Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have mum guilt over childcare situation

319 replies

ChamomileHoneyTea · 26/01/2024 10:09

DP and I both work full time so I will have to leave DS in nursery when my maternity leave is over (when he turns one).

I know most parents rely on childcare these days but I just feel so guilty! Growing up my mum didn’t work when we were kids because they could live off one salary. My auntie had to go out to work but left my cousins with my grandma because she didn’t work.

Fast forward to now and I can’t afford to not work because we need my salary to survive. My parents are both still working full time so they can’t help. DP’s parents are retired but don’t want to help out.

Just feeling so down and guilty as if I’m abandoning my DS :( can’t help but think my DS is worse off than me at his age and me & DP are failing him :(

OP posts:
Bewler · 31/01/2024 07:21

@Midwinter91 why can’t you just say that your child is at nursery and doing well instead of implying he’s more advanced than children receiving care at home. So passive aggressive! People caring for children at home don’t just plonk them in front of the telly - I spent many years in a SAHM circle of friends. We did countless activities with our kids, took them on day trips, weathered all the behavioural developments, socialised endlessly, took them to preschool when they were older and we loved each others kids to bits. We were a village and they were my best days! It’s not for everyone but please stop putting SAH carers down, they put every bit of effort into the care of kids as a nursery might.

Bewler · 31/01/2024 07:05

Missola · 31/01/2024 06:19

@Midwinter91 this is nonsense, you have absolutely no relevant or accurate gauge of this just a finger in the wind type measurement based on your wish to believe that your life choices are correct.

What nonsense @Midwinter91!

Missola · 31/01/2024 06:19

@Midwinter91 this is nonsense, you have absolutely no relevant or accurate gauge of this just a finger in the wind type measurement based on your wish to believe that your life choices are correct.

Urgenthelplease · 31/01/2024 05:24

I feel you. I'm also beyond annoyed at how much it costs. We have 2 kids and it's half my partners take home pay monthly for 7 days between them a week (1 does 3 and 1 does 4). If they were full time it would obviously be closer to 65%. He's a high earner and even combined it's more than a quarter so combined with mortgage and bills I really don't see how they expect people to cope.

Midwinter91 · 31/01/2024 00:10

My child goes to nursery as we both have to work full time to afford to live. He is way ahead developmentally, of my friends children the same age and who stay home with parents or grandparents every day.

Jeannie88 · 30/01/2024 22:45

I think we all feel this when maternity leave is over and have to pay for someone else to look after out LOs. Those working in nurseries will feel the same, unless they have their DC there. We get to cherish evenings, weekends and holiday time even more. Not easy but unfortunately that's what we have to do to keep our houses, pay bills, treat them and pay for a life they can enjoy in the long term. Living on one wage is more difficult now with so many more things that cost more, mobile phones, WiFi etc. Life has got much more expensive, expectations also, as I said, not easy. Xx

HolyGuacamole28 · 30/01/2024 16:59

Cookiecrumblepie · 30/01/2024 15:57

It’s sad that modern life is so expensive that parents don’t get the choice often to stay at home. Ideally it would be nice if a family could survive comfortably off one income and everyone could have freedom of choice (men included)

This 👏🏻

Cookiecrumblepie · 30/01/2024 15:57

It’s sad that modern life is so expensive that parents don’t get the choice often to stay at home. Ideally it would be nice if a family could survive comfortably off one income and everyone could have freedom of choice (men included)

Elizadomuchly · 30/01/2024 15:25

Bumpitybumper · 30/01/2024 15:14

Let's also not forget that the majority of people that work aren't doing inspirational, world changing jobs where they are being the best they can be each day. It's ridiculous to pretend otherwise! Most of my friends (me included) do work that keep the wheels of life turning but isn't massively 'virtuous' or impactful to wider society. Some arguably work for organisations that actively detriment society (e.g. tax dodging Amazon, gambling and oil companies) so it really isn't the case that all working people are the making the world a better place.

Your volunteering has undeniable value and merit but a lot of what people do for money can be morally hazey and not necessarily the stuff you instantly think of when imagining a great role model for children. I think lots on this thread think that working for money in of itself is virtuous but I don't subscribe to this. The world isn't as black and white as this!

