Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

After Nottingham Is It Time for a MH Database

119 replies

WillimNot · 26/01/2024 07:24

After seeing one of the victims family suggest that huge errors had been made in the Nottingham case that, if they hadn't of occurred the victims would still be alive.

So it makes me wonder whether we need a national database of people with Mental health issues.

Not for minor depression. But for potentially dangerous conditions like schizophrenia.

The guy who killed those people had been flagged before. He had other violent incidents. Yet as soon as he would leave custody or hospital, no checks were done to ensure he took his medication or engaged with his GP or MH team.

Over the years there were 3 other times he behaved in a way to get sectioned.

We know the NHS is struggling. So if we had a national database, it could flag someone who hasn't attended a review, or who hasn't had their medication prescribed. It could also flag someone for a random check, where they'd be expected to attend so a professional can make sure they have been taking their medication and they're feeling well.

There have been so many incidents now of people with severe mental illness who have harmed or killed people. I'm also thinking of the Reading stabbings in 2020. If they'd been flagged before they stopped engaging with medication or doctors, these incidents could've been avoided.

I have bi-polar and would have no issue with being on this database, because I engage with my GP and do what I should. But sadly not everyone does and this would go some way to try and ensure we don't have to see anymore families torn a part.

OP posts:
Throckmorton · 26/01/2024 12:00

scorpiogirly · 26/01/2024 11:33

Oh thirdly, appropriate justice for the families.

I've lost someone to a violent horrific crime. You don't speak for me in your call for state-sanctioned murder.

x2boys · 26/01/2024 11:55

scorpiogirly · 26/01/2024 11:37

Well you could argue that most people who commit heinous crimes are mentally unwell. It's not a get out if jail free card if one has some sort of mental illness. Look at many serial killers or mass murderers. Many reported hearing voices etc.

Most people who commit Henious crimes are not mentally unwell.and those are will have had full asesemens ,yes some people may claim to.hear voices but its usually very obvious to mental.health staff ,if they are not genuine ,i used to be a mental.health nurse
I don't know if you have ever been inside a secure hospital but they are not somewhere you would wish to be I had a placement in a medium secure unit when I wax a student nurse and that was bad enough ,a high secure area would be a lot worse
.

TipulophobiaIsReal · 26/01/2024 11:45

WillimNot · 26/01/2024 11:09

Well aren't you rude?

I've not been rude to you. You asked a question, I answered it from my experience. It's not smug.

In fact, I would hate that of I did enter a period of crisis, I would find it very hard in my area to access help. It would be all on me, someone who was struggling to function, to sort it out. And if you have had periods of MH crisis, however big or small, that can be impossible to achieve. In my experience, I found it hard to get out of bed I put my phone in a drawer, and I detached from everything.

Your suggesting that the person with MH can be capable of dealing with their illness. That's far from true.

They then have to run the exhausting gauntlet of calling the GP at 8am. If on the slim chance they get through, it can hard to be understood, especially by the type of person on a GP surgery phone line. So will they get an appointment? Probably not.

If they do, it will potentially be a phone call, which they probably won't answer. If the GP even bothers. It will also be a triage GP, or practice nurse, who the patient probably doesn't have as their named practitioner. So they won't know to look out for queues, or previous illness. They will have a whole list of people to call so you're lucky if you get 5 minutes, if not 2. So the person calling is hardly going to go through years of notes, are they?

Every time this individual was forced to engage with authorities, it was after a violent incident or a potentially violent incident, such as him following a woman home and entering her property. At that point, it becomes a crime, a Police incident. But where was his GP? His MH consult?

Yes, if they don't engage, and the home visit doesn't receive an answer, would that not cause concern? That they could be very unwell? A danger to their own health? They may not be able to leave the house to get shopping, they may be at risk of losing their home or job.

We don't do enough for people with MH issues. We really don't. Too much is put at the door of the police and the patient.

Is this post aimed at me?

Personally, I find it quite rude when someone argues that they'd like to put me on a national pre-crime nutter database, but there you go.

And please stop pretending your nasty little authoritarian post was anything to do with removing barriers for people with mental illness needing help and support.

Trappedandunhappy · 26/01/2024 11:43

I don’t think that’s the right approach to be honest. I think only people with dangerous hallucinations would be more of a risk than the general population.

Plus, ‘Mental Health’ diagnoses are notoriously unreliable and don’t actually stand up to scientific rigour. They are just a description of thoughts, feelings and behaviours that tend to come together. It’s nit like you can get a blood test. Research has shown (carried out as part of the DSm-V work) that even for seemingly clear diagnoses like major mood disorders, psychiatrists don’t provide reliable diagnoses.

Would we have a register for someone caught drink driving? Someone who is ordinarily gentle, but punches the bloke who is sleeping with his wife whilst he is drunk?

Schizophrenia isn’t actually a diagnosis. It’s an umbrella term for various psychotic illnesses.

What about a woman with puerperal psychosis after giving birth? Would she go on the register? A young man with drug induced psychosis? A woman with PTSD following a brutal sexual assault who declares murderous thoughts towards her aggressor?

Where would you draw the line? How would you draw the line in an area of medicine with such dubious reliability and accuracy?

Better outreach and pro active mental health services is what we need. Mental
health services are always underfunded. A decent and regularly reviewed risk assessment and proactive engagement is what would help but still, you can’t predict and prevent all risks.

scorpiogirly · 26/01/2024 11:37

x2boys · 26/01/2024 11:33

Please explain how it is a deterrent to someone who is acutely psychotic and quite literally not in reality ,you clearly know absolutely nothing about severe mental illness, s such as schizophrenia.

Well you could argue that most people who commit heinous crimes are mentally unwell. It's not a get out if jail free card if one has some sort of mental illness. Look at many serial killers or mass murderers. Many reported hearing voices etc.

TipulophobiaIsReal · 26/01/2024 11:35

Dotjones · 26/01/2024 10:55

A database is all well and good but the people are still out on the streets. We should go back to the old system where people who had serious mental illness were securely locked up away from the public. The problem now is that the whole process is focused on the rights of the mentally ill person, the number one priority should be public safety.

Some of the old "lunatic asylums" were inhumane in how they treated the inmates, but just because there were horrific abuses during the Victorian era that doesn't mean we have to treat patients cruelly today. The important thing is to get them secured away from society and allow them to live out their lives in acceptable conditions.

The trouble with "care in the community" was that the emphasis was on "in the community" with little regard to actual care.

Good luck. In 2022, there were fewer than 25,000 psychiatric care beds in the UK, for a population of 67 million, or one bed for every 2680 people.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/473278/number-of-psychiatric-care-beds-in-the-united-kingdom-uk/

Just prior to the big "care in the community" push in the early 1980s, there were about 85,000 beds, for a population of 56 million, or one bed for every 659 people.

https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/1997-11-27/debates/62d0a01a-2264-482f-a042-1b9f72bdb210/PsychiatricBeds

In other words, we've got a quarter of the psychiatric hospital places, per person, that we had in 1980.

Doctors and other mental health workers want people who are desperately ill to be able to stay in hospital until they're truly well enough to go home, or, say, to be able to have a gradual return with nights at home but keeping their hospital place. But they have to kick desperately unwell people out of hospital because someone even worse off needs their place. And running at less than full capacity is unthinkable, when so many people need a bed but can't get one — even though you need spare spaces for emergency admissions.

When someone is so seriously unwell that they need to be admitted to a psychiatric hospital right now, their doctors and their families would usually like to be able to admit them straight away to the local psychiatric ward. Instead, patients wait, often with only their family to try and keep them safe if they're lucky, while staff call around the country to see if there's a bed anywhere. If they're lucky enough to find one, the patient is locked up potentially hundreds of miles from home — no family support, no visits. If not — well, the person might still be sectioned, but with nowhere to go.

Doctors would like to be able to do planned admissions like they used to, to prevent deterioration or to monitor trying a new medication. No go.

People used to be voluntarily admitted sometimes, and the wards they were admitted to were places with patients with various levels of severity. Now, wards are temporary holding pens crammed full of only the most severely and dangerously unwell people, a place for chemical stabilisation at best, not a place to start getting well.

Psychiatric patients are crying out for more beds, mental health services are crying out for more beds, for people who are so severely, acutely mentally unwell that the average person would be agog that they weren't in hospital weeks ago, long before they reached this point. Just being psychotic or suicidal isn't high enough severity.

Families live on suicide watch, retrieve psychotic family members from abroad, watch loved ones sink into squalor or homelessness or chaos, and none of these things are necessarily severe enough to qualify for one of the very few beds left. Psychiatric patients kill themselves, ones who might've been kept alive and recovered, if inpatient treatment had been available.

None of these things is enough to convince our government to fund adequate inpatient care for mental illness. God only knows how many avoidable deaths and how many ruined lives that adds up to.

I suppose it's entirely possible that our governments will change their minds and decide it is worth spending the money on, when it's the deaths and ruined lives of a tiny number of people who don't have a mental illness, or a mentally ill family member, themselves (rather than the much larger number of deaths and ruined lives they're happy to accept for the mentally ill and their families). But they'll have to find at least four times as many staff, at least four times as many adequate physical facilities, and spending all that money on mentals when there's Hardworking Families out there will be a hard sell.

By the way, how are you intending to distinguish the hundreds of thousands of people with schizophrenia who will never harm anyone in their lives from the ones who are so dangerous they should be secured away from society? I'm sure you're not advocating for life sentences for people who've committed no crime beyond having a mental illness that's beyond their control, who have never harmed anyone and never will?

After Nottingham Is It Time for a MH Database
x2boys · 26/01/2024 11:33

scorpiogirly · 26/01/2024 11:30

For a start as a deterrent. Secondly, this evil specimen, who will never be able to contribute to society in any way, will not be a burden on the taxpayer by keeping him alive in a secure hospital for the rest of his pointless life.

Please explain how it is a deterrent to someone who is acutely psychotic and quite literally not in reality ,you clearly know absolutely nothing about severe mental illness, s such as schizophrenia.

scorpiogirly · 26/01/2024 11:33

Oh thirdly, appropriate justice for the families.

scorpiogirly · 26/01/2024 11:30

x2boys · 26/01/2024 11:25

And how will.that help?

For a start as a deterrent. Secondly, this evil specimen, who will never be able to contribute to society in any way, will not be a burden on the taxpayer by keeping him alive in a secure hospital for the rest of his pointless life.

user1477391263 · 26/01/2024 11:28

My understanding was that people with severe mental illness are far more likely to be victims of crime than perpetrators so no, let's not go there.

That's true, but it is also true that a person with schizophrenia is still several times more likely to commit a violent crime, than a person who does not have schizophrenia. The data is extremely clear on this.

For male persons with schizophrenia, it looks like the lifetime risk of committing a violent crime is around 10-25%, which is extremely high compared with men in general. (Of course, this also means that the majority of men with schizophrenia do not ever commit a violent crime - I am not trying to scaremonger here).

These facts are relevant when discussing risks and countermeasures.

The drugs used to manage this condition are mostly very effective if taken correctly. The trouble is that a very high % of people with schizophrenia have episodes of not taking their medications.

Association of Schizophrenia Spectrum Disorders and Violence Perpetration in Adults and Adolescents From 15 Countries: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis | Adolescent Medicine | JAMA Psychiatry | JAMA Network

Association of Schizophrenia Spectrum Disorders and Violence Perpetration in Adults and Adolescents From 15 Countries

This systematic review evaluates risk of perpetrating interpersonal violence in individuals with schizophrenia spectrum disorders compared with general population control individuals.

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapsychiatry/article-abstract/2787197

ProfessorInkling · 26/01/2024 11:28

There aren't enough MH resources to do any bloody work so not sure how a database would help.

x2boys · 26/01/2024 11:25

scorpiogirly · 26/01/2024 11:19

No, I think it's time to bring back the death penalty.

And how will.that help?

scorpiogirly · 26/01/2024 11:19

No, I think it's time to bring back the death penalty.

InAnotherLifetimeMaybe · 26/01/2024 11:17

Hermittrismegistus · 26/01/2024 07:39

Why not for minor depression? So many men have used depression and anxiety card an excuse for killing their partner and/or children.

As do females

Also post natal depression

Tandora · 26/01/2024 11:15

Abhorrent suggestion with potentially devastating consequences . YABU

AgnesX · 26/01/2024 11:11

WillimNot · 26/01/2024 08:11

At no point did I suggest this would be used by anyone other than MH services. Or be shared with anyone other than the patient and these medical services.

It's not to seek to vilify anyone. It's to ensure that people with MH issues get support that is seriously lacking, and to keep people safe, both patient and community.

Clearly current methods do not work. As one of the families said, these agencies need to take some level of responsibility as in her view they have blood on their hands.

An automated service would mean less chance of people falling through very vast cracks. It's the same as with smear tests, it's automated, we've all forgotten at some point and the text or letter we receive means we get a handy reminder to book. I don't see this as any different.

Of course, only those who repeatedly fail to engage and who end up arrested will end up known to the police. But if we had a medical only system hopefully before people became ill they'd already be receiving help and guidance and it wouldn't get to that point.

No need to clutch your pearls ladies. As I say, I have Bipolar. Wouldn't have an issue with this at all.

Elsewise this is a growing issue because of the way the NHS does next to nothing until a situation like this happens. By that time it's too late.

You mightn't have an issue of being in such a database. I would if I was in that position.

I get where you're coming from but think that it would be end up being abused in some way, not least because things change as time moves in.

WillimNot · 26/01/2024 11:09

Well aren't you rude?

I've not been rude to you. You asked a question, I answered it from my experience. It's not smug.

In fact, I would hate that of I did enter a period of crisis, I would find it very hard in my area to access help. It would be all on me, someone who was struggling to function, to sort it out. And if you have had periods of MH crisis, however big or small, that can be impossible to achieve. In my experience, I found it hard to get out of bed I put my phone in a drawer, and I detached from everything.

Your suggesting that the person with MH can be capable of dealing with their illness. That's far from true.

They then have to run the exhausting gauntlet of calling the GP at 8am. If on the slim chance they get through, it can hard to be understood, especially by the type of person on a GP surgery phone line. So will they get an appointment? Probably not.

If they do, it will potentially be a phone call, which they probably won't answer. If the GP even bothers. It will also be a triage GP, or practice nurse, who the patient probably doesn't have as their named practitioner. So they won't know to look out for queues, or previous illness. They will have a whole list of people to call so you're lucky if you get 5 minutes, if not 2. So the person calling is hardly going to go through years of notes, are they?

Every time this individual was forced to engage with authorities, it was after a violent incident or a potentially violent incident, such as him following a woman home and entering her property. At that point, it becomes a crime, a Police incident. But where was his GP? His MH consult?

Yes, if they don't engage, and the home visit doesn't receive an answer, would that not cause concern? That they could be very unwell? A danger to their own health? They may not be able to leave the house to get shopping, they may be at risk of losing their home or job.

We don't do enough for people with MH issues. We really don't. Too much is put at the door of the police and the patient.

OP posts:
Poppysmom22 · 26/01/2024 11:09

Yep let’s put more stigma onto mental health issues. Who else do we know who made a list of people with mental heath illness hmmmm
or we could spend the millions that would cost on actually treating mental health like the illness it is and help the people who are suffering with it

YouveGotAFastCar · 26/01/2024 11:07

Dotjones · 26/01/2024 10:55

A database is all well and good but the people are still out on the streets. We should go back to the old system where people who had serious mental illness were securely locked up away from the public. The problem now is that the whole process is focused on the rights of the mentally ill person, the number one priority should be public safety.

Some of the old "lunatic asylums" were inhumane in how they treated the inmates, but just because there were horrific abuses during the Victorian era that doesn't mean we have to treat patients cruelly today. The important thing is to get them secured away from society and allow them to live out their lives in acceptable conditions.

The trouble with "care in the community" was that the emphasis was on "in the community" with little regard to actual care.

My mum was "locked up" in a mental hospital for a lot my childhood. She was often in a restrictive jacket when we saw her, and definitely if we were allowed out to the tiny, very secure garden area. I was not born in the Victorian era, I was born in the 90s. It was pretty dire, but not abusive. No way to live, though. Almost all of my memories of my mum are there, or in an ambulance on the way there.

What are "acceptable conditions"? We rarely jail criminals for their whole lives. Most people would consider being locked away as unacceptable.

Who is providing the care? There are massive abuses in the elder care industry, and those people aren't unwell. Who are you going to recruit who wants an inevitably low paid, hard career?

Who is funding the care? Realistically the poorly person, if they're unwell enough, won't be. Their family probably can't either, in most cases. Tax payer? So it'll be bottom dollar, again, and just like care homes? And there will be pressure to release people as quickly as possible to save money.

Who gets locked up? Is it enough to just be diagnosed? Do you need to be spiralling? Have committed a crime? Who is building the scale of what illnesses are bad enough to deserve you being locked up? PTSD? Bipolar? Post-partum psychosis?

Once the people you've deemed as not deserving society or freedom are locked up, how will secure public safety from all the people who commit crimes who are not mentally ill? There's a lot of those. The news may sometimes appear to suggest otherwise, but that's what sells papers...

BestBadger · 26/01/2024 10:59

Hermittrismegistus · 26/01/2024 07:39

Why not for minor depression? So many men have used depression and anxiety card an excuse for killing their partner and/or children.

Think about it. That would mean 15% of women and 9% of men in the UK would have their medical data uploaded to a likely privately run database.

We don't have functioning mental health support, it's underfunded, understaffed & poorly intergrated. That's what needs to be addressed if we want to lessen the risks for everyone.

TipulophobiaIsReal · 26/01/2024 10:55

Thisisnottheend · 26/01/2024 10:33

I have heard a radio programme about an area of the country that has massively improved its care for those mentally ill people who commit crime ,by setting up really close working between the police force and other agencies in the area……whereas other areas have ended up with the police force refusing to intervene because (quite rightly) they feel the mental health services in that area are not stepping up. I think what was flagged up on the news was lack of joint working, cooperation and (for the police)connecting a pattern of violent criminality that was treated as separate incidents rather than 1 person heading down a path that ended in murder……we have to have local policies and initiatives that are a. Joined up b. Funded.

Out of interest, that wouldn't be anything to do with the High Intensity Network’s Serenity Integrated Mentoring model, would it? That was a scheme introduced in a number of Trusts in the UK, under various names, which involved mental health services working together with the emergency services and police, in a way which resulted in significant problems for some seriously unwell individuals, including the criminalisation of seriously ill and suicidal people, and potentially even human rights and equality law violations. Patient groups came together to campaign against it pretty vigorously, but I haven't been following the story for a couple of years.

Dotjones · 26/01/2024 10:55

A database is all well and good but the people are still out on the streets. We should go back to the old system where people who had serious mental illness were securely locked up away from the public. The problem now is that the whole process is focused on the rights of the mentally ill person, the number one priority should be public safety.

