Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents buying somewhere for DD - is it a good idea

244 replies

ctownsie · 26/01/2024 11:06

Hi, mainly looking to see if this a good idea or not as I'm clueless.
DD is 18, in her first year of med school in London - 6 year course.
My parents recently sold their London home the area went through a lot of gentrification in the time they lived there (over 50 years) so the house ended up selling for over 2 mil.
They relocated, downsized and have a lot left to play with. They've topped up their already pretty good pensions.
I have 2 kids and im an only child. DD18 and DS15.
My parents are now wanting to buy DD a flat in London that she can share with friends. They've found a 4 bed they and DD like near uni and friends, for a little over a million.
They are planning to put down a deposit of £500,000 or so, this will be all of DDs inheritance. Then she can rent the other 3 rooms for roughly £1250-£1350. My parents said they will deal with all the landlord related tasks. They are 74 and 75 so I'm not sure that's the best idea but ok.
DD says she already has 2 friends who would be able to stay there.
My parents think this is a much better alternative to DD looking for somewhere to live for the next 5 years.
AIBU to be worried this might not be the best idea? Are there any flaws they might not have considered?
They'd still have money left should DS want the same though DS hates London and would never go to London again if he would so I doubt he would need somewhere so expensive.

OP posts:
SquirrelsAssemble · 26/01/2024 22:55

Someone upthread made a very sensible suggestion of investing the 500k and using the monthly interest to pay for the accomodation.

Sounds like a low risk idea to me. You'd be clearing 1.5k after tax at the current rates and have 500k to buy a property after graduation without the hassle of selling etc.

Caveat: no idea if you can gift 500k. And who knows what's happening to the interest rate.

Borrowedtime · 26/01/2024 21:47

500k is a huge mortgage to take on as a student and first time property owner. Even if the mortgage isn't in her name, she bears the responsibility to keep tenants contributing financially and share houses don't always work out well. There are also the ongoing costs of maintaining a home. I'd be opting for a cheaper property that's more affordable and comes with less debt - preferably no debt at all.

girlfriend44 · 26/01/2024 21:17

They say they will deal with everything?
How experienced are they in renting
What happens if the friends don't pay the rent?

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 26/01/2024 20:59

NO again, no joint purchase with a friend

They will squabble about who has the biggest bedroom ! etc.

and friends fall out / want to move elsewhere at some point / have partners / want partner to move in etc. etc. etc.

One property / One owner and a lodger.

HolefreeGrail · 26/01/2024 18:15

When I was at uni, one of my friend’s parents bought a three bed in Hammersmith for him, and two other friends moved in and paid rent for a few years. All went fine and he and his family still live in the property 20 years later! It would be a very bad idea to co-own with a mate though. But the principle of buying a student a house / flat and then renting out the rooms is sound.

Throwawayme · 26/01/2024 18:00

Agree with all the pps who say don't encourage them to buy together. It's a terrible idea. Things change so much at that age.

AbbeFausseMaigre · 26/01/2024 17:43

Personally I think this all sounds very generous but completely insane. You are all behaving as if the GPs are talking about popping off to a car dealership and buying your DD a second hand VW Polo, not a million (or even half a million) pound property.

I'd strongly recommend seeking professional financial advice.

Jingleballs2 · 26/01/2024 17:40

Sounds like a well meaning disaster waiting to happen. I wouldn't be taking out another mortgage if I was you.
Buy her a smaller flat or gift her the money, but this comes with to many potential complications

Singlespies · 26/01/2024 17:40

My parents' neighbour bought a house for his student son. The son then changed university and the neighbour has had problems with all subsequent student tenants!

anyolddinosaur · 26/01/2024 17:22

She is a first year medical student. That means she is pretty intelligent and on the whole they tend to be more mature than the average 18 year old, perhaps because they mostly have volunteering or work experience or both. I doubt she will be rushing into marriage with a predator.

FollieSun · 26/01/2024 17:13

My partner and his DD have just gone through something similar with a few big differences. Her mum passed away when she was younger and this money had been held separately for her and no mortgage involved.
She got a lovely 2 bed in a nice area, need some updating.
They spent the summer renovating then had one of her acquaintances rather than friend move in as a lodger. As she is mortgage free she doesn’t charge full market rate but it is enough that it covers all the bills and gives her some profit which she uses in addition to her wage from working to live on/save.
She still has money from the inheritance left (her dad and mum owned a big house in London, when her mum passed her dad moved to somewhere much cheaper, bought a house for less than half of what the other house had sold for (life insurance had paid off the mortgage), a good chunk of the remainder was her inheritance and that’s accumulated interest over 8/9 years. So she can use that for travel and wedding etc. She’s also well aware she needs to be on guard for any predatory relationships and not rush into marriage.
So far there hasn’t been any issues but she has a list of emergency plumbers etc. And is a sensible girl.

brassbells · 26/01/2024 16:52

Why not get 2 one bedroom flats next door in the same block to each other?

DD buys one and her friend buys the other 🙂🙂🙂🙂

That way they are not reliant on each other for selling or buying or living away BUT they are sort of living together and can be in each others spaces as much or as little as they like

🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂

Then if the friend turns round and says they are going to live abroad for a year and meets a partner and decides to stay there then no problem for your DD

ALSO, don't forget about inheritance tax if your parents die within 7 years of the gift to your DS

So I think he gets his £500,000 now and gets it invested

Otherwise his money goes into IHT fines

Perhaps buy a house elsewhere and use for RENTAL or Airbnb and/or holiday home for everyone including your parents?

Purplesilkpyjamas · 26/01/2024 16:48

In her clinical years she will be outside of London as the London deaneries are vast.

She needs to go into halls for first year to make friends. It is a tough course and friendship groups are very important for study and relaxation.

Purplesilkpyjamas · 26/01/2024 16:37

What happens if one or both grandparents need to go into a care home?

BeadedBubbles · 26/01/2024 16:07

@Miyagi99 - dd is in her first year now.

Miyagi99 · 26/01/2024 16:02

ctownsie · 26/01/2024 11:36

Just spoke to DD and she has jumped at the idea of a 2 bed to share with one friend. I'll call my parents now and hopefully talk them round too. DD really doesn't want to live alone (she's a social butterfly and quite anxious at the thought of being in London alone)

Surely she’d be better off in halls for the first year then? That’s where everyone else will be.

MzHz · 26/01/2024 15:53

AhBiscuits · 26/01/2024 11:23

They'd be better buying her a one bed of her own outright.

That’s what I thought

Mynewnameis · 26/01/2024 15:44

Sounds like a potential night. I wouldn't want that mortgage and I have an OK job.

BeadedBubbles · 26/01/2024 15:28

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 26/01/2024 11:23

I think this is an excellent way for DD to fall out with her 3 friends.
It will be very awkward for her to be living there for free while they are paying her over a grand a month each. The friendship will start to feel unbalanced and resentments will build.
Few 18 year olds can handle the responsibility of being a landlord on top of studying and, as you say, the GP are elderly and might also struggle with that side of things.
I understand the desire to sort out DDs housing. But every student-landlord arrangement I've seen has ended in acrimony.
Either buy a one bed for DD. Or have DD and all the friends be tenants of the GP. Perhaps for reduced rent.

Totally agree

silverbubbles · 26/01/2024 15:22

What a fantastic opportunity for your daughter. Don't jeopardise it!!

Dacadactyl · 26/01/2024 15:05

They ought to buy her her own place outright. Saves a lot of faff for everyone.

NamingConundrum · 26/01/2024 15:02

Few things to consider, many already addressed. If she owns she will lose out on any benefit for buying in future as first time buyer. Parents may have a lot now, but what if in a couple months one (god forbid) got diagnosed with terminal cancer? What if they need care? The gift could have tax implications and may not be enough left to give DS equivalent. Buying with someone else bad idea, makes selling complicated if one wants to sell and other doesn't - or if one has change in circumstances and gets in debt. If DD marries new partner could claim against her equity. Have they looked into other options such as buying themselves, placing in trusts etc?

followmyflow · 26/01/2024 14:52

it sounds like a bad idea to me, for a few reasons

  1. unfair on other grandchildren? (i dont know how many grandchildren are in the picture, but it seems very unlikely theyd be able to do this for all of them?)
  2. saddling an 18-year-old with a 500,000 mortgage. omg!
  3. someone will need to handle all of the rent/upkeep related stuff while granddaughter is busy in her medical degree, who?
MadinMarch · 26/01/2024 14:52

The mortgage wouldn't be in DDs name - ideally they'd like DH or I to take on the mortgage but we are only just mortgage free so that's another deterrent.
So you'd be a joint owner with your dd. It'd be a BTL mortgage either repayment or interest only basis? There could be a problem with your dd living in the property if it was a BTL. You'd best speak to an experienced mortgage broker to find out what's possible and the implications. There would be the usual tax implications for both you and your dd. tax would be due on the rent over the £7,500 tax free rent a room out allowance.
I think it would be best for Gp's to buy a smaller place outright in DD's name- either a one bed with a separate kitchen so dd could get a lodger and not have a lounge (very common in London now, especially as a student) and having just one lodger would be uncomplicated. Alternatively, a two bed, still with just one lodger, though £500k wouldn't go far for a decent two bed in London.

WallaceinAnderland · 26/01/2024 14:52

From your point of view OP, would you be taking out a mortgage on a property that you have 0% ownership of? Presumably you would have to borrow on your own home as no lender will loan on a property you don't own.

This would mean that DD could sell it, keep the cash and you would still have to meet the mortgage repayments.

The same applies if the GPs buy a smaller property with cash. If it's entirely in DD's name she could sell and have the cash to do whatever she wants with.

DD could meet anyone. It wouldn't take a reasonably smart man very long to see £££ signs and easily take advantage of her. If she thinks she is 'in love' she could easily be persuaded to sell up. And then spend the money on what? Cars, holidays, drugs.

Do you really want her having all that cash at her disposal at such a young age? I think you would be making her very vulnerable to predators.