I love this post. When I think of the things I admire about my parents, it's not the things they do for money. It's the things they do for nothing! The thousands of hours unpaid care work my mum has done for friends that need help, the time my dad has spent helping my kids with their homework, the kindness they have showed to us in times of need.
My dad did well in his career and my mum was mostly a SAHM, but I absolutely don't look up to her any less for it. She was absolutely integral to our happy family home.

Bumpitybumper · 30/01/2024 15:14

Coffeeandtveasily · 30/01/2024 14:35

When their primary female role model is staying at home....

Haha this is just ridiculous!

I was a SAHP - I volunteered at a charity specifically for women who were experiencing difficulties in their lives. My charity work was my passion, I raised hundreds of pounds fundraising, I helped many many women.... I'm sure that my daughter sees me as an inspirational, hard working, determined and strong supportive woman.
In fact I know she does because she's told me.

And me?! A SAHP who sits about all day setting a bad example! Who'd have thought it?!

You can do other things of value in life other than putting your children in nursery all day and going to work.

Edited

Let's also not forget that the majority of people that work aren't doing inspirational, world changing jobs where they are being the best they can be each day. It's ridiculous to pretend otherwise! Most of my friends (me included) do work that keep the wheels of life turning but isn't massively 'virtuous' or impactful to wider society. Some arguably work for organisations that actively detriment society (e.g. tax dodging Amazon, gambling and oil companies) so it really isn't the case that all working people are the making the world a better place.

Your volunteering has undeniable value and merit but a lot of what people do for money can be morally hazey and not necessarily the stuff you instantly think of when imagining a great role model for children. I think lots on this thread think that working for money in of itself is virtuous but I don't subscribe to this. The world isn't as black and white as this!

Nightowl1234 · 30/01/2024 15:10

@Coffeeandtveasily your medal is in the post 🙄 I didn’t criticise SAHMs. I said I could see both sides.

Coffeeandtveasily · 30/01/2024 14:35

Nightowl1234 · 28/01/2024 08:20

Amazing response!!! SAHM’s are sensitive to criticism and I can understand why. Some people question how a SAHM can parent a daughter and expect them to aspire to be the best they can be and have aspirations to make an impact on the world when their primary female role model is, well, “staying at home”. Not saying I’m one of them. But I can see how both sides have their views. I guess everyone should just make their own choice and make the most of it. Of course, some people don’t have a true choice - parenting is tough and we all do the best we can.

When their primary female role model is staying at home....

Haha this is just ridiculous!

I was a SAHP - I volunteered at a charity specifically for women who were experiencing difficulties in their lives. My charity work was my passion, I raised hundreds of pounds fundraising, I helped many many women.... I'm sure that my daughter sees me as an inspirational, hard working, determined and strong supportive woman.
In fact I know she does because she's told me.

And me?! A SAHP who sits about all day setting a bad example! Who'd have thought it?!

You can do other things of value in life other than putting your children in nursery all day and going to work.

CuttingMeOpenthenHealingMeFine · 30/01/2024 13:44

HolyGuacamole28 · 30/01/2024 08:56

I disagree with this. It’s shaming mothers/parents who have to work and use childcare and blaming them for mental health issues later on, of which there’s no proof it’s linked to SAHP versus nursery care. I’m assuming you’re a SAHM, lucky for you but for the rest of us, we have no choice so how about some support rather than shame? This thread is quite toxic (not the Ops fault)

Agree. I was raised by a militant ‘women should never abandon their children in a nursery!’ type SAHM but I have severe social anxiety and my brother is also plagued with mental health issues, can’t hold a job and is a feckless father to multiple children who he doesn’t see so any claims of SAHM’s automatically being better for DC’s mental health just go in one ear and out the other for me as studies will never truly capture the full picture of people’s lives. I know my own experience so no amount of studies will change my mind.

But then I also grew up relatively poor and that also clouds my vision so it’s why I work, although I didn’t use a nursery until my DC were 3 and had the benefit of family help, I 100% would have used one if I had to.

Missola · 30/01/2024 12:01

This is just pure confirmation bias re nursery attending children being better socialised / better behaved / better adjusted. It sucks that a lot of parents can’t be SAHP because they either can’t afford to or possibly just don’t want to for whatever reason.
No one should be suggesting that kids without experience of nursery’s are a certain way for the rest of their lives - such a load of nonsense purely said to reassure your own life decisions.

Bumpitybumper · 30/01/2024 09:49

HolyGuacamole28 · 30/01/2024 08:56

I disagree with this. It’s shaming mothers/parents who have to work and use childcare and blaming them for mental health issues later on, of which there’s no proof it’s linked to SAHP versus nursery care. I’m assuming you’re a SAHM, lucky for you but for the rest of us, we have no choice so how about some support rather than shame? This thread is quite toxic (not the Ops fault)

I agree that we can't really be sure that it's the use of childcare that is behind the rise in mental health issues. Especially when an increase can be seen in all demographics and not just the young.

I do think though that we have to be open to evidence about the impact that childcare/having a SAHP has on our children without automatically accusing everyone of 'mum shaming'. There is more than one way to crack a nut and if a study does find for example that childcare is causing some issues then this doesn't mean that it's a 'mothers' issue or that all WOHMs need to stay at home. It is a society issue and we all need to work together to find solutions that ensure our children get great childhoods and women are empowered to make choices that suit them and their families.

HolyGuacamole28 · 30/01/2024 08:56

MamaLlama123 · 30/01/2024 07:00

Completely agree

We have big society problems with children's mental health in the last 10years that corresponds with increasing use of daycare/ institutionalised childcare.

Nurseries may provide all these constant, stimulating activities etc but is an assembly line of constant activities what children actually need? Many children would be quite content with simple activities eg jumping in a puddle/ exploring the garden/ baking biscuits etc whilst been close to their mother/ dad/ primary attachment figure and having this stability

Nurseries are big business at the end of the day.

I disagree with this. It’s shaming mothers/parents who have to work and use childcare and blaming them for mental health issues later on, of which there’s no proof it’s linked to SAHP versus nursery care. I’m assuming you’re a SAHM, lucky for you but for the rest of us, we have no choice so how about some support rather than shame? This thread is quite toxic (not the Ops fault)

MeandT · 30/01/2024 07:49

My two are well beyond the nursery years & both their year groups are having assorted issues with not sharing, bullying, disrespectful chat. Mine have got a great grounding in not getting sucked into the nastiness & looking out for others - not because of any halo-polishing activity on my part! But precisely because they had a really solid grounding at a great nursery as well.

They were very big on kind hands, sharing well (which is much harder to teach to a first or an only at home on your own), talking about problems not solving them with hands & feet - and knowing who your trusted adults are if there's a problem.

I also benefit from being able to flex my career far more now as a result of not having a huge CV gap then.

It's a long game OP & all part of the balance.

We can all only do what we can do, but as others have said, there aren't many men who feel back-to-work guilt, so concentrate on the many benefits. For BOTH of you! Flowers

Coffeeandtveasily · 30/01/2024 07:35

@Mariposistaaa What a silly predictable post about stay at home mums!
You can offer support without belittling the choices other parents made.

I was a SAHM for years and absolutely loved it. Sitting around at home with toddlers? Ehh no. We had a great time doing all the things they wouldn't get to do if they were in a nursery all day.

That was my choice. There were sacrifices but it was worth it.
Exactly how a parent who chooses a nursery might feel.

Missola · 30/01/2024 07:26

But even if you are a SAHP that stays off work, who really cares? If someone wants to be a homemaker and the working family member supports that…why does it affect anyone else?

2mummies1baby · 30/01/2024 07:19

A lot of people on this thread seem to be assuming that SAHPs will spend the rest of their lives as SAHPs, which seems a very strange assumption to make. All the SAHPs/previous SAHPs I know are taking/took a career break to be at home with their pre-school-aged children, but then are planning to go/went back to work. Not saying there aren't any people who have never gone back to work since having children, but they're not the majority.