Some of the old "lunatic asylums" were inhumane in how they treated the inmates, but just because there were horrific abuses during the Victorian era that doesn't mean we have to treat patients cruelly today. The important thing is to get them secured away from society and allow them to live out their lives in acceptable conditions.

The trouble with "care in the community" was that the emphasis was on "in the community" with little regard to actual care.

YouveGotAFastCar · 26/01/2024 10:42

*I strongly believe, as a MH sufferer myself, that those who genuinely engage and do what we need to to stay well would not have any issues. We all get busy and a timely reminder would be handy. As I said, just like smear test reminders- do you have an issue with those? Or when the dentist reminds you you're due a check up? Or the opticians?

Those who didn't engage would receive a visit from the MH team. If they're not engaging it is a huge red flag. Because I know I want to be well. Only someone who could be on the verge of crisis would want to keep the teams at arms length.*

I have a sister with a bipolar diagnosis. She doesn't engage with services and hasn't for years; because she doesn't seem to have bipolar. She had intense trauma, as we all did, when she was a teenager. The psychiatrist I saw recognised the trauma and eventually CPTSD, hers diagnosed her as bipolar. She tried medication for a while but it didn't help, because it was trauma, not bipolar. She eventually got therapy and it did help; over a long period. She's been symptom-less forever but has a diagnosis that nobody will get rid of. She'd be considered as "not engaging", I presume?

If you were "not engaging" on purpose, you'd probably ignore a timely reminder; which you'll know that you already get. You also get phone calls, if your service hasn't died a death under all the other things they have to do. And the police can get involved and check on you, again, if they're not so underfunded that they basically don't exist anymore.

So really you'd just have a database of people; similar to the one doctors already hold, and you'd... what? There are already reminders. It's already flagged to medical professionals. If it's only being seen by medical professionals, that's all that can happen, and it already does. If you're information sharing with uni, or work, does the person relinquish the right to consent to that just because they've got a diagnosis? Do the police also get to see? Do the police get to review it to see if there's anyone in the area that they think is more likely to commit crimes because of their health? That would pose obvious issues...

Surely you can see the huge flaws in this.

TipulophobiaIsReal · 26/01/2024 10:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Chickenkeev · 26/01/2024 10:42

WillimNot · 26/01/2024 10:26

Who said anything about punishments?

Never let it be said there isn't a contingent of MN that read a thread and immediately add and embellish to suit their narrative.

I would argue that this man should have been on indefinite psychiatric hold before he commited mass murder.

What was the point of allowing him to join a uni flat, where the residents had quite the nickname for him? Why were they at risk? He was sectioned and then, on leaving, could go off and commit more violent crime. No checks.

So please, what is the answer? Because frankly I agree with the parent who said the agencies have blood on their hands, and in the US there would've been repercussions for those who failed to intervene and prevent this incident.

I strongly believe, as a MH sufferer myself, that those who genuinely engage and do what we need to to stay well would not have any issues. We all get busy and a timely reminder would be handy. As I said, just like smear test reminders- do you have an issue with those? Or when the dentist reminds you you're due a check up? Or the opticians?

Those who didn't engage would receive a visit from the MH team. If they're not engaging it is a huge red flag. Because I know I want to be well. Only someone who could be on the verge of crisis would want to keep the teams at arms length.

As for funding, we are currently wasting money on a system which doesn't work. So why not use modern tech systems to automate it.

Let's be honest, every few days there's a post about GPs not working daily, they seem to be universally on part time now. This would mean they were responsible for that patient- not ring and hope you get any GP so there's no continuity of care- and would be required to contact within a set time scale. It makes GPs responsible and helps take pressure off the patient, the community and the police.

As I say, keen to hear what others reckon is the alternative?

If they're not engaging, but causing no trouble, what then? Do they continue to be harassed by this automated system? MH problems need meaningful, human support. This will often be instigated/pushed by family or friends, as they are best pkaced to see the differences/problems etc in their loved one's behaviour. An app can't do that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread