will never have to worry about where she is living, she will be able to pick her flatmates instead of having to hope she can find a space in a decent flatshare. Sure there night be maintenance needed on the place sometimes but she and your parents can make sure the place is up to standard before she moves in, and if anything needs fixed she can just arrange it herself instead of having to go through landlords, who IME don't tend to have much of a sense of urgency, particularly when renting to students. The accommodation will be a lot higher standard than she would otherwise be able to afford in London as well.
I would just say make sure it is all above board and it's clear who owns it and who is going to be the guarantor of the mortgage etc. IIRC, if she were to go for a BTL mortgage the interest rate would be a little higher but you might be happier with that if it means you don't have to be the guarantor.
Regarding flatmates I think she would probably be better renting out to colleagues who are not such close friends, as it can be difficult if the boundaries get blurred.

BlokeHereInPeace · 26/01/2024 12:07

Yeah, being a landlord is hard work. The government prefer institutional investors to private landlords and the main money is often in capital appreciation, which isn't happening.

Perhaps your very generous and lovely flats are better offering to pay the rent in a really nice student development and put money aside for both your children to get a property slightly later in life.

Hate to say it but be careful about inheritance tax.

JadeSeahorse · 26/01/2024 12:07

Smaller flat sounds idyllic to me in your daughter’s situation.

Also, wouldn’t a one/two bedroomed in London be much easier to sell later than a four bedroomed although I only know the London property market from what I read and from my friend who is a tenant?

Nanny0gg · 26/01/2024 12:06

ctownsie · 26/01/2024 11:16

Mortgage to be covered by renting the other rooms out.

I hope they're discussing this with a solicitor expert in wills and IHT. Also tenancy agreements and legal obligations as landlords

Otherwise there could be a lot of problems when they die

On the surface though, she should bite their hands off

WallaceinAnderland · 26/01/2024 12:05

How long will she live there OP and will she need to sell when she moves on?

soupycustard · 26/01/2024 12:05

This sounds like an amazing idea, and lovely of DGP but... I can see a lot of problems. The landlord/friends thing, as many PPs have pointed out - it would have to be managed by an agent I think just to provide a buffer and to make sure that when the toilet blocks on a Saturday or the boiler breaks on a weekend cold snap, you/parents/DD aren't trying to sort emergency workmen.
Secondly, horrible I know, but IHT implications do need to be thought about. Bear in mind that gifts made with 7 years of death are brought back within the deceased's estate. And it will depend what is in their wills as well as to what comes within the 325K tax-free limit. Just make sure that everyone knows what the tax implications are as it's horrible trying to untangle that stuff if someone dies unexpectedly.

ReignOfError · 26/01/2024 12:05

Friends of mine looked at this for both their children (at different times), and decided the best (and simplest) way was to buy a house in the cities where the children were studying, and let it to them for a low rent, to cover things like insurances, management fees (they didn’t manage it themselves, they weren’t local).

They had a proper tenancy agreement setting out all the terms and conditions, and which allowed the tenant to house-share, and thus bring in enough to cover not just the their costs of the house, but enough to cover quite generous living costs.

The properties remained part of my friends’ estate, and was in some form of Trust, preventing it being sold for a period if both of them died before their kids had finished studying.

Their return on this was the equity gain over several years, although in one case, that meant they kept the house after their child moved out, and rented it out to other students (no doubt at a hefty profit).

it saved all the issues about other people getting mortgages, potential deprivation of assets etc etc.

Gymnoob · 26/01/2024 12:05

And I don’t agree with outright. We are in massive era of inflation. Borrowing money is expensive right now but it’s still less than traditional investment returns. And the housing market is flattening. So no I definitely wouldn’t buy outright. It is not financially sensible in the long run. You aren’t leveraging your money, it’s not being put to work. It’s literally just at the whim of the housing market.