Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents buying somewhere for DD - is it a good idea

244 replies

ctownsie · 26/01/2024 11:06

Hi, mainly looking to see if this a good idea or not as I'm clueless.
DD is 18, in her first year of med school in London - 6 year course.
My parents recently sold their London home the area went through a lot of gentrification in the time they lived there (over 50 years) so the house ended up selling for over 2 mil.
They relocated, downsized and have a lot left to play with. They've topped up their already pretty good pensions.
I have 2 kids and im an only child. DD18 and DS15.
My parents are now wanting to buy DD a flat in London that she can share with friends. They've found a 4 bed they and DD like near uni and friends, for a little over a million.
They are planning to put down a deposit of £500,000 or so, this will be all of DDs inheritance. Then she can rent the other 3 rooms for roughly £1250-£1350. My parents said they will deal with all the landlord related tasks. They are 74 and 75 so I'm not sure that's the best idea but ok.
DD says she already has 2 friends who would be able to stay there.
My parents think this is a much better alternative to DD looking for somewhere to live for the next 5 years.
AIBU to be worried this might not be the best idea? Are there any flaws they might not have considered?
They'd still have money left should DS want the same though DS hates London and would never go to London again if he would so I doubt he would need somewhere so expensive.

OP posts:
CaptainClover · 26/01/2024 12:34

We bought a 3 bed flat for this purpose, not in London but centrally in another big university city.
It worked OK, most of the friends who lived there with my kids (x3) paid without any problems but I didn't think it was fair on my kids to have to act as landlord to their friends, so I had to take on that role sort out any issues.
There were also times when it wasn't fully occupied for various reasons, so you do have to factor this in.
Buying a £500k flat, mortgage free and just having one friend at a time is the easy option. Buying a more expensive one and using the rent(s) to cover the loan is a valid idea and would give your daughter a very valuable asset at the end of the period. A lot more hassle though.

Waterfallsandrainbows · 26/01/2024 12:34

They would have to give DS the same amount so the inheritance tax rule of 7 years counts down equally.

DS is 15 he may change his mind and want to live in London.

babyproblems · 26/01/2024 12:33

amazing offer - good idea but I would be asking if they could put the flat in both of the childrens names so they own it jointly or if the equivalent will be put in a trust for the sibling.. even then I think fairness would be an issue as money made from flat and also increase in value over time etc.

the other thing I though is that flat could be put in your name; and then you can manage how it all works going forward.

Get some proper financial and wealth planning advice here, would be best for all involved. X

HappyHamsters · 26/01/2024 12:33

Seaweed42 · 26/01/2024 12:26

Do not let your DD buy with the friend, absolutely not.

Why is an 18yr old being saddled with all this extra responsibility.
Medicine is a very intensive degree.

Does DD really want to be a 'landlady' at aged 18?

It sounds like you are all running around like headless chickens.

Your parents are trying to do something nice for DD, but these phone calls and deciding on the hoof - "4 beds, oh no, OK a 2 bed, oh you rent it from us, oh no, actually we'll buy you a 2 bed, ok fine"...., it all sounds a bit manic.

And none of you are really thinking things through.

I think the heart is ruling the head here and it's unfair pressure to be dragging DD in before the 'grown ups' have decided what to do.

Now DDs friend is being dragged in as well to this massive financial undertaking.

This is food for thought. At 18 I would personally prefer to spend at least my first year in student accommodation, meet new people, explore London, have peer support, no worries, no real shopping, cooking, cleaning or maintenance, ucl has great central accommodation and loads of extra circular activities including tennis.

Mix56 · 26/01/2024 12:32

Terrible idea to co own with friend
Abort

PieAndLattes · 26/01/2024 12:31

I’d suggest doing nothing for the first year. My DD is also going to uni next year. I want her to live in halls so she can find her feet and make friends without having to commit to who she’ll be living with longer term. I want her to live in an environment with lots of other students to get a feel for what she likes and doesn’t like in a flatmate. The drop out rate is up to around 20% in some courses/universities. How do you know your DD will want to be there for 6 years at this stage? She may want to take a gap year and go travelling or suddenly decide she hates medicine in London and want to go and study English in Bradford instead. She may want to move her friends out and a boyfriend in (who pays the big mortgage then?). I think owning a property for her to live in is placing too many constraints on an 18 year old. If they are desperate to buy a property get them to buy a flat and lease it out via and estate agent but without your DD’s involvement. I also don’t think it’s a good idea for an 18yo to be the landord of a £1m property.

Longsight2019 · 26/01/2024 12:30

This has got disaster written all over it.

she’s too young to have all this responsibility.

Her friends will be unreliable. Boyfriends will stay over. It’ll be a squat before you know it.

it’s too much money to tie up in a place where prices could fall.

the mortgage won’t be agreed in her name or your parents. It’s a bad time to borrow as well.

This is the outcome of a conversation between your parents that needs to consider all angles. It sounds like their minds are made up so you need to tread carefully and make them
accept the risks.

FreddyFishsticks · 26/01/2024 12:30

My brother did something similar for my niece.
At the start of her second year of uni he bought her a two bed flat (also London - was maybe £500,000 or so). £200,000 was a mortgage in his name but she was also on it I think? She had a lodger live with her paid rent which covered the mortgage. She then went to travel for a year so my brother used a letting agency to let it out just for the 1 year. She came back, now doing her masters and has a lodger again. Seems to have worked for them really well . His idea was, when her mum passed they kept a fair amount back as nieces inheritance. He thought it better in a house where someone else is effectively paying the mortgage, than going in expensive student accommodation.
Pretty sure when niece is employed and earning enough he will remove himself from the mortgage and it will be hers to do as she pleases with.

DriftingDora · 26/01/2024 12:30

Have they had legal advice on this? This is a hell of a lot of money to pay out without getting some ideas as to the pros/cons of what they're proposing. What about if any work needs to be done on the property in future, who pays for that? And who arranges for the work to be done (will a couple in their late seventies want to be doing with all that in a few years time)? Supposing your daughter hits trouble with one of her tenants - will she/grandparents be able to sort it out? And why a four-bed place? Wouldn't a 3-bed be big enough for your daughter plus two tenants? Or just a one-bed for your daughter?

I wonder if they've properly thought this through, or are just blinkered by the amount of money they have - why ever not spend some of it getting good legal advice first!

Edited to say I agree with the poster above - you all seem to be chasing your own tails, plucking ideas out of the air. I just cannot understand the logic of anyone just taking the idea and running with it - surely the first essential is to get some proper legal advice? Bonkers. And is your daughter mature enough to cope with what COULD go wrong here? She's doing a very demanding degree.

Babyroobs · 26/01/2024 12:29

Do they have money set aside should they need it to pay for care in the future?

Londisc · 26/01/2024 12:27

They have to give the same amount to your DS and be mindful of inheritance tax 7 year rule. Do not brush over this because DS is only 15 and hates London.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 26/01/2024 12:27

What is the plan for the property when your DD has completed her university course? It may suit for a few years if she remains working in London and is happy to continue in shared accommodation but what happens if she wants to move to another area or wants to travel - or she prefers somewhere smaller and her own company (or to be within a relationship).

Would your parents continue with this as a buy to let, or does part of the property remain your DD's?

Seaweed42 · 26/01/2024 12:26

Do not let your DD buy with the friend, absolutely not.

Why is an 18yr old being saddled with all this extra responsibility.
Medicine is a very intensive degree.

Does DD really want to be a 'landlady' at aged 18?

It sounds like you are all running around like headless chickens.

Your parents are trying to do something nice for DD, but these phone calls and deciding on the hoof - "4 beds, oh no, OK a 2 bed, oh you rent it from us, oh no, actually we'll buy you a 2 bed, ok fine"...., it all sounds a bit manic.

And none of you are really thinking things through.

I think the heart is ruling the head here and it's unfair pressure to be dragging DD in before the 'grown ups' have decided what to do.

Now DDs friend is being dragged in as well to this massive financial undertaking.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 26/01/2024 12:26

Beepbeep12345 · 26/01/2024 12:25

Lucky girl. Deffo two bed outright no mortgage where she doesn't NEED an income from a lodger. But if she gets home, great. Ideally freehold with a garden and no service charges.

If it were me I'd go for a small house (I've got a 2/3 bed 'cottage') if affordable. Yes, it's small but no bloody freeholder to worry about.

Final comment from me (ha!) - as others have said, this all seems very rushed. Do not, I repeat, do not, rush into this. In SIL's case her DM is an ex-lawyer (property) so her DM has knowledge there.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 26/01/2024 12:25

I've just thought, could you both be guarantors for mortgage for DD? SIL's DP's parents were that for her and her DB's purchase.

Beepbeep12345 · 26/01/2024 12:25

Lucky girl. Deffo two bed outright no mortgage where she doesn't NEED an income from a lodger. But if she gets home, great. Ideally freehold with a garden and no service charges.

CaribouCarafe · 26/01/2024 12:25

I'm biased because I've never had inheritance or much financial help, but I don't think handing an 18 year old a 500k property will do them favours in the long run.

Obviously, you can't turn back now as your daughter and her grandparents are invested in the idea, however I think there's a lot of skills and experiences to be learnt just by living a normal student life and managing your own budget. It also allows more flexibility, and removes the stress of home ownership (and all the maintenance that comes along with it). It also gives you a better perspective on normal people's lives, rather than automatically being given the privilege of a decent, stable living situation which is something that most of DD's peers will not be experiencing for the next decade most probably.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 26/01/2024 12:24

If she does rent to a friend (or someone she knows) bear in mind that sometimes they expect 'mates rates' - well SIL had this when she rented her spare room out. One woman was a complete and utter nightmare and was her best friend!

For me, if ever I did this, I preferred it to be someone I didn't know well or at all, at market rate but got references from.

Saracen · 26/01/2024 12:23

Echoing most everyone else: I think it is a fantastic idea to secure somewhere for your DD to live. Renting is so expensive and stressful, and that will only get worse in the coming years. I do agree that some of the details of how it would work should be reconsidered - I'm glad everyone in your family agrees that smaller/cheaper is better. Fewer flatmates to fall out with and less financial risk.

It's very kind for your parents to be wanting to take over the legal and maintenance issues (was that the idea?), but it may not be the best plan at their ages. I think it would be even better to let your daughter get to grips with that herself, while her parents and grandparents offer lots of advice from the sidelines. That does take time for her to do, but presumably the free accommodation means she won't need a part-time job. These are important skills, and ultimately it's her flat, so she should be making the decisions and sorting it out.

Bunnycat101 · 26/01/2024 12:22

Buying with a friend is going to be a bad idea especially if they are doing different length courses. Friend could want out after 3 years forcing a sale.

moomoomoo27 · 26/01/2024 12:22

I did this in a different area, but I got the mortgage with my dad so we had the double advantage of his money + my age.

Bought him out and still live there 10 years later 😂

Had nightmares of housemates/tenants (even friends who turned out to be great in small doses but terrible to live with), but some were okay.

Not sure they'll get a mortgage for the rest at their age if they're only putting down 50% on such a large amount?

Also it will likely be considered an HMO, depending on the specific council (where I am more than 2 people from different families is considered an HMO). If it is you'll have to get approved for that, have all the licensing costs if you do get approved, and also have to meet all the requirements regarding fire doors, locks, fire blankets, etc. etc., which will cost a fair bit and not necessarily improve the look of the place if it's a family home.

HappyHamsters · 26/01/2024 12:22

I wouldn't advise buying with her friend, they could fall out, get into a relationship and want their partner to move in, how would you dd buy her out,

crumblingschools · 26/01/2024 12:21

Does she have to go anywhere for working in hospital experience or will that be local to university?

ctownsie · 26/01/2024 12:20

Seaweed42 · 26/01/2024 12:17

Where is DD living now?
There is a lot to be said for living in student accommodation as there is a big sociability factor in that.
Living with just one other person for your entire student time is fine, if you are very social. But if herself and the other girl are quiet and reserved then, dunno...

Sometimes quiet and reserved people do better being put into situations where there are ready made flatmates so they are thrown into a social group as such.

The way I'd put it to my parents is - 'forget about DD for a minute, this is a flat YOU want to buy to rent out. DD might decide she's moving out in 3 years to move in with a partner - then are you guys happy to rent to strangers?'

It sounds like a stressful headache for all concerned.
Where the hell will a 74 year old get a mortgage though? It's just not possible.

Edited

Student accommodation- but this isn't easy to come by after first year and the private's are ridiculously expensive.
DD has known the other girl for a while (they both played competitive tennis) but they were never close until they ended up at the same uni!
I think the best bet is big outright, friend as lodger and that be that!

OP posts:
soupycustard · 26/01/2024 12:20

Definitely don't encourage DD and friend to co-own. They're far too young and it will be a total nightmare if one wants/needs to sell and the other doesn't.
I think you need to simplify this down: could DGP just gift the equivalent money? Sooner rather than later because of the 7 year IHT rules and perhaps on the basis of a trust so that your DD doesn't just have access to loads of cash (even if she's sensible, it's about youth, vulnerability, other people etc). Then take a breath and have a think about how to do this without the pressure.
Buying property is a very good idea, but it does need a bit of calm reflection.