Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have mum guilt over childcare situation

319 replies

ChamomileHoneyTea · 26/01/2024 10:09

DP and I both work full time so I will have to leave DS in nursery when my maternity leave is over (when he turns one).

I know most parents rely on childcare these days but I just feel so guilty! Growing up my mum didn’t work when we were kids because they could live off one salary. My auntie had to go out to work but left my cousins with my grandma because she didn’t work.

Fast forward to now and I can’t afford to not work because we need my salary to survive. My parents are both still working full time so they can’t help. DP’s parents are retired but don’t want to help out.

Just feeling so down and guilty as if I’m abandoning my DS :( can’t help but think my DS is worse off than me at his age and me & DP are failing him :(

OP posts:
Bewler · 28/01/2024 12:40

Just read the comment about not wanting a child to be “attached to your apron strings”. Jesus, the thinly veiled scorn towards SAHMs…

KarenNotAKaren · 28/01/2024 12:30

SquitMcJit · 28/01/2024 12:29

I thought it was an awful post tbh. Reads like in the rush to be positive and supportive of the OP you’ve thrown other women and their choices under the bus.

Saying that a child of a SAHM is likely to be”that kid”… offensive and naive. Some kids would have all the socialisation in theworld pre-school and still not like the environment and vice versa. Some parents will try one type of childcare and then have to rethink it due to how their child responds or due to changing family circumstances.

We’re all trying to navigate childcare.I agree with posters who’ve said it mainly suits the government and the economy to have 2 parents working.

I agree.

It was a thinly veiled way of shitting on other women and legitimising the disrespect SAHMs face constantly

SquitMcJit · 28/01/2024 12:29

Mariposistaaa · 26/01/2024 10:40

OP you are going to be a parent for 18 years, and beyond. It is not all about the baby/toddler years. (Tbh it's not even the best part of parenting). Your child will grow up with a mum setting a great example, showing him that the world does not revolve around him and his needs, and that if he wants clothes on his back, a roof over his head and food on the table, this is done by working, not sitting around at home. He will see his mum as an equal partner as dad. and he will learn to value family time in the evenings and at weekends. Oh and he is less likely to be 'that kid' clinging to you howling on his first day in Reception. He will learn to share and be socialised.
Dust off that work suit (or whatever you wear to work). It will be fine!

I thought it was an awful post tbh. Reads like in the rush to be positive and supportive of the OP you’ve thrown other women and their choices under the bus.

Saying that a child of a SAHM is likely to be”that kid”… offensive and naive. Some kids would have all the socialisation in theworld pre-school and still not like the environment and vice versa. Some parents will try one type of childcare and then have to rethink it due to how their child responds or due to changing family circumstances.

We’re all trying to navigate childcare.I agree with posters who’ve said it mainly suits the government and the economy to have 2 parents working.

SouthLondonMum22 · 28/01/2024 12:12

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 12:06

I find it really odd that the government has offered free childcare basically for institutional settings only, but not made any provisions for parents who wish to stay at home. Why not give the money to families so they can either use it to afford to stay at home, pay for a nanny share with other families (which is psychologically better for the child as it's just one other main caregiver), or allow parents to use it to pay grandparents etc. They are literally only willing to fund the form of care, which is also the worst for the child. This is obviously because they don't care about what women actually want, or about children, they just care about boosting the economy.

It's definitely about boosting the economy. The funded childcare can cover anyone as long as they are an approved childcare provider so not just nurseries.

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 12:06

SouthLondonMum22 · 28/01/2024 11:55

Or the government could properly fund childcare and pay staff better.

I find it really odd that the government has offered free childcare basically for institutional settings only, but not made any provisions for parents who wish to stay at home. Why not give the money to families so they can either use it to afford to stay at home, pay for a nanny share with other families (which is psychologically better for the child as it's just one other main caregiver), or allow parents to use it to pay grandparents etc. They are literally only willing to fund the form of care, which is also the worst for the child. This is obviously because they don't care about what women actually want, or about children, they just care about boosting the economy.

MrsB74 · 28/01/2024 11:57

Bumpitybumper · 26/01/2024 11:58

What weird anti-SAHM rhetoric! I understand that you're trying to make OP feel better but you have implied that SAHMs aren't equal partners, don't set a great example for their children, sit at home all day and are more likely to have clingy kids. It's pretty depressing that it always comes down to these lazy clichés where SAHMs and WOHMs seek to undermine the other to justify their own decisions. It's unnecessary, unkind and just ends up with everyone being dragged down.

OP, it's fine to feel a bit disappointed if you wanted to be a SAHM and can't be one or if you feel that your child would benefit from having a SAHP. The reality is that not many families can afford to have a SAHP and times have changed from when you grew up so there is no point in making a comparison. It is also important to take a long term view, not only from a financial perspective but just from a parenting perspective. We cannot be perfect parents and we all will make compromises at some point. I think when you have a baby you get a false sense of control where you feel completely responsible for making the 'right' decisions for them because we feel like we are effectively their world.

In reality though, the real world will open up to them over time and this will be just one of many compromises that will be made as your control over your child's situation diminishes. They may go to sub optimal schools, have questionable friends, not be able to pursue every interest they have and ultimately make decisions for themselves that you feel are bad choices. You being a SAHM or not won't seem like such a big deal in the context of the wider journey of them becoming independent adults so please don't feel like this is the be all and end all. Do the best you can in the circumstances that you find yourself in and this is all you can expect fro yourself. Don't go chasing impossible ideals!

I agree that you were unnecessarily negative against SAHMs - we all have to do what suits our situations at the time; whether we like it or not. Every mum feels guilt, whatever choices they make. Personally I loved being at home for the first few years and then loved being back at work too. We were extremely lucky that we could afford it. I also know plenty of children who went to full time childcare. I don’t think it’s made much difference in the long run.

SouthLondonMum22 · 28/01/2024 11:55

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 11:07

This is true in some rare cases, however generally it is possible to live off one income if you make big adjustments (such as moving, downsizing etc). Since we moved to 2 income households, people's standard of living has generally risen, which has become the new normal, making it extra difficult for people to adjust to one income.
If those who could afford to live off one income would look after their own children instead of using childcare, it would mean that those who really really needed childcare could access it at a much better quality, because it would be on a smaller scale, the children would have more attention, and the staff turnover would be less because they'd be better paid. And a lower staff turnover in childcare really benefits the children. Generally, the less often the carer changes, the better for the child. The mass use of nursery has really lowered the quality of care.

Or the government could properly fund childcare and pay staff better.

Channellingsophistication · 28/01/2024 11:20

I think mums always feel guilt whatever really.

I worked 4 days whilst DS was small. Is that an option for you?

My DS went to nursery, he loved it, never looked back when he went in and I’m sure its what has made him self assured and able to make friends easily.

Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 28/01/2024 11:19

Well, if you pick a good childminder/nursery, your kid will have the attention and education that they deserve. This is not to say that SAHMs aren’t great, but I could never have imagined providing such diverse activities at home. That’s all. Plus they will be home 50% of the tome the first years with illnesses anyways 😂 you better prepare for that.
Guilt is useless.

WimbyAce · 28/01/2024 11:15

I understand the guilt completely as I think there is a huge pressure on mothers to do everything where as fathers seem to still be getting a free ride. We are expected to contribute financially while still juggling the childcare situation, it is tough.
I had a situation recently where we had an issue with childcare and the expectation was that I would simply take the day off. There is still this blinkered view that the man couldn't possibly take a day off short notice and it is down to the woman to sort, regardless of her other commitments.

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 11:07

NerrSnerr · 28/01/2024 08:31

Lots of parents genuinely do not have a choice and need the two incomes to live.

This is true in some rare cases, however generally it is possible to live off one income if you make big adjustments (such as moving, downsizing etc). Since we moved to 2 income households, people's standard of living has generally risen, which has become the new normal, making it extra difficult for people to adjust to one income.
If those who could afford to live off one income would look after their own children instead of using childcare, it would mean that those who really really needed childcare could access it at a much better quality, because it would be on a smaller scale, the children would have more attention, and the staff turnover would be less because they'd be better paid. And a lower staff turnover in childcare really benefits the children. Generally, the less often the carer changes, the better for the child. The mass use of nursery has really lowered the quality of care.

cockadoodledandy · 28/01/2024 10:53

Don’t feel guilty. Your child will benefit from being around other children and in my opinion will benefit from not being tied to your apron strings every day. Your family will have a better quality of life as a result of the dual wage, your child will see hard work being demonstrated on a daily basis and you’ll benefit from being more than ‘just’ Mummy.

Our DD8 went to a childminder from age 5months and still does 3 afternoons a wee / 3 days a week in holidays. We could have survived on one salary but I wanted / needed to go back to my career for my own wellbeing and satisfaction.

I sometimes get ‘mum guilt’ when her friends go to extra curricular activities that she can’t do because they start at 4 pm. But that guilt fades when I look at the benefits of us both working (and not all of them are material).

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 10:50

cockadoodledandy · 28/01/2024 10:45

That’s because the guilt doesn’t actually come from inside us, it comes from people outside of us who tell us we should feel guilty. Normally other women, often those closest to us. Hopefully gen X onwards will gradually remove that stigma and create generations of ‘older’ women who want to empower women to do what they need or want to do, not what our dated tradition or old fashioned society expects.

What about empowering women to make decisions that actually make them happy? You're minimising her very real sadness at leaving her child l, by suggesting she's just been conditioned by external influences. If she loved having her mother at home, and longs to do the same with her own child, she should b3 empowered to do that. Even if it comes at a huge financial cost, being content with your decision is worth it.

cockadoodledandy · 28/01/2024 10:45

Wictc · 26/01/2024 11:05

Funny there is no such thing as dad guilt. We never judge men who go back to work full time, present or past. You child will grow up to see both parents working effectively as a team, contributing equally to the house, and showing that women are just as capable as men in terms of having a career and financially supporting the household. Hopefully this next generation will see further equality!

That’s because the guilt doesn’t actually come from inside us, it comes from people outside of us who tell us we should feel guilty. Normally other women, often those closest to us. Hopefully gen X onwards will gradually remove that stigma and create generations of ‘older’ women who want to empower women to do what they need or want to do, not what our dated tradition or old fashioned society expects.

duckydoo234 · 28/01/2024 10:42

Oh god, don't feel guilty at all. My two were both full time from 9 or 10 months. No family close by and wouldn't have asked them anyway. It was expensive, but you know it's not forever, and once they go to school it's like you've won the lottery. Anyway as for nursery itself, they loved it. First week a bit weepy but then it just became what they did every day, had their own little routines, their own mates etc. The only thing I ever kind of got sad about is that they had their own lives 8-5 that I basically wasn't part of. But hey ho, nothing lost. They had a great time, had more stimulation and learning than they would possibly have had at home. They're 8 and 12 now and we're very close. Going back to work will be brilliant for everyone.

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 10:42

We work to live, we don't live to work. If you are deeply unhappy about leaving your child in childcare, you need to take ownership of your life and radically readjust your living situation so it's possible for you to stay at home. It may mean moving, downsizing... But radical adjustments are worth it to live the life you want

CatsTheWayToDoIt · 28/01/2024 10:42

My mum always worked and clearly enjoyed her job. I never saw it as a negative as a child - it spurred me to want a career. At the same time I’ve always known I wanted a family and I never doubted I would juggle the tapas I watched her do it. I had my first child overseas as an expat and I remember how everyone would ask ‘what does your husband do/ who does your husband work for’ and it was always a really great feeling to explain we were there for MY job. It can be hard being a working mum but there are joys in every path in life. I know guilt is an emotion you can’t switch off, but do have faith there will be positives.