MamaLlama123 · 30/01/2024 07:00

Juneday · 29/01/2024 23:17

I think it will feel different for every parent BUT it will feel similar for most children. Children don’t fully feel that they are an independent being until 18 months and even then need the security of a small group of familiar trustworthy and regular care givers. The issue with nursery care is that the caregivers change, with different age groups and changes of staff. The child’s bond gets formed then broken again and again. By the time they are school age maybe 5 adults have broken that bond so they need the security of enough waking hours with adults that are always present. Not just an hour before and after drop off. This makes the time with parents precious and often demanding and can have knock on effects on the parents relationship. I knew a lovely mum and daughter where the mum had an enjoyable and well paid job, and a great nanny for two children who was with them until the daughter turned 4, She then went to a great nursery before school but was unsettled and ill a lot. The nursery asked parents permission to try and work out the cause through chat and drawings. Of course she was in mourning and bereft because her main caregiver had left her and she thought she was to blame, her heart was broken. Her closest relationship was her nanny who had abandoned her. When a young child feels this and can’t explain it and it happens more than once they build up an idea of the world that loving relationships are not for life and that they don’t deserve lasting love. And we keep blaming social media for mental health issues. …. I don’t want to say women should give up careers for years, but parents need to find a way to create tight and loving bonds, not just a couple of hours a day. This will help when the teenage years hit…. A parent needs to be available at least for a while every evening. Some children are born more resilient than others. But don’t mistake outward confidence and attention seeking with inner resilience. I have seen friends still battling with 20 somethings with mental health issues, it’s a tough world for young people and those whom I have observed with most problems appear to come from families where both parents rushed back to work. Yes they have lovely houses, skiing holidays, drama, music, sport etc. every opportunity. But bulimia, anxiety, drugs etc. Too. I think children of all ages have a tougher time and more challenges than previous generations, & being home full time for them isn’t a cure but being at work for majority of a child’s waking hours exacerbates feelings of anxiety. Stephen Biddulph has written lots on how to have Happy Children, whilst first stating it is impossible to have Happy Children all of the time, we aren’t happy all of the time ourselves and shouldn’t expect it. But in choosing to have children we have some obligations to their mental well being. Why is working setting a good example. Your employer can sack you at the drop of a hat, you may not get in with all colleagues, you may not like your job - setting a good example us kindness and respect for others, manners, and giving up your time for loved ones.

Completely agree

We have big society problems with children's mental health in the last 10years that corresponds with increasing use of daycare/ institutionalised childcare.

Nurseries may provide all these constant, stimulating activities etc but is an assembly line of constant activities what children actually need? Many children would be quite content with simple activities eg jumping in a puddle/ exploring the garden/ baking biscuits etc whilst been close to their mother/ dad/ primary attachment figure and having this stability

Nurseries are big business at the end of the day.

Missola · 30/01/2024 06:37

Sorry but this is just nonsense. If a child is brought up by a SAHM they don’t become ‘lazy’ from being waited on 🙄 a lot of these comments are so eye rollingly cringe. Also the nonsense about kids not being socialised or having a role model.
Everyone can speak to their own circumstances and romanticise their own as being superior.
Im a SAHM and it’s like me coming on and saying, it’s much better for the child as they don’t have abandonment issues Or I’m a great role model because I’m able to show my children I sacrificed my career for 5 years to dedicate it to them….blah blah, everything can be twisted to suit your own narrative.
I also have studied and have a higher education, I also worked for years before leaving my job to do something else and look after my children full time. Just do what makes you happy or what you need to do, or do what gives you purpose! Stop the nonsense about kids brought up at home and all the pitfalls, you definitely know it’s nonsense at its pretty much the basic standard of the nuclear family.

Miisty · 30/01/2024 04:22

I was raised by a working mum who ran her own business (rare in the 1950s) and also worked in the late 1970s albeit part time when most mothers stayed at home My children loved childcare and thrived They also had the advantage of going abroad on holidays It also teaches children to help at home my husband was brought up by a SAHM he was waited on all the time and had a huge shock when he married me and would sit in a chair waiting for me to get home to cook dinner That soon changed and yes I was expected to give up work after having first child (his dad )no way I didn’t study for years to stay at home I would have been bored to tears and I was the breadwinner Also elderely parents can struggle with a toddler health wise and they would give up alot

pineapplesundae · 30/01/2024 01:46

My daughter went to daycare and loved it. Sometimes she didn’t want to come home. Just find a good one with a stimulating program and baby will be just fine.

Dibdob27 · 30/01/2024 00:36

I have worked in childcare for nearly 23 years. I have two children of my own. I get this. Your child will get messy and paint, explore, get independent, try new things, lots of sensory play, go out in the garden, water play - and your house still stays clean lol.
Seriously, talk to your child's key person about how you feel. They are there to support you as well as your beautiful child. You have to do what you have to do. My favourite saying is...'It is what it is'. You need to work to survive. It isn't easy but you have to do what you have to do. She will have a great time there and you can talk to adults and enjoy hot tea and coffee. I hope she settles quickly and that you are OK. Xxx