Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have mum guilt over childcare situation

319 replies

ChamomileHoneyTea · 26/01/2024 10:09

DP and I both work full time so I will have to leave DS in nursery when my maternity leave is over (when he turns one).

I know most parents rely on childcare these days but I just feel so guilty! Growing up my mum didn’t work when we were kids because they could live off one salary. My auntie had to go out to work but left my cousins with my grandma because she didn’t work.

Fast forward to now and I can’t afford to not work because we need my salary to survive. My parents are both still working full time so they can’t help. DP’s parents are retired but don’t want to help out.

Just feeling so down and guilty as if I’m abandoning my DS :( can’t help but think my DS is worse off than me at his age and me & DP are failing him :(

OP posts:
Garlicdoughball · 29/01/2024 11:02

My concern is that most of the women I know who had a significant SAHM period are now under financial stress, either because they have now split from their partner or things are complicated by the level of financial imbalance, or are worried about their pensions. If you are doing it because you are worried your partner won’t step up and you are going to be run ragged working while doing all the childcare then then IME being a SAHM exacerbates that imbalance while adding a layer of financial vulnerability on top. Just be very very careful.

Bumpitybumper · 29/01/2024 10:48

LuckySantangelo35 · 29/01/2024 08:28

@toppitytop

unfortunately I think some women will do it even if it makes them miserable because they feel it’s something that they should do, that they need to do as a woman and mother and that they need to be a Martyr because that is what is so deeply entrenched within women due to the kind of misogynistic, patriarchal society that we live in.

I think we need to sense check all our decisions as women for this exact reason. Is what we are doing motivated by our intrinsic wants and needs or what society tells us we should want and need?

You seem convinced society is pushing women to be miserable SAHM martyrs but I think there is now a much bigger pressure from society for women to do it all. They are now expected to maintain a well paid, fulfilling career, a beautiful house, cook all meals from scratch and be the perfect parent. To opt out of any part of this is seen as controversial so for a lot of women being a SAHM is actually pushing against societal expectations. You can see this demonstrated in this thread where posters have suggested that SAHMs are somehow lesser than WOHMs. Don't get me wrong, I know as a WOHM that there is a different kind of pressure and judgement but my point is the patriarchal misogynistic society we live in no longer favours the SAHM. It doesn't really favour any of us as by definition we can't be all things at the same time.

The real question is, what matters to you and what do you think is best? Whether that's being a SAHM, WOHM, WAHM etc doesn't really matter as long as you're happy with your choice, it makes practical and financial sense for you and your family in the long term and you are living a life that is authentic to you. Don't let society's BS take you down a path you don't want to be on.

LuckySantangelo35 · 29/01/2024 08:28

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 16:56

They wouldn't have done it if it made them miserable. They valued time and relationship over money. I remember one particular friend explaining to me very cogently that she's accepted that they'll never own a house, but that spending the early years with her daughter was so so much more precious to her. Just because it's not what you would choose doesn't mean it's not the more positive choice for others.

@toppitytop

unfortunately I think some women will do it even if it makes them miserable because they feel it’s something that they should do, that they need to do as a woman and mother and that they need to be a Martyr because that is what is so deeply entrenched within women due to the kind of misogynistic, patriarchal society that we live in.

ElaineMBenes · 29/01/2024 01:26

No I mean comparing less affluent children with a SAHM vs wealthier with 2 working parents

Firstly, you said that having a SAHP was more beneficial than being financially comfortable. That's different to being affluent and slightly less affluent......

Poverty is one of biggest indicators of future outcomes. The evidence on that is clear.
The education level of parents (particularly mothers) is also important.

The evidence of the outcomes of working parents vs SAHP is less clear cut.
One interesting piece of research recently found that daughters of working mums went on to achieve more senior jobs and earn more as adults and son's of working mothers are more likely to take on more caring responsibilities and household chores.

moomoomoo27 · 28/01/2024 23:03

There are plenty of parents who have a better relationship with their kids because they're very present when they are there and you're more appreciative of it and plan stuff to do.

My mum was a stay at home mum and yes she was physically there, but she rarely spent any actual time with us. We were in front of the TV from a young age. She had a lot of stuff to do, especially as a single parent, and was often snappy or resentful, so it's a grass is always greener thing really.

2under4 · 28/01/2024 22:53

I think it's disgusting that most families are in a position where both parents HAVE TO work full time, when the children are so young. Of course it's different if parents WANT TO, and it works for them. But must be really hard if you are forced into that situation, I feel for you OP.

Could you (or your DP) perhaps do something like work evenings / weekends, around your child, if you really don't want to leave them? It would just be for a couple of years, after all. By 3 when they get their 30 free hours, they seem to really benefit from preschool at least a few days a week. You could chat to your parents and in-laws about whether they might be able to commit to perhaps a day a week too. So long as you're not too pushy, I don't think asking the question is out of order.

If not, you will still make it work. Lots of children go to nursery FT after all, and are fine x

Suka84 · 28/01/2024 22:51

How rude with your comment 'there's always one' when someone disagrees with you. I also disagree with your comments and as a SAHM I found it quite offensive.
It's fine to make a comment to make someone feel better about their situation without shitting over a whole other group of parents. So let's make that 'there's always two'.

Redpaisley · 28/01/2024 22:31

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 13:07

In an ideal world, government would provide childcare for all parents.

I disagree. Childcare is necessary in many cases, but it is far from ideal. Attachment theory and multiple studies have shown that the ideal for the child is to have one main caregiver in their first 3 years of life. And UK surveys show that the majority of women would choose to care for their own children if money were no object. So that would be the opposite of ideal actually.

You disagree what? Who is going to pay childcare for all the parents in the country. Should we forget that we have millions in waiting list for NHS, people losing jobs. You decided to be a parent and a stay at home and you now want government to provide you a Nanny to help you in childcare. Do you know anything more than attachment theories about the real world?

Redpaisley · 28/01/2024 22:25

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 19:09

But I'm not trying to argue that this friend has made the right or wrong decision. Just that, if a mother knows deep down that she wants to stay at home, she should be empowered to make that decision, even if it comes at a cost, not have her very real feelings minimised because working is the norm and told that she's wrong to feel as she does.

I come from a country, where atleast in my generation, it was common to have SAHM, there are still problemetic adults in abundance. Also if you send a one year old child to a grandparent, child may feel anxiety at least in the beginning to part from mother. Or sometimes premature babies need to spend time away from mother in the care of hospital staff, but they grow up and thrive. Attachment theory is one theory, a lot more goes into making a well adjusted and emotionally secure adult.

Stephx2 · 28/01/2024 22:18

Scottishskifun · 28/01/2024 21:19

You will probably be surprised they adjust very well and just feed when with you - that can be a bit more at weekends or they will just settle into a new routine with it.
Both DS's started nursery around 12 months, DS1 continued bf til 22 months, DS2 is still going and is 23 months. Mine would want a feed on getting home from pick up for the first few months then switched to morning and evenings mostly unless unwell.

Same here, DC started nursery at 1 and BF for over 3 years, wasn’t an issue at all, just had a feed in the morning and evening and more at weekends or if off ill

oliviapsu · 28/01/2024 22:04

Feel exactly the same.

NorthernSarcasticandDownrightFantastic · 28/01/2024 22:04

I felt exactly the same... except neither of my parents worked (disability reasons, not dossers, before anyone starts...) but honestly I've been back at work 3 weeks now and it's been amazing for all of us 🩷
We really make the most of our time together now, and even took a day's leave to match my partners day off, when lo was at nursery, so we could have a day together. What kids need is happy parents who are present when they're together

thebestinterest · 28/01/2024 21:43

Scottishskifun · 28/01/2024 21:19

You will probably be surprised they adjust very well and just feed when with you - that can be a bit more at weekends or they will just settle into a new routine with it.
Both DS's started nursery around 12 months, DS1 continued bf til 22 months, DS2 is still going and is 23 months. Mine would want a feed on getting home from pick up for the first few months then switched to morning and evenings mostly unless unwell.

Oh, wow. This is so promising! Thank you for sharing your experience with me. I’d be lying if I told you that I wasn’t anxious about this.

Scottishskifun · 28/01/2024 21:19

thebestinterest · 28/01/2024 20:12

In the same camp as you, only I’ve had a bit more time, which I’m not sure has been for the best. LO is 18mon and breastfed and I’m returning to work… so we’re in for a hellish transition.

You will probably be surprised they adjust very well and just feed when with you - that can be a bit more at weekends or they will just settle into a new routine with it.
Both DS's started nursery around 12 months, DS1 continued bf til 22 months, DS2 is still going and is 23 months. Mine would want a feed on getting home from pick up for the first few months then switched to morning and evenings mostly unless unwell.

Urgenthelplease · 28/01/2024 20:51

I've also found whilst it can be really nice to be a SAHP to a baby, a toddler is a very different behaved and with 2 or more years off work it can be harder to go back to your career and they're much more difficult to settle into nursery.

Mummingit85 · 28/01/2024 20:29

Mariposistaaa · 26/01/2024 12:03

there's always one.

Everyone else who has quoted my post agrees with me

As a SAHM to a 17 month old I can assure you there is next to no “sitting around at home.” I agree with previous posters, you can highlight the benefits of being a working mum - which you have done wonderfully - without dragging down SAHMs. We’re all as worthy as each other

GKD · 28/01/2024 20:16

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 19:09

But I'm not trying to argue that this friend has made the right or wrong decision. Just that, if a mother knows deep down that she wants to stay at home, she should be empowered to make that decision, even if it comes at a cost, not have her very real feelings minimised because working is the norm and told that she's wrong to feel as she does.

I’m not sure anyone has minimised the OPs feelings, quite the opposite no?

most posters have said they understand/it’s normal but reassured OP that it will be ok.

thebestinterest · 28/01/2024 20:12

In the same camp as you, only I’ve had a bit more time, which I’m not sure has been for the best. LO is 18mon and breastfed and I’m returning to work… so we’re in for a hellish transition.

PeppermintMandy · 28/01/2024 19:52

OP I’m a SAHM. My DS has been going to nursery 3 half days a week since he was 18 months.

I do not feel a single ounce of guilt. He loves it & I’m a much better Mum for having 3 half days to do chores/admin/attend appointments etc. in peace. I know I’m incredibly lucky. We also have zero help from family (which we knew would be the case and are completely happy with).

So please don’t feel guilty for sending him to nursery because you have to work. I don’t feel guilty and my DS doesn’t “have to” go to nursery.

Stephx2 · 28/01/2024 19:30

I was a parent who would of never imagined putting my baby into nursery, however along came the pandemic and went from having a fabulous time out at groups and friends every day with my older baby to a baby who was bored senseless at home. The only option at the time was to start DC at nursery, he was so much happier. He ended up having to go full time due to the job I returned to, really I never imagined this would ever have been the case but it was the best resolution to a bad situation and did really change my perspective. (Have older children also) he learned so much, how to be gentle around younger children, table manners, still now years later eats a much wider range of food than any of my other children and is doing really well at school. I was happier than the alternative and found I had so much more energy and patience at the weekends than had ever had before. Weekends became something I really cherished and looked forward to. There’s probably pros and cons to each option and it’s sad you don’t have the choice. I look forward with our next child to working and only having to send our child part time. However just to reassure you, it’s not the end of the world if your child has to go full time to nursery, sometimes circumstances are what they are and all you can do is make the best choice. As long as the nursery a really high quality setting, that’s the most vital thing

WithACatLikeTread · 28/01/2024 19:19

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 13:08

But it offers nothing to mothers who want to stay at home

Obviously you don't need it.

GintyMcGinty · 28/01/2024 19:13

Jeezo there are some real insecure arseholes on this thread.

Be secure in your own choices and stop trying your validate yourself by being a dick to others who chose to live their lives differently to you.

If you love your children and do the right thing for you and your family that's all that is needed. Whether that is going out to work or staying at home.

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 19:09

GKD · 28/01/2024 17:55

‘I remember one particular friend explaining to me very cogently that she's accepted that they'll never own a house, but that spending the early years with her daughter was so so much more precious to her.’

Unless social housing, renting is so precarious just now with kids having to leave schools or have long trips due to a S21, not to mention renting is horrifically expensive, I actually think it’s better to try to own than rent.

Or at least have enough income (dual?) so another rental can be secured.

OP, it’s hard at first but due to covid I had a 18m maternity and my whole family benefitted from my returning 4 days.

Due to the personal allowance, dropping to 4 days isn’t a straight 20% salary reduction…

But I'm not trying to argue that this friend has made the right or wrong decision. Just that, if a mother knows deep down that she wants to stay at home, she should be empowered to make that decision, even if it comes at a cost, not have her very real feelings minimised because working is the norm and told that she's wrong to feel as she does.

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 19:06

Redpaisley · 28/01/2024 17:31

I was responding to this

I chose to be a SAHM is because I certainly do remember being left in nursery with loads of other kids and barely getting a look in.

I am sure there are more options and better children to carer ratio now compared to when the poster was a kid as there is an increase in both parents working.

Also, are you telling OP that she should not work and stay at home because the kids need wont be met in the daycare? My SIL kids are teenagers and doing very well emotionally and other wise and they went to daycare as both parents were working. And there are many more examples.

No I was responding to the common argument made that, because generally quality of life is better now, children nowadays will do better in childcare. Which doesn't make sense because attachment theory transcends what era you're born in and children's basic psychological needs remain the same.

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 19:03

toppitytop · 28/01/2024 17:04

When they really need you (the parents) and only you that tends to be in the difficult adolescent years

I'm afraid all of the science on secure attachment actually points to the opposite... When individuals experience secure attachment to one person in the early years, they develop a sense of trust and confidence in their other relationships on later life.

I'm not saying there isn't a place for childcare, but we need to be honest about the studies, as this also helps us to understand which form of childcare is best.

Sorry I meant to quote: "toddlers/ pre schoolers don't really care who is giving them food or shaking a tambourine with them or singing wheels on the bus during the day" beforehand

Swipe left for the next trending thread