Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have mum guilt over childcare situation

319 replies

ChamomileHoneyTea · 26/01/2024 10:09

DP and I both work full time so I will have to leave DS in nursery when my maternity leave is over (when he turns one).

I know most parents rely on childcare these days but I just feel so guilty! Growing up my mum didn’t work when we were kids because they could live off one salary. My auntie had to go out to work but left my cousins with my grandma because she didn’t work.

Fast forward to now and I can’t afford to not work because we need my salary to survive. My parents are both still working full time so they can’t help. DP’s parents are retired but don’t want to help out.

Just feeling so down and guilty as if I’m abandoning my DS :( can’t help but think my DS is worse off than me at his age and me & DP are failing him :(

OP posts:
toppitytop · 28/01/2024 13:57

the vast, vast majority of women have to go back to work in some kind of capacity. It's only the very wealthy who don't!

That's simply not true. I know SAHMs whose husbands are factory workers, who live in small flats, who have had to move towns to afford to live on one income. But they knew that staying at home was more valuable to them than a financially comfortable life.

kisstheblarney · 28/01/2024 13:51

BIWI · 26/01/2024 10:44

where had OP said she expects full time childcare from her in-laws? Maybe she was hoping for a day or 2 a week? Perfectly normal arrangement in my experience.

Well she might have been hoping for it, but it's not unreasonable at all for her in-laws to not want to do it! You should never expect parents to provide childcare for you. Childcare arrangements are something you really have to consider before you have a child - you can't just hope for something.

@ChamomileHoneyTea it's quite normal to feel as you do before you go back to work - but the vast, vast majority of women have to go back to work in some kind of capacity. It's only the very wealthy who don't! You certainly aren't abandoning your child. That's catastrophic thinking.

Please don't feel guilty about it - as PP have said, it's a wasted emotion. I wonder how many fathers feel this kind of guilt?!

I agree about parents not having to help, but child care decisions before you have a child are very different to his you feel after the child is born.

HelenTherese2 · 28/01/2024 13:47

Wictc · 26/01/2024 11:05

Funny there is no such thing as dad guilt. We never judge men who go back to work full time, present or past. You child will grow up to see both parents working effectively as a team, contributing equally to the house, and showing that women are just as capable as men in terms of having a career and financially supporting the household. Hopefully this next generation will see further equality!

Just because you don’t see it doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist. And not all mums get ‘mum guilt’. I didn’t. I would have loathed to be a SAHM.

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/01/2024 13:46

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 13:41

Shouldn't the parents' and child's preferences and needs be held as equal though?

@toppitytop

thats what I’m saying- travel is good for both parents and kids

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 13:41

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/01/2024 13:31

@Bakensmile

some parents would rather have holidays and big house. They can still be great parents. Don’t underestimate the value of travel.

Shouldn't the parents' and child's preferences and needs be held as equal though?

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 13:36

It's not true that nurseries have improved. Before it was the norm to have 2-income households, childcare was generally done on a much smaller scale and in a home-setting. As childcare became more in demand, it shifted to become majority institutional settings, and studies have shown that in terms of the psychological welfare of the child, the smaller the number of other children, the fewer the caregivers, and the more homelike the setting, the better it is for the child. So the shift to nurseries becoming the norm is not an improvement at all.

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/01/2024 13:31

Redpaisley · 28/01/2024 12:43

World has changed since you were a baby.
There are a lot of great nurseries available.

@Bakensmile

some parents would rather have holidays and big house. They can still be great parents. Don’t underestimate the value of travel.

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 13:30

SouthLondonMum22 · 28/01/2024 13:25

Some fathers want to stay at home too.

It offers something to parents who want to work, I don't see that as a bad thing.

This is mumsnet and the poster is a mother. And an offering that limits choice and incentivises only one lifestyle, that serves the economy only and not the family or those who want to look after their children themselves, is not a good thing in my opinion. As a solution it's extremely narrow and uncreative in its remit.

Bakensmile · 28/01/2024 13:28

Redpaisley · 28/01/2024 12:43

World has changed since you were a baby.
There are a lot of great nurseries available.

Yes the world has changed indeed, as have nurseries and I would argue not for the better. With the growth in population, funding and staffing issues, a lot of nurseries are not what they used to be.

I was fortunate enough to live in a good area and attended a wonderful nursery (early 90s). The standard and care was at a much higher level and better quality than what I’ve seen/experienced with my own and friends DC. I still didn’t like it, all children are different and nursery won’t suit the temperament of every young child. I just wanted to play at home with my mum and I sadly don’t have many memories of my own parents, just that of my caregivers.

SouthLondonMum22 · 28/01/2024 13:25

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 13:08

But it offers nothing to mothers who want to stay at home

Some fathers want to stay at home too.

It offers something to parents who want to work, I don't see that as a bad thing.

Bewler · 28/01/2024 13:24

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 13:18

Perhaps controversially, I really believe you should listen to your "guilt". If you know deep down that what you want is to stay at home, that you will thrive looking after your child yourself, then that is absolutely worth sacrificing a career and even wealth for. So often in these discussions, women's choices are valued only when they want to work. That's good to be free to work, but what's not good is finding your hands tied and making a decision you are deeply unhappy with because of your circumstances and social expectations.

I agree. If you are asking complete strangers for reassurance then you must be seriously wavering over your decisions. What do you really want deep down? To go back to work and have everyone chorus that it’s fine? To be persuaded to stay at home? You only get one life. Do what you have to to make it work for you. But don’t waste your life feeling guilty about it!

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 13:20

I know women who have given up the idea of home ownership because they wanted to stay at home, and honestly I applaud them for realising what's truly valuable to them and making such a brave choice

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 13:18

Perhaps controversially, I really believe you should listen to your "guilt". If you know deep down that what you want is to stay at home, that you will thrive looking after your child yourself, then that is absolutely worth sacrificing a career and even wealth for. So often in these discussions, women's choices are valued only when they want to work. That's good to be free to work, but what's not good is finding your hands tied and making a decision you are deeply unhappy with because of your circumstances and social expectations.

BritAirwaysgirl · 28/01/2024 13:14

I was back at full-time work 12 weeks after having my baby as I had my mortgage to pay and had no choice but to return to full-time work.

Hopefully you will be able to reflect and appreciate that you are luckier than some and have had over a year off with your son.

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 13:13

The Economy should serve the Family, not vice versa

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 13:11

Redpaisley · 28/01/2024 12:50

A good economy is not a bad thing. In an ideal world, government would provide childcare for all parents. But UK does not have that much money.

Tata steel closing down, John Lewis closing down many of its stores, people losing jobs,
cost of living crisis.
Economy is on decline in the UK sadly. And public does not hold politicians accountable. So free childcare to alI parents is very down in the list of priority.

Of course a strong economy is important, but children's needs and women's freedom to choose to stay at home, should they wish to, is far more important.

peakygold · 28/01/2024 13:11

Wait until you sit on that train alone with a book, or drink a hot coffee at your desk, or have a conversation about anything other than babies, then you will stop feeling so guilty.

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 13:08

SouthLondonMum22 · 28/01/2024 12:12

It's definitely about boosting the economy. The funded childcare can cover anyone as long as they are an approved childcare provider so not just nurseries.

But it offers nothing to mothers who want to stay at home

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 13:07

Redpaisley · 28/01/2024 12:50

A good economy is not a bad thing. In an ideal world, government would provide childcare for all parents. But UK does not have that much money.

Tata steel closing down, John Lewis closing down many of its stores, people losing jobs,
cost of living crisis.
Economy is on decline in the UK sadly. And public does not hold politicians accountable. So free childcare to alI parents is very down in the list of priority.

In an ideal world, government would provide childcare for all parents.

I disagree. Childcare is necessary in many cases, but it is far from ideal. Attachment theory and multiple studies have shown that the ideal for the child is to have one main caregiver in their first 3 years of life. And UK surveys show that the majority of women would choose to care for their own children if money were no object. So that would be the opposite of ideal actually.

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 13:04

Redpaisley · 28/01/2024 12:43

World has changed since you were a baby.
There are a lot of great nurseries available.

Children's needs have not changed

BiddyPop · 28/01/2024 13:04

DC will leave school this year and time in formal childcare has not been an issue for her - she still has some friends from there and is well used to meeting all sorts of people and just getting stuck into finding out about them etc.

BiddyPop · 28/01/2024 13:02

DH and I had no choice as DPs/DPILs were 2.5 hours away.

In our case, 1 mum didn't work as traditional roles and the other as no nursing jobs near where she moved for husband's work. Money always tight in both households.

DH and I both have professional jobs and DC travelled with us to Creche in city centre from 5 months old (I took an extra month unpaid but that was all available at the time). DC commutes by car initially, then back of bike/public transport from 15 months until going to school. It was totally normal around us as very few had family to rely on.

Lainey0930 · 28/01/2024 12:52

Please don’t feel guilty. It’s is what it is. This is your situation - not everyone gets help from grandparents or family for whatever reason.

Firstly, it is normal for you to feel like this after maternity leave. After all, you’ve just spent a whole year together day in day out. I felt exactly the same.

What I did was compress my full time hours so that I finished at lunch time on Wednesdays. Could this be an option for you? This meant that we had some time together mid week which was nice. Admittedly, my children went to my parents two days a week but still.

Now, when my children started school it was basically effortless! They were able to take it in their stride to a large extent (by the way, yep, I still worried!). They even started school with a few familiar faces from nursery.

They are now 10 and 13 and not one bit affected! They have some great memories of nursery.

We are all just doing our best and it will find its way. You’ll find a new routine soon and your mindset will change once you’re all settled 😊

Redpaisley · 28/01/2024 12:50

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 12:06

I find it really odd that the government has offered free childcare basically for institutional settings only, but not made any provisions for parents who wish to stay at home. Why not give the money to families so they can either use it to afford to stay at home, pay for a nanny share with other families (which is psychologically better for the child as it's just one other main caregiver), or allow parents to use it to pay grandparents etc. They are literally only willing to fund the form of care, which is also the worst for the child. This is obviously because they don't care about what women actually want, or about children, they just care about boosting the economy.

A good economy is not a bad thing. In an ideal world, government would provide childcare for all parents. But UK does not have that much money.

Tata steel closing down, John Lewis closing down many of its stores, people losing jobs,
cost of living crisis.
Economy is on decline in the UK sadly. And public does not hold politicians accountable. So free childcare to alI parents is very down in the list of priority.

Redpaisley · 28/01/2024 12:43

Bakensmile · 28/01/2024 08:02

“What they will remember when they are older is the house they lived in, the opportunities you gave them, the holidays you took them on etc. It is when they are older that they truly need mum or dad to meet there emotional needs and are in school full time at this point anyway.”

I would personally disagree with this and think it’s quite sad! I value time spent with my parents and the simple day to day things over holidays and living in a big house (which I had and am incredibly thankful for but feel sad I don’t have many memories of my parents in my early years!). Would never tell my parents of course, they’re amazing and did their very best. But the reason I chose to be a SAHM is because I certainly do remember being left in nursery with loads of other kids and barely getting a look in, let alone my emotional needs met (please look at the research with regards to attachment and needs that babies/toddlers need for healthy development).

World has changed since you were a baby.
There are a lot of great nurseries available.