CuttingMeOpenthenHealingMeFine · 28/01/2024 10:41

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/01/2024 10:30

I don’t think this is op particularly but it always amazes me when people expect the grandparents to provide childcare!

I mean like why?! many will still be working and those that aren’t are entitled to enjoy their retirement!

I think a lot of people remember being cared for by their own grandparents and then expect that their parents will then ‘pass it on’ so to speak.

I didn’t grow up with this, three grandparents were dead and one lived far away so there was no going to Granny’s at the weekend etc. for me and I was so jealous of my friends who had that relationship. I am so lucky that my own parents cared for my DC while we worked (they offered - I didn’t ask or expect) and now they are in school they will happily have them round for a few hours whenever needed. It’s a lovely relationship even though I don’t always get on with my parents myself.

My in laws still work so it hasn’t been an option with them and that’s fine, they aren’t obligated in any way.

M103 · 28/01/2024 10:41

Both my kids went to nursery at around 1 year and both absolutely loved it! There are well past nursery now and are still very happy kids. Most of their mates have gone to nursery when young like them, and you can't teally tell the difference fronm those who didn't.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 28/01/2024 10:36

Childcare is fantastic. They get to do child-centred activities all day, with fun people trained to do this stuff and better still, other children of their own age.

If I was at home with my kids, the lure of books and internet would be too great and there would be less stimulation or fun. They wouldn't be at the centre of the day. There would be no pressure to fit stuff in and this would turn me into a slob.

Once they were in daycare, it was always lovely to collect them and and use the few hours that were left before bedtime to do nice things together. I do remember taking them to the park a lot after school/ childcare and having the whole place to ourselves. I always wondered where the stay-at-home mums were on the fine afternoon, missing out on the park, while I listened to the poplar leaves rustle and took joy from being with my own kids. Same with the weekends; time with kids was a novelty and we enjoyed it more and were happy to base the two days solely around them.

Zanatdy · 28/01/2024 10:35

BananaPalm · 26/01/2024 10:50

This response should be framed somewhere! 💯👏🏻

I agree completely and I definitely think it’s done my children much more good than harm seeing their mum have a career, do well and able to do nice things with them. Much rather them be in paid childcare with grandparents who begrudged looking after them as they wanted their free time (and rightly so after years of working). Those first 5yrs go so fast, guilt really is a wasted emotion and does no-one any good

Doone22 · 28/01/2024 10:31

Don't stress, it's actually good for them, so much more they can do with kids, so many resources and they generally read well there. Only downside is cost, inevitable illnesses, tiredness when you get them home, etc.
It took longer for me to get used to it but I love my job and glad I didn't ditch it

Koalasparkles · 28/01/2024 10:31

BodenCardiganNot · 26/01/2024 10:12

DP’s parents are retired but don’t want to help out.

Providing full time childcare for a toddler is a lot more than 'helping out'. Don't put the blame on your dp's parents for their decision.

I don't think she was putting the blame on her in-laws. I just read it as her stating the facts

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/01/2024 10:30

I don’t think this is op particularly but it always amazes me when people expect the grandparents to provide childcare!

I mean like why?! many will still be working and those that aren’t are entitled to enjoy their retirement!

TheMoth · 28/01/2024 10:27

Every time I felt guilty, I used to ask myself whether dh did. I asked him once, and he just looked blank.
I also reminded myself that sahm were not the norm in most wc families; one of my aunties remembers being kept off school to look after younger kids cos her mum was in work. My other gmither's mil lived there and looked after the kids whilst she went to work in a factory. These women didn't have careers, they were just surviving. At least your kids will be loved after well.

It passes in a blink of an eye too, then you'll be feeling guilty cos all their mates are allowed out until x time but you won't let them.