Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents buying somewhere for DD - is it a good idea

244 replies

ctownsie · 26/01/2024 11:06

Hi, mainly looking to see if this a good idea or not as I'm clueless.
DD is 18, in her first year of med school in London - 6 year course.
My parents recently sold their London home the area went through a lot of gentrification in the time they lived there (over 50 years) so the house ended up selling for over 2 mil.
They relocated, downsized and have a lot left to play with. They've topped up their already pretty good pensions.
I have 2 kids and im an only child. DD18 and DS15.
My parents are now wanting to buy DD a flat in London that she can share with friends. They've found a 4 bed they and DD like near uni and friends, for a little over a million.
They are planning to put down a deposit of £500,000 or so, this will be all of DDs inheritance. Then she can rent the other 3 rooms for roughly £1250-£1350. My parents said they will deal with all the landlord related tasks. They are 74 and 75 so I'm not sure that's the best idea but ok.
DD says she already has 2 friends who would be able to stay there.
My parents think this is a much better alternative to DD looking for somewhere to live for the next 5 years.
AIBU to be worried this might not be the best idea? Are there any flaws they might not have considered?
They'd still have money left should DS want the same though DS hates London and would never go to London again if he would so I doubt he would need somewhere so expensive.

OP posts:
Ducksinthebath · 26/01/2024 12:58

This is crazy. She's in first year, so we're talking about her buying a property - probably a half million pound plus investment - with someone she's known six months.

If she suggested this with a boyfriend you'd tell her it was a dreadful idea, so why is it all sunshine and roses because there's no romance involved and the relationship is strictly platonic? If things go south your DD could have a nightmare on her hands legally and end up isolated from her friendship group.

LostTheMarmite · 26/01/2024 12:58

Lots of good points here but deprivation of assets should also be considered. Any capital, assets or property which they divest or own can be taken into account if they require care in the future

Deprivation of Assets | Age UK

https://www.ageuk.org.uk/information-advice/care/paying-for-care/paying-for-a-care-home/deprivation-of-assets/

PlanBea · 26/01/2024 12:56

I've not RTFT but my thoughts would be:

Inheritance tax if something happens to your parents in the next 7 years - could be £200k you'd have to find to cover the tax on a £500k gift. Way more expensive than rent even in London. And what if your parents suddenly need care and it looks like you've hidden their assets?

Buying together - what if friend decides she wants expensive flooring/remodelling etc? Or daughter wants to get the boiler serviced and friend doesn't want to pay? Or when one wants to sell but the other doesn't? So many scenarios that say disaster.

I'd be amazed in this situation if is getting a £500k mortgage as a student or in their 70s. Would your daughter evict a friend for non payment of rent? I lived with a friend at uni who was bought a flat by her parents, it caused a resentment that she was rent free, getting money from me, and her own job, and complaining about being broke to me when she was measurably better off each month. It doesn't always work with the imbalance.

Fairness for your son has been mentioned too.

anyolddinosaur · 26/01/2024 12:55

Honestly some people clearly have no idea what to do with money. The daughter would get some sort of buy to let mortgage based on likely rental income. The lender would have a 50% deposit, they arent going to be worried about getting their money back, they can always repossess. I wouldnt suggest a £1 million property, though and if they could keep under £500,000 the lower Stamp duty for FTBs is a nice bonus. Parents can be guarantors for a mortgage instead of the student rent - it's less of a risk than the perils of guaranteeing rent!

The grandparents need to consider if they have enough for care home fees if needed. For that reason investing the money and gifting your children the income would be one one of handling it. You can gift any amount of money free from CGT if it's out of income.

But this does mean wasting a fortune on London rents and all the hassle that comes with it,

The very WORST thing the grandparents can do is sit on all the money until they die.

Afestivechange · 26/01/2024 12:55

A two bed means that she can potentially stay in it right through training and the early years, through meeting someone, until she’s married with babies - for someone working as hard as medics do and for such proportionally crap pay for what they do, that will be life changing a decade down the track. A four bed or buying with friends will be a potential millstone.

waterproofed · 26/01/2024 12:54

Whatever you decide, make sure to get some legal advice - you need to appreciate the inheritance tax implications in particular.

But really, I can only see upsides to such an amazing gift ❤️

CastleHunter · 26/01/2024 12:54

Can the flat be bought in trust for BOTH grandchildren?

IMustDoMoreExercise · 26/01/2024 12:52

Dinosaurus86 · 26/01/2024 12:15

Noo don’t buy with a friend! Sounds like a disaster waiting to happen. Just get a 2-bed outright. A different friend can always live in if needed. We sold ours last year for just under £500k, zone 2, about a 20 minute cycle (nice proper cycle paths) from Bloomsbury.

I agree with this. Too many things to go wrong and just too complicated.

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 26/01/2024 12:52

No

It was a lovely idea until I read the word mortgage ! then I read that the mortgage may be in your name !!!

NO

If they wish to buy their grand daughter / your daughter a property outright for £500,00 and it is solely in her name then fine. She can then have a lodger rather than a tenant to help her cover her costs of living there.

She ought to have a large say in what property it is as she will be the one living there.

Heronwatcher · 26/01/2024 12:51

No way would I be taking out that kind of mortgage- seems like a massive route to disaster/ stress. What if DD wants to move, or can’t get house sharers? What if house prices tank? You will be on the hook for that amount regardless. This seems like a really unnecessary risk, and might lead you all to becoming professional landlords. Have they also considered that the rental income will be taxed in the hands of whoever is due to receive it.

I agree much better to buy a more modest place outright.

percypigletss · 26/01/2024 12:50

@ctownsie Is your daughter assertive and thick skinned? Mature enough to understand the level of responsibility?

It would be a great oppourtunity for her to have stability and not waste loads of money of london rent, but it's likely to land her in awkward situations with her friends (e.g., them not having as much respect for the property, annoyances about paying her money, squabbles over fairness). I just think of in general what student houses are like, and how students tend to treat them, and would have hated to have been in the position of live in landlord with my friends!

I wouldn't have been able to deal with that well when I was 19, but it completely depends on personality.

I think it would be far less stress for her to have a 1 or 2 bed bought for her, however it depends on whether that might be isolating, as part of the university experience is living with friends.

Duchessofmuchness · 26/01/2024 12:48

My friend's DD had a very similar scenario although in her case the DD had an inheritance. DD med student in London. They used it to buy a flat in London - was a 2 up 2 down. The kitchen was large enough for a small table to at various points she had 1 or 2 flatmates and they used the living room as a bedroom. It wasn't the most plush flat (1960s ugly block) but it was good location for uni. She loved there all through uni and then a few years after. She's moved out of London now but has kept it on and rented it out. It has worked out brilliantly for her. I'm sure there were some boggles with flatmates sometimes and maintenance but surely better than renting and moving etc

I think it's important that the siblings understand this is their inheritance. Does DS get his now? If not do they ring fence somehow? Even things like her £500k could be worth £600k by time your DS gets his share. What if his is still only £500? Is that ok? Or should they both get now?

Seaweed42 · 26/01/2024 12:45

As other poster said she might have to go and live in a different city to do a specialisation at a different hospital.

Of course DD is jumping at the chance, because like every 18 year old student in First Year, they are worrying about where they will live next September.

So she'll agree to anything that seems very handy. And of course she'll run off and ask Maisie to ask her Dad can they buy a fab pad in London for themselves.

LuckySantangelo35 · 26/01/2024 12:42

CaribouCarafe · 26/01/2024 12:25

I'm biased because I've never had inheritance or much financial help, but I don't think handing an 18 year old a 500k property will do them favours in the long run.

Obviously, you can't turn back now as your daughter and her grandparents are invested in the idea, however I think there's a lot of skills and experiences to be learnt just by living a normal student life and managing your own budget. It also allows more flexibility, and removes the stress of home ownership (and all the maintenance that comes along with it). It also gives you a better perspective on normal people's lives, rather than automatically being given the privilege of a decent, stable living situation which is something that most of DD's peers will not be experiencing for the next decade most probably.

THIS!!

cloudtree · 26/01/2024 12:41

So much of this is extremely risky and foolish.

If heaven forbid something happened to your parents over the next few years there may well be inheritance tax to pay on the gift given the size of the estate. Where will that come from? Will there be enough left over to pay any tax.

You and your DH can't get a mortgage on a property in someone else's name and your DD won't get a £500k mortgage (or in fact probably any mortgage at the moment).

Buying with a friend is insane. Where on earth does your DD think she'd get the money from to buy out the friend if they fall out or the friend or your DD want to buy with partners in a few years' time.

The only sensible option is for your parents to buy a property they can actually afford and allow DD to live there and then she and DS inherit an equal split of their estate when they pass (if there is money in the estate at that time and assuming you're not also a beneficiary).

WallaceinAnderland · 26/01/2024 12:41

I think giving anyone an advance on their 'inheritance' is a terrible idea. Especially when there is a sibling who, presumably, will not receive anything until the GPs actually die.

Then there is the matter of how much has been spent in the meantime and how much is actually left to beneficiaries after IHT etc.

Your DD is essentially getting a massive advantage over her brother in that she has the capital benefit of half a million for many years. Unless they are also investing the same for him and making sure that he also has capital growth, then it's unfair.

crossculturalwedding24234 · 26/01/2024 12:39

Also OP a flat in your daughter's name would cause her to lose FTB status!

IthinkIamAnAlien · 26/01/2024 12:39

One of my daughters got 5 medical school offers. Within a term she decided it wasn't for her and switched to chemistry at the other end of the country.

