Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have mum guilt over childcare situation

319 replies

ChamomileHoneyTea · 26/01/2024 10:09

DP and I both work full time so I will have to leave DS in nursery when my maternity leave is over (when he turns one).

I know most parents rely on childcare these days but I just feel so guilty! Growing up my mum didn’t work when we were kids because they could live off one salary. My auntie had to go out to work but left my cousins with my grandma because she didn’t work.

Fast forward to now and I can’t afford to not work because we need my salary to survive. My parents are both still working full time so they can’t help. DP’s parents are retired but don’t want to help out.

Just feeling so down and guilty as if I’m abandoning my DS :( can’t help but think my DS is worse off than me at his age and me & DP are failing him :(

OP posts:
Juneday · 29/01/2024 23:17

I think it will feel different for every parent BUT it will feel similar for most children. Children don’t fully feel that they are an independent being until 18 months and even then need the security of a small group of familiar trustworthy and regular care givers. The issue with nursery care is that the caregivers change, with different age groups and changes of staff. The child’s bond gets formed then broken again and again. By the time they are school age maybe 5 adults have broken that bond so they need the security of enough waking hours with adults that are always present. Not just an hour before and after drop off. This makes the time with parents precious and often demanding and can have knock on effects on the parents relationship. I knew a lovely mum and daughter where the mum had an enjoyable and well paid job, and a great nanny for two children who was with them until the daughter turned 4, She then went to a great nursery before school but was unsettled and ill a lot. The nursery asked parents permission to try and work out the cause through chat and drawings. Of course she was in mourning and bereft because her main caregiver had left her and she thought she was to blame, her heart was broken. Her closest relationship was her nanny who had abandoned her. When a young child feels this and can’t explain it and it happens more than once they build up an idea of the world that loving relationships are not for life and that they don’t deserve lasting love. And we keep blaming social media for mental health issues. …. I don’t want to say women should give up careers for years, but parents need to find a way to create tight and loving bonds, not just a couple of hours a day. This will help when the teenage years hit…. A parent needs to be available at least for a while every evening. Some children are born more resilient than others. But don’t mistake outward confidence and attention seeking with inner resilience. I have seen friends still battling with 20 somethings with mental health issues, it’s a tough world for young people and those whom I have observed with most problems appear to come from families where both parents rushed back to work. Yes they have lovely houses, skiing holidays, drama, music, sport etc. every opportunity. But bulimia, anxiety, drugs etc. Too. I think children of all ages have a tougher time and more challenges than previous generations, & being home full time for them isn’t a cure but being at work for majority of a child’s waking hours exacerbates feelings of anxiety. Stephen Biddulph has written lots on how to have Happy Children, whilst first stating it is impossible to have Happy Children all of the time, we aren’t happy all of the time ourselves and shouldn’t expect it. But in choosing to have children we have some obligations to their mental well being. Why is working setting a good example. Your employer can sack you at the drop of a hat, you may not get in with all colleagues, you may not like your job - setting a good example us kindness and respect for others, manners, and giving up your time for loved ones.

Mariposistaaa · 29/01/2024 23:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Lilianfrogslegs · 29/01/2024 22:27

Thank you for this brilliant response! I started getting worried reading so many people agreeing with this lady’s post, let’s stop comparing and putting each other down! I don’t understand why some women commented “never hear much about father’s guilt” that wasn’t the point of this post! So thank you for your wise words, they made me feel a lot better <3

Goingsunny · 29/01/2024 21:36

If you feel this strongly about it OP have you looked at working part time? Compressing your hours? As child care costs are so high, depending on what you and DH earn the financial hit from going part time may not be so bad. Could you work in the evenings or at weekends , is this an option? What lifestyle changes could you make? If you really want to spend more time with your child I think you should spend some time thinking about how you could do it, and discuss with DH. I work full time now but was part time until youngest was three. It was a good balance.

Teenagehorrorbag · 29/01/2024 21:17

You're not wrong - there is a lot about our lives nowadays that is a huge improvement on the past - but the cost of living is not one of them. Our mothers may have wished they could have a fulfilling career - but at least they had the choice financially.

The next generation have it even harder - it's difficult to see how most of them will ever even get on the property ladder....

But it is what it is. Fewer and fewer mums can stay afford to stay at home these days, so it's pretty much the norm. There's no point feeling guilt, it's just what you have to do.

I do get why you'd want to stay home with your DS, but there will be benefits as well as downsides to childcare - he will learn to socialise and get other skills earlier than some children that don't. And it will upset you far more than him. Flowers

Morgysmum · 29/01/2024 21:16

Child care guilt, is a thing l. But child care can be helpful. It will help your child learn how to share, with other kids, how to make friends. It will also help them adjust to being away from you, for when they go to school, hopefully they will help with toilet training, when your DC is older.

Bumpitybumper · 29/01/2024 21:10

Missola · 29/01/2024 21:03

I’m a SAHM too and I completely understand what @Bumpitybumper is saying here. Most people will defensively list the ways that their own situation is far more superior, by doing so it just unnecessarily knocks those that have made a different choice.

Op is looking for some reassurance, it doesn’t mean anyone needs to be rude and unkind about those that have made other choices.

If it helps, I have one child that has always happily walked off into pre school / reception / year 1 and a clingier second child that I’m unsure how they will react to pre school later this year. I’ve stayed home with both of them from birth so go figure…

Also, to be clear, I would say for the vast majority of SAHM’s - we don’t spend our husband’s money, it’s one pot. He has a career that he couldn’t do without me being around 24/7 to look after the kids and the household. Don’t confuse the cost and value of things in life, I might not earn a salary, but what I do has a value.

I think it's totally possible to talk about the positives of something without criticising the alternative.

An example would be that 'my favourite colour is yellow because it's bright and cheerful' as opposed to 'my favourite colour is yellow because it isn't dull and depressing like blue'. The former is just a positive affirmation of why you have made a choice whilst the latter intends to elevate yellow at the expense of blue. There is literally no need to drag blue into the discussion, by implication everyone would know that you prefer yellow to blue without having to directly reference blue or criticise it.

Missola · 29/01/2024 21:03

I’m a SAHM too and I completely understand what @Bumpitybumper is saying here. Most people will defensively list the ways that their own situation is far more superior, by doing so it just unnecessarily knocks those that have made a different choice.

Op is looking for some reassurance, it doesn’t mean anyone needs to be rude and unkind about those that have made other choices.

If it helps, I have one child that has always happily walked off into pre school / reception / year 1 and a clingier second child that I’m unsure how they will react to pre school later this year. I’ve stayed home with both of them from birth so go figure…

Also, to be clear, I would say for the vast majority of SAHM’s - we don’t spend our husband’s money, it’s one pot. He has a career that he couldn’t do without me being around 24/7 to look after the kids and the household. Don’t confuse the cost and value of things in life, I might not earn a salary, but what I do has a value.

Bumpitybumper · 29/01/2024 21:02

Lorralorr · 29/01/2024 20:47

🙄

clearly there are pluses and minuses to both choices and here @Mariposistaaa was just setting out some of the plusses for going back to work. She presumably wasn’t intending to list every single benefit and disadvantage in a totally comprehensive way. So you can just let her post lie or come in with points of your own, no need to attack her!

Except she didn't just simply outline the positives of going back to work (which there are undoubtedly many) but virtually every point she made was disparaging towards SAHMs which was inflammatory and completely unnecessary. There is no requirement for anyone to write completely balanced or comprehensive posts but you can't expect to write a post basically shitting on SAHMs (or WOHMs) and expect not to get called out on it. We don't have to let any post 'lie' and all posts are open to challenge.

To be honest I find it laughable that you think I have attacked poor @Mariposistaaa when all I have done is highlight the anti SAHM rhetoric she has used in her post.

Lorralorr · 29/01/2024 21:01

Nightowl1234 · 28/01/2024 08:20

Amazing response!!! SAHM’s are sensitive to criticism and I can understand why. Some people question how a SAHM can parent a daughter and expect them to aspire to be the best they can be and have aspirations to make an impact on the world when their primary female role model is, well, “staying at home”. Not saying I’m one of them. But I can see how both sides have their views. I guess everyone should just make their own choice and make the most of it. Of course, some people don’t have a true choice - parenting is tough and we all do the best we can.

Agree with this. I am back at work in a challenging job I enjoy that benefits society. I think if I was staying at home to be a mum, I would enjoy that in many ways but I would also think what was the bloody point then of going to university, getting qualified, if it was just for a few short years? And yes I have two sons so I do think about how important it is for them to see me not just working but enjoying work.

I personally think the way forward is flexible working and working less hours should become the norm, so that young kids need less hours per day in childcare settings. The world of 9-5 was most def set up for men in the 1950s and feels totally irrelevant now! In my industry we are definitely going in the flexible working direction for men and women.

agonyau · 29/01/2024 21:00

Don’t feel guilty for leaving your child in Nursery, they may be upset/unsettled at first but should soon adapt & enjoy their time there. A change of scenery & other adults to care for your child will widen their horizons & ultimately boost their confidence. I left my child in nursery at 13 months & after initial wobbles she soon settled down - I used to have to chase her around the nursery garden to round her up at hometime! 😃 A good Nursery will keep you informed of your child’s daily activities/dietary intake. It’s not the same as looking after them ourselves but it’s a good & practical solution for childcare when there are no family members available to support - in fact some parents opt to use Nursery’s at least 1 or 2 days a week even when grandparents are available to give them a break & their child the opportunity to interact with their peers. You may miss your child more than they miss you, but will make the time you have together more precious.

Lorralorr · 29/01/2024 20:54

CalmAfterTheStorms · 28/01/2024 08:28

You can dress it up as much as you like but it's better in my opinion for both baby and Mum to be together at home in the early years. Nobody is going to care for a baby like Mum, plus l think it's a very stressful experience trying to work and parent at that age.
If l had the choice l would have preferred to be a SAHM. I worked part time, a few evenings so at least l had time in the day, and l wouldn't have swapped it for the world.
I know women who work in nurseries who say they would never put their own child in one.
I think it's a real shame that so many mum's feel they don't have a choice. I managed to live on a tight budget. Of course you will get parents saying their kids thrive in nursery, which they would also have done if they were at home. It suits the government to have both parents back at work full time, no one else.

Not sure this is quite true. Gov hasn’t actually set the system up to enable women to go back to work full time. In fact a large chunk of the budget goes on 15 free hours for those who don’t work at all - because gov actually doesn’t trust sahps on benefits to look after their kids properly (poverty etc). So the 15 free hours is meant to socialise the kids, help their development etc.

Sheerdetermination · 29/01/2024 20:49

Kazzybingbong · 28/01/2024 00:00

I have no issues with parents working FT, I’ve done it and felt the guilt. It wasn’t for me. But to refer to a child upset to leave their mum as ‘that child’ is disgusting and ableist. Come on, are we really judging a kid who is four and doesn’t want to leave? It’s got nothing to do with whether you’re a SAHM or not. Stop being so stupid.

I thought the “that kid” comment was unkind too. I certainly wouldn’t judge any child who’s crying as they settle into Reception, and I wouldn’t judge their parents either.

Lorralorr · 29/01/2024 20:47

Bumpitybumper · 26/01/2024 11:58

What weird anti-SAHM rhetoric! I understand that you're trying to make OP feel better but you have implied that SAHMs aren't equal partners, don't set a great example for their children, sit at home all day and are more likely to have clingy kids. It's pretty depressing that it always comes down to these lazy clichés where SAHMs and WOHMs seek to undermine the other to justify their own decisions. It's unnecessary, unkind and just ends up with everyone being dragged down.

OP, it's fine to feel a bit disappointed if you wanted to be a SAHM and can't be one or if you feel that your child would benefit from having a SAHP. The reality is that not many families can afford to have a SAHP and times have changed from when you grew up so there is no point in making a comparison. It is also important to take a long term view, not only from a financial perspective but just from a parenting perspective. We cannot be perfect parents and we all will make compromises at some point. I think when you have a baby you get a false sense of control where you feel completely responsible for making the 'right' decisions for them because we feel like we are effectively their world.

In reality though, the real world will open up to them over time and this will be just one of many compromises that will be made as your control over your child's situation diminishes. They may go to sub optimal schools, have questionable friends, not be able to pursue every interest they have and ultimately make decisions for themselves that you feel are bad choices. You being a SAHM or not won't seem like such a big deal in the context of the wider journey of them becoming independent adults so please don't feel like this is the be all and end all. Do the best you can in the circumstances that you find yourself in and this is all you can expect fro yourself. Don't go chasing impossible ideals!

🙄

clearly there are pluses and minuses to both choices and here @Mariposistaaa was just setting out some of the plusses for going back to work. She presumably wasn’t intending to list every single benefit and disadvantage in a totally comprehensive way. So you can just let her post lie or come in with points of your own, no need to attack her!

1mabon · 29/01/2024 20:33

I for one wouldn't want to look after a one-year-old full-time. You surely don't expect retired in-laws to do that, you are not entitled. Millions have to go out to work these days just get on with it and fork out the nursery fees.

BooBooDoodle · 29/01/2024 18:56

I had to go back to work after 6 months of maternity leave. We couldn’t survive on the maternity pay, it was dreadful. When I was pregnant we saved up to be able to put DS in nursery 3.5 days a week. We all worked full time, even grandparents. My son thrived at nursery and I got my old self back, it did us all good. I had guilt but we needed my proper wage back.

HolyGuacamole28 · 29/01/2024 18:41

The guilt eases. My 2 and 4 year old are 4 days in nursery (my parents do a day a week) and I work full time. I hate this but we need 2 incomes (and I'm the breadwinner) my mum stayed at home with us as kids but it’s just not realistic for most now. Keep going. I hate the fees more than leaving them there :-)

ImNotARegularMumImACoolMum · 29/01/2024 18:38

I completely relate to this.

I’m due to go back to work at the beginning of April and it’s breaking my heart that I’ll be sending my son to nursery. To make matters worse I keep getting comments from my mum and grandma about how they stayed at home with their children and it’ll break my sons heart to be away from me, they just don’t seem to understand that we cannot afford for me to not work.

I’ve been trying to focus on the positives like he’ll be able to mix with other children and will hopefully get him to come out of his shell as I’ve heard from others that their children really blossomed when they started nursery.

Fingers crossed it’s a positive experience for you and your little one

Tigernoodles81 · 29/01/2024 18:36

I went back to work after maternity leave with both of mine when they were 10 months. They loved nursery, had loads of friends, learnt loads of social skills, played all day, had access to loads of new foods to try and were with people who adored them. I had terrible mum guilt but ultimately they learnt far more than I could teach them and we could maintain our standard of life with treats and holidays and special time together at weekends. There’s two sides to everything, this will become their norm and they won’t have a clue about your guilt

Ibizamumof4 · 29/01/2024 18:21

I think the children are fine it’s the parents that perhaps feel they have missed out as it is such a short time them been that little. I have always worked full time with all 4 kids and I do think it helped progress my career and gave them days out snd holidays and memories we cherish, however if I had had the financial option then yes would have done 4 days. But we do what we need to do and we make hard choices as mums

Wonderfulstuff · 29/01/2024 18:05

As a Mum who is on the other side of nursery... please don't waste your time feeling guilty. It's really positive for a chid to see their parents working and, enjoying working (totally get not every day feels like that!). I went back full time and was fortunate to have help from my DM but DC still went to nursery.

Don't get me wrong I missed mine hugely when I returned to work but I didn't feel guilty as such... I would feel far more guilty if we didn't have a roof over our heads or if I wasn't able to keep the constant stream of babybels that are seemingly essential for their diet!

Nursery has lots of advantages... one of which is that if you and your partner take a day off together you can have a whole day of child free time whilst they are being well cared for... I really miss this now we are in school.

MrPickles73 · 29/01/2024 17:34

I am our main breadwinner. I enjoy work - being stuck at home with small children is not the party everyone makes it out to be.

ShoePalaver · 29/01/2024 13:37

Aptique · 27/01/2024 23:21

@Bumpitybumper you are not the only one. I had to read that post again to see what posters thought was so amazing. Sorry but that post was so passive aggressive towards SAHM's. I'm one and I didn't know that my dc will view me as not being an equal partner. And WTF about clinging and crying on their first day of reception?? How is that not judgy?

My child went to nursery from 15 months and cried on her first visit to reception.

Anyway most 3 year olds will attend nursery for a few mornings at least whether or not mum works. That's different to sending a 10 month old full time.

Elizadomuchly · 29/01/2024 13:31

ElaineMBenes · 29/01/2024 01:26

No I mean comparing less affluent children with a SAHM vs wealthier with 2 working parents

Firstly, you said that having a SAHP was more beneficial than being financially comfortable. That's different to being affluent and slightly less affluent......

Poverty is one of biggest indicators of future outcomes. The evidence on that is clear.
The education level of parents (particularly mothers) is also important.

The evidence of the outcomes of working parents vs SAHP is less clear cut.
One interesting piece of research recently found that daughters of working mums went on to achieve more senior jobs and earn more as adults and son's of working mothers are more likely to take on more caring responsibilities and household chores.

Of course it is very difficult to establish cause and effect. One can't assume that daughters of working mothers go on to senior jobs BECAUSE their mothers worked.
Genetics will also play a huge part here, as will the socioeconomic status of the parent and therefore opportunities of the child. A high flying parent is likely to produce a high flying child, regardless of upbringing.

There were studies done that did show that nurseries made children more aggressive, however the researcher's were vilified. In fact I know someone who works as a professor at university who said noone dares touch this subject. If you produce research that says nurseries have a negative effect on children you would be called a sexist and accused of trying to tie women to the home.
But to me it is quite obvious that nursery makes children more aggressive as they have to fight it out for resources with less input from adults.

In my mind it is quite obvious, long periods in nursery do not benefit the child emotionally and can be detrimental, compared to short sessions and more calm homely one to one care. However I do need to put them in nursery 3 long days a week. I do this as I think the benefits of having more money and more opportunity outweighs the downsides of those 3 long days and there are some benefits to them being there after age 3 for social and learning reasons
I don't really see any benefits before 2.5/3 though except to facilitate me working, which is a perfectly valid reason to do it.
I don't feel guilty as I'm just doing what's best for our family, and the children are loved and adored which is the most important thing.

Chimpandcheese · 29/01/2024 12:55

They say it takes a village to raise a child- nursery, grandparents, your friends with children are all part of that village. I agree with PP that guilt is a wasted emotion, but that probably won’t stop you feeling it. Try and channel it into something positive, by making your time at home together as lovely as it can be. If you can make any changes job-wise, like cutting your hours a bit or more WFH then do it, but if not just try and accept. All children need in life is to feel secure and loved- I’m sure his “village” will help you provide that. Best of luck!

Swipe left for the next trending thread