All very well for your DD, OP, but she will at the least be subject to some jealousy from peers. She's only 18! I'm sure the offer is well meant but how about a trust fund instead. I'm trying not to point out the growing inequality in the UK because some people have got lucky in the the property market.....

anyolddinosaur · 26/01/2024 12:38

By the time anyone buys a property it will be the next tax year, if not the next academic year. Your parents should, to reduce inheritance tax liability, gift the money to your daughter in this tax year. A property in your daughter's name or with someone who doesnt yet have a property attracts lower Stamp Duty Tax if less than £500,000 but she may not find much for that price. They should also gift the money they want to give to your son. They need to be aware of the risks that inheritance tax may become payable if either of them dies and each should gift half the amount to each child. Ideally their wills specify that any tax that become due is paid from their estate on death.

Buying a property that she can live in for 5 years and rent out would be a good use of the money. Rental properties for students in London are often miserable places or they cost more than £1300 a month. She will have no problem finding others who want to live there but needs to make sure they are properly screened with parent guarantors.

She needs to consider location not just now but where she may have to travel to placements. I've known of UCL med students live outside London in their later years.

Alternatively your parents could consider paying her student fees and living expenses. I believe this is still exempt from Capital Gains Tax While it's not generally a great idea most doctors will never pay off their student loans and will be paying 9% of salary for 40 years.

Acapulco12 · 26/01/2024 12:38

Just a thought, based on the latest posts on here. Would your parents consider putting the money they plan to give your DD and DS in trust for them, to give them when they’re say early twenties - e.g. 25, 26? By that time, they’ll likely both have jobs, and they’ll likely be a bit more settled than at the ages they are now.

I know nothing about putting money in trust - definitely best to have a proper discussion on this with your family and speak to a few financial advisers - but that could be an option to consider. I just brought it up because I think putting valuable things in trust - e.g. money, property - can help to protect it if it’s not needed straightaway.

MalewhoisLaffinalltheway · 26/01/2024 12:38

ctownsie · 26/01/2024 11:44

I'm not sure, DD is at UCL and would ideally want to remain as close to there as possible. I think the one they had looked at (the 4bed) was Kings Cross sort of way.
DD plays tennis frequently out at the sports centre near Latimer Road so i imagine she would be happy there but really it comes down to where she can find somewhere she can afford.

UCL is near Great Portland St, isn't it?

Latimer Road is West London, but linked to Gt Portland St by tube, Hammersmith & City line I think...

Should easily be able to get a 2 bed flat somewhere around Latimer Road, Westbourne Park, Sheperds Bush, somewhere like that, and it's an easy journey to Great Portland St. Probably only about 20 minutes.

cheddercherry · 26/01/2024 12:38

Definitely do not let them buy a house for her with a friend. It’s got disaster written all over it. Couples fall apart buying houses never mind two teen girls who have only fairly recently forged a friendship.

It all sounds quite impulsive that off the back of the thread you’ve all just switched completely what you’re planning. Take proper financial advice and research the market. I don’t think you’ll get a two bed property outright in that specific location and I wouldn’t plunge her into significant financial ties with friends to try and make it happen. Just rethink.

If you’re adamant maybe Look at buying somewhere else outright as a step on the ladder and renting it out which would then cover her rent in London? Then she can sell once she’s finished uni and put it towards what she wants, when she knows where/ what she wants.

crossculturalwedding24234 · 26/01/2024 12:36

Co-owning is a terrible idea OP. If your daughter's really a 'social butterfly' she'd be happy getting a stranger as a flatmate. Making a new friend. Why the fixation with this girl?
Honestly with @PieAndLattes suggested is the best. One of the adults owns the property - or it's placed in trust - your daughter then rents for a nominal fee and sublets. Use the rent to pay a management company to manage the property.

Don't saddle your daughter with all this at such a young age, when she's on such a gruelling course as well.

ctownsie · 26/01/2024 12:36

PieAndLattes · 26/01/2024 12:31

I’d suggest doing nothing for the first year. My DD is also going to uni next year. I want her to live in halls so she can find her feet and make friends without having to commit to who she’ll be living with longer term. I want her to live in an environment with lots of other students to get a feel for what she likes and doesn’t like in a flatmate. The drop out rate is up to around 20% in some courses/universities. How do you know your DD will want to be there for 6 years at this stage? She may want to take a gap year and go travelling or suddenly decide she hates medicine in London and want to go and study English in Bradford instead. She may want to move her friends out and a boyfriend in (who pays the big mortgage then?). I think owning a property for her to live in is placing too many constraints on an 18 year old. If they are desperate to buy a property get them to buy a flat and lease it out via and estate agent but without your DD’s involvement. I also don’t think it’s a good idea for an 18yo to be the landord of a £1m property.

She is already in her first year, this wouldn't come into effect until the start of her second year when she is unlikely to get student Accomodation again.

OP posts:
EvelynKatie · 26/01/2024 12:35

I live in a small University city and it's extremely common here for wealthy parents to buy up the houses for their children to live in whilst at University.

There's a planning restriction that's supposed to prevent more than 2 unrelated people living in some of the houses, but they get away with it anyway. I just mention this to be sure there's nothing similar when you're looking at places for her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread